AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Oral Order (Hon'ble Mr. Justice M.R. Shah)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an oral order by Hon'ble Mr. Justice M.R. Shah disposing of a group of connected tax appeals and cross-objections arising out of common orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) and earlier orders of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)]. The litigation concerns (a) payments made by the assessee for hiring of JCB machines, rollers and tractors and the question whether tax was deductible under particular provisions of the Income Tax Act; and (b) tax treatment (as interest) of payments to a finance company (referenced in the record as both "TMT Finance Ltd." and "TML Finance Ltd.").

The revenue preferred multiple Tax Appeals (Nos. 599, 600, 601, 602, 603 of 2014) challenging the ITAT's common judgment and order in various ITA and Cross-Objection matters (e.g., ITA Nos. 38, 39, 40 Ahd/2011; CO Nos. 45 and 46 Ahd/2011) for Assessment Years 2008-09, 2009-10 and 2010-11. The CIT(A) had, inter alia, set aside tax demands under section 201(1) insofar as deductees had already paid tax, and remitted certain issues (notably interest under section 201(1A) and penalties) back to the Assessing Officer for verification and recomputation following a CBDT circular. The ITAT dismissed the revenue appeals, allowed the assessee's cross-objections in part, and remitted specific matters back to the Assessing Officer with directions to verify and compute liabilities.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Question A (Tax Appeal No. 599 of 2014 — arising out of ITA No. 38.Ahd/2011 for AY 2008-09): Whether the Appellate Tribunal erred in treating payments for hire of JCB Machine, Roller & Tractors as subject to tax deduction under section 194C instead of section 194-I?
  2. Question B (Tax Appeal No. 599 of 2014): Whether, after amendment in section 194-I via the Taxation Law (Amendment) Act, 2006 w.e.f. 13th July, 2006, tax deduction at source (TDS) on payment made on hiring of machinery is covered under section 194-I?
  3. Tax Appeal Nos. 601 and 603 of 2014 (arising out of ITA Nos. 39.Ahd/2011 and 40.Ahd/2011 for AY 2009-10 and 2010-11 respectively) raised similar substantial questions of law as in Tax Appeal No. 599 of 2014.
  4. Tax Appeal Nos. 600 and 602 of 2014 (arising out of CO Nos. 45.Ahd/2011 and 46.Ahd/2011 for AY 2008-09 and 2009-10): Whether the ITAT was right in law and on facts in allowing the assessee's cross-objection in respect of payment of interest to "TMT Finance Ltd."?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hindustan Coca-cola Beverage Pvt. Ltd., (2007) 293 ITR 226 (S.C.) The principle that once the tax due has been paid by the deductee, tax cannot be recovered again from the assessee. The court examined this decision, agreed with the tribunal's reliance on it, and held that no error was committed by the tribunal in quashing and setting aside the demand raised under section 201(1) for payments made for hiring of machinery where the deductees had already paid tax.
CBDT Circular No. 275/201/95-IT(B) dated 29/1/1997 Guidance on verification of tax payment by deductees and treatment of consequential actions (procedural guidance for assessing/tax authorities). The CIT(A) and the tribunal followed the Circular's guidance in remitting the matters back to the Assessing Officer to verify the exact date of payment by the deductees and to recompute demand under section 201(1A) and consider penalty under section 271(C) as applicable.
Taxation Law (Amendment) Act, 2006 (amendment to section 194-I w.e.f. 13th July, 2006) Statutory amendment relied on by the revenue for the proposition that TDS on hiring of machinery falls under section 194-I after amendment. This amendment was cited in the revenue's proposed substantial question. The court noted the question but, on the facts before it (deductees having paid tax), resolved the matter in favour of the assessee by applying the Hindustan Coca-cola principle and thus did not disturb the tribunal's outcome on the facts before it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining (a) the ITAT's reliance on Hindustan Coca-cola and the CBDT Circular, and (b) the factual position that the concerned deductees had already paid the tax on the payments for hiring of machinery.

