AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 3 (1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • Workmen's Compensation Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 3 (1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • Workmen's Compensation Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from an order dated 18 June 1980 by the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Coimbatore, awarding Rs. 18,000 as compensation to the respondent for the death of her husband, Arulswami. The deceased was employed as a laskar responsible for regulating water flow in the Ponneri branch canal of Udumalai canal. Prior to his death, Arulswami had raised complaints about unauthorized alterations and obstructions in the canal affecting irrigation and canal bank safety. On 13 October 1978, while performing his duties under the Junior Engineer's direction, Arulswami was killed. The respondent filed a claim for compensation alleging the death occurred in the course and out of the employment. The appellant, the Superintending Engineer, challenged the claim, contending the death was accidental and contested the compensation award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the death of the deceased arose out of and in the course of his employment under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923.
  2. Whether the appellant is liable to pay compensation to the respondent based on the circumstances of the death.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Although the deceased died in the course of employment, it was not established that his death arose out of his employment.
  • The death was due to an assault and was reported as accidental by the police.
  • The compensation claim is defective as it was filed without disclosing the existence of the deceased's children.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court decision in Mackinnon Mackenzie v. I.M Issak to argue the death did not meet the statutory requirement for arising out of employment.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The deceased's death occurred both in the course and as a result of his employment while discharging his duties.
  • But for performing his employment duties, the deceased would not have been killed.
  • Relied on precedents including Naima Bibi v. Lodhne Colliery Co. (1920) Ltd., Union of India v. Smt. Noor Johan, and Varkeyachan v. Thomman to support the claim that the death arose out of employment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mackinnon Mackenzie v. I.M Issak [(1969) 2 SCC 607 : A.I.R 1970 S.C 1906] Definition and test for "arising out of" and "in the course of" employment under the Workmen's Compensation Act. The court applied the test that injury must result from a risk incidental to employment and that the deceased’s death had a causal nexus with his employment duties.
Naima Bibi v. Lodhne Colliery Co. (1920) Ltd. [1977 — I L.L.N 338] Supporting authority on compensation claims arising from employment-related deaths. Referred to in support of the proposition that death resulting from duties performed in employment qualifies for compensation.
Union of India v. Smt. Noor Johan [1979 — I L.L.N 538] Precedent on the scope of Workmen's Compensation Act in employment-related injuries or deaths. Used to reinforce the finding that the death arose out of employment.
Varkeyachan v. Thomman [1979 — I L.L.N 477] Precedent on employer liability under the Workmen's Compensation Act. Supported the conclusion that the deceased’s death was compensable under the Act.
Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway Company v. Highley [1917 A.C 352] Test for determining whether an accident arose out of employment based on whether it was part of the injured person’s employment to hazard or suffer the cause of injury. The court approved this test to establish the causal connection between the deceased’s employment and the accident causing death.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the facts that the deceased, Arulswami, reported for duty on the day of his death and was engaged in regulating water flow in the canal as part of his employment. The court applied the statutory test under Section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, requiring that injury must arise out of and in the course of employment. The court relied on the Supreme Court's interpretation in Mackinnon Mackenzie v. I.M Issak, which clarified that "in the course of employment" means during the work assigned and incidental thereto, and "arising out of employment" requires a causal connection between the employment and the injury.

The court found that the deceased’s death was caused by an assault linked to his official duties of regulating water flow, as he had made complaints about unauthorized water diversion affecting irrigation. This created a peril directly connected to his employment. The court held that the risk faced was not personal but incidental to the employment, establishing a proximate causal nexus. There was no evidence that the deceased contributed to or aggravated the peril. Thus, the death arose both out of and in the course of employment, attracting employer liability under the Act. The court maintained the compensation award of Rs. 18,000, as no dispute was raised on quantum.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the appeal and upheld the compensation order of Rs. 18,000 awarded to the respondent. The decision confirms that death caused by risks incidental to employment duties, even if due to assault by third parties, qualifies for compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act. The ruling directly affects the parties by affirming the appellant’s liability to pay compensation to the respondent. No new legal precedent beyond the application of established principles was set.

