The Learned Advocate General makes a statement that the State Government has taken a decision to pay an additional sum of Rs. 3,00,000/- to the legal heirs of the persons who died in the incident and that the amounts have already been paid. It is submitted that this payment has been made ex gratia.
It is made clear that it will be open for the State Government to recover the amount already paid to the person as victim of Netai carnage, from the persons who will ultimately be found guilty and responsible for the said incident.
Mr. Roy, the Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the Bar Association submits that the petitioner understand the concern of the State Government and taking into consideration the financial condition of the State Government, the petitioner does not want to press any further on the issue of compensation.
The Learned Counsel for the petitioner has drawn our attention to an affidavit filed by one Laxman Sen, S/o - Debadi Sen, who was injured in the incident and was hospitalized for almost a month. It is submitted that the C.B.I has failed to investigate the complicity of one Dipak Sarkar, District Secretary, CPIM, Paschim Midnapore, who were one of the conduits or collaborators of the miscreants who was responsible for the Netai carnage. It is further stated in the affidavit that the said person is a very influential political leader of Paschim Midnapore and is moving freely in the district and there is every possibility that he may influence the witnesses and/or tamper with the evidence to the detriment of the CBI investigation ordered by this Court.
Considering the allegations made against Shri Dipak Sarkar in the affidavit, we do not think it proper to make any observation or issue any direction on this aspect. Needless to say that in case any important material is brought to the notice of the CBI by any person concerned with the incident, the CBI would definitely examine the same and take appropriate step. Further, during trial, it will be open for the Trial Court to take cognizance of complicity of any person who is not charge-sheeted as provided under Section 319 of the Cr.P.C
Another contention made by Mr. Roy is in respect of a news item which appeared in Hidustan Times on Saturday, July 23, 2011 under the caption ‘CBI Officers land in Rajarhat row’. It is submitted that at a very crucial stage of investigation of this case when charge-sheet was to be filed, the State Government obliged the CBI for having given them an offer of land for Housing Colony of their Officers. It is contended that some of the officers do not belong to West Bengal, have been allotted land and they have invested in the land to profit out of the transaction which is not in public interest. Secondly, there are officers who have flats and properties in West Bengal and still they have become members and beneficiaries of the allotment. It is brought to the notice of this Court that this transaction to the benefit of CBI was not proper as by this the CBI has compromised its interest in the investigation of Netai Carnage and may not take action against persons who are highly placed like the one mentioned in the affidavit as Mr. Dipak Sarkar.
We do not think that the allocation of land, if any, to CBI for Housing Colony for their Officers, in any manner, would compromise with the investigation conducted by the CBI in the Netai carnage case and if the Learned Counsel is so obsessed with the news item, nothing prevents him from filing a separate petition challenging the allocation of land to the CBI Officers on the grounds available to him under the law.
Out of the same news item, our attention is drawn to a box item under the caption - ‘Key Questions’. It is submitted that the CBI should answer this question.
This Court does not undertake any exercise as suggested and, therefore, such a request by the Learned Counsel for the petitioner cannot be entertained.
In our view, nothing survives in the petition and therefore, this petition and other connecteud petitions stand disposed.
Plain copy of this order duly signed by the Assistant Registrar (Court), be given to the parties on usual undertaking.