Hon'ble A.P Sahi, J.
Hon'ble V.K Birla, J.
This review petition has been filed contending that the respondent - Indian Oil Corporation while filing its affidavit had concealed certain facts that has resulted in an erroneous judgment, particularly, the brochure of 2007 in relation to the award of L.P.G Distributorship that is being claimed by the petitioner under the category of Government Personnel.
Sri. Gautam Kumar Upadhyay, learned counsel for the applicant has urged that this incorrect reflection of facts has resulted in the consideration of a wrong classification as projected by the respondent - corporation in its brochure of 2011 and had the brochure of 2007 been taken into account, the court would have arrived at a difference conclusion. He submits that the categorisation, which has been referred in the judgment dated 19.7.2013, does not take into account the disabilities that have been fixed for being treated as interse priority under the Government Personal (PMP) category.
He has invited the attention of the Court to Clause (e) of Clause 5 of the 2007 brochure to contend that if it is read with Clause 7.2 (c), Government and Public Sector Personnel, the same would leave no room for doubt that the priorities would fall in favour of the petitioner, and as such an incorrect approach of classification by the respondent - corporation has resulted in an incorrect decision which deserves to be reviewed.
Sri. Upadhyay has further advanced his submission on the issue of ailment contending that the petitioner's father was ailing, and had not abandoned his service, as such he was not out of duty. He submits that there was no wilful absence from service and the technical consideration applied by the division been in the judgment under review is not in conformity with the law on which reliance has been placed by Sri. Upadhyay.
He has invited the attention of the Court to three decisions relating to service matters, namely, Jai Maa Kali A.M Works v. Tilak which is a division bench judgment of this Court decided on 11.10.1995 Further reliance is placed on the Dulal Chandra Sharma v. State of Mizoram, a division bench judgment of Assam High court reported in 2002 (5) SLR Pg. 694 and the third division bench judgment of this Court in the case of Rani Bhardwaj v. State of U.P, Special Appeal No. 1583 of 2006, decided on 13.9.2007 He urges that a technical defect of non supply of a certificate was found to be an incorrect approach and the court interfered with the judgment of the learned Single Judge to direct consideration.
He has further relied on the observations made by a division bench presided over by one of us in the order passed in Writ Petition No. 49306 of 2013, which is an order inviting a counter affidavit on a prima facie reasoning to urge that the same reasoning would also apply in the present case for consideration of the eligibility of the petitioner.
Having heard Sri. Upadhyay, we find that the very same petitioner had filed writ petition no. 7305 of 2014 in relation to a location in Suriyawan, District - Sant Ravidas Nagar under the same advertisement which is under consideration in the present writ petition. We have already dismissed the said writ petition relying on the final judgment in the present case, the review whereof has been sought. The said judgment dated 6.2.2014 has been placed before us.
We find that, Sri. Upadhyay has virtually advanced all such submissions which ought to have been advanced at the time of the disposal of the present writ petition. A review is no rehearing and it has to be invoked when there is some error apparent on the face of record. Sri. Upadhyay has tried to press into service the 2007 brochure before us.
Smt. Archana Singh, learned counsel for the respondent is right in her submission that the aforesaid brochure would not apply when the present selection relates to an advertisement governed by the 2011 brochure. The entire argument of Sri. Upadhyay therefore is being advanced on the premise that the 2011 brochure does not fix the priorities, but since the 2007 brochure is no different, the priority indicated therein should be read in consonance with the 2011 brochure for the purpose of the present case.
We are also unable to accept the said submission of Sri. Upadhyay as merely because a better argument can be advanced the same cannot be a ground for review. More so, We do not find any such concealment as alleged by the petitioner in relation to the priorities indicated in the 2007 brochure which were not at all relevant to the present controversy. The classification and the criteria fixed under the 2011 brochure, in our opinion, does not suffer from any infirmity, nor has the judgment under review reflected any error on the face of record for us to review the same.
The contention of Sri. Upadhyay on the issue of an ailment of his father during service, is also an argument which has already been dealt with by the bench while dismissing the writ petition.
We are therefore not persuaded by the aforesaid submissions and the judgements which have been relied upon by the learned counsel for the applicant - petitioner clearly relate to employment and not to award of dealership under the 2011 brochure. The brochure has been specifically interpreted while proceeding to deal with the words “while performing their duties” and we see no good ground to differ with the same.
The reference of the learned counsel to the order passed in writ petition no. 49306 of 2013 also cannot be countenanced as the same is only an order inviting a counter affidavit in a pending writ petition where no decision has been taken and therefore the same is not either a precedent or a binding order.
No ground for review has been made out. The review petition is accordingly rejected.