Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • article 144 of schedule II of the Limitation Act,
  • Article 141 of Schedule II to the Limitation Act
  • article 144 of schedule II to the Limitation Act
  • article 144 of schedule 2 of the Limitation Act,
  • Article 141 schedule II to the Limitation Act
  • Article 141, Schedule II of the Limitation Act,
  • SECTION 28 LIMITATION ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • article 144 of schedule II of the Limitation Act,
  • Article 141 of Schedule II to the Limitation Act
  • article 144 of schedule II to the Limitation Act
  • article 144 of schedule 2 of the Limitation Act,
  • Article 141 schedule II to the Limitation Act
  • Article 141, Schedule II of the Limitation Act,
  • SECTION 28 LIMITATION ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Jaggannath Dube, owner of the entire village Sakhra Jot, died leaving three daughters (then childless widows): Jai Kunwari, Sanjhari and Amirta. Each daughter obtained possession of a one-third bhare (share) in the village. On Amirta's death in 1875 the defendant (a cousin of her husband) took possession of her one-third share, excluding the rightful heirs Jai Kunwar and Sanjhari. More than twelve years after Amirta's death, Jai Kunwar sued the defendant for possession of Amirta's share; that suit was dismissed. Sanjhari died in July 1887 and Jai Kunwar died in January 1897. The present plaintiff (who obtained possession of the shares of Sanjhari and Jai Kunwar in earlier proceedings) sued for possession of the share formerly held by Amirta.

The plaintiff contended that he was the nearest reversionary heir of Jaggannath Dube and that his right to sue accrued on the death of Jai Kunwar (the last surviving daughter); he also alleged that the suit previously brought by Jai Kunwar was collusive and therefore should not bind him. The defendant admitted that the plaintiff was the nearest reversioner but pleaded (a) that the claim was barred by res judicata due to the dismissal of Jai Kunwar's suit, and (b) that it was barred by limitation under Article 144 of Schedule II of the Limitation Act because the defendant had held adverse possession for more than twelve years.

The Subordinate Judge dismissed the suit on the ground that it was barred by the decree of the previous suit. On appeal the District Judge held that if the plaintiff's right to sue had accrued on Amirta's death the suit was barred by Article 144 of Schedule II, and if the right accrued on the death of Jai Kunwar the suit was barred by the decree in Jai Kunwar's suit. This appeal followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the dismissal of Jai Kunwar's earlier suit operates as res judicata to bar the present suit by the plaintiff.
  2. Whether the plaintiff's suit for possession of Amirta's share is barred by limitation, and if so whether Article 141 or Article 144 of Schedule II to the Limitation Act governs (i.e., when the plaintiff's cause of action is deemed to have accrued — on the death of Amirta or on the death of the last surviving female heir).
  3. Whether a dismissal of a suit for possession for want of time-bar (adverse possession) constitutes an adjudication on the merits (title) such as to bind subsequent reversionary claimants.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's (Appellant's) Arguments

  • The plaintiff is the nearest reversionary heir of Jaggannath Dube and therefore entitled to sue for the share formerly held by Amirta.
  • The plaintiff's right to sue accrued on the death of Jai Kunwar, the last surviving daughter, and the suit was brought within the period applicable to that accrual.
  • The suit previously brought by Jai Kunwar was collusive and should not bind the plaintiff (i.e., he is not bound by the decree in that suit).

