ORDER
1. Since the questions raised and the parties in these writ petitions are common, they arc clubbed together, heard and disposed of by this common order.
2. Petitioner is a construction company incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956. In this writ petition, it is aggrieved by the refusal by respondents 1 & 2 to grant permission for road cutting to lay the electrical underground cable for the residential project known as Sobha Ruby and Sobha Platinum constructed in Sy. No. 5/3. 18/1 to 18/6, 23, 68, 69/2 and 70, situated at 8th Mile, Nagasandra Village, Yeshwantpura Hobli, Bangalore North Taluk.
3. The lands in question were purchased by the petitioner under a Sale Deed dated 23.3.2005 in auction proceedings initiated by the Court receiver as per the order passed by the Debts Recovery Tribunal-I. Mumbai in O.A No. 264/2001. After the purchase, petitioner claims to have got the property converted to residential use for the purpose of construction of residential apartments. The petitioner applied for all necessary clearances, approval and sanctions from various statutory authorities for the purpose of putting up construction. The Surveyor attached to the office of the Special Land Acquisition Officer, Bangalore Development Authority, conducted a survey and submitted a survey sketch on 3.3.2006 as per Annexure-C.
4. It is the case of the petitioner that the said survey sketch was prepared on ‘as is where is’ and ‘as is what is’ basis. It is relevant to notice here that before the petitioner purchased the property and got it converted for residential use, there were industrial sheds and factory building belonging to Deepak Insulated Cables Corporation Ltd., which came to be sold in public auction pursuant to the order passed by the Debts Recovery Tribunal. The petitioner approached the then Bangalore Development Authority with the development and building plan and after the same were approved, petitioner undertook demolition of the factory and commenced the construction of residential building complex. Necessary commencement certificate came to be issued by the Bangalore Development Authority.
5. It is the further case of the petitioner that they have relinquished their rights in a portion of the aforementioned properties for undertaking development as required under the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act. According to the petitioner they have relinqhished an area measuring 11,623.52 sq. mtrs. for park and open spaces, an area measuring 7,749.01 sq.mtrs for civic amenities and an area measuring 2,606.751 sq.mtrs for road widening in favour of the Bangalore Development Authority, vide relinquishment deed dated 1.12.2006 The Bangalore Development Authority issued work order dated 26.2.2007 and plan sanction order dated 23.3.2007 authorizing the petitioner to construct the group housing project on the aforementioned properties. A copy of the work order and the plan sanction order are produced at Annexure-F. It is also urged by the petitioner that after the revised Master Plan, 2015, came into force, based on the application made by the petitioner to the Bangalore Development Authority, the modified work order dated 26.3.2010 and modified plan sanction order dated 23.4.2010 authorizing the petitioner to construct the group housing project in terms of the modified plan came to be issued. A copy of the same is also enclosed to the writ petition at Annexure-G.
6. Petitioner has filed W.P No. 29108 & 29318-327/2011 alleging interference with the possession by the respondents herein on the ground that the petitioner had put up construction on a Nala and a pathway as depicted in the village map. The petitioner has since put up construction of multistoried apartment building and it is urged by the petitioner that the built up area comes to around 19 lakhs sq. ft. on the property in question and the construction has been put up strictly in terms of the modified plan sanctioned.
7. It is the case of the petitioner that out of the 1200 apartments, the petitioner has already sold more than 934 apartments to various purchasers. According to the petitioner, in terms of the modified plan sanctioned, there are in all 6 blocks to be constructed, out of which block No. 1 & 5 have already been constructed for which occupancy certificate has been issued by the Bangalore Development Authority on 26.5.2011 In furtherance of the same, sale deeds have been executed in favour of third parties and the said parties are stated to be in occupation of their respective apartments. The construction in respect of other blocks as urged in the writ petition has been under progress at varying stages, in that, while some of them are completed, some are nearly completed and the others are at an advanced stage of construction. In fact the petitioner has produced along with a memo during the course of arguments, one more occupancy certificate issued by the Bangalore Development Authority on 12.1.2012 for the constructed residential block No. 4 with 184 dwelling units.
