Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Dawson Miller, C.J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff (landlord) instituted a suit against a number of his tenants in mauza Mangarpal claiming enhancement of rent under Section 30 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. Other reliefs were pleaded but not material here.

At trial the Munsiff held for the plaintiff under Section 30A, finding the rents were below prevailing rates and assessed rents accordingly. On appeal the Subordinate Judge held the claim under Section 30(a) barred by Section 31B, dismissed that claim but found ground for enhancement under Section 30(b).

The plaintiff appealed further to this Court (second appeal). This Court held that the claim under Section 30(a) was not barred, remanded the case to the Subordinate Judge to determine whether the tenants' rents were below prevailing rates in the village and directed that the method laid down in Brij Behari Singh v. Sheoshankar Jha should be followed. The Court also directed that the prevailing-rate inquiry should take account of both zapti and taufir lands and that, if it proved impossible to arrive at prevailing rates on the record, a commission for local investigation could be issued.

On remand the Subordinate Judge concluded the record lacked sufficient material to ascertain prevailing rates and ordered a commission for local investigation. The present application (under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Section 107 of the Government of India Act) is by the plaintiff seeking to set aside that commission order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Subordinate Judge's order directing a commission to issue for a local investigation should be set aside (this is the central relief sought in the application under Section 115 CPC and Section 107 of the Government of India Act).
  2. Whether, in ascertaining prevailing rates of rent in mauza Mangarpal, the court must take account of both zapti and taufir lands (and specifically whether rates payable by tenants of taufir lands must be included).
  3. Whether comparisons for determining prevailing rent should treat diara lands and karari lands separately (i.e., whether land of a particular description should be compared only with lands of the same description and class, notwithstanding alleged changes in relative productivity).

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant / Plaintiff

  • The plaintiff sought to set aside the Subordinate Judge's order directing a commission and to have rents determined on the materials already on the record.
  • The plaintiff (referred to as the petitioner in part of the opinion) contended that Raghunath Tola no longer formed part of the mauza as defined by Section 3 of the Bengal Tenancy Act (and therefore its khatian need not be produced or considered).

Respondents / Defendants

  • The defendants insisted that the khatian of Raghunath Tola (said to form part of the village) had not been included in the record and that the rates prevailing in that part of the mauza were therefore not before the court — hence they pressed for a local investigation by commission.
  • The defendants suggested that the admitted similarity between zapti and taufir lands as recorded in earlier assessments (1903 settlement evidence) might not hold presently — i.e., the evidence of similarity might be outdated and hence a commission was required.
  • The learned Subordinate Judge also relied upon observed present conditions (e.g., diara lands sometimes being at least as productive as karari lands despite lower rates) to justify refusing comparison on the basis of historical block-entry classifications and to support the need for a local investigation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Brij Behari Singh v. Sheoshankar Jha Provides the method to be followed for ascertaining prevailing rates of rent in the village (the procedural method referred to by this Court in remanding the case). The Court directed that the Subordinate Judge should proceed according to the method laid down in this case when determining whether the rents paid were below prevailing rates; the remand was explicitly to apply that method.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the Subordinate Judge's three stated grounds for ordering a commission and addressed them in turn.

1. Raghunath Tola omission:

  • The Court noted Raghunath Tola is a small tola about three miles from mauza Mangarpal and appears to have formed part of the mauza before 1903. The Court observed that, even if it still appertains to the mauza, the defendants could be given a reasonable opportunity to produce the khatian for that tola without the necessity of a commission.
  • However, before requiring production of that khatian, it must be clearly shown that Raghunath Tola is part of the village as defined by Section 3 of the Bengal Tenancy Act; the Court declined to make that determination on the present record.

