Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • appointment.5. Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • first.6. Sub section IV of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • (xiii) of Sub section IV of Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual, Railway
  • Rule 2511 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • SECTION 19 ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS ACT 1985
  • SECTION 25 G INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • appointment.5. Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • first.6. Sub section IV of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • (xiii) of Sub section IV of Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual, Railway
  • Rule 2511 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual
  • SECTION 19 ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS ACT 1985
  • SECTION 25 G INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT

    Ram Pada Metia v. Union Of India

    P.K Mallick, A.M:— This is an application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, filed by 29 casual labour employed in the Civil Engineering Department, Kharagpur Division of S.E Railway praying for (i) their confirmation in their initial and further grades, (ii) extension of the benefits of the restructuring of cadre and/or upgradation of posts and (iii) a direction on the respondents that all consequential benefits arising out of their regularisation as permanent employees be released to them with immediate effect.

    2. The applicants were employed as casual labour in the Civil Engineering Department of Kharagpur Division of S.E Railway on different dates between 30.11.1962 and 24.9.1971 and have been working without break. Accordingly, they had put in service without break for about 16 to 25 years in October, 1987 when the present application was filed. They were initially appointed as Khalasis and were thereafter assigned to work in higher posts like Driller, Sarang, Gas Cutter, Rivetter and Rivet Heater etc. Their contention is that though as per Railway rules they had attained temporary status on completion of 120 days and had worked for the Railways for 16 to 25 years without break, their services were not regularised. They submitted a representation dated 28.6.1986 (Annexure ‘D’), but could not get any relief from the Department. They have also stated in the application that persons junior to them have been appointed against permanent vacancies in sister units. The names of 10 such employees, allegedly junior to the applicants, have been mentioned at para 6(xii) of the application and it has been further stated that there are other employees, junior to the applicants who have been appointed against permanent vacancies.

    3. We have heard Mrs. Kanika Banerjee for the applicants and Mrs. Sikha Dutta Gupta for the respondents.

    4. Mrs. Kanika Banerjee has strongly argued that since the applicants have already completed several years of continuous service, they have attained temporary status and that in terms of Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual, Railway Board's letter dated 8.6.1981 (Annexure ‘B’) and para (xiii) of Sub section IV of Indian Railway Establishment Manual all the applicants are entitled to regulari-sation on the basis of a division wise seniority list after taking into consideration their respective dates of initial appointment.

    5. Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual is regarding the absorption of casual labour in regular vacancies. According to this Rule, casual labour are to be given temporary status after working for four months and are to be considered for regular appointment without having to go through employment exchanges. It is further mentioned in the Rule that the names of all casual labour, whereever employed, should be entered in the registers maintained by Division or District or by any other convenient unit of recruitment strictly in the order of then taking up casual appointments at the initial stage. It is also mentioned that while showing preference to casual labour over outsiders in the matter of recruitment to regular Class-IV Establishment, their total length of service as casual labour, either continuous or in broken periods, should be taken into account so as to ensure that casual labour, who are senior by virtue of longer service, are not left out. Mrs. Banerjee submits that this Rule makes it clear that a division wise seniority list of casual labour, whereever they may be employed, is to be maintained and those with longer service should be regularised first.

    6. Sub section IV of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual is regarding the recruitment of Class-IV Railway Servants. Para (xiii) of this sub-section is regarding casual labour, substitutes and temporary hands. Para (xiii)(c) states that a register should be maintained by all Divisions or Districts concerned to indicate the names of casual labour, substitutes and temporary workmen who have rendered 6 months' service (now 4 months for casual wrokers) either continuous or broken period for the purpose of employment as casual workmen and also as regular employees and that the name should be recorded strictly in the order of their taking up casual appointments at the initial stage. It is further mentioned that for the purpose of empanelment for regular Class-IV posts, they should, as far as possible, be selected in the order maintained in the aforesaid register and it should be ensured that casual labour, who are senior by virtue of longer service, are not left out. These provisions are identical with those of Rule 2512 of the Manual summarised in the previous paragraph.

