AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sections 195 to 198 of the Criminal Procedure Code as provisions
  • section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act (V of 1881),
  • section. Section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act
  • sections 195 to 199 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act
  • sections 304-A or 326 of the Indian Penal Code
  • sections 14 and 16 of the Limitation Act.
  • section 323 of the Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sections 195 to 198 of the Criminal Procedure Code as provisions
  • section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act (V of 1881),
  • section. Section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act
  • sections 195 to 199 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act
  • sections 304-A or 326 of the Indian Penal Code
  • sections 14 and 16 of the Limitation Act.
  • section 323 of the Indian Penal Code

    Muhammad Ibrahim Sahib v. Shaik Davood (First Accused), First .

    Ayling, J.:— In this case the police preferred a charge sheet against two persons, Shaikh Davood and Muhammad Abu Bakar, for offences under sections 304-A or 326 of the Indian Penal Code by beating one Sultan Marakkayar and causing his death. The magistrate after hearing the prosecution evidence held that death was not the result of the beating and framed a charge under section 323 of the Indian Penal Code only. Accused entered on their defence and adduced evidence. After the close of the defence evidence the defence pleader drew the magistrate's attention to a ruling of the Punjab Chief Court, Labhu v. Emperor(1), and argued that owing to the death of the person injured the charge against the accused must be held to have abated. The magistrate accepted this contention and closed the case without recording any judgment of conviction or acquittal.

    The present Revision Petition is filed by one Muhammad Ibrahim Sahib, son-in-law of the deceased Sultan Marakkayar. He was examined as fourth prosecution witness in the case and it was he who reported the occurrence to the village munsif and to the police (vide Exhibits C and D) on 18th February 1919, the day after the occurrence. Sultan Marakkayar died on 20th February 1919. The police charged the case on 21st March 1919.

    It was found impossible to serve the second accused, Muhammad Abu Bakar, and with the consent of petitioner, the petition in so far as it affected him was dismissed on 29th October 1920. It remains to consider what orders should be passed as regards the case against the first accused, Shaik Davood.

    With all respect to the two learned Judges of the Punjab Chief Court, who have held otherwise in Rama Nand v. Emperor and Labhu v. Emperor(2), I must dissent from the view that a criminal prosecution under section 323 of the Indian Penal Code abates by reason of the death of the person hurt. It appears to be based on what seems to me a mistaken reading of section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act (V of 1881), which runs thus:

    “All demands whatsoever, and all rights to prosecute or defend any suit or other proceeding, existing in favour of or against a person at the time of his decease, survive to and against his executors or administrators, except causes of action for defamation, assault as defined in the Indian Penal Code or other personal injuries not causing the death of the party, and except also cases, where after the death of the party the relief sought could not be enjoyed, or granting it would be nugatory.”

    This provision has no reference to criminal prosecutions, but to civil actions only. The right to institute criminal proceedings, subject to certain limitations contained in sections 195 to 199 of the Criminal Procedure Code with which we are not concerned in this case, is common to any person cognisant of the commission of the offence, and does not exist merely in favour of the person injuriously affected by the offence; The word “prosecute” which occurs in the section implies no connexion with criminal proceedings, but is used in the same sense as in sections 14 and 16 of the Limitation Act. The use of the term “causes of action,” a phrase unknown to the criminal law, is clearly indicative of the scope of the section. section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act being inapplicable, it makes not the slightest difference whether the offence is compoundable or not.

    This is in accordance with the views expressed in In re Ganesh Narayan Sathe(3), Emperor v. Sultan Singh(4), and by this Court in In re Gangamma Dorayya(5).

    I Have already referred to the provisions of sections 195 to 198 of the Criminal Procedure Code as provisions with which we are not now concerned, but I would not be understood as suggesting that the death of the complainant after the institution of the proceedings caused any abatement even in such cases. It was held by this Court in In re Gowdar Kottra, that in the case of a criminal prosecution for adultery, the death of the husband after he had instituted the prosecution did not cause the prosecution to abate.

    I would therefore direct the Magistrate to restore the case to his file and to dispose of it according to law as against first accused, Shaik Davood.

    Coutts Trotter, J.:— I entirely agree and I only add a few words of my own, because there are two reported decisions of the Punjab Chief Court which countenance the view that section 89 of the Probate and Administration Act (V of 1881) applies to criminal as well as to civil proceedings. Ayling, J., has pointed out several considerations that appear to me completely to dispose of such a contention, but there is a further one which reduces it to a positive absurdity. By the section,

    “all rights to prosecute or defend any suit or other proceeding … survive to and against the executors or administrators,”

    with certain defined exceptions. So that if the Punjab view is correct, an executor or administrator can be put in the dock to answer for the criminal acts of his testator. This of course cannot have been pointed out to the learned Judges; but it ought to have occurred to the reporters, who put these decisions in the volumes of reports, and who had ample leisure to consider what was involved in them. With six High Courts, overburdened with work, putting forth a heavy outturn of judgments which they have no time to consider at length except in cases of special importance, some responsibility of discrimination ought to rest on the reporters as to what they select for publication. The present indiscriminate system of reporting everything throws an unnecessary burden on both Bench and Bar; and these cases seem to me to afford a signal instance of the mischief.

    M.H.H

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Muhammad Ibrahim Sahib v. Shaik Davood (First Accused), First .
    (Dec 15, 1920)