2. Whether zapti and taufir lands remain comparable (the "1903" issue):

  • The Court found the Subordinate Judge had erred in treating the evidence as relating to 1903. In fact, the recorded evidence related to the state of affairs existing at the time of the suit.
  • The Court held the findings at trial were emphatic and conclusive that lands of a particular chakla in the taufir lands were in every respect similar to lands of the same chakla in the zapti lands, and that lands within one chakla, whether zapti or taufir, are similar and have similar advantages. These were issues litigated at trial and resolved against the defendants; the Court held they could not now be relitigated as a basis for commissioning a local investigation.

3. Comparison of diara and karari lands:

  • The Subordinate Judge had relied on observed present productivity (some diara lands rated lower but appearing equally or more productive than karari lands) to argue against simple block-based comparisons. The Court answered that this phenomenon was known at the time of the 1903 settlement and was expressly recognised: diara lands were rated lower because tenants in the diara block are exposed to larger risks and therefore rents are lower despite similar productive powers.
  • The Court held that, if there had been any recent change in relative values, it was for the defendants to produce evidence at trial; they failed to do so. The presumption therefore is continuity of the established distinctions between diara and karari lands, and defendants may not, at this stage, re-open matters they should have raised before the Munsiff.
  • The Court concluded karari lands must be compared with karari lands and diara with diara, whether in taufir or zapti; the only contest at trial was between zapti and taufir lands.

Overall assessment:

  • The Court considered that ordering a local investigation on the lines suggested by the Subordinate Judge would cause a "calamitous waste of time and money", determine rights on an improper basis, unnecessarily prolong a litigation that had already lasted several years, and cause irreparable loss.
  • The Court therefore exercised its powers of superintendence and revision to prevent such an enquiry. The result: the Subordinate Judge was directed to decide the rents upon the materials already on the record, subject to permitting the defendants an opportunity (within a reasonable time to be fixed) to produce the khatian for Raghunath Tola if they can show it still forms part of the village under Section 3.
  • In arriving at prevailing rates, the Subordinate Judge must compare diara with diara and karari with karari, and take into account both zapti and taufir lands as previously directed.
  • On retrospective effect, the Court expressed doubt as to how far the court could make any enhancement retrospective. It considered it would be a hardship on tenants to make excess rates retrospective to the date of suit, and observed that Section 36 of the Act allows the Subordinate Judge to make an order less harsh upon tenants. The ordinary course (for back rents) is laid down in Section 154 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, but the Court left these matters to the exercise of the Judge's discretion on remand.

Holding and Implications

CORE RULING: The application to set aside the Subordinate Judge's order directing a commission for local investigation was allowed in substance: the Court intervened to prevent the commission and directed that the Subordinate Judge decide rents on the materials on the record, subject to a limited opportunity for the defendants to produce the khatian of Raghunath Tola if they can show it still forms part of the village as defined in Section 3 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.

Consequences and practical implications:

  • The Subordinate Judge must determine prevailing rates following the method previously directed (including consideration of both zapti and taufir lands) and compare diara lands only with diara lands and karari with karari lands of the same class.
  • The defendants retain a procedural right to produce the khatian for Raghunath Tola within a reasonable time if they establish that the tola still forms part of the mauza under Section 3; the Court considered that producing the khatian does not require a commission.
  • The Court signalled reluctance to allow any retrospective enhancement of rents back to the commencement of the suit as unfair to tenants, and noted the Subordinate Judge's discretion under Section 36 to mitigate hardship; the ordinary rule on retrospective rents is in Section 154. The Court left these matters for the Subordinate Judge to decide in his discretion on remand.
  • The costs of the present application were ordered: each party to bear their own costs. The costs of the proceedings before the Subordinate Judge (which the Judge reserved) will be decided by him after complying with the directions given.
  • No broad new legal principle or precedent was announced beyond applying the previously cited method (Brij Behari Singh v. Sheoshankar Jha) and applying established provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act; the decision's direct effect is the setting aside of the commission order and the specific remand directions described above.

Disposition on costs: The order for the costs of the present application is that each party will bear his own costs. Costs before the Subordinate Judge are to be determined by him after compliance with the directions.