8. The petitioner applied on 20.8.2011 to the 2nd respondent requesting permission for road cutting so as to lay the electrical underground cable for its project from the Nelagadaranahalli KPTCL Sub-Station. There was no response. Another application was submitted on 9.11.2011 requesting the 1st respondent to act upon the application at the earliest pointing out the difficulties faced by the occupants of the premises in the residential project. These two representations are produced at Annexures-R & S, respectively. By an endorsement dated 19.11.2011, the 1 respondent has rejected the request made for permission to lay the electrical underground cable on the ground that certain illegalities have been resorted to by the petitioner in diverting the natural course of a Nala and the pathway running in the property in question. It is also stated that the petitioner had approached this Court in W.P No. 29108 & 29318-327/2011 against the BBMP and Bangalore Development Authority wherein an interim order is obtained against the Corporation in connection with the property in question and therefore, no permission could be granted. It is also stated in the endorsement that the subject is seized by the Public Works Standing Committee of the Corporation for consideration and decision. Thus, the stand taken by the respondent Corporation as per the impugned endorsement is that, as the petitioner had committed illegality as stated above and the cases were pending, no permission could be granted for road cutting. In this background, aggrieved by the endorsement issued refusing permission for road cutting and seeking a direction of the 1 respondent to grant permission for road cutting, the present writ petition is filed.
9. It is contended by Mr. K.G Raghavan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner that the entire action of the 1 respondent is wholly illegal and arbitrary and is violative of Articles 14, 19 & 21 of the Constitution. His contention is that the petitioner having obtained the sanctioned plan from the Town Planning Authoirty viz., the Bangalore Development Authority and the said plan having been granted strictly in conformity with the comprehensive development plan and as also the revised master plan and zonal regulations, followed by the construction already put up by the petitioner culminating in the grant of occupancy certificate by the BDA. it was absolutely impermissible for the 1 respondent to subject the petitioner to such harassment by intentionally refusing to issue the road cutting permission on baseless and untenable grounds.
10. It is his further contention that the petitioner has not violated any of the conditions imposed and has in fact, relinquished in favour of the BDA vast extent of vacant land for the purpose of earmarking the same as park, open space and for road. It is urged that sale deeds have been executed in favour of various third parties by the petitioner in respect of most of the apartments and as such third party rights have been created in respect of the persons who have purchased the various apartments by raising loans from banks and financial institutions and refusal to grant permission for road cutting has been causing irreparable injury to the petitioner and the residents who have occupied premises.
11. He has invited the attention of the Court to Section 505 of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act, to contend that the Corporation is bound to act in conformity with the Town and Country Planning Act, meaning thereby the master plan and the zonal regulations and the revised master plan prepared are binding on all the authorities including the respondent-Corporation and it is not open for the 1 respondent to contend by relying on a village map that there existed a Nala or a pathway, when in fact no such Nala or pathway has been shown to have been in existence at the place with such width in the revised master plan. It is his contention that suitable and adequate arrangement for roads, storm water drains, culverts have been made in the revised Master Plan.
12. It is urged by him that there is no power or jurisdiction vested with the 1 respondent to enforce the village map ignoring the revised Master Plan and the roads, streets and other things provided for in the revised Master Plan in the locality. In other words, according to him, the BBMP had failed to establish that the land was covered by a Nala and pathway belonging to Government by producing any valid documents in any proceedings validly instituted before any Court of law.
13. Sri. K.G Raghavan, learned Senior Counsel has taken me through the provisions contained under the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, particularly Sections 12, 14, 26 and 76. To support his contention that when there is a Master Plan prepared by the Planning Authority, the same superimposed over any village map that might have been in existence prior to the area being included in the Comprehensive Development Plan and the Master Plan prepared and revised. He has further contended, by referring to Section 61 A of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act, that there is no power vested in the Standing Committee to sit in judgment over the plan sanctioned by the Planning Authority as all works in private land are being regulated by the planning authority. The impugned endorsement issued stating that the Standing Committee is seized of the matter has been attacked as exfacie illegal. His contention is that once the Planning Authority sanctions the building plan and permits the construction in terms of the Master Plan prepared and strictly in conformity with the rules and regulations framed, it will not be open for the Corporation at the fag end when the entire construction is almost completed, to deny road cutting permission on the ground that the construction put up was on a pathway or a Nala as depicted in a village map. He urges that principles of promissory estoppel applies. Reliance is placed on the judgment of the Apex Court in this regard in the case of STATE OF PUNJAB v. NESTLE INDIA LTD. - (2004) 6 SCC 465. He has also relied on the judgment of the Division Bench in the case of H.Y VIJAYARAGHAVAN v. MALATHI DAS - 2009 (4) KCCR 2313, to contend that once Master Plan is prepared and finalized, any change in the same can only be as per Section 14A as interpreted by the Supreme Court in S.N CHANDRASHEKAR v. STATE OF KARNATAKA - (2006) 3 SCC 208.