Defendant's (Respondent's) Arguments

  • The defendant admitted that the plaintiff is the nearest reversioner but pleaded that the claim is barred by res judicata because Jai Kunwar's earlier suit against the defendant had been dismissed.
  • The defendant further pleaded that the claim is barred by limitation under Article 144 of Schedule II to the Limitation Act, on the basis that the defendant had held adverse possession for more than twelve years.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shivagunga case (Privy Council) (referenced) The rule about what constitutes a trial of right for res judicata purposes (their Lordships' rule regarding trial of rights). The court held that Jai Kunwar's suit was dismissed only on the ground of adverse possession and there was "no trial of any right within the meaning of the rule laid down by their Lordships of the Privy Council in the Shivagunga case," so that dismissal does not operate as res judicata against the present suit.
Ram Kali v. Kedar Nath (Full Bench of this Court) Authority that Article 141 of Schedule II applies where a female heir is kept out of possession and a reversioner sues after her death; suit by reversioner is within twelve years measured from the death of the female. The court treated the present case as indistinguishable in principle and applied the Full Bench decision to hold the present suit within time under Article 141.
Hanuman Prasad Singh v. Bhagauti Prasad (Allahabad cases cited) Held that alienation by a female heir in possession is good against her for life and that Article 141 provides the period of limitation for a suit by the reversioner; but the judgment suggested Lachhan Kunwar might be inconsistent with the Full Bench decision. Cited as one of the later cases expressing doubt about the Full Bench decision; the present Court addressed and distinguished the points raised there in light of later Privy Council authority.
Tika Ram v. Shama Charan (Allahabad case cited) Expressed the view (like Hanuman Prasad) that Lachhan Kunwar supports the proposition that twelve years' adverse possession against a female heir bars the rights of the reversionary heir on her death. Cited as a case taking the contrary view; the present Court held that later Privy Council authority (Runchordas) and the Full Bench decision govern and that Tika Ram cannot be followed.
Lachhan Kunwar v. Manorath Ram (Privy Council) The Privy Council held that suits for possession were barred by limitation where adverse possession had continued for more than twelve years against certain claimants; discussion in the judgment concerned whether adverse possession against a female widow accelerated rights of reversionary heirs. The Court analysed the facts and holdings and concluded Lachhan Kunwar is distinguishable: it did not decide that adverse possession against the widow barred the reversionary heirs after her death; accordingly it does not upset the Full Bench's rule applied in this case.
Runchordas v. Parvatibai (Privy Council) Held that Article 144 did not apply to the suit there, Article 141 applied, and therefore a reversioner who sues within twelve years of the death of the last female heir is not time-barred even though the female had been out of possession for more than twelve years. The Court regarded this latest Privy Council pronouncement as conclusive and directly supportive of applying Article 141 to the present facts; it accordingly held the present suit was not barred by limitation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

On the plea of res judicata: The Court examined the record of the earlier suit by Jai Kunwar and observed that the dismissal in that suit was solely on the ground that the defendant had held possession adversely to Jai Kunwar for more than twelve years. There was no "trial of any right" within the meaning of the Privy Council's rule in the Shivagunga case. Because the earlier proceedings contained no adjudication on title, their dismissal could not operate as res judicata against the present plaintiff. The Court therefore dismissed the res judicata plea without further inquiry into alleged collusion.

On the question of limitation: The Court found the present case to be governed by the Full Bench decision in Ram Kali v. Kedar Nath, where Article 141 of Schedule II to the Limitation Act was held applicable: where a female heir is kept out of possession and the reversioner sues after her death, the reversioner may bring suit within twelve years of the female's death. The Court observed that subsequent decisions in this Court (Hanuman Prasad; Tika Ram) had cast doubt on the Full Bench decision by construing an earlier Privy Council case (Lachhan Kunwar) as barring reversionary rights after adverse possession against the female. The Court analysed Lachhan Kunwar and concluded that it did not decide that adverse possession against the female widow extinguished the reversioner's right to sue after her death; instead Lachhan Kunwar dealt with whether the rights of reversionary plaintiffs were accelerated into a right of suit during the lifetime of the widow.

The Court gave significant weight to the Privy Council's later decision in Runchordas v. Parvatibai. In Runchordas the Privy Council held that Article 144 did not apply and that Article 141 applied; therefore a reversioner who sues within twelve years of the death of the last female heir is not time-barred even though the female had been out of possession for more than twelve years. The Court treated Runchordas as a clear authority supporting the Full Bench view and as not controlled by Lachhan Kunwar. On that basis the Court held the plaintiff's suit was within time (Article 141) when brought within twelve years of Jai Kunwar's death.

The concurring judge (Banerji, J.) reinforced this reasoning: Runchordas was conclusive; it affirmed the Full Bench view in Ram Kali and indicated that some earlier local decisions (e.g., Tika Ram) could not be followed. Banerji, J. also emphasised that the plaintiff's right did not accrue on Amirta's death (because Amirta's share devolved on surviving sisters, not immediately on the reversioner) and that the decree dismissing Jai Kunwar's suit contained no adjudication on title but only a finding of limitation against Jai Kunwar.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeal decreed.