Foster, J. concurred with the reasons and conclusion given by Dawson Miller, C.J.

    Ramji Ram v. Ramasre Raut

    Dawson Miller, C.J:— This is an application on behalf of the plaintiff under Section 115 of the CPC and Section 107 of the Government of India Act asking us to set aside an order of the Subordinate Judge directing a commission to issue for a local investigation to arrive at the prevailing rate of rent of the mauza. The suit out of which the application arises was instituted by the landlord against a number of his tenants in mauza Mangarpal claiming enhancement of rent under Section 30 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. Other reliefs were claimed in the plaint but these are not material for present purposes.

    2. The Munsiff before whom the case came for trial held that the plaintiff was entitled to enhancement under Section 30A of the Bengal Tenancy Act on the ground that the rents were below the prevailing rates of rent of lands of a similar description and with similar advantages in the same village and he assessed the rents accordingly. The Subordinate Judge on appeal held that the claim under Section 30(a) was barred by the provisions of Section 31B and dismissed the claim under Sec. 30(a) but directed that there was ground for enhancement under Sec. 30(b).

    3. The plaintiffs being dissatisfied with that decision appealed to this court. This court on second appeal held that the claim under Sec. 30(a) was not barred and remanded the case to the Subordinate Judge to determine whether the rates of rent paid were below the prevailing rate of lands of a similar description and with similar advantages in the same village, proceeding according to the method laid down in Brij Behari Singh v. Sheoshankar Jha (1). We were not satisfied that the Munsiff in assessing the rents had proceeded upon a proper basis because he had taken no account of the rates payable by the tenants of what are known as the taufir lands but had only taken into consideration the rates payable in what are known in this village as the zapti lands. We accordingly directed that in ascertaining the prevailing rates of the different descriptions of land account should be taken not only of the rates payable by the tenants of the zapti land but also of the rates payable by tenants of similar lands in what was previously the taufir estate. We added a further direction that if upon the evidence on the record it should be impossible to arrive at the prevailing rates then the court should issue a commission for a local investigation.

    4. The Subordinate Judge on remand considered that there were not materials on the record to enable him to ascertain the prevailing rates of lands of similar description in the mauza and ordered a commission to issue for a local investigation. The present application is made in objection to that order.

    5. The grounds upon which the learned Subordinate Judge based his decision were (1) that the khatian of Raghunath Tola which it was said formed a part of the village had not been included and therefore there was no evidence before the court of the rates prevailing in that part of the mauza relating to lands of similar description to those which it was sought to enhance, (2) that although it was admitted that the zapti and taufir lands in each chakla of the same description were of similar quality and of similar advantages and productiveness still there was nothing to show that this was so at the present moment, and he considered that the state of affairs existing in 1903 when survey was made and certain rents assessed might have altered, (3) he compared the rents of the diara lands, as existing, with the rents of the karari lands and pointed out that in some cases the rents of the former were less than the latter although their productiveness in 1920 was equal or greater. Prom this he deduced that what is considered an inferior block yields more at present than that which is considered a superior block. He therefore concluded that lands of one description ought not to be compared merely with lands of a similar description according to the blocks in which they were at that time entered. I will deal with each of these points in turn.

    6. With regard to Raghunath Tola this was a small tola some three miles away from what is now known as mauza Mangarpal. It appears to have formed a part of the mauza before the year 1903 but if lit still appertains to this mauza it does so only in name and, assuming that it still forms a part of the mauza, and the defendants insist upon having the rates of rent in that tola before the court then they may have an opportunity of producing the khatian for that tola within a reasonable time to be fixed by the Judge. This, however, does not require a commission for the purpose. But before the defendants are given an opportunity of producing the khatian for that tola it must be shown clearly that it does form part of the village as defined in Section 3 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. Whether it is so or not we are not in a position at present to say. It was contended on behalf of the Petitioner that it no longer formed a part of the village as defined in Sac. 3 of the Act.

