Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 14 of the Constitution of India;viii. Declare that Section 13 of SARFAESI Act, 2002
  • CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 8(5) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002.10.
  • provisions of the SARFAESI Act, in particular, Section 13(8),
  • Order 21 Rule 72A of the Code of Civil Procedure.ix)
  • Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, Rule 8
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002,
  • sub causes (a) to (d). Sub Rule (6)
  • Sub Rule (5) of Rule 8
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 14 of the Constitution of India;viii. Declare that Section 13 of SARFAESI Act, 2002
  • CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 8(5) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002.10.
  • provisions of the SARFAESI Act, in particular, Section 13(8),
  • Order 21 Rule 72A of the Code of Civil Procedure.ix)
  • Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, Rule 8
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002,
  • sub causes (a) to (d). Sub Rule (6)
  • Sub Rule (5) of Rule 8
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The judgment addresses two writ petitions concerning issues related to the same loan account involving multiple mortgaged properties provided as security for the loan extended by the respondent Bank to M/s. P.T Mathai & Sons (P) Ltd. The petitioner in one petition is a guarantor and mortgagor of certain properties. The writ petitions challenge the Bank's exercise of powers under Section 13(4) and Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act, particularly regarding the sale of secured assets. Initially, the Debts Recovery Tribunal dismissed the securitisation application filed by the petitioner but allowed the Bank to proceed with the sale of secured assets. During the pendency of the writ petitions, some mortgaged properties were sold by the Bank. The petitioners seek declarations on the limits of the Bank’s powers, quashing of certain sale orders, and challenge the constitutional validity of Section 13 and Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Bank exercising powers under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act functions as an executing court and whether it can sell the entire property without ascertaining the real market value.
  2. Whether the Bank’s jurisdiction under Section 13(4) is limited to selling only such portion of the property as would satisfy the debt fully and finally.
  3. Whether Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act is ultra vires the statute and unconstitutional under Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
  4. Whether Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act violates the basic features of the Constitution, including Articles 21 and 300A, and should be struck down.
  5. Whether the sale of mortgaged properties by the Bank complied with statutory requirements, including fixation of reserve price and proper valuation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Bank’s powers under Section 13(4) are akin to those of an executing court and should be limited to selling only such portion of property as necessary to satisfy the debt after ascertaining the real market value.
  • Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act is ultra vires and unconstitutional, violating Article 14 of the Constitution.
  • The entire property cannot be sold without proper valuation and fixation of reserve price.
  • The petitioners’ constitutional rights under Articles 14, 21, and 300A are infringed by the Bank’s actions.
  • The sale of properties was conducted without proper procedure, including inadequate notice and undervaluation.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The account was classified as Non-Performing Asset in 2013 and multiple properties were mortgaged as security.
  • The Bank filed recovery applications and obtained permission from the Debts Recovery Tribunal to proceed with sale of secured assets.
  • Properties were valued, and reserve prices fixed; where no bidders emerged, the Bank, under Section 13(5A), bid for the properties.
  • The Bank contends that sales were confirmed after due procedure and that petitioners failed to discharge their liabilities within prescribed timelines.
  • The Bank denies the constitutional and procedural violations alleged by the petitioners.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mardia Chemicals v. Union of India [2004 KHC 584] Upheld the vires of the SARFAESI Act (prior to insertion of Section 13(5A)). Referenced to establish that the SARFAESI Act is constitutionally valid and Section 13(5A) must be examined within that context.
K.T Plantation Private Limited v. State of Karnataka [(2011) 9 SCC 1] Constitutional limits on deprivation of property under Article 300A; public purpose and compensation principles. Used to analyze the constitutional validity of Section 13(5A) and the protection of property rights.
Gnan Das v. Paulin Moraes [1998 (2) KLT 88] Court’s duty to ensure property is not sold at inadequate price; sale limited to portion satisfying debt. Supports the proposition that only necessary portions of property should be sold to satisfy debt.
Narasayya v. Subba Rao [1989 Supp (2) SCC 693] Only such portion of property as satisfies the decree should be sold, not the entire property. Affirmed the principle limiting sale to necessary property portions.
Desh Bandhu Gupta v. N.L Anand and Rajinder Singh [(1994) 1 SCC 131] Sale of property without notice to judgment debtor is null and void. Emphasized mandatory procedural requirements for sale validity.
Lal Chand v. Additional District Judge [(1997) 4 SCC 356] Decree holder cannot bid in auction without prior court permission. Supports procedural safeguards in sale of secured assets.
Mathew Varghese v. M. Amritha Kumar [(2014) 5 SCC 610] Sale without mandatory 30-day notice is illegal; secured creditor acts as trustee of property. Reinforces the requirement of strict adherence to statutory procedure in sales under SARFAESI.
Ram Kishun v. State of U.P [(2012) 11 SCC 511] Requirement of proper valuation and fixing reserve price by authority with application of mind. Supports the necessity of fair valuation and reserve price fixation before sale.
Palpap Ichinichi Software International Ltd. v. Indian Bank [2012 KHC 2353] No statutory prohibition on secured creditor bidding but cannot manipulate reserve price or purchase at reduced rate. Clarifies limits on secured creditor’s participation in auction.
Varghese Ukken v. State Bank Of India [2011 (1) KLT 114] Bid must commence at upset price; sale in decree holder’s name only after court leave. Applied Order 21 Rule 72A CPC principles to auction sales.
Anita Sadana v. Baljinder Kaur [2014 KHC 3393] Sale not in compliance with Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules if valuation report is outdated. Emphasized timely and compliant valuation for sale validity.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considered the constitutional validity of Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act in light of Article 300A and relevant case law. It acknowledged that the SARFAESI Act is a special statute enabling secured creditors to take possession and sell secured assets without court intervention, a validity upheld by the Supreme Court in prior judgments. The Court explained that Section 13(5A) permits the secured creditor to bid for immovable property only if a sale is postponed due to lack of bids meeting the reserve price, which must be fixed through an approved valuer and consultation with the secured creditor as mandated by Rule 8(5) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002.

