Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order VIII Rule 10 of CPC.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order VIII Rule 10 of CPC.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion: IA No. 5105/2017 (Order VIII Rule 10 CPC)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff instituted a commercial suit seeking recovery of Rs. 1,68,52,650/- stated to be on account of price of goods (rice) supplied. In the plaint the principal amount claimed is recorded as Rs. 1,61,26,938/- (value of 15 invoices dated between 2 April 2016 and 21 May 2016) with the balance claimed as interest at 18% per annum from 31 May 2016 until institution of the suit.

The plaintiff filed IA No. 5105/2017 under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC seeking a decree forthwith on the ground that the defendant failed to file a written statement within the statutory period of 120 days. The plaintiff relied on OKU Tech Private Limited v. Sangeet Agarwal (as stated in the application).

Service and procedural history (as recorded in the opinion):

  • Service by speed post on the defendant is recorded as 10 November 2016; ordinary process recorded as 19 November 2016.
  • The defendant appeared before the Joint Registrar (JR) on 6 December 2016; the defendant's counsel stated six pages were missing and undertook to supply them; JR directed written statement to be filed within four weeks thereafter and adjourned to 21 February 2017.
  • On 21 February 2017 the defendant's counsel said the paper book had not been received; JR again directed the defendant to file written statement within the stipulated period and an application for condonation of delay, and adjourned the matter to 12 May 2017.
  • By office note, notice of the present IA was served on the defendant through counsel on 3 May 2017; a copy of the application was again supplied on 12 May 2017.
  • No written statement was on record within 120 days counted from 10 November 2016 (the Court applied the rule that time runs from the date of first service); the 120-day period expired on 10 March 2017.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant's right to file a written statement is forfeited under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC for failure to file within 120 days from first service.
  2. Whether, in the circumstances of this commercial suit supported by the plaint, affidavit and documents, the plaintiff is entitled to a decree forthwith without being relegated to lead evidence.
  3. What rate of interest and other reliefs (costs) should be awarded if a decree is entered forthwith.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff sought a decree forthwith under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC because the defendant failed to file a written statement within 120 days.
  • The plaintiff supported the application with an affidavit and filed photocopies of 15 invoices, transporter's receipts, delivery receipts bearing the defendant's stamp, and a legal notice dated 6 June 2016 indicating the defendant admitted receipt of rice and non-payment.
  • The plaintiff stated that the missing six pages had been supplied on 6 December 2016 to the defendant's counsel (as per the plaintiff's affidavit).

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant's counsel contended that notice of the IA was not served in pursuance of the order dated 28 April 2017 (the Court found this contention to be false based on office noting that the notice was served on 3 May 2017).
  • The defendant's counsel argued there was hardly any time after 12 May 2017 to file a reply to the IA (the Court rejected this, observing four days were sufficient and that defaults cannot be cured by such contention).
  • The defendant orally stated that a written statement had been filed on 22 March 2017 and claimed the missing six pages were supplied on 21 February 2017 so that the written statement was within thirty days of supply (the counsel could not substantiate this and admitted he had not appeared on 21 February 2017).
  • The defendant's counsel later sought permission for the written statement to be taken on record on terms (the Court addressed this request in light of the 120-day rule and the defendant's default).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
OKU Tech Private Limited v. Sangeet Agarwal Relied upon by the plaintiff in support of seeking a decree forthwith (exact principle from the decision is not elaborated in the opinion). The Court notes the plaintiff's reliance on this authority in the application for decree forthwith; the opinion does not set out detailed exposition of what part of the decision was applied beyond recording reliance.
Ashok Kumar v. Purshottam Lal Verma, 2016 SCC OnLine Del 5358 Where service is effected by multiple modes, time for filing is to be counted from the date of the first service (as held by the Division Bench). The Court applied this principle to hold that the 120-day period for filing a written statement must be counted from the first service, recorded as 10 November 2016, so that the period expired on 10 March 2017.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a step-by-step factual and legal assessment:

  1. Service and time-computation: The Court accepted the office records showing service by speed post on 10 November 2016 and applied the Division Bench ruling in Ashok Kumar (2016 SCC OnLine Del 5358) that when multiple modes of service are effected, time is to be counted from the date of first service. Consequently, the 120-day period expired on 10 March 2017.
  2. Opportunity given: The defendant had multiple opportunities before the JR to file the written statement—JR orders of 6 December 2016 and 21 February 2017 recorded directions and undertakings to supply missing pages and to file written statement within stipulated time. A copy of the present IA was served on counsel on 3 May 2017 and again supplied on 12 May 2017, with an opportunity to reply; no reply was filed.
  3. Alleged defects or late filing: The defendant's oral assertions that the missing pages were supplied on 21 February 2017 and that a written statement was filed on 22 March 2017 were examined against the record. The Court noted that the office note dated 22 March 2017 recorded the written statement as not in order and returned with objections (because it lacked an application for condonation of delay). The defendant's counsel did not pursue removal of objections or take steps to place the written statement on record.
  4. Legal effect of default: Given the defendant's failure to file a written statement within the statutory period and subsequent inaction when a defective written statement was returned, the Court concluded the defendant had forfeited the right to file a written statement under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC.
  5. Whether to relegate plaintiff to lead evidence: The Court examined the plaint and accompanying documents (invoices, transporter's receipts, delivery receipts with defendant's stamp), verified averments and affidavits, and concluded that relegating the plaintiff to lead evidence would not materially improve the defendant's position. Additionally, the plaintiff had produced a legal notice dated 6 June 2016 in which the defendant, through its advocate, admitted receipt of rice and non-payment—material that supported entering judgment forthwith.
  6. Relief and interest: Although the plaintiff sought interest at 18% per annum, the Court, "considering the prevalent rate of interest," awarded interest at 10% per annum from 31 May 2016 until three months after the decree; if the decretal amount remained unpaid after that three-month period, interest would run at 12% per annum thereafter.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Application allowed; defendant's right to file written statement forfeited; plaintiff entitled to a decree forthwith under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC.

