Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The employees of the Coimbatore District Co-operative Central Bank, members of the appellant-union, issued a strike notice and went on strike starting 17 April 1972 due to unmet demands. The management initiated disciplinary proceedings against 76 workmen, issuing charge memos alleging wilful absence, participation in an illegal strike, instigation of other employees to join the strike, and threats to loyal employees. The workmen did not participate in the disciplinary enquiry, which was held ex parte, resulting in punishments including stoppage of increments for 1 to 4 years, confirmed suspension without salary or subsistence allowance during suspension, reinstatement on 23 January 1973, and warnings against future misconduct.

Following the enquiry, the workers raised an industrial dispute challenging the punishments. After conciliation failed, the Government, by G.O Rt. 758 Labour and Employment dated 19 April 1976, declined to refer the dispute for adjudication, providing specific reasoning for each issue raised. This writ petition was filed to quash the Government's order declining the reference.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Government's discretion under Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act to refer or not refer an industrial dispute was exercised lawfully in this case.
  2. Whether the Government erred by going into the merits of the dispute instead of limiting itself to the question of making a reference or not.
  3. Whether the order declining reference with respect to the 53 workers (excluding 23 supervisory staff) was sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bombay Union of Journalists v. State of Bombay [A.I.R 1964 S.C 1617] Limits on Government discretion under Section 10 to refer disputes; discretion cannot be arbitrary or go into merits. Established the principle that the Government should not decide the merits of disputes but only whether a dispute exists to warrant reference.
Workmen of Syndicate Bank, Madras v. Government of India [1985 — I L.L.N 589] Restriction on Government discretion for dismissal or removal disputes under Section 2-A and 10. Distinguished from the present case; cited to clarify scope of discretion under Section 10.
Ram Avtar Sharma v. State of Haryana [1985 — II L.L.N 280] Clarification of Government's discretion under Industrial Disputes Act. Supported the limitation of Government discretion in refusing reference.
Balakrishnan v. Government of Tamil Nadu [1987 — I L.L.N 580] Judicial interpretation of Government discretion under Industrial Disputes Act. Used to reinforce the principle that Government cannot go into merits while deciding reference.
Madhya Pradesh Irrigation Karamchari Sangh v. State of Madhya Pradesh [1985 — I L.L.N 781] Scope of Government discretion under Section 10; limited jurisdiction to reject patently frivolous demands. Emphasized that adjudication of demands is for the Tribunal, not the Government; Government may only refuse reference if the dispute is patently frivolous.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the Government's order declining to refer the dispute and found that the Government improperly went into the merits of the dispute rather than restricting itself to the question of whether to refer the dispute for adjudication. The Government's reliance on the fact that charges were proved during the management's enquiry and its view that certain actions were not punishments were deemed impermissible. The Court held that issues such as stoppage of increments, non-payment of salary and subsistence allowance during suspension, and warnings against misconduct are substantive demands that must be adjudicated by the Industrial Tribunal. The Court further observed that 23 of the 76 workers were supervisory staff and thus not workmen under the Industrial Disputes Act, so the Government's refusal to refer their disputes was not interfered with. However, as to the remaining 53 workers, the refusal to refer was unsustainable because the Government improperly decided the merits rather than the existence of a dispute.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed and the impugned Government order declining to refer the dispute is set aside with respect to the 53 workers who are not supervisory staff.

The Government is directed to reconsider the question of reference strictly on the basis of whether a dispute exists or is apprehended, without delving into merits, and to issue a revised order within three months. There is no order as to costs. The decision directly affects the parties by mandating reconsideration of the reference issue but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond reiterating established principles regarding Government discretion under Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act.