    7. With regard to the second point this is the very matter which was the subject of controversy at the trial before the Munsiff in the present suit. The learned Subordinate Judge seems to assume that the evidence relates to the year 1903. In this, however, he is in error. The evidence related to the condition of affairs easting at the time of suit. The findings on this question are emphatic and conclusive that the lands of a particular chakla in the taufir lands were in every respect similar to lands of the same chakla in the zapti lands and further that the lands within one chakla whether zapti or taufir are similar to one another in all respects and have got similar advantages. These were the very questions which were in controversy in the suit and it can no longer be contended that lands in karari, for example in chakla A or B, whether zapti or taufir, are in any sense different, and similarly with regard to diara lands those in each chakla are found to be now, as in 1903, similar in every description.

    8. With regard to the third point the learned Judge was impressed by the fact that some diara lands although rated lower than karari lands were equally productive or even more productive than the latter and from this he considered that a fair basis of comparison could not be obtained by merely comparing the rates of the lands of each description. The answer to this is to be found in the fact that at the time of the settlement in 1903 the same phenomenon existed and was recognised, but the diara lands were rated somewhat lower because as the Assistant Settlement Officer pointed out that “It is an admitted fact that the tenants of lands in the diara block are generally speaking exposed to larger risks than those holding lands in the karari portion. The rent rates for the diara portion should be therefore lower than those of lands of similar, productive powers in the karari blocks.” There is therefore this general distinction between these two classes of land which presumably exists to the present day. Had there been any recent change it was for the defendants at the trial to give evidence on the matter but they failed to do so. The presumption therefore is that the same considerations apply and that they should not be allowed now to go into matters which it was their duty to have raised before the Munsiff at the trial. The karari lands must be compared with karari lands and the diara lands with diara lands whether in taufir or zapti. The only contention raised at the trial was between zapti and taufir and there was never any suggestion that the diara and karari lands had changed their respective values. In my opinion the reason given by the learned Judge are, with all respect to born, based upon considerations which have no real force in the present case. The only question is whether we should interfere in revision or under our powers of superintendence to prevent what, in my opinion, would be a calamitous waste of time and money if an enquiry on the lines suggested by the learned Subordinate Judge were to take place. It would, I consider be not only fruitless but would be determining the rights of the parties upon an improper basis and would inevitably and unnecessarily prolong a litigation, which has already occupied several years, and cause irreparable loss. I have no doubt that we ought it interfere to prevent such a calamity. The learned Subordinate Judge must decide the rents upon the materials on the record subject to the right of the defendants, if so advised, to produce the khatian of the Raghunath Tola assuming that tola still forms a part of the village as defined in Section 3 of the Act. In arriving at the prevailing rates he will compare diara lands with diara lands of the same class and karari lands with karari lands of the same class. If he should, on ascertaining the prevailing rates of each class, find that a case for enhancement is made out then I am not sure how far the court has power to make the decision retrospective; but in the present case I think that it would be a hardship upon the tenants that any rates which should be found in excess of the rates which they now pay should be retrospective, that is to say, from the date of the suit, and in any case the learned Subordinate Judge has power under Section 36 of the Act to make an order which will bear less hardly upon the tenants. This, of course, is a matter for his discretion. I merely indicate what my own view would be in dealing with a case of this sort which has now lasted for a long time. I consider that it would be manifestly unfair in a case which has been prolonged like the present to order any enhancement of back rents, that is to say, rents from the commencement of the suit. The ordinary course is no doubt laid down in Section 154 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. The costs of the proceedings before the Subordinate Judge which he kept for future determination will be decided by him when he has dealt with the case according to the directions which have been given. The order for the costs of the present application will be that each party will bear his own costs.

    9. Foster, J.:— I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramji Ram v. Ramasre Raut
    (Jun 25, 1924)