The decision of the CIC was given by:
Wajahat Habibullah, CIC
By an application of 12.10.06 Shri Navin Singh of Dehradun made the following application to the CPIO, BSF New Delhi:
“I appeal your Honour that I may be permitted to see the proceedings and marks obtained by selected candidates of I.T.B.P at Sr. No. 5 to 7 obtained by them in written examination as well as during interview under Sec. 6 of R.T.I Act 2005 so that appellant can go for judicial justice if any misappropriation has been done in the selection. For this purpose, I enclose bank draft of Rs. 25/- as per rules.”
To this he received a reply from CPIO Shri M.I Khan DIG (Personnel) on 26.10.06 as follows:
“The case has been examined in detail. In conformity to sec. 24 of the RTI Act2005 the information/documents sought for cannot be provided.”
Aggrieved, Shri Navin Singh made his first appeal on 21.11.06, but also to the same Shri M.I Khan, CPIO who had responded to his earlier application. To this he received a reply from Shri P.C Sabharwal, IG (Personnel) in a letter of 13/14-12-06 repeating the response of DIG Shri Khan.
The appeal was heard through Video Conferencing on 9.10.07 at 4.00p.m The following are present:
Appellant:
Insp. Yog Ram Negi (representing Insp. Navin Singh)
Respondents:
Sh. Y. Y. Handral, DIG, BSF Sh. B.S Kasana, Commandant
Shri Yog Ram Negi presented a letter of authorization from appellant Shri Navin Singh. Scanned through e-mail, a copy has been placed on record. Shri Negi argued that the case fell within Proviso to Sec 24 as in his second appeal before us Shri Navin Singh has raised the possibility of corruption in the grounds for the relief sought.
DECISION NOTICE
The prayer of Shri Navin Singh before us is as follows:
“The undersigned asked for the marks scored by all the fifteen (15) candidates qualified from ITBP in the written examination for selection of Asstt. Commandants in CPOs through LDCE(2005), conducted by BSF and also to examine the evaluated mark sheets and documents thereof.”
In this prayer there is no allusion to possible corruption or human rights Violation. This is not a plea that has been taken either in the original application or in the first appeal. We cannot accept such an argument as only a basis for the 2 appeal whereas the prayer in appeal itself does not mention any such charge.
As per item 9 of Schedule 2 of the RTI Act 2005, the BSF is one of the organizations identified u/s 24. Therefore, it is quite clear that it is an exempt organization, not subject to the application of the RTI Act 2005. It is open to the BSF to process this request under its own administrative rules if it wishes, taking into account our Full Bench rulings in Appeal No. CIC/MA/A/2006/00793 Shiv Shambhu v. UPSC dated 13.11.06 and Appeal Nos. CIC/OK/A/2006/00266;00058;00066;00315 Shri Rakesh Kumar Singh v. Lok Sabha Sect dated 23.4.2007 If appellant on the other hand has any substantive evidence of corruption in this case, he is free to move a fresh application under the RTI Act. However, the present appeal stands dismissed.
Announced in the hearing. Notice of this decision be given free of cost to the parties.