Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Case Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by the first accused against his conviction under section 363 of the Indian Penal Code and a sentence of one year rigorous imprisonment imposed by the Fifth Presidency Magistrate, Egmore, Madras. The accused was tried along with another person who was acquitted by the magistrate.

The prosecution evidence established that P.W.1 (an assistant secretary to the Government of Madras) lived with his wife and two daughters: P.W.2 (Rama) and P.W.4 (Savithri). In the months before 30-9-1960 P.W.4 became friendly with the appellant, who lived next door. On 30-9-1960 P.W.2 observed the appellant speaking with P.W.4; P.W.4 told P.W.2 she intended to marry the appellant. P.W.1 took P.W.4 to the house of a relation (P.W.6) to keep her away from the appellant.

On 1-10-1960 P.W.4 left P.W.6's house, telephoned the appellant, met him on Arcot Road, and got into his car. They travelled together to several places: a Sami's house in Mylapore, then to the shop of Govindarajulu Naidu where the appellant purchased two gundus and a thirumangalyam (marked M.O.1(a)), and thereafter to the Registrar's Office where an agreement of marriage (Exhibit P.7(a)) was registered. The appellant made P.W.4 wear the thirumangalyam. They stayed at Ajanta Hotel, then travelled by train on 2-10-1960 to Sattur, later to Sirukulam (staying 10-12 days), then to Coimbatore and Tanjore. The C.I.D. located them and brought them to Madras on 3-11-1960.

P.W.1 filed a complaint (Exhibit P.1) at Nungambakkam Police Station on 1-10-1960 when P.W.4 did not return. There was dispute about P.W.4's age, but the Sub-Registrar's Birth Register (Exhibit P-6 and entry P-6(a)) and the appellant's own admission established P.W.4's date of birth as 13-11-1942, making her a minor on the date of the events.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant's conduct amounted to an offence under section 363 IPC (kidnapping from lawful guardianship) in respect of P.W.4, a female minor.
  2. Whether P.W.4 had, as a matter of law and fact, abandoned her father's guardianship such that the appellant's conduct would not constitute taking a minor out of lawful guardianship.
  3. Whether the sentence of one year rigorous imprisonment imposed by the trial court was excessive and whether leniency should be afforded in view of the relationship between the appellant and P.W.4 and their intent to marry.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • It was argued that the proven facts did not amount to an offence under section 363 IPC because P.W.4 had voluntarily left her father's roof and had resolved not to return, i.e., she had abandoned her father's guardianship.
  • The appellant relied on P.W.4's evidence that she telephoned the appellant, had no intention of returning to her father's house when she left her uncle's house, and that the appellant did not induce her to leave or ask her to marry him; she said it was her suggestion to enter into an agreement of marriage.
  • On sentencing, it was urged that a lenient view should be taken because the friendship was mutual, P.W.4 would attain majority within about a month from the offence, and both intended to marry and settle down; documentary exhibits (referred to as Exs. D-1, P-2 and P-3) supported that the parties had commenced marital life.

Prosecution / Respondent Position

  • The prosecution's case, as reflected by the evidence the court accepted, was that P.W.4 remained under the guardianship and protection of P.W.1 (her father) at all material times, that she had been taken to P.W.6's house to keep her away from the appellant, and that the appellant thereafter took P.W.4 out of her father's guardianship without the father's consent.
  • The prosecution relied on documentary proof of P.W.4's minority (birth register) and witness testimony describing the sequence of events and searches made by P.W.1 and P.W.6 when she did not return.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abdul Azeez v. State, 1952 M.W.N. 231 Consideration of whether proof that a minor had abandoned her guardian with no intention of returning is sufficient to conclude abandonment of guardianship; the decision observed that it depended on the facts of each case. The court noted the appellant relied on this case but distinguished it on the facts, finding no abandonment by the minor here and stating that the proposition relied upon had not been accepted by later decisions of the court.
In Re Abdul Sathar Held that where, but for something the accused consented to do (and did), a minor would not have left, there is sufficient "taking" in law for the purposes of section 363 IPC. The court agreed with this statement of law and applied it to find that P.W.4 would not have left but for the appellant's promise to marry her, thereby constituting taking within s. 363 IPC.
Regina v. Kumaraswami, 1865 2 M.H.C.R. 331 Under facts of a related provision, if a man knowingly goes away with a woman living with her husband in such a way as to deprive the husband of control, it is a "taking" within the meaning of the section (case under s. 498 IPC). The court cited and relied on the principle that deprivation of lawful control by taking a person away can constitute the relevant offence; it used this authority to support the legal concept of "taking" relevant to s. 363 IPC.
In Re Sundara Das Tevan Approval and application of the principle in Regina v. Kumaraswami (relating to deprivation of control). Mentioned as a decision that approved the earlier principle; the court referenced this line of authority in its reasoning about what constitutes taking from lawful guardianship.
Ramaswamy Udayar v. Raju Udayar, 1952 M.W.N. 604; CR. 176 Held that it was not open to a minor in law to abandon her guardian; any amount of abandonment would not take her out of the guardian's keeping. The court cited this decision to support the view that a minor cannot, as a matter of law, abandon her guardian, and found on the facts that the minor here had not abandoned her guardian.
Debaprasad v. The King, 1950 A.I.R. CAL. 406 Contains an observation that if it was proved a minor had abandoned her guardian with no intention of returning, she could not thereafter be deemed to continue in the keeping of the guardian. The court referred to this observation and to commentary in Ramaswamy Udayar which questioned its application; the present court did not accept that a minor's abandonment (as argued by the appellant) took her out of the guardian's keeping on the facts of this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the testimony and documentary evidence sequentially and applied the statutory definition of kidnapping from lawful guardianship (section 361 IPC) and the elements of section 363 IPC.