The Court emphasized that the reserve price fixation and valuation are statutory preconditions before sale and bidding by the Bank’s officer is lawful only when no other bids meet the reserve price. Hence, the provision is not arbitrary nor violative of fundamental rights. The Court rejected the petitioners’ argument that the entire property cannot be sold, stating such factual questions are unsuitable for adjudication in writ petitions under Article 226 and that statutory remedies exist to challenge illegal sales.

The Court also relied on precedents that require proper notice, valuation, and procedural compliance in sales of secured assets, reinforcing that the Bank acts as a trustee and must adhere to statutory safeguards. Since the petitioners did not avail available remedies or demonstrate grounds for interference, the Court found no reason to grant relief.

Holding and Implications

The writ petitions are dismissed.

The Court held that Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act is neither ultra vires nor unconstitutional and that the Bank’s exercise of power to bid for immovable property after postponement of sale due to lack of adequate bids is lawful, provided statutory conditions including valuation and reserve price fixation are complied with. The judgment clarifies that the Bank’s powers under the Act do not violate fundamental rights under the Constitution. The decision directly affects the parties by upholding the Bank’s actions and dismissing the petitioners’ claims, but it does not set any new precedent beyond affirming the existing legal framework governing SARFAESI proceedings.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Roger P. Mathew v. South Indian Bank Limited

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    A.M Shaffique, J.:— The above two writ petitions concern the issues projected by the debtors with reference to the same loan account and hence heard and decided together.

    2. WP(C) No. 26290 of 2014 has been filed seeking the following reliefs:

    “i. Declare that the Bank which is exercising the powers under Sec.13(4) of the SARFAESI Act is exercising the same powers of an Executing Court and it cannot sold out the whole property in realisation of a debt, without ascertaining the real market value of the property.

    ii. Declare that the jurisdiction conferred on a Bank under Sec 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act for conducting a sale is only limited to the extent or portion of the property which would fully and finally satisfy the whole debt amount and in no way more than that and for that purpose the duty is vested with the Bank to ascertain the real market value of the property.

    iii. Call for the records leading to issuance of Exhibit P8 and quash the same by way of issuance of a writ of Certiorari.

    iv. Issue a Writ of Mandamus directing the 1st respondent not to conduct the sale, pursuant to Exhibit P10, till the real market value of the property is assessed and direct 1 respondent to keep all further proceedings pursuant to Exhibit P8 in abeyance, in the interest of justice.

    v. Pass such any other direction, order or reliefs, as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit in the interest of justice, equity and good conscience.

    vi. Call for the records leading to Exhibit P14 and to quash the same by way of issuance of a Writ of Certiorari;

    vii. Declare Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002, as ultra vires the scheme of the statute and unconstitutional as violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India;

    viii. Declare that Section 13 of SARFAESI Act, 2002 as unconstitutional, opposed to basic feature of Constitution of India, violative of Articles 21 and 300A of the Constitution of India, and therefore void, and inoperative and strike down the same, in the interest of justice.”