14. He has furnished the list of dates and events starting from the date on which the application was submitted to the Town Planning Member, Bangalore Development Authority on 1.2.2006 ranging over various stages through which the entire process of obtaining the sanction plan, commencement, construction and other activities have gone on. He therefore contends that the respondents are estopped from alleging that the petitioners deviated the natural course of storm water drain from the Centre of their property to the western most periphery.
15. Respondent-BBMP has filed statement of objections. It is contended by him that apart from diverting the Nala and the natural course of the stream which was running across the schedule property from North to South, the petitioners have brought down the size of the passage of the water course, thereby increasing the scope for unexpected floods. He has further referred to the stand taken by the BBMP that the joint survey was conducted as requested by the petitioner and it was found that the petitioner had put up construction on the Nala violating the building bye-laws and the provisions of the Town and Country Planning Act. The map issued by the revenue authorities is referred to substantiate that there was a kachcha road and the Nala in existence in the land in question.
16. The Bangalore Development Authority has not filed any statement of objections. However, learned Counsel representing the Bangalore Development Authority Mr. M.B Prabhakar has sought to justify the action of the BBMP. He has further contended that though Annexure-C-sketch and map depicting the kharab portion in the land in question, its topography is prepared by the survevor attached to the Land Acquisition office of the Bangalore Development Authority, the said sketch does not seem to reflect the true state of affairs. He has placed reliance on the decision of the Apex Court in the case of M.C MEHTA v. KAMAL NATH(1997) 1 SCC 388.
17. Counsel for the respondent-BBMP contends that the petitioners have not only disturbed and shifted the natural course of the stream which was running across the schedule property from North to South passing across National Highway No. 4, but have also brought down the size of vent way of the water course thereby increasing the scope of unexpected floods and unwarranted mishap during the rainy season. According to him, petitioner has closed the natural Nala that was running across the center of the schedule property in contravention of all the rules and regulations. It is also urged by them that BBMP had issued a show cause notice to the petitioners calling upon them to show cause why the building license should not be cancelled. Petitioner had replied requesting the BBMP to conduct joint survey and the BBMP obliged and conducted the survey.
18. As the petitioners had contended that the survey had been conducted by the BBMP behind their back, this Court directed a fresh survey to be conducted by the Surveyor in the presence of the petitioner and the representatives of the Corporation. Accordingly, a fresh survey is conducted and a report is filed before this Court. On the basis of the said report, Mr. Gachchinmath, learned Counsel for the respondent-Corporation submits that even as per the said survey, it was apparent that the petitioner had deviated the natural flow of the Nala and also the pathway that was running in the land.
19. Upon hearing the learned Counsel for the parties and on careful perusal of the materials on record, the only question that requires to be examined in the instant case is,
“whether the respondent-Corporation is justified in denying the road cutting permission to the petitioner to lay underground cable to the residential apartments constructed by them in the lands in question?”
20. Petitioner has produced along with the rejoinder filed on 22.11.2011, a Revised Master Plan 2015, and the proposed land use map in respect of the area in question. The drain passing in the lands in question is indicated with two parallel green lines under the category Hydrography. The area earmarked in purple colour is shown as industrial area, whereas the area shown in yellow colour is the residential area. It is not in dispute that the petitioner has got the area that was earlier reserved for industrial purpose changed into residential purpose. It is also not in dispute that as per the Master Plan, its construction is in the area meant for residential purpose including the portion for which the petitioner got the change of land use from industrial to residential purpose. Admittedly, there is no other drain, nala or pathway in the Master Plan to demonstrate that the petitioner had deviated the same for the purpose of putting up construction. It is also evident from Annexure-C - survey sketch prepared by the BDA on 03.03.2006 that no Nala or pathway as claimed by the respondent-Corporation has been shown to be running in the lands in question as is sought to be projected in the survey sketch prepared by the Surveyor based on the village map. Annexure-C - Sketch prepared by the BDA is prior to the date on which the petitioner was granted license.