The Court reversed the decrees of both lower courts and decreed the plaintiff's suit. The relief granted to the plaintiff included costs in all Courts and mesne profits from the date of suit to the date of delivery of possession, or until the expiration of three years from the date of the decree, whichever occurred first.

Consequences for the parties: the plaintiff obtains a decree for possession of the share formerly held by Amirta, recoverable mesne profits as specified, and costs. The earlier dismissal of Jai Kunwar's suit was held not to bar the plaintiff's claim because that dismissal did not involve an adjudication on title.

Broader implications: The Court applied the Full Bench authority (Ram Kali v. Kedar Nath) and the Privy Council's later ruling in Runchordas v. Parvatibai to hold that Article 141 governs reversionary suits brought within twelve years of the death of the last female heir, even where the female had been out of possession for more than twelve years; the decision disapproves following contrary local views (such as Tika Ram) insofar as they conflict with Runchordas and the Full Bench ruling. The opinion does not state that it is establishing a new principle beyond applying and reconciling existing authorities.

    Amrit Dhar v. Bindesri Prasad

    Chamier, J.:— This is an appeal from a decree of the District Judge of Gorakhpur confirming a decree of the Sub-ordinate Judge of Gorakhpur by which the plaintiff's suit was dismissed with costs.

    The facts are as follows:—One Jaggannath Dube, the owner of the entire village Sakhra Jot, died many years ago, leaving three daughters—then childless widows—named Jai Kunwari, Sanjhari and Amirta, who each obtained possession of a one-third Bhare in the village. On the death of Amirta in 1875, the defendant, a cousin of her husband, took possession of her share to the exclusion of the rightful heirs, Jai Kunwar and Sanjhari. More than twelve years after the death of Amirta, heir sister, Jai Kunwar, sued the defendant for possession of the share formerly held by Amirta, but that suit was dismissed. Sanjhari died in July, 1887, and Jai Kunwar in January, 1897. Thereupon the plaintiff sued for, and obtained possession of, the shares that had been of Sanjhari and Jai Kunwar. He now sues for possession of the share formerly held by Amirta. His case is, that he is the nearest reversionary heir of Jaggannath Dube, and that his right to sue accrued upon the death of Jai Kunwar, the last surviving daughter of Jaggannath Dube; he also alleges that the suit brought by Jai Kunwar against the defendant was a collusive suit, and that he is not bound by the decree passed therein. The defendant admits that the plaintiff is the nearest reversioner to Jaggannath, but pleads that the claim is barred by the rule of res judicata by reason of the dismissal of Jai Kunwar's suit, and also that it is barred by limitation under article 144 of schedule 2 of the Limitation Act, inasmuch as he has held adverse possession for more than twelve years.

    The Sub-ordinate Judge dismissed the suit as being barred by the decree in the previous suit. On appeal the District Judge held that if the plaintiff's right to sue accrued upon the death of Amirta, the suit was barred by limitation under article 144 of schedule II of the Limitation Act, and that if his right to sue accrued upon the death of Jai Kunwar, the suit was barred by the “decree in Jai Kunwar's suit.

    As regards the plea of res judicata, I think it is quite clear that the dismissal of Jai Kunwar's suit does not, under the circumstances, bar the present suit. The judgment of this Court in that suit is on the record of the present suit. It shows that suit was dismissed only upon the ground that the defendant had held possession adversely to Jai Kunwar for more than twelve years. There was no trial of any right within the meaning of the rule laid down by their Lordships of the Privy Council in the Shivagunga case . It is therefore unnecessary to inquire whether that was a collusive suit. The proceedings in it have no effect upon the present case and may be dismissed from consideration.

    Upon the question of limitation it is obvious that the present case cannot be distinguished in principle from the case of Ram Kali v. Kedar Nath . There, as here, a female heir was kept out of possession by a trespasser for more than twelve years, and on the death of the female, the reversionary heir sued the trespasser for the property. It was held by the Full Bench that Article 141 of Schedule II to the Limitation Act applied, and that therefore the suit was within time, having been brought within twelve years of the death of the female.

