AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Sheo Nath Singh (Judgment-Debtor) v. Ram Din Singh And Others (Decree-Holders).

    Sir John Edge, C.J, Knox, Blair, Burkitt and Aikman, JJ.:— The question referred to the Full Bench in the case was:—“Can an order made under the Code of Civil Procedure, and from which an appeal is given by s. 588 of that Code, be questioned under s. 591 in an appeal made from the decree in the suit if the ground of objection is stated in the memorandum of appeal? The Full Bench of this Court in Rameshur Singh v. Sheodin Singh decided that the legality of a remand order made under s. 562 of the Code of Civil Procedure could, under s. 591 of the Code, be questioned in the appeal from the decree in the suit, provided the objection was raised in the memorandum of appeal, although no appeal under s. 588 had been brought from the order of remand. The question which their Lordships of the Privy Council had before them in Saiyid Muzhar Hossein v. Mussaniat Bodha Bibi, and in which their Lordships intimated that an order of remand made under s. 562 of the Code of Civil Procedure in the case was a final order, does not appear to affect the question which has been referred to the Full Bench.

    Whether the Full Bench decision was right or wrong, we consider ourselves bound by a decision of a Full Bench of this Court, [22] and, as it does not appear from any subsequent legislative enactment or from any judgment of their Lordships of the Privy Council that the Full Bench decision was wrong in law, we, and the Bench which referred this question, are bound by that Full Bench decision.

    The appeal will go back to the Bench which made the reference.”

    The appeal coming on for disposal before the Bench which had made the above reference, the following judgment was delivered:—

    JUDGMENT OF THE DIVISION BENCH

    Sir John Edge, C.J and Aikman, J.:— In the appeal to this Court the appellant wished to question an order of remand made in March 1892. The appeal in this Court was not under s. 588 of Act No. XIV of 1882 from that order. It was an appeal from an order of the 12th of April 1893, passed on appeal after the case had been heard on remand. The appellant had one ground in his memorandum of appeal. That ground complained of the decision of the 12th of April 1893, and did not allege any error, defect or irregularity in the order of 23rd of March 1892. It appears to us that the appeal must necessarily fail. The only question upon which the appellant proposes to support the appeal is the propriety of the order of the 23rd of March 1892. In the case of Tilak Raj Singh v. Chakardhari Singh this Court held that in order to take advantage of the provisions of s. 591 of the Code of Civil Procedure the ground must be set out in the memorandum of appeal. It has not been set out in this memorandum of appeal. Further, it would appear that s. 591 does not enable a litigant to avoid limitation by coming up under s. 591 when the only ground of appeal is the order made under s. 562. S. 591 contemplates two things—there being a regular appeal about something else, and in that appeal the insertion of a ground of objection under s. 591. We dismiss the appeal with costs.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sheo Nath Singh (Judgment-Debtor) v. Ram Din Singh And Others (Decree-Holders).
    (Jun 19, 1895)