Arun Banerjea, A.M:— This application has been filed under section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 against the excessive reservation in favour of the scheduled caste/tribe candidates for the posts of Chief Clerk/O.S Grade Hand O.S Grade.
2. Applicants No. 1, 2 and 3 are working as Head Clerks and Applicant No. 4 as Chief Clerk under the administrative control of the Senior Superintendent, Printing and Stationery, Eastern Railway, Calcutta, respondent No. 2. Applicants No. 1, 2 and 3 have been assigned seniority positions at Sl. Nos. 14, 15 and 16 respectively in the seniority list of Head Clerks of the Howrah Depot as on 23.7.1987 Applicant No. 4 is borne in the seniority list of Chief Clerks to which post he was promoted on 1.1.1984 and he is the senior most in that grade bsed on his date of promotion.
3. The applicants have stated that one Shri Netai Ch. Das, a scheduled caste employee was given accelerated promotion to the posts of Clerk, Grade-I, Head Clerk & Chief Clerk on the basis of caste based roster oriented reservation policy. He was wrongly assigned seniority position in the grade of Chief Clerk on 1.1.1984 The seniority positions of two other scheduled caste employees, viz, Shri Rath in Saha and Shri B.N Naskar, respondents No. 3 and 4 in the grade of Head Clerks wete shown at Sl. 32 and 33 respectively. As such they were much junior to the applicants before us. The sanctioned strength in the grade of Office Superintendent Grade-II/Chief Clerk in the Howrah Depot is only 12 posts, out of which have been reserved for the Scheduled caste employees by irregular and wrongful application of the roster point rules. In a test scheduled to be held on 13.1.1988 for selection of Chief Clerks, (3 unreserved posts and one scheduled caste post), 9 unreserved candidates and 2 scheduled castes candidates, including respondents No. 3 and 4 had been called. Applicants 1 to 3, who had not been called to appear in that test, felt aggrieved as out of 12 posts of Chief Clerk/Office Superintendent, Grade II, 3 posts are already occupied by Scheduled caste employees, and appointing one more scheduled caste employee would result in reservation exceeding the prescribed limit of 15% in favour of such employees. They are apprehensive that if one more post is given to the scheduled caste candidates resulting in 4 out of 12 then 33% would be awarded to the scheduled caste employees. The legitimate claim of applicants No. 1, 2 and 3, who are senior to respondents 3 and 4, would also be jeopardised.
4. They have further stated that the sanctioned strength of Office Superintendent Grade-I is only 6 and according to the reservation rules, no posts can be carved out in favour of scheduled tribe candidate to the prescribed quota of 7.5%. By ignoring the claim of applicant No. 4 the post has been earmarked for scheduled tribes by irregular application of the roster point. The post has been kept vacant for a long period with a view to filling it up by promoting a scheduled tribe candidate, although no such employee is available in the grade. The applicants have challenged the circular issued by the respondents on 13.1.1988 at document A-1, calling for a written test on 30.1.1988 During the admission of this matter we had passed an interim order directing the respondent authorities to allow applicants No. 1, 2 and 3 to sit in the written test held on 30.1.1988, who according to the respondents, didnot fall within the zone of consideration.
5. While the respondents have generally contested the application they have not specifically dealt with the points raised in the application with respect to excessive reservation. They have stated that they have followed the specified roster points for promotions. They have also not stated anything specific about the rules and decisions cited by the applicants about applicability of the percentage to the number of posts. In the reply filed by the respondents they have merely denied the statement made by the applicants.
6. While arguing this case Mr. Ganguly, counsel for the applicants emphasised on the decision of the other Bench of this Tribunal recorded in O.A 71 of 1987 on 1.9.1987 We find that the facts of the case are not identical, in as much as, the scheduled caste employee in that matter came within the zone of consideration by his seniority acquired by accelerated promotion to the feeder grade. In the case before us, respondents No. 3 and 4 are very much junior to applicants No. 1, 2 and 3. In the normal course of events respondents No. 3 and 4 would not have been called for the selection test. The respondent authorities by interpretation of the rules, have come to the conclusion that out of the remaining vacancies one should be filled up by a scheduled caste candidate and hence they have considered the case of respondents No. 3 and 4 who are very much junior. Mr. Ganguly also referred to the case of J.C Malik v. Union of India, 1978 (1) SLR 844, and to the case of T. Devadasan v. Union of India, AIR 1964 SC 179. In all these matters it has been held that the percentage for reservation quota are with respect to the number of posts and not to the number of vacancies that may occur in a cadre at any point of time. In the case of J.C Malik v. Union of India (supra), it has been held that power of reservation cannot be exercised in a manner to make the reservation so excessive that it may practically deny a reasonable opportunity of employment to the members of other communities. In the case before us we find that the total number of sanctioned posts in the grade of Chief Clerk is 12 and applying the ratio of 15% we come to a figure of 1.8 i.e, rounded up to 2 for the reservation quota. The 40 point roster system has been fixed on the basis of this fixed ratio. Respondents have stated that 4 vacancy points, namely 27, 28, 29 and 30 are due to be filled up. Out of these, point 28 is reservedfor Scheduled Caste candidates as per the 40 point roster. The other 3 points are available to general category candidates. Accordingly, they have called three times the number of eligible candidates of the respective communities to appear in the test. The number of available eligible Scheduled Caste candidates being only two, both these candidates have been called. 9 candidates from the unreserved communities have been called as due. We find that by blindly applying the roster point rules in the manner indicated above, the respondents are creating a situation by which the employees of the scheduled caste communities are being given more than double the quota of the number of posts due to them. Instead of two out of twelve posts to be given to the reservation quota, the application of the roster point would result in 4 posts to that communities in the cadre of Chief Clerk/O.S Grade II. In this connection we would like to quote the following from the judgment of Madhya Pradesh High Court in case of G.C Jain v. Divisional Railway Manager, Jabalpur, 1986 (1) SLR 588 at (p. 592-593 para 8).
“The 40 point roster, which was the medium for the reserved candidates, would also come to an end and came to be applicable provided the limit of 15% of 7-½% total 22-½% of the reserved candidates has been reached. The Railway are not justified in applying 40 point roster as and when vacancies occur in any grade.”
7. We agree with the above conclusion. Applying the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of J.C Malik v. Union of India (supra), we find that mechanical application of the roster point system would result in excessive reservation for the scheduled caste community denying reasonable opportunities to the members of the other communities.
8. Regarding the grievance of applicant No. 4 that one post of Office Superintendent Grade-I has been irregularly kept reserved by the respondents ignoring his claim, the respondents have not given any specific argument. They have merely denied the allegation. Hence we hold that in case there is any such vacancy kept unfilled due to non-availability of scheduled tribe candidates, the respondents should take urgent steps to consider the case of the applicant No. 4 along with others who are due for consideration for filling up the vacancy treating it as unreserved for the time being according to the prescribed rules.
9. On the basis of the above findings the application succeeds. It is directed that, for the time being reservation of one post of scheduled caste candidate in roster point 28 is to be converted to that of a general category candidate. Applicants 1, 2 and 3 should be considered for promotion to the posts of Chief Clerk/OJS. Grade II against the unreserved community vacancies. It is also directed that the vacant post of Office Superintendent, Grade I should be earmarked for general community candidate and the case of applicant No. 4 along with other eligible candidates be considered for promotion to that vacancy as per ruled, on an urgent basis. The case is disposed of accordingly without any order for costs.
10. Application allowed.