AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 21 of the Act
  • Right to Information Act, 2005
  • Order 7 Rule 14(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Order 41 Rule 27
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code
  • Section 21 of the Rajasthan Rent Control Act, 2001
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 21 of the Act
  • Right to Information Act, 2005
  • Order 7 Rule 14(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Order 41 Rule 27
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code
  • Section 21 of the Rajasthan Rent Control Act, 2001
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, M/s Chakreshwari Construction Pvt. Ltd., is the owner of a shop (“the suit shop”) that was let to the respondent, Manohar Lal, on a monthly rent of Rs 670. An eviction petition was filed before the Rent Tribunal, Jaipur, under the Rajasthan Rent Control Act, 2001, alleging (i) sub-letting of the suit shop to M/s Goel Iron and Hardware Store without the landlord’s consent, and (ii) that the respondent had alternative accommodation in the same city.

After both parties had completed their evidence and the case was at the closing stage, the appellant moved two applications:

  • Order 6 Rule 17 CPC + Section 21 of the Act: sought to amend the eviction petition to substitute the name of the respondent’s alternative business premises from the earlier description to “Bright Iron Traders”, information recently obtained through the Right to Information Act, 2005.
  • Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC + Section 21 of the Act: sought leave to place on record the supporting documents received from the concerned State department.

The Rent Tribunal dismissed both applications on 26-2-2014 for delay and irrelevance. The High Court, by orders dated 8-1-2015 (2015 SCC OnLine Raj 1116 & 1117), upheld that dismissal in two writ petitions. The appellant approached the Supreme Court by special leave, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Rent Tribunal and the High Court erred in rejecting the appellant’s application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC read with Section 21 of the Rajasthan Rent Control Act seeking amendment of the eviction petition.
  2. Whether the appellant should have been permitted under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC read with Section 21 of the Act to place additional documents on record in support of the proposed amendment.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The proposed amendment merely corrects and clarifies facts recently discovered through an RTI response and does not alter the cause of action or nature of the eviction petition.
  • The additional documents are necessary for effective adjudication of the issues of sub-letting and availability of alternative accommodation.
  • Any delay was explained and would not prejudice the respondent, who would have an opportunity to respond.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The applications were filed belatedly, after closure of evidence.
  • The proposed amendment and documents were immaterial to the determination of the eviction petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Revajeetu Builders and Developers v. Narayanaswamy & Sons (2009) 10 SCC 84 Laid down guiding factors for allowing or refusing amendments under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC. The Court extracted and applied the six illustrative factors (imperative nature, bona fides, prejudice, multiplicity, change in character, and limitation) to decide that the appellant’s amendment should be allowed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reaffirmed the principles in Revajeetu Builders governing amendments. Applying those principles, the Court held:

  • The amendment did not change the nature or character of the eviction petition and introduced no new cause of action.
  • The facts sought to be added were relevant to the core issues—sub-letting and alternative accommodation—and had only recently come to the appellant’s knowledge through RTI disclosures.
  • Allowing the amendment would avert multiplicity of proceedings; refusing it would cause injustice.
  • No irremediable prejudice would be caused to the respondent, who could amend his written statement and file rebuttal evidence.
  • Although there was delay, it was satisfactorily explained; courts have discretion to permit amendments and additional evidence even at appellate stages when justified.

The Court similarly held that Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC permits filing additional documents at any stage with leave of the court, and the appellant had made out a case for such leave.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS ALLOWED; impugned orders of the High Court and Rent Tribunal set aside.

The appellant’s applications for amendment and for bringing additional documents on record are allowed. The documents are taken on file subject to payment of Rs 1500 as costs to the respondent. The respondent may file consequential amendments, additional documents, and further oral evidence. The Rent Tribunal is directed to conclude the proceedings within three months of receiving the Supreme Court’s judgment.

The decision reiterates the liberal approach toward amendments and introduction of additional evidence when necessary for complete adjudication, but it does not lay down a new legal principle beyond applying the settled law in Revajeetu Builders.