    It would have been sufficient to say that the present case is governed by the decision of the Full Bench, but in two later cases in this Court doubts have been expressed as to the correctness of that decision. The first of these cases is that of Hanuman Prasad Singh v. Bhagauti Prasad . The point actually decided in that case was that an alienation made by a female heir in possession is good against her for her life, but if it is not binding on the reversioner a cause of action accouters to him on the death of the female, and that Article 141 of Schedule II to the Limitation Act provides the period of limitation for a suit by the reversioner in such a case; but in the course of his judgment in that case, Burkitt, J., suggested that the decision of their Lordships of the Privy Council in the case of Lachaan Kunwar v. Manorath Ram was inconsistent with the decision of the Full. Bench in the case cited above. The second case in this Court is that of Tika Ram v. Shama Charan in which the same view was taken. In both these case it was considered that the decision of their Lordships in Lachhan Knnwar's case was an authority for the proposition that twelve years' adverse possession against a female heir bars not only the rights of the female, but also those of the reversionary their entitled to the property on her death.

    The latest pronouncement on this subject by their Lordships of the Privy Council is in the case of Runchordas v. Parvatibai . In that case the facts were that a separated Hindu died in 1869, leaving two widows, the survivor of whom died in 1888. He had made a will by which he left certain specific property to his widows for their lives, and bequeathed the residue of his property to trustees upon certain trusts. On his death the widows took possession of the property bequeathed to them, and the trustees took the residue and applied it in the manner directed in the will. On the death of the survivor of the two widows, the plaintiff, who was the nephew of the testator, sued to have the trusts of the residue declared void, and, in effect, for possession of the entire property of the testator. The defence was that the trusts were valid, and even if they were invalid the suit was barred by limitation, inasmuch as the property had been held by the trustees for more than twelve years adversely to the persons entitle, viz. the widows. Their Lordships held that the trusts were void, that article 144 of schedule II to the Limitation Act did not apply to the suit, but that article 141 applied, and therefore the suit was not barred by limitation. In this case it was quite clear that the trustees had held possession of the residuary estate adversely to the widows for more than there years. It will be seen that the facts were very much like those of the case decided by the Full Bench of this Court.

    If the decision of their Lordships in Lachhan Kunwar's case was correctly interpreted in the cases in the 19th and 20th volumes of the Allahabad Reports to which I have referred, then the decision of their Lordships in the Bombay case must be taken to be in conflict with their decision in Lachhan Kunwar' case. Their Lordships do not refer to Lachhan Kunwar's case in their Judgment in the Bombay case, although, as the report shows, that case was cited during the argument. From this it in ay be inf or red that their Lordships did not consider that their decision in Lachhan Kunwar' case governed the case then before them.

    In Lachhan Kunwar' case the facts were these: Jit Kunwar took possession of her son Pahlad's estate on his death, asserting an absolute title in herself to the exclusion of the rightful heir his widow Laohhan Kunwar, and held possession for twenty-five years (there was Borne doubt whether Jit Kunwar had not taken possession at an earlier date, but for the purposes of the decision it teems to have been assumed that she had taken possession on Pahlad's death). Jit Kunwar died in 1887. Thereupon two suits were instituted for the recovery of possession of two portions of the property which had been transferred to the defendants by Jit Kaawar. Their Lordships held that the suits were barred by limitation. It is important to notice that these suits were instituted by Lachhan Kunwar along with other persons who claimed to be the reversionary heirs of Pahlad Singh. As such, those persons would have been entitled to the property on the death of Laohhan Kunwar, but not before. Lachhan Kunwar had been defeated in an attempt to get possession of the property of her husband during the lifetime of Jit Kunwar, her suit against Jit Kunwar being held to be barred by limitation, but setting aside that circumstance, their Lordships held that the suit of Laohhan Kunwar with which they were then dealing was barred by limitation, because Jit Kunwar and her transferees had held possession of the property in dispute for more than twelve years adversely to Lachhan Kunwar. Article 141 schedule II to the Limitation Act had no application to the suit as far as Lachhan Kunwar was concerned, for she was not, in the words of that article a person entitled to possession, on the death of a Hindu femals.” Primâ facie the other plaintiffs in the suit had no right to claim possession during the lifetime of Lachhan Kunwar, but they seem to have contended that they had such a right. It appears to me that, as regards the male plaintiffs, all that their Lordships decided was that the circumstance that Lachhan Kunwar's rights were extinguished did not let in the rights of the reversions. This is what I understand by the following passage in their judgment:—“The contention that although it (i.e, the suit) might be barred as against the son Pahlad and all persons claiming under him, the effect was only to extinguish those rights and to let in the rights of any persons who would claim as reversionary heirs, does not appear to their Lordships to be supported by authority Possibly the word “against” in this passage is a misprint for “regards,” but whether that is so or not their Lordships did not in this case rule that adverse possession against Lachhan Kunwar barred the rights of the male plaintiffs. On the contrary, what they decided was that the rights of those plaintiffs were not accelerated by the circumstance that Lachhan Kunwar's rights had been extinguished by the adverse possession of Jit Kunwar and her transferees.