21. As rightly contended by the Counsel for the petitioner, once the Master Plan is prepared indicating the existence of roads, drains, streets etc., and particularly the Planning Authority at an undisputed point of time had prepared a sketch of the lands wherein no such passage of Nala in the middle of the property or the existence of pathway therein was shown, it is not open for the Corporation at such a belated stage to raise an objection solely based on the village map to contend that the existing Nala was deviated by the petitioner. It is to be noticed that the draft of the Master Plan would be published and sent to the Government enclosing the report of the survey conducted and after taking into consideration all the relevant aspects, the Master Plan submitted by the Planning Authority viz., BDA for approval and the same is approved. The BBMP, at no stage had raised any objection nor is there anything to show that anybody had raised any objection to the contents of the revised Master Plan when the objections were called for. The Revised Master Plan 2015 has come into effect on 25.06.2007 The Master Plan contains showing of lands, street pattern, areas reserved for parks, playgrounds and other civic amenities or for public purpose as also areas of special control and development. In such circumstances the objection raised by the Corporation at the stage of grant of underground cable connection to the occupants of the premises is wholly unjustified. Section 505 of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act. 1976, makes it clear that exercise of powers by the Corporation shall be in conformity with the provisions of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961, with regard to any matter relating to land use or development as defined in the explanation to Section 14.
22. Section 76M of the Karnataka Town & Country Planning Act, 1961, gives primacy to all the provisions of the Act over any other provisions of any other law. It is not the case of the respondents that there is any violation of the usage mentioned in the Master Plan or the building plan sanctioned and when there is no grievance made regarding the violations of any set backs or permissible vacant areas to be set part, it is not understandable how the Corporation can, by referring to a village map deny permission for road cutting after the petitioner put up construction by investing huge amount of money. The plan is sanctioned on 23.03.2007 The commencement certificate and work order has been issued by the BDA followed by the work order, in such event, how the Corporation can come to the conclusion that the original path or stream/nala has been deviated and its width is reduced by 10 feet before deviating its route is not clear.
23. As rightly urged by the learned Counsel for the petitioner. Section 61-A(1) deals with the power of the Standing Committee. It is not demonstrated how the Corporation can defer or deny the permission sought for road cutting stating that the matter is seized by the Standing Committee. Nothing is pointed out regarding the powers and functions of the Standing Committee to go into this aspect of the matter, particularly when the complaint is not with regard to the violation of the building plan or deviation from the usages mentioned in the revised master plan. The Corporation undoubtedly has to ensure that the existing Nalas and the drains have to be kept intact and no encroachment is made by any private parties on the same. They have every right to prevent the obstruction to be caused for free flow of water in the Nala/drain. The existence of the drain in the instant case is also evident from the master plan. The survey sketch now prepared now prepared also discloses that the nala is in existence and the same is constructed on the sites by the petitioner as it passes by the side of the petitioner's construction. If the width of the nala is reduced only at the place where the nala passes through the properties of the petitioner and if the Corporation on expert's opinion finds that the reduced passage would cause flooding in the area in and around then the best course is to find a solution to the problem by engaging the petitioner and owners of the area over with the nala passes for widening the nala in the interest of their own safety and security. The Corporation can also resort to other legal measures in this connection. But that does not enable the Corporation to block the entire project that is either substantially completed, in respect of some blocks or nearing completion in respect of several others from being occupied or enjoyed. Such an action is totally arbitrary and unreasonable.
24. The reasons assigned in the impugned endorsement to deny the permission for road cutting are legally untenable. Interim order passed in the connected writ petition cannot be a ground to deny the said permission as the interim order passed is restraining the respondents from in any manner interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the schedule property owned by petitioner. The connected petitions are filed seeking a direction restraining the respondents from in any manner trespassing on the schedule property belonging to the petitioner and/or in any manner demolishing or attempting to demolish the construction or any of its peripheral compound wall or other structures erected by the petitioner on the schedule property. Now the said writ petition does not survive for consideration in view of the order passed in this case setting aside the impugned endorsement.
25. For all the aforementioned reasons, W.P No. 44277/2011 is allowed. The impugned endorsement is set aside. The Corporation is directed to give permission to the petitioner for road cutting to lay underground cable in accordance with law, expeditiously.