    7. Railway Board's letter No. E(NG)II-77 CL/46 dated 8.6.1981 (Annexure ‘B’) is a comprehensive letter on the subject of casual labour addressed to all General Managers and others. Mrs. Banerjee has drawn our particular attention to sub paras (iv) and (v) at p. 11 of the letter. Thesetwo sub paras are reproduced below:

    “(iv) For the purpsoe of screening and employment of Casual Labour a Division should be treated as the unit for all departments,

    (v) After working out vacancies for recruitment in this unit, all casual labour who have put in a minimum of 120 days continuous service whereon the open line in the Division or on adjacent construction Project should be listed for screening, the seniority being fixed by reckoning their previous spells of employment on the basis of such cumulative aggregate service. Casual labour who have not been re-engaged will also be considered for employment/screening based on the length of their employment prior to the date of discharge if such discharged casual labour who had completed 120 days continuous service and had been discharge, lue to the completion of work and not been offered further engagement, approach administration at the time of screening.”

    8. Mrs. Banerjee asserts that these instructions of the Railway Board make it absolutely clear that the regularisation of casual labour has to be done on the basis of a division wise seniority list.

    9. In support of her contention Mrs. Banerjee has relied upon the following judgments:

    (i) Inder Pal Jadav v. Union of India, 1985 SCC (L&S) 526.

    (ii) Narayan Ala v. Union of India, AISLJ 1987 (3) CAT 185.

    (iii) Ram Kumar v. Union of India, (1988) 1 SCC 306 : AIR 1988 SC 390.

    (iv) Smt. Gyarsi Devi v. Union of India, ATR 1986 (2) CAT - 132;

    (v) L. Robert D'Souza v. Executive Engineer, Southern Railway, (1982) 1 SCC 645 : AIR 1982 SC 854.

    10. In Inder Pal Jadav (Supra), the Supreme Court directed the Railway administration to prepare a list of project casual labour with reference to each Division of each Railway and then start absorbing those with the longest service. The principle of last come first go or to reverse it first come last go, as enunciated in section 25(G) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1987 was accepted and the Railways were directed to implement the same.

    11. In Narayan Ala (Supra), the Ahmedabad Bench of this Tribunal allowed 5 transferred applications relating to the retrenchment of casual labour of Railways by holding that retrenchment can be done only on the basis of a division wise seniority list. In the judgment the contention of the respondents that the decision of the Supreme Court in Inder Pal Jadav (Supra) should be construed to be project wise seniority was rejected and it was clarified that this judgment required preparation of a division-wise senioritylist.

    12. In Ram Kumar (Supra), the petitioners were casual labour in the Northern Railway having worked for periods varying between 10 and 16 years. They had filed the writ petition as the Railway administration had not treated them as temporary servants and had applied discriminatory rates and wages. In its judgment, the Supreme Court referred to the judgment in Inder Pal Jadav (Supra) and Rule 2511 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual and directed the Railway administration to take prompt steps to screen such of the petitioners who had not yet been tested for the regularisation of their service and to consider the claims of each of the petitioner promptly and make appropriate orders for their regularisation.

    13. The case of Smt. Gyarsi Devi (Supra) was regarding conferment of temporary status to a seasonal labour on the basis of Railway Board's letter dated 8.6.1981 The facts of this case were quite different and as such this judgment has no relevance to the present application.

    14. The following extracts from the judgment of the Supreme Court in L. Robert D'Souza (Supra) would be of interest:—

    “………Railway administration has miles to go and promises to keep and this becomes evident from the fact that the appellant, a daily rated workman, continued to render continuous service for 20 years which would imply that there was work for a daily rated workman everyday for 20 years at a stretch without break and yet his status did not improve and continued to be treated as daily rated casual labour whose service can be terminated at the whim and fancy of local satraps. It is high time that these unfair provisions wholly denying socio-economic justice are properly modified and brought in conformity with the modern concept of justice and fair play to the lowest and lowliest in Railway administration.”

    15. Mrs. Banerjee has concluded her argument with the observation that since the applicants have been working for many years and have thus attained temporary status, they are entitled to immediate regularisation on the basis of the division-wise seniority list as directed in the above-mentioned judgments.

    16. Mrs. S. Dutta Gupta, learned counsel for the respondents, has strongly reiterated the contention of the respondents in their reply that the absorption and regularisation of casual labour is to be done unit-wise, and that the applicants, who are working the Bridge Inspector Unit, will have to be absorbed and regularised in the said unit and that the regularisation of other casual labour in other units has no relevance to the present application. She has stressed that the rules for project labour and open line labour are quite different and that the various judgments cited by Mrs. K. Banerjee refer to project casual labour only.