    Chakreshwari Construction Private Limited v. Manohar Lal .

    Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.— Leave granted. These appeals are filed against the final judgment and order dated 8-1-2015 passed by the High Court of Rajasthan, Jaipur Bench at Jaipur in Chakreshwari Construction (P) Ltd. v. Manohar Lal 2015 SCC OnLine Raj 1116 and Chakreshwari Construction (P) Ltd. v. Manohar Lal 2015 SCC OnLine Raj 1117 whereby the High Court dismissed the writ petitions filed by the appellant herein challenging the order of the Rent Tribunal dated 26-2-2014 dismissing its application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “the Code”) read with Section 21 of the Rajasthan Rent Control Act, 2001 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) and Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code read with Section 21 of the Act respectively.

    2. We herein set out the facts, in brief, to appreciate the issue involved in this appeal.

    3. The short question, which arises for consideration in this appeal, is whether the Rent Tribunal and the High Court were justified in rejecting the two applications filed by the appellant in their pending main eviction petition viz. one filed under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code read with Section 21 of the Act (Annexure P-6) seeking to amend their eviction petition and other filed under Order 7 Rule 14(3) of the Code read with Section 21 of the Act seeking permission to file some additional documents in support of the amendment sought?

    4. The appellant is the plaintiff/applicant whereas the respondent is the defendant/non-applicant.

    5. The appellant a limited Company is the owner of the shop [details of the shop are described in Column 3 of the main Application No. 741 of 2005 (Annexure P-1)] (hereinafter referred to as “the suit shop”). The appellant has let out the suit shop to the respondent on a monthly rent of Rs 670.

    6. The appellant has filed the eviction petition against the respondent under the Act before the Rent Tribunal, Jaipur claiming eviction of the respondent from the suit shop. The eviction is claimed, inter alia, on the ground of subletting of the suit shop alleged to have been done by the respondent in favour of one “M/s Goel Iron and Hardware Store”. It is averred that the respondent has parted with the possession of the suit shop in favour of the alleged sub-tenant without the consent of the appellant and hence he is liable to be evicted from the suit shop. The other ground on which the eviction is claimed relates to availability of an alternative accommodation to the respondent in the city where he is carrying on his business.

    7. The respondent filed his written statement. While admitting the tenancy, he denied material averments made in the eviction petition. The parties have adduced their respective evidence. The case is now at its closing stage.

    8. As mentioned above, the appellant, after close of the evidence, filed two applications. One was under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code read with Section 21 of the Act wherein they sought to amend their main eviction petition. It was alleged therein that the appellant had filed an application under the Right to Information Act, 2005 seeking to find out the name under which the respondent is carrying on the business in their alternative accommodation in the city. It was alleged that recently they were informed by the Department concerned that the name of the respondent's shop is “Bright Iron Traders”. The appellant, therefore, sought permission to amend the eviction petition and substitute the name of the shop which was initially mentioned in the eviction petition to the one proposed in the amendment application. In support of the proposed amendment, the appellant filed another application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) of the Code read with Section 21 of the Act seeking leave of the Court to file the documents, which they claimed to have obtained from the Department concerned.

    9. The respondent opposed these applications contending, inter alia, in his reply that firstly, both the applications were filed belatedly and secondly, neither the proposed amendment nor the documents sought to be filed are relevant for the disposal of the main case.

    10. By the order dated 26-2-2014, the Rent Tribunal dismissed both the applications on the ground of delay and being immaterial.

    11. Felt aggrieved, the appellant filed two writ petitions before the High Court. By impugned orders 2015 SCC OnLine Raj 1116 2015 SCC OnLine Raj 1117, the High Court dismissed the writ petitions and affirmed the order of the Rent Tribunal giving rise to filing of the appeals by special leave by the plaintiff/applicant before this Court.

    12. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record of the case, we are inclined to allow the appeals and while setting aside the impugned orders, allow the aforementioned applications of the appellant.