    Workmen Of The Coimbatore District Co-Operative Central Bank Employees' Association v. Secretary To Government, Department Of Labour And Employment

    Ramaswami, J.:— The employees of the Coimbatore District Co-operative Central Bank, who were the members of the appellant-union, issued a strike notice and struck work from 17 April, 1972, on the ground that certain of their demands had not been met by the management. The management took disciplinary proceedings alleging various acts of misconduct and issued a charge memo against 76 workmen. The acts of misconduct alleged against the workmen, for which the show-cause notice was issued, were

    (1) that they wilfully absented themselves from attending duty on 17 April, 1972,

    (2) that they participated in the illegal and unjustified strike organised by the appellant-union from 17 April, 1972, and wantonly refused to report for duty,

    (3) that they instigated other loyal employees of the bank to desert their normal duties and participate in the strike, and

    (4) that they threatened other loyal employees to participate in the illegal strike with a view to create apprehension of danger in their minds if they attended the normal duties.

    The workers refused to take part in the disciplinary enquiry and, therefore, the enquiry was held ex parte and the following punishments were imposed uniformly on all the 76 workmen, and they are as follows:

    (1) Stoppage of increment for 1 to 4 years with cumulative effect;

    (2) suspension pending enquiry was confirmed and the workmen would not be entitled to any salary or subsistence allowance, during the period of suspension, i.e, from 17 April, 1972 to 16 January, 1973;

    (3) the workmen were to join duty on 23 January, 1973; and

    (4) they were warned not to commit acts of misconduct in future.

    It may be mentioned that pending the enquiry they were under suspension and some workmen were also transferred to other sections. The workmen thereupon made demands on the management and raised an industrial dispute challenging the punishments given to them. But the management insisted upon holding to that position. Conciliation having failed, the Government, on receipt of the conciliation failure report and on a consideration of the entire facts and circumstances, in G.O Rt. 758 Labour and Employment, dated 19 April, 1976, declined to refer the dispute for adjudication and the said Government order is extracted below:

    “The Government have considered the conciliation report of the Labour Officer III, Coimbatore, submitted in the reference first read above in regard to the dispute between the workmen represented by the Coimbatore District Co-operative Central Bank Employees' Association, Coimbatore, and the Management of the Coimbatore, District Co-operative Central Bank, Ltd., Coimbatore, and they pass the following orders:

    Issue No. I: Stoppage of increments ranging from one to four years with cumulative effect.

    It is seen that the charges are held proved against each individual during the enquiry conducted by the management.

    Issue No. II: Non-payment of salary for the suspension period; and

    Issue No. IV: Warning against committing misconduct in future. These actions of the management are not punishments.

    Issue No. III: Non-payment of subsistence allowance for the period that is, from 17 April, 1972 to 16 January, 1973.

    It is seen that the 53 workmen mentioned in the annexure of this order are eligible for subsistence allowance during the period of suspension and that others have ceased to be workmen under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, since their work is supervisory in nature. Orders will issue separately by the Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Madras, regarding the quantum of subsistence allowance to be paid during the period of suspension.

    Issue No. V: Transfer to other sections.

    It has been reported that this issue has since been settled.

    The Government do not, therefore, refer the above issues for adjudication.” [The annexure is omitted.]

    It is to quash the order declining to make reference this writ petition has been filed.

    2. At the outset it is to be mentioned that out of the 76 workers, against whom disciplinary proceedings were taken, as found by the Government 23 were holding positions in a supervisory capacity and, therefore, they are not workmen within the meaning of that word under the Industrial Disputes Act and the dispute between them and the management, therefore, cannot be considered to be an industrial dispute and the declining by the Government to refer the dispute in respect of these 23 persons cannot be interfered with in this writ petition. It may also be mentioned that there is no evidence to show that they are not holding positions of supervisory character nor is there any specific allegation in the affidavit that they were not holding positions of supervisory character and are workmen and hence the order declining to refer the dispute between them and the management is in no way illegal. Therefore, this judgment relates only to the 53 persons whose names are given in the annexure to the Government order.

