The case raises rather an interesting question as regards the true meaning of Sect. 425 of Indian Penal Code. What happened was that the complainant had a wall on the boundary of the accused's land. They had some dispute because the complainant would not let the accused lean the rafters of a building which he desired to erect on the complainant's wall and thereupon the accused dug a trench-along his own land in places going down to lower levels than the foundations of the complainant's wall. The Magistrate took the view, which is doubtless right, that this was done deliberately in order to annoy the complainant and the probable effect of it will be that the complainant's wall in course of time will subside. It is clear ever since the decision of Dalion v. Angus that the right to lateral support from an adjacent land belonging to others is a right which can only be acquired by prescription and by prescription for the required number of 20 years in this country in respect of land in the state in which it has been throughout the period; so that if you put an additional burden on land, by a superstructure, you can have prescriptive rights for the land so burdened, only if you have had 20 years' enjoyment of the land in that condition without any interruption, ‘Mischief’ is defined in Sect. 425 as follows:—“Whoever with intent to cause, or knowing that he is likely to cause, wrongful loss or damage to the public or to any person, causes the destruction of any property, or any such change in any property or in the situation thereof as destroys or diminishes its value or utility or affects it injuriously, commits mischief” “Wrongful loss” is defined by Sect. 23 as being “the loss by unlawful means of property to which the person losing it is legally entitled.” Therefore in order that what happened may come within this section, we must find that what was contemplated and caused was by unlawful means. The question then is, is it unlawful to do something on your own land without trespassing on your neighbour's land which something necessarily causes injurious effects to the property of your neighbour? Dalton v. Angus owns this passage:—“It is the law, I believe I may say without question, that at any time within 20 years after the house is built, the owner of the adjacent soil, may with perfect legality dig that soil away and allow his neighbour's house, if supported by it, to fall in ruins to the ground.” That passage appears to us completely to cover the present case and to make it clear that which the accused did, however malicious it was, was not mischief within the true construction of Sect. 425 of the Indian Penal Code.
We, therefore, think that the conviction must be set aside and that the fine, if paid, must be refunded.
C.KConviction set aside.