    13. The principle applicable for deciding the application made for amendment in the pleadings remains no more res integra and is laid down in several cases. In Revajeetu Builders and Developers v. Narayanaswamy & Sons (2009) 10 SCC 84, this Court, after examining the entire previous case law on the subject, culled out the following principle in para 63 of the judgment which reads as under:

    “63. On critically analysing both the English and Indian cases, some basic principles emerge which ought to be taken into consideration while allowing or rejecting the application for amendment:
    (1) whether the amendment sought is imperative for proper and effective adjudication of the case;
    (2) whether the application for amendment is bona fide or mala fide;
    (3) the amendment should not cause such prejudice to the other side which cannot be compensated adequately in terms of money;
    (4) refusing amendment would in fact lead to injustice or lead to multiple litigation;
    (5) whether the proposed amendment constitutionally or fundamentally changes the nature and character of the case; and
    (6) as a general rule, the court should decline amendments if a fresh suit on the amended claims would be barred by limitation on the date of application.
    These are some of the important factors which may be kept in mind while dealing with application filed under Order 6 Rule 17. These are only illustrative and not exhaustive.”

    14. Applying the aforesaid principle of law to the facts of the case at hand, we are of the considered opinion that the amendment proposed by the appellant so also the permission sought for filing additional documents deserved to be allowed.

    15. It is for the reasons that firstly, the amendment proposed did not change the nature of the case originally set up by the appellant in the eviction petition; secondly, the amendment did not introduce any fresh cause of action; thirdly, the amendment was relevant for deciding the question of subletting and availability of alternative accommodation with the respondent; fourthly, the facts proposed in the amendment not being in the personal knowledge of the appellant and having obtained from the State Department concerned recently, the same could be allowed to be brought on record for its consideration; fifthly, no prejudice was likely to be caused to the respondent, if the applications had been allowed because the respondent in such eventuality would have got an opportunity to make consequential amendment in his written statement and file additional documents in rebuttal; and lastly, in order to prove the case, the amendment proposed and permission to file documents should have been granted.

    16. It is true that there was some delay on the part of the appellant in filing the applications but, in our opinion, the appellant had explained the delay. One cannot dispute that in appropriate cases, the parties are permitted to amend their pleadings at any stage not only during the pendency of the trial but also at the first and second appellate stage with the leave of the court provided the amendment proposed is bona fide, relevant and necessary for deciding the rights of the parties involved in the lis.

    17. Similarly, the law also permits the parties to file additional evidence at any stage of the trial [Order 7 Rule 14(3)] including at the first or/and second appellate stage (Order 41 Rule 27) with the leave of the court provided a case is made out to seek such indulgence.

    18. In this case, we find that the appellant has made out the case in support of their two applications under consideration.

    19. In the light of foregoing discussion, we cannot concur with the reasoning and the conclusion of the courts below, which wrongly resulted in dismissal of the two applications filed by the appellant.

    20. The appeals thus succeed and are accordingly allowed. Impugned orders 2015 SCC OnLine Raj 1116 2015 SCC OnLine Raj 1117 and the order dated 26-2-2014 passed by the Rent Tribunal are set aside. As a consequence, the applications made by the appellant for amendment of the eviction petition and the application made for filing additional documents are allowed and the documents, as prayed for, are allowed to be taken on record. To meet the ends of justice, the appellant shall pay costs of Rs 1500 to the respondent.

    21. The respondent is also granted opportunity to make consequential amendment in the written statement and is further granted liberty to file any additional documentary evidence, if he so desires to file in rebuttal. Parties are also granted liberty to adduce any further oral evidence in support of their case in addition to what has already been led.

    22. The Tribunal shall conclude the proceedings and pass final orders within three months from the date of receipt of copy of this judgment. The parties are directed to appear before the Rent Tribunal on 20-2-2017 to enable the Rent Tribunal to conclude the proceedings.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chakreshwari Construction Private Limited v. Manohar Lal .
    (Feb 10, 2017)