    3. I need not elaborate on the facts of the present case. but for stating that the petitioner is a guarantor to the overdraft and other facilities granted by the respondent Bank to M/s. P.T Mathai & Sons (P) Ltd. The directors of the company who are guarantors have also mortgaged 12 items of property as security for the loan of which two items of property belong to the petitioner herein. Initially, the writ petition was filed at a stage when the Debts Recovery Tribunal, while dismissing the securitisation application filed by the petitioner permitted the Bank to proceed with sale of secured assets. During the pendency of the writ petition, certain items of mortgaged properties were sold by the Bank. Petitioner therefore amended the writ petition inter alia seeking the aforesaid reliefs.

    4. Counter affidavit has been filed by respondents 1 and 3 controverting the contentions urged on behalf of the petitioners. It is contended that the account was classified as Non-Performing Asset in the year 2013. It is submitted that a total of 14 items of property have been mortgaged with the Bank thereby creating security interest over the property. The Bank had filed O.A No. 564/2013 before the DRT, Ernakulam for recovering a sum of Rs. 20,65,43,369/- which was due as on 19/11/2013. Additional properties were also attached as the mortgaged assets, which were not sufficient to recover the amount due. It is stated that respondents 5 and 6 filed an application in the O.A for releasing their residential/tharavadu property claiming that it is an agricultural property. The property was valued and as permitted by the Tribunal, the property of respondents 5 and 6 were released on them paying Rs. 4.90 Crores. It is further stated that bank attempted sale of property on several occasions but sale did not take place as there were no bidders. Therefore, the Bank sought for permission from the higher authorities to bid the property by invoking Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act and accordingly, the property of the petitioner situated at Panampilly Nagar was bid by the Bank for an amount of Rs. 4,00,01,000/- and the said amount was paid to the authorised officer. The auction was held on 10/10/2014 and the sale has been confirmed. Similarly, another item of property belonging to respondents 7 and 8 was purchased by the Bank at Rs. 2,25,10,000/- and sale certificate has been issued. It is further stated that the petitioner and respondents 3 and 4 were permitted to sell the property by paying the bid amount at 9% interest per annum within 15 days from the date of receipt of the order but no attempt was made to pay the amount. It is further submitted that one another item of property belonging to respondents 5 and 6 was sold for Rs. 1,00,01,000, sale was confirmed and the successful bidder has paid the entire amount. The respondents also denied the other legal contentions raised by the petitioner.

    5. WP(C) No. 28523/2015 has been filed by one of the Directors and his wife seeking the following reliefs:

    “a) Issue a Writ of Mandamus or other appropriate writ, order or direction commanding the 1 respondent bank to consider and dispose Exhibit P1 and P2 applications and thereby permit the petitioners to release their individual property by selling it to 3rd person based on the reserve price so as to pay the sale amount to the loan account of the 1 respondent Bank to discharge that extent of liability.”

    6. 2nd petitioner is also a guarantor who had given certain items of property by mortgage. Petitioners offers to pay the reserve price to release the property from mortgage.

    7. Heard the learned counsel appearing on either side.

    8. The main contention urged by the petitioners is regarding the vires of Section 13(5A) of the Act. The vires of the Act has been upheld by the Court in Mardia Chemicals v. Union of India [2004 KHC 584]. At the relevant time Mardia Chemicals (supra) was decided, Section 13(5A) was not in the statute. The only question to be considered is whether Section 13 (5A) is ultra vires the Statute or unconstitutional. Petitioner submits that the right of the petitioner over the property can be taken away only by due process of law in so far as it is a constitutional right. Reference is made to the judgment in K.T Plantation Private Limited v. State of Karnataka [(2011) 9 SCC 1] wherein the Apex Court, while considering the question regarding claim for enhanced compensation and the scope of Article 300A of the Constitution, held that when a person is deprived of his property, the limitations are implied in Article 300A as well as List III of Entry 42 and a constitutional Court can always examine the validity of statute on those grounds. Paragraphs 170 and 193 are relevant which reads as under:

    “170. Article 300-A, therefore, protects private property against executive action. But the question that looms large is as to what extent their rights will be protected when they are sought to be illegally deprived of their properties on the strength of a legislation. Further, it was also argued that the twin requirements of “public purpose” and “compensation” in case of deprivation of property are inherent and essential elements or ingredients, or “inseparable concomitants” of the power of eminent domain and, therefore, of List III Entry 42, as well and, hence, would apply when the validity of a statute is in question.

    193. Right to property no more remains an overarching guarantee in our Constitution, then is it the law, that such a legislation enacted under the authority of law as provided in Article 300-A is immune from challenge before a constitutional court for violation of Articles 14, 21 or the overarching principle of the rule of law, a basic feature of our Constitution, especially when such a right is not specifically incorporated in Article 300-A, unlike Article 30(1-A) and the second proviso to Article 31-A(1).”

    9. Further reference is made to the following judgments:

    i) Gnan Das v. Paulin Moraes [1998 (2) KLT 88] wherein it is held that it is the duty of the Court to ensure that the property is not being sold at an inadequate price and only Court has to consider whether sale of one item of property or portion of the property, if sold would satisfy the decree debt.

    ii) Narasayya v. Subba Rao [1989 Supp (2) SCC 693] wherein it is held that only such portion as would satisfy the decree should be sold and not the entire property.

    iii) Desh Bandhu Gupta v. N.L Anand and Rajinder Singh [(1994) 1 SCC 131], wherein it is held that sale of property without notice to the judgment debtor is a nullity and sale without following the mandatory requirement is set aside.

    iv) In Lal Chand v. Additional District Judge [(1997) 4 SCC 356], the Apex Court held that the decree holder has no right to bid in auction without prior permission of Court.

    v) In Mathew Varghese v. M. Amritha Kumar [(2014) 5 SCC 610], the Apex Court held that the sale conducted without complying with the mandatory procedure of issuing thirty days notice to the debtor is illegal and is liable to be set aside. It is held that the secured creditor when it comes to the question of realising the dues by bringing the property entrusted with them for sale to realise the money advanced without approaching any Court or Tribunal acts as a trustee and cannot deal with the property in any manner it likes and can be disposed of only in the manner prescribed in the Act. Paragraphs 25 and 30 are relevant which reads as under:

    “25. Having heard the learned counsel for the respective parties and having perused the judgments and the orders impugned in these appeals and other material papers, in the first instance, we wish to deal with the appeal filed against the judgment dated 8-3-2010 in Amritha Reji v. Union Of India. The Division Bench, after holding that the sale was not conducted in a fair and reasonable manner and thereby the borrowers’ rights have been seriously infringed, set aside the sale effected on 28-12-2007, in favour of the appellant and directed the borrowers to give a demand draft for Rs. 2,00,00,000 drawn on a local branch of a nationalised bank in favour of the appellant and hand over the same to him within a period of two months from the date of the judgment. It further held that if the payment was not made, as directed, the sale in favour of the appellant would stand confirmed and the writ appeal would stand dismissed.

    30. Therefore, by virtue of the stipulations contained under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act, in particular, Section 13(8), any sale or transfer of a secured asset, cannot take place without duly informing the borrower of the time and date of such sale or transfer in order to enable the borrower to tender the dues of the secured creditor with all costs, charges and expenses and any such sale or transfer effected without complying with the said statutory requirement would be a constitutional violation and nullify the ultimate sale.”

    vi) In Ram Kishun v. State of U.P [(2012) 11 SCC 511], it was held that law requires a proper valuation report, its acceptance by the authority concerned by application of mind and then fixing the reserve price accordingly. The authority is duty bound to decide as to whether sale of part of the property would meet the outstanding demand. Valuation is a question of fact and valuation of the property is required to be determined fairly and reasonably.

    vii) In Palpap Ichinichi Software International Ltd. v. Indian Bank [2012 KHC 2353], a Division Bench of the Madras High Court held that though there is no statutory prohibition against the secured creditor taking part in the auction, it will not enable them to purchase the property by refixing the market price as well as the reserve price and to purchase the property at such reduced rate.

    viii) In Varghese Ukken v. State Bank Of India [2011 (1) KLT 114], a learned Single Judge of this Court held that the bid has to commence at the upset price which may not be an amount below the reserve price. When the decree holder avails leave granted by the Court, the sale will have to be effected in his name for the reserve price. This judgment was delivered in the light of Order 21 Rule 72A of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    ix) In Anita Sadana v. Baljinder Kaur [2014 KHC 3393] the Division Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court held that when the valuation report was obtained about two years prior to the publication of sale, the sale was not in compliance with Rule 8(5) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002.