Direct consequences and orders issued by the Court:

  • A decree is passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant for recovery of Rs. 1,61,26,938/- (principal as claimed in the plaint in respect of 15 invoices).
  • The plaintiff is awarded interest at 10% per annum on the amount of Rs. 1,61,26,938/- from 31 May 2016 until three months after the decree; if the decretal amount is not paid within that three-month period, interest shall run thereafter at 12% per annum.
  • The plaintiff is also entitled to costs of the suit; the decree sheet is to be drawn up.

Broader implications: The opinion does not state that a new legal precedent is being laid down; the Court applied existing authorities (notably Ashok Kumar) and exercised the remedy available under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC in the factual matrix before it. No additional, general legal principle beyond the application of those authorities is articulated.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Rajesh Goel v. Jasbir Singh

    Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.

    IA No. 5105/2017 (of plaintiff u/O VIII R-10 CPC)

    1. The plaintiff, in this commercial suit for recovery of Rs. 1,68,52,650/- on account of price of goods (rice) supplied, seeks a decree forthwith on the defendant not filing written statement within the time of 120 days. Reliance is placed on OKU Tech Private Limited v. Sangeet Agarwal.

    2. This application came up before this Court first on 28th April, 2017 when none appeared for the defendant inspite of advance notice shown to have been given by way of registered post AD receipt dated 20 April, 2017.

    3. Though there was no need for issuance of notice but notice was ordered to be issued returnable before the Joint Registrar (JR) on 12 May, 2017, the date already fixed and the application was posted before this Bench for today.

    4. The office noting under the order dated 28 April, 2017 is to the effect that the notice of the application was served on the defendant through counsel on 3rd May, 2017.

    5. However on 12 May, 2017 the counsel for the defendant took a stand that copy of the application had not been supplied to him. The copy of the application, as per order dated 12 May, 2017, was supplied “again” on 12 May, 2017 and opportunity given to the defendant to file reply and the matter posted for today.

    6. No reply has been filed to the application.

    7. The office noting under the order dated 27 September, 2016 vide which the suit was admitted and summons ordered to be issued for 6 December, 2016, is to the effect that the defendant was served through ordinary process on 19 November, 2016 and was also served by speed post. A perusal of the service by speed post shows the defendant to have been served by speed post on 10 November, 2016.

    8. I may at this stage notice that though the view earlier prevailing was that when service by multiple modes is effected, it is the date of last service from which the time is to be counted but the Division Bench of this Court in Ashok Kumar v. Purshottam Lal Verma 2016 SCC OnLine Del 5358 has held that it is from the date of the first service that the time is to be counted.

    9. The defendant appeared before the Joint Registrar on 6 December, 2016 and the counsel for the defendant stated that he will be filing his Vakalatnama during the course of the day and further stated that six pages had not been supplied to him. The JR, recording the undertaking of the counsel for the plaintiff to supply the said six pages within two days, directed written statement to be filed within four weeks thereafter with copy to the plaintiff and adjourned the suit to 21st February, 2017.

    10. The plaintiff, in this application supported by affidavit, has stated that the said six pages were supplied on 6 December, 2016 itself to Mr. Siddhant Sharma, Advocate who had appeared for the defendant on that date.

    11. No written statement was however filed by the defendant.

    12. On 21 February, 2017, the Advocate for the defendant stated before the JR that the defendant had not received the paper book. Recording that the said plea was unreasonable in view of the earlier order dated 6 December, 2016, the JR again adjourned the matter to 12 May, 2017 with a direction to the defendant to file his written statement within the stipulated period along with an application for condonation of delay.

    13. Still no written statement was filed by the defendant and the plaintiff filed this application.

    14. The time of 120 days from 10 November, 2016 for filing written statement expired on 10 March, 2017.

    15. Admittedly no written statement was filed till then.

    16. The counsel for the defendant though has not filed any reply to this application despite opportunity, firstly contends that the notice of the application was not served on the defendant in pursuance to the order dated 28 April, 2017.

    17. The said contention of the counsel for the defendant is false as aforesaid. The office noting under the order dated 28 April, 2017 is of the defendant having been served through counsel with the notice of the application on 3 May, 2017.