    Superintending Engineer, Parambikulam Aliyar Project, Pollachi v. Smt. Andammal

    1. This is an appeal at the instance of the Superintending Engineer, Parambikulam Aliyar Project, against the order of the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Coimbatore, dated 18 June, 1980, in W.C No. 31 of 1980, awarding compensation in a sum of Rs. 18,000 to the respondent herein for the death of her husband. The deceased husband of the respondent, one Arulswami, was employed as a laskar in the Ponneri branch canal of Udumalai canal between kilometres 12 and 15 and it was his duty to regulate the flow of water in the branch canal by operating upon the sluices and shutters under the directions of the Junior Engineer-in-charge of Udmalai canal. On 30 September, 1978, Arulswami addressed a letter to the Junior Engineer drawing his attention to the cutting of the canal bank near the left branch canal of Udumalai canal near survey No. 203, in East Tnanthoni village at the instance of one Arumugha Gounder and stating that as a result of that it was difficult for men to walk along the bank and also to use cycles. Arulswami had also requested that suitable action should be taken regarding this. Again Arulswami had addressed another letter to the Junior Engineer informing him that the flow of water had been obstructed in the right branch canal and after removing the bricks in the bank, water had been made to overflow in Kannimar pond and therefrom the owners of survey Nos. 205 and 114 in Thanthoni village were irrigating their fields with water, with the result that the cultivators in the lower reaches of the canal had been affected besides resulting in damage to the canal bank. A personal inspection by the Junior Engineer had been requested for taking further action. While matters stood thus, on 13 October, 1978, Arulswami had met the Junior Engineer at 7.30 A.M and informed him of what had happened and requested him to come in person and do the needful as some persons were obstructing him in the discharge of his duties. Thereupon, the Junior Engineer directed Arulswami to do his duty and assured him that he would come there in person and pursuant to the oral orders of the Junior Engineer, Arulswami went about performing his duty in the matter of regulating the water in the canal by opening and closing the shutters and sluices, and finally, when he went to the sluice where there was some trouble referred to earlier, he was done to death. Alleging that Arulswami met with his death in the course of his employment and also out of his employment and that he was earning a sum of Rs. 210 per mensem at the time of his death, the respondent herein filed W.C No. 31 of 1980, before the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Coimbatore, praying for payment of compensation in a sum of Rs. 18,000.

    2. This application was resisted by the appellant herein on the ground that though the deceased Arulswami was employed by the department as a laskar and he had also put in more than seven and a half years of service on the date of his death on 13 October, 1978, Arulswami was found floating in the canal and on a complaint made to the police since some injuries were found on his head, it was reported that it was a case of accidental death and that the claim for compensation in a sum of Rs. 18,000 made by the respondent alone without disclosing the existence of the children, cannot be entertained.

    3. Before the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, the respondent alone was examined in chief, and she was not even cross-examined by the appellant. On a consideration of the materials made available, the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Coimbatore, found that Arulswami succumbed to death owing to an assault by some people who were inimically disposed towards him in connexion with his employment in the release of water for the purpose of irrigation and that he died due to an accident which arose out of and in the course of his employment. Since the deceased was in the wage group of Rs. 200 to Rs. 300 the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Coimbatore, proceeded to award a sum of Rs. 18 000 to the respondent in accordance with Sch IV of the Workmen's Compensation Act. It is the correctness of this order that is challenged in this civil miscellaneous appeal.

    4. The principal contention of the learned Additional Government Pleader, on behalf of the appellant, is that though it may be that the said Arulswami met with his death in the course of his employment, it cannot be taken to have been established that his death resulted out of his employment as he was done to death and, therefore, inasmuch as this requirement has not been substantiated, the award of compensation to the respondent cannot be sustained. Reliance in this connexion was placed upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Mackinnon Mackenzie v. I.M Issak, [(1969) 2 SCC 607 : A.I.R 1970 S.C 1906]. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the facts inferable in this case, which are as good as facts established on evidence, show that the deceased met with his death not only in the course of his employment, but as a result of his employment and in the discharge of his duties while regulating the flow of water in the canal, and that but for the performance of the duties in regulating water in the canal, the deceased would not have met with his death, and, therefore, this is a case where death had taken place not only in the course of the employment, but also out of the employment of the deceased as a laskar and as such, the award of compensation is quite correct. In support of his submission, the learned counsel drew attention to the decision in Naima Bibi… v. Lodhne Colliery Co. (1920) Ltd.…., (1920), Ltd., [1977 — I L.L.N 338], Union of India v. Smt. Noor Johan, [1979 — I L.L.N 538] and Varkeyachan v. Thomman, [1979 — I L.L.N 477].

    5. Under S. 3 (1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, the liability of the employer to pay compensation arises if an injury is caused to the workman by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment. The respondent, in the course of her evidence, has stated that on the morning of 13 October, 1978, her husband reported to duty as usual stating that he would be back home for lunch, but that he did not come as promised and that she learnt that evening that he died. Her further evidence is that she went to the hospital at Udumalpet where she was told that somebody had beaten him up and that she did not know who did that or why. That there were disputes between the deceased and others in the matter of regulation of water in the ??? has also been spoken to by her and she has specifically stated that the disputes arose only out of the employment. There has been absolutely no cross-examination even on this evidence.