    10. While challenging the vires of Section 13(5A), petitioner also submits that the market value of the property has not been properly fixed, the reserve price has not been fixed and the bank had knocked down the properties at a nominal amount.

    11. There cannot be any quarrel to the proposition of law relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioners. However, it has to be considered whether the provision is ultra vires the Constitution. Article 300A of the Constitution of India reads as under:

    “300A: Persons not to be deprived of property save by authority of law.- No person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of law.

    12. The SARFAESI Act is a special statute which permits the mortgagee to take possession and conduct sale or management of the secured asset. The vires of the Act has already been upheld by the Apex Court. In such circumstances, it is not open for the petitioners to contend that the exercise of power by the Bank under the statute amounts to violation of Article 300A of the Constitution of India. The limited question is whether Section 13(5A) of the Act is arbitrary or affect any fundamental right of the petitioners. Section 13(5A) reads as under:

    “13. Enforcement of security interest.-

    (1) xxx

    (5A) Where the sale of an immovable property, for which a reserve price has been specified, has been postponed for want of a bid of an amount not less than such reserve price, it shall be lawful for any officer of the secured creditor, if so authorised by the secured creditor in this behalf, to bid for the immovable property on behalf of the secured creditor at any subsequent sale.”

    13. The Statute itself indicates that in respect of sale of immovable property, for which a reserve price has been specified, is postponed for want of a bid of an amount not less than such reserve price, it shall be open for the secured creditor to authorise an officer to bid for the immovable property on behalf of the secured creditor. What is reserve price of a property? The reserve price of a property is not defined under the Act. In the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, Rule 8 relates to sale of immovable secured assets. Sub Rule (5) of Rule 8 specifies that before effecting sale of the immovable property, the authorised officer shall obtain valuation of the property from an approved valuer and in consultation with the secured creditor, fix the reserve price of the property and may sell the whole or any part of such immovable secured asset by any of the methods specified in sub causes (a) to (d). Sub Rule (6) indicates that the authorised officer shall serve to the borrower a notice of thirty days for sale of the immovable secured assets and if it is being sold by public auction or by inviting tenders, necessary newspaper advertisements are also required to be published showing the reserve price as well. Therefore, fixation of reserve price is a pre-condition to be observed by the authorised officer before effecting sale of the property and it has to be done through an approved valuer and in consultation with the secured creditor. When the secured creditor's right to bid in auction arises at a stage when the auction is postponed for want of a bid for the reserve price fixed by the authorised officer. Only in such an event, the secured creditor is entitled to authorise an officer of the bank to bid for the immovable property on behalf of the secured creditor on any subsequent sale. Therefore this is not an instance where, in all auctions, the secured creditor can authorise an officer to participate in the auction. In an instance where it is found that there are no bidders, such a method can be adopted. The officer can participate in the auction and if there are other bidders, the bank is entitled to proceed further. Therefore I do not think that the statute, in any way, is arbitrary or it violates the fundamental rights of the petitioners, in any manner. There is no reason to grant any of the reliefs, as sought for.

    14. Petitioners have raised a contention that only a portion of the property is required for the purpose of settling the liability which apparently depends upon the value of the property as has been fixed by the authorised officer. Since there are several items of property, such questions of fact cannot be decided in a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The Statute also provides a remedy to challenge the sale, if it is conducted illegally or if any of the measures taken under Section 13(4) is contrary to the rights conferred on the authorised officer on secured creditor. Petitioner in this case has not availed of any such remedies. None of the grounds warrant interference by this Court.

    15. These writ petitions are, hence, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Roger P. Mathew v. South Indian Bank Limited
    (Nov 17, 2016)