Key steps in the court's analysis:

  • Age determination: The court relied on the Sub-Registrar's Birth Register (Ex. P-6 and entry P-6(a)) and the appellant's admission to conclude that P.W.4 was born on 13-11-1942 and was therefore a minor on the date of the events; the minor status was thereby clearly established.
  • Assessment of P.W.4's testimony: The court evaluated P.W.4's account that she phoned the appellant, had no intention of returning to her father's house, and that she alone suggested marriage. The court found portions of this testimony not credible, particularly later statements made in re-examination which the court interpreted as attempts to protect the appellant.
  • Guardianship status: The court accepted the evidence of P.Ws.1, 4 and 6 that P.W.4 was living under the protection of her father (P.W.1), had been taken to P.W.6 to keep her away from the appellant, and therefore continued in the guardianship of P.W.1 while at P.W.6's house. The court concluded that she had not abandoned her father's guardianship.
  • Legal effect of inducement/promise: The court applied authority (In Re Abdul Sathar and Regina v. Kumaraswami) to hold that where the accused's conduct (promise to marry and acts done in furtherance) caused the minor to leave the guardian's custody, there is sufficient "taking" within the meaning of s. 363 IPC. The court found that P.W.4 would not have left but for the appellant's promise to marry her.
  • Rejection of abandonment defense: The court considered precedents (including Abdul Azeez, Ramaswamy Udayar, Debaprasad) and concluded, on the facts, that the minor had not abandoned her guardian and that established jurisprudence does not permit a minor to effectually abandon guardianship so as to negate the offence in circumstances like these.
  • Sentencing considerations: The court considered the appellant's plea for leniency (mutual friendship, near attainment of majority by P.W.4, documentary indications of marital life) but emphasized that the offence is against guardianship, is grave in nature, and that inducement by a minor does not excuse the accused. On that basis the court upheld the trial court's sentence as not excessive.

Holding and Implications

Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence confirmed.

Holding (core ruling): The court held that the appellant was guilty of taking P.W.4, a female minor, out of the lawful guardianship of her father without his consent, thereby committing an offence under section 363 IPC. The trial court's sentence of one year rigorous imprisonment was upheld.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The appellant's conviction under section 363 IPC and the one year rigorous imprisonment sentence imposed by the trial court remain in force.
  • Legal significance: The court applied and reaffirmed principles from earlier authorities concerning (a) the inability of a minor effectively to abandon her guardian so as to negate guardianship in law in similar circumstances, and (b) that inducement or a promise by the accused which results in the minor leaving guardian's custody constitutes "taking" for purposes of s. 363 IPC. The judgment treats the offence as grave and does not treat inducement by the minor or the parties' intent to marry as mitigating enough to alter the sentence imposed by the trial court.
  • No broader novel precedent was announced beyond the application of existing authorities to the facts; the outcome is the confirmation of the conviction and sentence on the specific facts presented.

This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion and does not add facts or inferences beyond that text.

    S. Varadarajan Alias Varadan v. State

    This is an appeal by the 1st accused against his conviction under s. 363 I.P.C and sentence of one year rigorous imprisonment passed by the fifth Presidency Magistrate, Egmore, Madras. He was tried along with another accused who was acquitted by the magistrate.