    18. Though admittedly a copy of the application was again supplied to the counsel for the defendant on 12 May, 2017 and opportunity again given to the defendant to file reply to this application before today, but still no reply has been filed.

    19. The counsel for the defendant only states that there was hardly any time after 12 May, 2017 to file reply.

    20. Once the defendant is already in default, he cannot make such arguments. Four days were enough to prepare reply; the same could have been filed with permission of Court, as is routinely done.

    21. The counsel for the defendant has orally stated that written statement has been filed on 22nd March, 2017. It is further contended that the missing six pages were supplied to the counsel for the defendant only on 21 February, 2017 and the written statement filed on 22 March, 2017 is within thirty days.

    22. The counsel for the defendant on being asked to show as to how missing pages were supplied on 21 February, 2017 has nothing to show but merely states that it was supplied after the hearing on 21 February, 2017.

    23. However the counsel who is appearing today admits that he did not appear on 21 February, 2017 and some other counsel had appeared.

    24. Written statement stated to have been filed, as per office note dated 22 March, 2017, was not in order and ordered to be returned with objections. The counsel for the defendant first feigned ignorance of the written statement being not on record. Thereafter he now states that it was returned because it was without any application for condonation of delay.

    25. The counsel, inspite of the knowledge that the written statement filed without application for condonation of delay, did not remove objections and did not take steps to have written statement placed on record.

    26. The counsel for the defendant now states that written statement be permitted to be taken on record on terms.

    27. This is a commercial suit and as per the dicta aforesaid of the coordinate bench, no time can be given after 120 days.

    28. The counsel for the defendant, at this stage, states that “he was under the impression that the written statement is within time”.

    29. “Impressions” of the counsel, which have no basis in facts or in law, cannot save the day and the defendant has to suffer therefor.

    30. I have examined the plaint and the documents filed therewith to verify, whether the suit qualifies for a decree forthwith or the plaintiff is to be relegated to lead evidence.

    31. The principal amount of Rs. 1,61,26,938/- claimed by the plaintiff in the suit is for the value of 15 invoices of between 2 April, 2016 and 21 May, 2016 towards price of sale and supply of rice. The balance amount claimed is towards interest thereon @ 18% per annum till date of institution. The plaintiff has filed before this Court photocopies of the invoices, the transporter's receipt and delivery receipts bearing the stamp of the defendant.

    32. I have enquired from the counsel for the plaintiff, whether there is any Value Added Tax (VAT) document of sale and delivery.

    33. The counsel for the plaintiff states that the supply was within the city of Delhi and thus there was no need for any VAT document.

    34. The counsel for the defendant, with reference to the invoices and transporter's receipts filed, states that the transporter's receipts are of supply from Karnal, Haryana to the defendant at Delhi.

    35. It is the averment of the plaintiff in the plaint that the plaintiff, though at Karnal, has a godown in Delhi at Narela and the deliveries were made from the godown at Delhi to the defendant.

    36. The invoices also of the plaintiff are at the address of Narela Mandi, of delivery to the defendant at Delhi. The transporters receipts are of consignment by the plaintiff to its office at Delhi with delivery at the address of the defendant.

    37. The defendant having forfeited the right to file written statement, I have weighed whether relegating the plaintiff to lead evidence qua which the defendant would not have a right to cross-examine on its defence, will serve any purpose.

    38. In the face of plaint, averments wherein, besides being verified are also supported by affidavit and the documents duly supported with statement of truth, I am of the view that the position would not be any better by relegating the plaintiff to evidence.

    39. The plaintiff along with its documents has also filed copy of legal notice dated 6 June, 2016 sent by Jaspreet S. Rai, Advocate on behalf of defendant to the plaintiff admitting receipt of rice from the plaintiff, non-payment of price thereof, export thereof by the defendant and claiming damages from the plaintiff for poor quality thereof.

    40. The application is thus allowed, the right of the defendant to file written statement to the suit is forfeited and the plaintiff is entitled to judgment forthwith.

    CS(COMM) 1349/2016

    41. In terms of the discussion aforesaid, the plaintiff has become entitled to a decree forthwith under Order VIII Rule 10 of CPC. The plaintiff, besides the principal amount of Rs. 1,61,26,938/-, has claimed interest @ 18% per annum from 31 May, 2016 till the institution of the suit.

    42. I am of the view that considering the prevalent rate of interest, the plaintiff should be awarded interest @ 10% per annum with effect from 31 May, 2016 till three months herefrom. If the decretal amount is not paid, the plaintiff shall be entitled to interest for the period thereafter @ 12% per annum.

    43. Accordingly, a decree is passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant (i) of recovery of Rs. 1,61,26,938/- with interest @ 10% per annum on the amount of Rs. 1,61,26,938/- from 31 May, 2016 till three months hereafter and @ 12% per annum for the period thereafter.

    44. The plaintiff shall also be entitled to costs of the suit.

    45. Decree sheet be drawn up.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajesh Goel v. Jasbir Singh
    (May 16, 2017)