    In my opinion the Full Bench decision of this Courts is not touched by the decision in Lachhan Kunwar's case. The decision of the Full Bench, as also the decision of their Lordships of the Privy Council in the case of Ruhchordas v. Parvtibai are clear Authorities in favour of the plaintiff in the present case.

    I would therefore accept this appeal, reverse the decree of both the Courts below, and decree the plaintiff's suit with costs in all Courts, and with mesne profits from the date of suit to the date of delivery of possession, or until the expiration of three years from the date of this decree, whichever event first occurs.

    Banerji, J.:— I fully agree with my learned colleague on both the questions which arise in this case.

    As regards the question of limitation, the ruling of their Lordships of the. Privy Council in the recent case of Runchordas Vandravandas v. Parvatibai is conclusive. In that case it was held that under Article 141, Schedule II of the Limitation Act, a suit could be brought by a reversioner for possession of immovable property within twelve years from the date of the death of the last female their, although she may have been out of possession for more than twelve years. With reference to the contention in that case based on section 28 of the Limitation Act that adverse possession against the female extinguished her right, and there was consequently no estate which could go to the reversioner? their Lordships said:—“The learned counsel for the appellant relied on section 28, which provides that at the determination of the period limited for instituting a suit for the possession of property, the right to the property shall be extinguished. The obvious answer to this argument is that in this case the period limited is not determined.” That was a case in which the widows had been out of possession for a much longer period than 12 years. It was held that the suit of the reversioner, which had been brought within twelve years of the date of the death of the survivor of the two widows was not time-barred notwithstanding section 28. The decision of the Privy Council has the effect of affirming the view of the law held by the Full Bench of this Court in Ram Kali v. Kedar Nath , and the dictum of Burkitt, J., in Hanuman Prasad v. Bkagauti Prasad , and the ruling in Tika Ram v. Shama, Charan cannot be followed. I agree with my brother Chamier that the case of Lachhan Kunwar v. Manorath Ram is distinguishable. As my learned colleague has pointed out, all that their Lordships of the Privy Council held in that case in regard to the rights of reversions was that the extinction of the rights of the widow by adverse possession did not let in the rights of any persons who could claim as reversionary heirs, so as to confer on them a right of suit to recover the property in the lifetime of the widow. As the present suit was brought within twelve years of the date of Jai Kunwar's death it was within time under Article 141. The learned Judge was clearly wrong in thinking that the plaintiff's right to obtain the property could accrue upon the death of Amirta. The right of succession to her share devolved upon her death on her surviving sisters and not on the reversioner.

    The decree in the suit brought by Jai Kunwar in 1889 would, in the absence of fraud and collusion, have operated as res judicata had there been any adjudication in that suit upon the question of title. But no such adjudication was made, and the suit was dismissed only on the ground of limitation, that is, on the ground that Jai Kunwar's right to bring the suit was barred by lapse of time.

    For the above reasons I concur with my learned colleague in making the decree proposed by him.

    Appeal decreed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Amrit Dhar v. Bindesri Prasad
    (Jun 25, 1901)