On the hiring-payments issue (Tax Appeals 599, 601, 603 of 2014): the court reviewed the Hindustan Coca-cola decision and accepted its core proposition that where the deductee has paid the tax, the tax cannot be recovered again from the assessee. Because the deductees in these matters had already paid the tax, the CIT(A)'s order quashing and setting aside the demand raised under section 201(1) was correctly upheld by the ITAT. The court found no error in the tribunal's confirmation of the CIT(A)'s order on this point.

On the question of interest under section 201(1A) (same group of appeals): the CIT(A) had remitted the matter to the Assessing Officer to verify the exact date of payment by the deductees and to recalculate the demand under section 201(1A), following the CBDT Circular, and to initiate penalty proceedings under section 271(C) if applicable. The court agreed that because the matter remained undecided on the precise dates of payment, remand to the Assessing Officer for verification and recomputation was appropriate. The court emphasized that liability for interest has to be determined after verifying the exact date of payment by the deductees and that the remand was properly directed by the lower authorities.

On the cross-objection appeals (Tax Appeal Nos. 600 and 602 of 2014 arising out of CO Nos. 45 and 46): the ITAT had observed (quoted in the impugned order's paragraph 7) that "the tax would be deductible only on the interest part and the liability can be fastened to that extent," and directed the Assessing Officer to verify the claim and compute the assessee's liability to the extent of interest paid by the assessee. The High Court found no reason to interfere with this direction and the tribunal's remand of the matter to the Assessing Officer.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: All the appeals before the court were dismissed.

Implications:

  • The tribunal's decision to quash and set aside the demand under section 201(1) in respect of payments for hire of JCB machines, rollers and tractors (on the ground that the deductees had already paid the tax) is affirmed.
  • The remittal to the Assessing Officer for verification of the exact date of payment by the deductees and recalculation of any demand under section 201(1A), and consideration of penalty under section 271(C) as directed by the CIT(A) and confirmed by the ITAT, remains in force. The Assessing Officer is to verify facts and recompute liabilities as directed; the High Court declined to interfere with that process.
  • The ITAT's remand regarding computation of liability in relation to interest payments to the finance company (as directed in paragraph 7 of the tribunal's order) is also left undisturbed.
  • No broader change to legal doctrine was announced by this order; the court applied existing authority (notably the Hindustan Coca-cola decision) to the facts before it and did not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond the application of those authorities to the particular factual matrix. The direct effect is a dismissal of the revenue's appeals and remittal of factual/quantificatory issues to the Assessing Officer for determination.

End of summary — prepared strictly from the content of the provided oral order.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Commissioner Of Income Tax (Tds) (S) v. D.P Vekaria Opponent(S)

    ORAL ORDER

    (PER: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.R SHAH)

    1.00 Leave to amend substantial question of law in Tax Appeal Nos. 600 and 602 of 2014.

    2.00 As common question of law and facts arise in this group of appeals between the same parties and with respect to the same assessee but with respect to the different Assessment Years and all these appeals arise out of the impugned common judgement and order passed by the learned Tribunal passed in respective Tax Appeals filed by the revenue and orders passed by the learned tribunal in respect of Cross Objections filed by the assessee, all these appeals are heard, decided and disposed of by this Common judgement and order.

    3.00 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgement and order passed by the learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as “the tribunal”) in ITA No. 38.Ahd/2011 for the year 2008-09, by which the learned tribunal has dismissed the said appeal preferred by the revenue confirming the order passed by the learned CIT(A), revenue has preferred Tax Appeal No. 599 of 2014 with the following proposed substantial questions of law:-

    “[A] Whether the Appellate Tribunal has substantially erred in law and on the facts by treating the payment made to hire of JCB Machine, Roller & Tractors u/s. 194C instead of 194-I?

    [B] Whether the Appellate Tribunal has substantially erred in law and on facts ignoring that after amendment in section 194-I vide Taxation Law (Amendment) Act, 2006 w.e.f 13th July, 2006, TDS on payment made on hiring of machinery are covered u/s. 194-I of the Act?”