    6. The materials made available in this case clearly establish beyond doubt that Arulswami reported to duty as usual on 13 October, 1978, and had also gone about discharging his duties of regulating the water in the branch canal of Udumalai canal. It was in the course of discharging his duties in the matter of regulation of water in the canal that Arulswami had met with his end and, therefore, it is manifest that the deceased died while in the course of his employment. The question, is, whether, having regard to the circumstances under which Arulswami died, his death can be said to arise out of his employment The proper test to be applied for determining the question whether an accident arose out of employment or not has been laid down by the Supreme Court in Mackinnon Mackenzie v. I.M Issak, [(1969) 2 SCC 607 : A.I.R 1970 S.C 1906] (vide supra). The Supreme Court has pointed out that the expression “in the course of employment” means “in the course of the work which the workman is employed to do and which is incidental to it”. The expression “arising out of employment” should be understood, according to the Supreme Court, to mean that

    “during the course of the employment, injury has resulted from some risk incidental to the duties of the service, which, unless engaged in the duty owing to the master, it is reasonable to believe, the workman would not otherwise have suffered”.

    In other words, there must be a causal relationship between the accident and the employment and if the accident had occurred on account of a risk which is an incident of the employment, then the claim for compensation must succeed, unless the workman had by his own imprudent act exposed himself to an added peril. It was also pointed out by the Supreme Court that in the case of death caused by the accident, the burden of proof, no doubt, rests on the dependants of the deceased workman to prove that the accident arose out of employment as well as in the course of employment, but that it may be inferred when the facts proved justify the inference.

    7. In this case, the deceased had to be in the place where he was done to death in the course of his employment for discharging his duties. By reason of his being in the particular place, he had to face the indignant agriculturists who had unauthorizedly diverted the water from the canal and about whom he had made a complaint to the Junior Engineer and by reason of that, the deceased had to face a peril and the accident resulting in his death was caused by reason of such peril which the deceased was obliged to face. In such a situation, there was a causal connexion between the accident and the employment and the deceased did not face any peril which was something personal to him in the sense that any other person in the place of the deceased would also have to face the same peril at the hands of the indignant agriculturists who had unauthorizedly taken water from the canal. In other words, the accident had taken place out of a peril which was very closly and intimately linked up with the performance of the duties of the deceased and thereby a causal connexion is established between the employment and the accident. Indeed, in Mackinnon Mackenzie v. I.M Issak, [(1969) 2 SCC 607 : A.I.R 1970 S.C 1906], referred to earlier, the following test laid down by Lord Summer in Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway Company v. Highley, [1917 A.C 352], has been approved:

    “there is, however, in my opinion, one test which is always at any rate applicable, because it arises upon the very words of the statute, and it is generally of some real assistance. It is thus: Was it part of the injured person's employment to hazard, to suffer or to do that which caused his injury? If yes, the accident arose out of his employment. If Bay, it did not, because, what was not part of the employment to hazard, to suffer, or to do, cannot well be the cause of an accident arising out of the employment. To ask if the cause of this was within the sphere of the employment or was one of the ordinary risks of the employment, or reasonably incidental to the employment, or conversely was an added peril and outside the sphere of the employment, are all different ways of asking whether it was a part of his employment, that the workman should have acted as he was acting, or should have been in the position in which he was, whereby in the course of that employment he sustained injury”.

    Applying the aforesaid test, in this case, it is clear that the injury sustained by the deceased was connected with his work and there was necessary nexus between the work and the injury resulting in his death. It has also to be remembered that but for the employment of the deceased he would not have been at the place where the accident happened and causal and proximate connexion between the accident and the employment is also established. There is no evidence in this case to indicate that by any action on his part the deceased either added to the peril or otherwise enlarged it and under these circumstances, it has to be held on the uncontradicted testimony of the respondent that the deceased met with his death only as a result of an accident which arose out of and also in the course of employment under the appellant and, therefore, the appellant was liable to pay compensation in accordance with the provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act. No point was raised touching upon the quantum of compensation and hence the award of Rs. 18,000 to the respondent has to be maintained.

    8. Consequently, the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 250.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Superintending Engineer, Parambikulam Aliyar Project, Pollachi v. Smt. Andammal
    (Feb 4, 1983)