    3. Number of cases have been cited at the Bar relating to the scope of the jurisdiction of the Government under S. 10 of the Act in referring or refusing to refer an industrial dispute for adjudication. We are not referring to these cases which related to the dismissal or removal or other termination covered by S. 2-A because the discretion vested in the Government under S. 10 in regard to that dispute has been considerably restricted, in view of the decisions of the Supreme Court in Bombay Union of Journalists v. State of Bombay [A.I.R 1964 S.C 1617], Workmen of Syndicate Bank, Madras v. Government of India [1985 — I L.L.N 589], Ram Avtar Sharma v. State of Haryana [1985 — II L.L.N 280] and Balakrishnan v. Government of Tamil Nadu [1987 — I L.L.N 580] (decision of one of us — V. Ramaswami, J.)

    4. Though the decisions dealing with other cases have noted that there is a discretion vested in the Government either to refer or not to refer, they also hold that neither the discretion could be exercised arbitrarily, nor capriciously, nor can the Government in exercise of that discretion go into the merits of the claim and decide the dispute which is to be adjudicated upon by the Labour Court. Any decision by the Government or the reasons for that decision should be with reference to the making of the reference or refusing to refer and not to the nature of the dispute or the merits of the dispute. Supreme Court, with reference to disputes other than the one falling under S. 2-A, in Madhya Pradesh Irrigation Karamchari Sangh v. State of Madhya Pradesh [1985 — I L.L.N 781], after referring to the decision in the Bombay Union of Journalists v. State of Bombay (vide supra), observed in Para. 4, at page 784:

    “… Therefore, while conceding a very limited jurisdiction to the State Government to examine patent frivolousness of the demands, it is to be understood as a rule, that adjudication of the demands made by workmen should be left to the Tribunal to decide. Section 10 permits appropriate Government to determine whether a dispute ‘exists or is apprehended’ and then refer it for adjudication on merits. The demarcated functions are:

    (1) reference,

    (2) adjudication …”

    Therefore, one of the grounds on which a reference may be rejected is that the issue or demand is patently frivolous. Even with a view to decline the reference, the Government should be very slow to permit an examination of the demand itself, which is to be adjudicated upon by the Tribunal.

    5. In this case, the impugned order of the Government had not restricted its jurisdiction to the question of making a reference or no reference, but they have tried to go into the question on merits. So far as the first punishment of stoppage of increment ranging from one to four years with cumulative effect is concerned, I find that the order states that the charges are already proved during the enquiry held by the management. One of the reasons for rejecting the reference is that the charges have been proved. This is not permissible, nor are we in a position to accept the statement in the order that the order of suspension as a substantive punishment and depriving the workers of salary during the period or the subsistence allowance during the period against (sic) in law not to punishment. Even this statement in the Government order is referred to as relatable to the warning of each against misconduct in future. The disputes relating to the non-payment of subsistence allowance and depriving of salary during the period of suspension, when it is made a substantive punishment, are all substantive demands which have to be decided on merits by the Industrial Tribunal at the time of adjudication. Punishments given also depend on the question whether there was any illegal strike as charged by the management, for which the punishment alone is not the criterion. The charges are also to be taken into account.

    6. In the circumstances, the order of the Government declining to make a reference cannot be sustained so far as the 53 workers mentioned in the annexure are concerned, as the Government had gone on the merits of the claim and decided it and on that basis refused to refer it.

    7. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed and the impugned order is set aside so far as the 53 workers are concerned, with a direction to the Government to reconsider the same in the light of the observations made in the judgment, restricting the consideration to a question of making a reference or no reference. The revised order will have to be made within a period of three months from the date of receipt of this order. There will be no order as to costs.

    8. The Periyar District Central Co-operative Bank Employees' Union has filed Civil Miscellaneous Petition No. 9192 of 1986 to implead them as party appellants in Writ Appeal No. 184 of 1981. This is on the ground that out of the 76 workmen, who were involved in the dispute, 24 have since been transferred to, Periyar District and, therefore, they have to be shown separately as parties. We do not think that it is necessary to implead them as parties, because the dispute related to an earlier period when they were workmen in the Coimbatore District Co-operative Central Bank, Coimbatore, and the Government will take note of the transfer of these people to Periyar District and make appropriate orders if they are not covered by the 23 people who are in a supervisory character.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Workmen Of The Coimb... v. Secretary To Governm...
    (Jul 9, 1987)