    P.W 1 is an assistant secretary to the Government of Madras in the Department of Industries and Co-operation. He was living in VI Street, Lake Area, Nungambakkam along with his wife and two daughters, Rama P.W 2 and Savithri P.W 4. P.W 2 is the elder and was studying in the Madras Medical College. P.W 4 is the younger and was studying in Ethiraj College. Some months before 30-9-60 P.W 4 became friendly with the appellant. P.W 4 used to go to her College in the College bus. On a few occasions the appellant used to give a lift in his car to P.W 4, The appellant was a neighbour living next door in No. 13, VI Street, Lake Area. P.W 4 and the appellant used to carry on conversation from their respective houses. P.W 2 saw the two carrying on the conversation on a few occasions, and on 30-9-1960 at about 9 a.m when she had occasion to see the appellant talking to P.W 4, she called P.W 4 and questioned her. P.W 4 replied that she was going to marry the appellant. When the father P.W 1 returned at about 11 a.m, P.W 2 informed him of what she heard from P.W 4. P.W 1 questioned P.W 4 and P.W 4 started weeping without uttering a word. Then P.W 1 and P.W 2 took P.W 4 to Kodambakkam to the house of a relation, P.W 6, as P.W 1 wanted to keep her away from the appellant for some time.

    P.W 4 left the house of P.W 6 at about 10 a.m on 1-10-1960. She telephoned to the appellant to come to the main road at Kodambakkam and went to Arcot Road, where she found the appellant with his car. P.W 4 get into the appellant's car, and both of them drove towards Guindy. The appellant was driving the car. They went to one Sami's house in Mylapore. Then they went to the shop of Govindarajulu Naidu in Nethaji Subash Chandra Bose Road, and the appellant purchased from P.W 12 two gundus and a thirumangalyam, M.O 1 (a). Both of them went to the Registrar's Office, and got an agreement of marriage Ex. P.7 (a) registered before the Sub Registrar, P.W 7. Then the appellant made P.W 4 wear the Thirumangalyam. The appellant and P.W 4 went to Ajanta Hotel and stayed there for a day. The appellant purchased two sarees and blouses for P.W 4 on the next day. On 2-10-1960 the appellant and P.W 4 boarded a train for Sattur and stayed in Sattur for a few days, and then went to Sirukulam on 4-10-1960 and stayed there for 10 or 12 days. Afterwards they went to Coimbatore and then to Tanjore where the C.I.D found them and took them to Madras on 3-11-1960.

    As P.W 4 did not return, P.W 6 went to the house of P.W 1 in the evening and asked P.W 2 whether P.W 4 had come there. Soon after P.W 1 returned home, and P. Ws. 1 and 6 went to the Railway Station and various other places and searched for P.W 4. P.W 1 then went to the Nungambakkam Police Station and preferred a complaint Ex. P. 1 on 1-10-1960.

    It is not admitted that P.W 4 was a minor on 1-10-1960, when she left her father's guardianship. P.W 1 stated that P.W 4 was born on 13-11-1942. The entry in the S.S.L.C Register regarding the age of P.W 4 is 10-12-1942, but P.W 1 stated that the age in the S.S.L.C Register was not correct. Ex. P-6 is the Birth Register in the Sub Registrar's Office, Thirukattupalli, and the entry relating to P.W 4 is Ex. P-6 (a). The name of the child is given as Savithri, and the parent's name as Nataraja Iyer and Akilandammal. The date of birth is 13-11-1942, and it was registered on 16-11-1942. P.W 3, the Clerk in the Sub Registrar's Office, proved the book Ex. P-6 and the entry Ex. P-6 (a). P.W 5, the Village Munsif, deposed that he maintained the book Ex. P-6, and that the entry relating to the birth of P.W 4, Ex. P-6 (a), was in his handwriting. The appellant in his statement also admitted that P.W 4 was born on 13-11-1942. Therefore, it has been clearly established that P.W 4 was a minor on the date of the occurrence.