    3.01 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgement and order passed by the learned tribunal in ITA No. 39.Ahd/2011 and ITA No. 40.Ahd/2011 with respect to the assessment years 2009-10 and 2010-11, revenue has preferred Tax Appeal Nos. 601 and 603 of 2014 with the similar proposed substantial questions of law proposed in Tax Appeal No. 599 of 2014 arising out of ITA No. 38.Ahd/2011 for Assessment Year 2008-09.

    3.02 So far as Tax Appeal Nos. 600 and 602 of 2014 are concerned, they arise out of the impugned common judgement and order passed by the learned tribunal in Cross Objection No. 45.Ahd/2011 and Cross Objection No. 46.Ahd/2011 for the Assessment Years 2008-09 and 2009-10 with the following substantial questions of law:-

    “Whether the ITAT is right in law and on facts in following the Cross Objection of assessee in respect of payment of interest to TMT Finance Ltd.?”

    4.00 We have heard Ms. Mauna Bhatt, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the revenue.

    4.01 Now, so far as Tax Appeal No. 599 of 2014 arising out of ITA No. 38.Ahd/2011; Tax Appeal No. 601 of 2014 arising out of ITA No. 39.Ahd/2011 and Tax Appeal No. 603 of 2014 arising out of ITA No. 40.Ahd/2011 are concerned, they relate to payment made by the assessee to hire of JCB Machine, Roller & Tractors. That the assessee treated the said payment under section 149(I) of the Income Tax Act and raised demand under section 201(1) and interest under section 201(1)(A) of the Income Tax Act.

    4.02 On appeal filed by the assessee as it was found that the concerned deductees already paid the amount of tax on the same, considering the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Hindustan Coca-cola Beverage Pvt. Ltd., reported in (2007) 293 ITR 226 (S.C) as well as CBDT Circular No. 275/201/95-IT(B) dated 29/1/1997, learned CIT(A) set aside the order passed under section 201(1) of the Act.

    4.03 Now, so far as the order passed by the Assessing Officer with respect to interest under section 201(1)(A) of the Act is concerned, the learned CIT(A) remitted the matters back to the file of the Assessing Officer and directed the Assessing Officer to recalculate demand under section 201(1)(A), if any, in the case of assessee and to initiate penalty under section 271(C) of the Act as applicable following CBDT Circular after verifying the exact date of payment of tax by the concerned deductees. It also appears from the order passed by the learned CIT(A) that the learned CIT(A) confirmed the charge of tax as interest under section 201(1) and 201(1)(A) of the Act in respect of demand of interest to TML Finance Ltd.

    4.04 It appears that feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the respective orders passed by the learned CIT(A) in so far as quashing and setting aside the demand of duty for hire of JCB Machine, Roller & Tractors and consequently quashing and setting aside the order passed under section 201(1) of the Act, the revenue preferred Appeals being ITA No. 38.Ahd/2011 (for Assessment Year 2008-09); ITA No. 39.Ahd/2011 (for Assessment Year 2009-10); and ITA No. 40.Ahd/2011 (for Assessment Year 2010-11).

    4.05 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order passed by the learned CIT(A) confirming the charge of tax as interest under section 201(1) and 201(1)(A) in respect of the interest to TML Finance Ltd. is concerned, the assessee preferred Cross Objection being CO. No. 45.Ahd/2011 (for Assessment Year 2008-09) and CO. No. 46.Ahd/2011 (for Assessment Year 2009-2010). That by the impugned common judgement and order, the learned tribunal has dismissed appeals preferred by the revenue being ITA No. 38.Ahd/2011; ITA No. 39.Ahd/2011 and ITA No. 40.Ahd/2011 and has allowed the Cross Objections preferred by the assessee and has remitted the matter back to the Assessing Officer, by directing the Assessing Officer to verify the claim, compute the liability of the assessee to the extent of interest paid by the assessee.