    17. She has asserted that Rule 2512 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual cited by Mrs. K. Banerjee supports her contention as this Rule refers to registers maintained by Division or District or by any other convenient unit of recruitment. She also argues that for open line casual workers the seniority is to be maintained in the unit of induction.

    18. She has referred to a Letter No. E(NG) II/77.CL/46 dated 27.2.1978 issued by the Railway Board to all General Managers and others on the subject of decasualisation of casual labour, in which it was mentioned that the present arrangement of inspector-wise seniority would continue and casual labour diverted from one unit to another would rank as juniormost in the unit for the purpose of seniority and retrenchment.

    19. She has also drawn our attention to the copy of letter dated 16.8.1980 from the Addl. Chief Personnel Officer, S.E Railway on behalf of the Chief Personnel Officer to all concerned regarding the screening of casual labour for absorption in regular cadre. It has been mentioned in this letter that in consultation with the organised labour it has been decided that for the purpose of service screening of casual labour of Civil Engineering Department (Open line), the unit of employment will be PWIs/IOWs/BRIs etc. instead of various subordinate units under the same Divisional Engineer of the Division. Mrs. Dutta Gupta argues that this letter also makes it clear that the screening wastobe made unit-wise for openline workers.

    20. She has further drawn our attention to Railway Board letter No. E(NG) 11/87.CL/87 dated 12.6.1987 on the subject of decasualisation of casual labour. It has been mentioned in this letter that proposals for creation of posts for decasualisation should be sent alongwith a self-contained note and that there should be a separate self-contained note in respect of each Department like Civil Engineering, S & T Electrical and Mechanical etc. She argues that this letter also implies that the regularisationis to bemade unit-wise.

    21. As regards Railway Board's letter dated 8.6.1981 (Annexure ‘B’), she has asserted that this letter is merely a compilation of various guidelines.

    22. In her reply, Mrs. K. Banerjee has reiterated that Annexure ‘B’ dated 8.6.1981, makes it very clear that seniority has to be determined division-wise and not unit-wise. She has drawn our attention to a letter dated 23.2.1989 issued by the Sr. Divisional Engineer (Co.). to all IOWs and BRIs of Kharagpur Division communicating the sanction of the Railway Board for decasualisation of certain posts. The letter also mentioned that it is for the Division to allot these posts to various units and that in order to do justice so that the benefit of decasualisation is extended to the most deserving candidates, the addressee should furnish a list of all CPCs staff working under them indicating against each the total length of service and the dates of superannuation. Mrs. Banerjee argues that its abundantly clear from this letter also that the intention is to give the benefit of decasualisation to the staff having the longer length of service.

    23. In conclusion, Mrs. Banerjee has sunmitted that the seniority of casual labour has to be on the basis of a division-wise seniority list and that if regularisation is done on the basis of unit-wise seniority list that will be arbitrary and discriminatory.

    24. The only point to be decided in this case is whether the casual labour are to be regularised on the basis of a division-wise seniority list or a unit-wise seniority list. We are unable to accept the contention of the respondents that the regularisation has to be done unit-wise on the basis of the seniority list maintained in the respective units. The latest direction of the Railway Board brought to our notice is their letter dated 8.6.1981 (annexure ‘B’). This letter will prevail over all previous instructions on the subject. The two relevant sub paras reproduced at para 8 above leave no scope for any doubt on this subject. The letter is quiteunambiguouson the point that for the purpose of screening and employment of casual labour a division should be treated as the unit for all departments. This was also the view taken by the Ahmedabad Bench of this Tribunal in Narayan Ala (Supra) and it was clarified that the judgment of the Supreme Court in Inder Pal Jadav (Supra) required preparation of division-wise seniority lists. We find that the views expressed by the Supreme Court in L. Robert D' Souza (Supra) as reproduced at para 14 above are equally applicable to the present case as all the applicants have been working for the Railways as casual labour for more than 16 to 25 years without break.

    25. In view of what has been stated above, this application succeed. The respondents are directed to regularise the services of the applicants as per rules on the basis of a division-wise seniortiy list and give them all the consequential benefits. This exercise should be completed within 4 months from the date of this judgment. O.A 482 of 1987 is, accordingly, allowed on the lines indicated above. There will be no order as to costs.

    26. Applications allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Pada Metia v. Union Of India
    (Jun 30, 1989)