    The learned counsel for the appellant strenuously argued that the facts proved would not amount to an offence under s. 363 I.P.C s. 361, I.P.C defines the offence of kidnapping from lawful guardianship. Whoever takes or entices any minor under eighteen years of age if a female, out of the keeping of the lawful guardian of such minor, without the consent of such guardian, is said to kidnap such minor from lawful guardianship. It was urged that P.W 4 had left her father's roof for good, having resolved not to return to his roof, and therefore the appellant cannot be held to be guilty of taking P.W 4 out of the keeping of the lawful guardian. The learned counsel for the appellant relied on the evidence of P.W 4 herself in support of his plea. P.W 4 stated that it was she who phoned up the appellant at 10 a.m on 1-10-1960. She also stated that when she left the house of her uncle, she had no intention of returning to her father's house and, when she met the appellant at Arcot Road, she told him of her idea of not returning to her father's house. She also stated that the appellant never induced her to come away from the house of her father, nor did he ask her to marry him and it was only she that suggested that they might enter into an agreement of marriage. In her evidence she also made it clear that it was her father that was giving food and protection and that her father never beat her, when he came to know that she intended to marry the appellant. She denied the suggestion that her father threatened to chase her out of his house. She also stated that she had an idea on that day of going away from her father's house. She also denied that she had decided to abandon her father's house for ever and it was her desire to have some days off till she could get the consent of her father. In her re-examination P.W 4 stated that, when she said that it was her desire to marry the appellant, it was because of her intention not to cause harm to the appellant by her evidence in the case. P.W 4 obviously had stated in the latter portion of her evidence, that she left the house of her uncle without any intention of her returning to her father's house, for the purpose of saving the appellant. So also her statement that she told the appellant that she had no idea of returning to her father's house. I am unable to accept this portion of P.W 4's evidence. The evidence of P.Ws 1, 4 and 6 is clear that P.W 4 was living under the protection of P.W 1 and that she was taken to the house of P.W 6 on the evening of 30-9-1960 in order to keep her away from the appellant for sometime. While P.W 4 was in the house of P.W 6, she continued to be in the guardianship of P.W 1. It cannot be stated that P.W 4 ever abandoned the guardianship of her father or left the house of P.W 6 with an intention of not returning to her father's house. The learned counsel for the appellant relied on a decision in Abdul Azeez v. State 1952 M.W.N 231 where it was observed that if it was proved that a minor had abandoned her guardian with no intention of returning back, it could not be deemed to be sufficient to constitute an abandonment of a guardian by a girl. It depended upon the facts of each particular case. On the facts of this case I am clear that there was no abandonment by the minor of the guardianship of P.W 1. The proposition that a minor, who had abandoned her guardian with no intention of returning back, cannot be deemed to continue in the keeping of the guardian has not been accepted by decisions of our Court. In In Re Abdul Sathar2 it was held that where the evidence disclosed that, but for something which the accused consented to do and did ultimately, a minor girl would not have left her husband's house, or would not have been able to leave her husband's house, there was sufficient taking in law for the purposes of s. 363 I.P.C I respectfully agree with the statement of law. In this case the minor, P.W 4, would not have left the house but for the promise of the appellant that he would marry her. In Regina v. Kumaraswami 1865 2 M.H.C.R 331, which was a case under s. 498 I.P.C, it was held that if, whilst the wife was living with her husband, a man knowingly went away with her in such a way as to deprive the husband of his control over her with the intent stated in the section it would be a taking from the husband within the meaning of the section. This decision was approved and followed in a later decision in In Re Sundara Das Tevan4. Somasundaram, J. in Ramaswamy Udayar v. Raju Udayar 1952 M.W.N 604 2; CR. 176 held that it was not open to a minor in law to abandon her guardian. Referring to the observation in Debaprasad v. The King 1950 A.I.R CAL. 406 that if it was proved that a minor had abandoned her guardian with no intention of returning back, she could not thereafter be deemed to continue in the keeping of the guardian, the learned Judge observed that any amount of her abandonment of her guardian would not take her away in law from continuing to be in the keeping of the guardian. In this case it is unnecessary to consider the question whether the minor by herself could abandon the guardianship. In this case I have found as a fact the minor never intended to abandon her guardian or left her father's roof for good.

    On the facts, therefore, there can be no doubt that the appellant is guilty of having taken P.W 4 out of the guardianship of P.W 1 without his consent.

    The lower Court has imposed a sentence of one year rigorous imprisonment. The learned Counsel for the appellant submitted that a lenient view of the sentence may be taken, in view of the fact that the friendship between the appellant and P.W 4 was mutual and perhaps it was due to P.W 4 that the appellant accepted to marry her. It was also submitted that P.W 4 would have attained majority within one month from the date of the offence, and that both P.W 4 and the appellant really intended to marry and settle down in life. The learned Counsel for the appellant also referred to Exs. D-1, P-2 and P-3. In Ex. D-1, P.W 4 requested the appellant to have the marriage celebrated at the earliest opportunity. In Ex. P-2, P.W 4 wrote her father stating that she had commenced her life. In Ex. P-3, a letter written by the appellant to his father, the appellant stated that he had selected a suitable bride and had commenced his wedded life. The offence is against the guardianship and the guardian is entitled to the custody of the minor and the fact that the friendship was induced by the minor cannot be of any avail. The offence is a grave one and I am unable to say that the sentence passed by the trial Court is excessive. The conviction and sentence are confirmed and the appeal is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S. Varadarajan Alias Varadan v. State
    (Mar 22, 1963)