    4.07 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the common judgement and order passed by the learned ITAT in respective appeals preferred by the revenue and respective Cross Objections filed by the assessee, revenue has preferred present Tax Appeals to consider the aforesaid substantial questions of law.

    5.00 We have heard Ms. Mauna Bhatt, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the revenue at length.

    5.01 Now so far as Tax Appeal Nos. 599, 601 and 603 of 2014 arising out of ITA No. 38.Ahd/2011; ITA No. 39.Ahd/2011 and ITA No. 40.Ahd/2011 are concerned, it is required to be noted that the learned CIT(A) as well as learned tribunal have relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Hindustan Coca-cola Beverage Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and considering the fact that the concerned deductees had already paid the tax on the same, have set aside the demand raised by the revenue and has quashed and set aside the order passed under section 201(1) of the Act. We have gone through the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Hindustan Coca-cola Beverage Pvt. Ltd. (supra). In the case of Hindustan Coca-cola Beverage Pvt. Ltd. (supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court has specifically observed and held that once tax due has been paid by the deductee, thereafter tax cannot be recovered once again from the assessee. We are in complete agreement with the view taken by the learned tribunal. Under the circumstances, as such no error has been committed by the learned tribunal in confirming the order passed by the learned CIT(A) in quashing and setting aside the demand of tax raised against the assessee and quashing and setting aside the order passed under section 201(1) of the Act with respect to payment made to hire of JCB Machine, Roller & Tractors.

    5.02 Now, so far as the challenge to the order passed by the learned CIT(A) quashing and setting aside the order passed under section 201(1)(A) of the Act and the same being confirmed by the learned tribunal is concerned, it is required to be noted that as such the learned CIT(A) has remitted the matters back to the Assessing Officer and has directed the Assessing Officer to recalculate the demand under section 201(1)(A) following CBDT Circular after verifying the date of payment of tax by the concerned deductees. Under the circumstances, as the matter is at large before the learned Assessing Officer and demand under section 201(1)(A) of the Act is required to be re-determined on verifying the exact date of payment of tax by the concerned deductees, no error has been committed by the learned tribunal in confirming the said order. As rightly observed by the learned CIT(A) confirmed by the learned tribunal, liability of interest [even after considering the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Hindustan Coca-cola Beverage Pvt. Ltd. (supra)] is required to be considered/determined considering the date of payment of tax by the concerned deductees. Under the circumstances, we see no reason to interfere with the impugned orders passed by the learned CIT(A) confirmed by the learned tribunal.

    5.03 Now, so far as the Tax Appeal No. 600 of 2014 arising out of Cross Objection No. 45.Ahd/2011 and Tax Appeal No. 602.Ahd/2011 arising out of Cross Objection No. 46.Ahd/2011 are concerned, it is required to be noted that the same is with respect to charge of tax as interest under section 201(1) and 201(1)(A) of the Act with in respect of payment of interest to TML Finance Ltd. From the impugned order passed by the learned tribunal, more particularly para 7 of the impugned common order passed by the learned tribunal, it appears that with respect to the said issue the learned tribunal has remitted the matter back to the Assessing Officer to verify the claim, compute the liability of the assessee to the extent of interest paid by the assessee. In para 7, the learned tribunal has observed as under:-

    “7. We have heard the rival submissions, perused the material available on record and gone through the orders of the authorities below. We find force in the contention of the Ld. Counsel for the assessee that the tax would be deductible only on the interest part and the liability can be fastened to that extent. Therefore, we direct the AO to verify the claim compute the liability of the assessee to the extent of interest paid by the assessee. Therefore, this ground of the assessee's cross-objection is partly allowed but for statistical purposes.”

    5.04 In view of the above, when the matter is remitted to the learned Assessing Officer with the above observations, we see no reason to interfere with the impugned common order passed by the learned tribunal.

    6.00 In view of the above and for the reasons stated above with the above observations, all these appeals deserve to be dismissed and are accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income Tax (Tds) (S) v. D.P Vekaria Opponent(S)
    (Jul 14, 2014)