Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A deed of partnership was executed on 13 March 2014 between the petitioner and respondents no. 1 and 2, commencing from 10 March 2014, to carry on business through the partnership firm M/s. Shikha Enclave located at Uttar Bakshara, Howrah. The deed contained contradictory clauses regarding dissolution: Clause 2 described the partnership as one at will, while Clause 29 stated it could be dissolved only by a deed of dissolution. The partnership capital was Rs. 6,00,000 per partner, and the business involved land development and construction activities.

The partnership firm entered into a development agreement on 21 March 2014 concerning a land parcel belonging to respondent no. 2. Disputes arose relating to the operation of the firm's bank account, with the petitioner alleging misappropriation of funds and exclusion from business affairs by respondents no. 2 and 3. The petitioner issued a notice on 22 November 2016 under Section 43 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, purporting to dissolve the partnership.

The partnership deed included an arbitration clause (Clause 36) mandating arbitration of disputes arising between partners. Respondents contested the dissolution notice, asserting that the partnership could only be dissolved by consent per Clause 29. The petitioner invoked the arbitration clause on 27 November 2016 by appointing an arbitrator, which the respondents did not acknowledge.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner validly dissolved the partnership treating it as one at will under Section 43 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, despite Clause 29 requiring dissolution by deed.
  2. Whether the respondents violated their duties by misappropriating partnership funds and excluding the petitioner from business operations.
  3. Whether the alleged expulsion of the petitioner from the partnership firm was lawful and compliant with the partnership deed and statutory provisions.
  4. Whether the petitioner is entitled to accounts, capital repayment with interest, and compensation from the respondents.
  5. Whether the revocation of the petitioner’s registered General Power of Attorney by respondent no. 2 is legally valid.
  6. Whether the respondents are barred from selling partnership assets without involving the petitioner.
  7. Whether the bar under Section 69(1) of the Indian Partnership Act precludes the petitioner’s suit given the firm’s non-registration.
  8. Whether the disputes between the parties are referable to arbitration under the partnership deed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The partnership was one at will and thus validly dissolved by notice under Section 43 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932.
  • The respondents misappropriated partnership funds and excluded the petitioner from business operations.
  • Demanded accounts, repayment of capital with interest, and compensation.
  • Invoked the arbitration clause to resolve disputes.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The partnership could not be dissolved by notice as Clause 29 requires dissolution only by a deed of dissolution.
  • Asserted that the petitioner was expelled from the partnership and the firm was reconstituted without him.
  • Argued that since the firm was not registered, under Section 69(1) of the Indian Partnership Act, the petitioner could not maintain a suit against the firm or partners.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jagadish Chandra Gupta v. Kajaria Traders (India) Ltd., AIR 1964 SC 1882 Section 69(1) bar applies to suits and arbitration when the firm is unregistered. Confirmed that the bar applies but does not extend to suits for dissolution or accounts under Section 69(3)(a).
Delhi Development Authority v. Kochhar Construction Work, (1998) 8 SCC 559 Section 69(1) bar applies to arbitration proceedings involving unregistered firms. Supported the principle that the bar applies generally but exceptions exist for dissolution and accounts suits.
Mohd. Monirul Hasan v. Mohd. Iftikar Ahmed, 2000 Gauhati 108 Reinforces the applicability of Section 69(1) bar to arbitration in unregistered firms. Used to illustrate limits of the bar and exceptions under Section 69(3)(a).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the contradictory clauses in the partnership deed regarding dissolution and noted the petitioner’s invocation of Section 43 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, treating the partnership as one at will. The respondents’ contention that dissolution required a deed was acknowledged but the Court observed that even if correct, the petitioner was entitled to sue for dissolution, accounts, and related reliefs under Section 69(3)(a) which exempts such suits from the bar in Section 69(1) applicable to unregistered firms.

The Court considered the precedents cited by respondents, which affirm that the bar under Section 69(1) applies to suits and arbitration involving unregistered firms, but emphasized the statutory exception permitting suits for dissolution and accounts. Thus, the petitioner’s suit is maintainable despite the firm’s non-registration.

Given the arbitration clause in the partnership deed and the nature of disputes enumerated by the petitioner, the Court found it appropriate to exercise its power to appoint an arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes. The Court appointed Dr. H.K. Saha Ray as arbitrator and directed the parties to proceed with arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the application and directed that all disputes between the parties, as detailed in the petition, be referred to arbitration under Clause 36 of the partnership deed. Dr. H.K Saha Ray was appointed as arbitrator with specified remuneration and a timeline of six months to deliver the award.

The direct effect of this decision is that the parties must resolve their disputes through arbitration rather than litigation, including issues of dissolution, accounts, and alleged misappropriation. No new precedent was established; rather, the Court applied established principles regarding the maintainability of suits and arbitration involving unregistered firms and the statutory exceptions thereto.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Monojit Das v. Sujit Roy Chowdhury & Anr.

    I.P Mukerji, J.:— A deed of partnership was executed on 13 March, 2014. It was between the petitioner and the respondent nos. 1 and 2. It was deemed to have commenced from 10 March, 2014. These parties would carry on business through a partnership firm M/s. Shikha Enclave having its office at Uttar Bakshara, P.S-Jagacha, District-Howrah.

    2. In Clause-2 of this deed, the partnership was described as one at will, although in Clause-29, which is contradictory, it was stated that it could be “dissolved” by a deed of dissolution. The death or retirement of any partner would not have the effect of dissolving the firm. The partnership would be continued by the surviving partners. Each of the partners, would bring in Rs. 6,00000/- as capital. The nature of business to be carried on by the partnership was development of land and building and to act as architect, designer, contractor etc.

    3. Now, it appears from the averments made in the petition that one of the first ventures into which the partnership firm entered into was development of a piece of land measuring 5 cottahs situated at mouza Uttar Bakshara within the jurisdiction of Jagacha P.S under Howrah Municipal Corporation belonging to the respondent no. 2. On 21 March, 2014 a development agreement was executed between the respondent no. 2 and the partnership firm, whereunder the respondent no. 2 empowered M/s. Shikha Enclave to build a multi-storied building on the said plot of land. A power attorney was executed by the respondent no. 2 in favour of the petitioner and the respondent no. 1 in connection with the development work.

    4. It appears that disputes and differences arose between the parties arising out of operation of the firm's account with Allahabad Bank, Howrah main branch. According to the petitioner the respondent no. 2 & 3 have carried on the business of partnership keeping him in the dark and have misappropriated partnership funds. He, treating the partnership as one at will, issued a notice on 22 November, 2016 under Section 43 of the Indian Partnership Act, dissolving the partnership.

    5. The partnership agreements between the parties contain an arbitration clause, Clause-36 which is follows:—

    “36. Arbitration Clause:- That in case of dispute arising between the partners regarding the partnership business as the same shall be referred to the Arbitration as stipulated in the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.”

    6. According to the letter of the Chief Manager of the Bank dated 19 October, 2016 to the petitioner, the respondent wrote to the bank that the petitioner was expelled from the partnership and that it was reconstituted without him.

    7. At the hearing of this application, it was contended by the respondents that the petitioner could not have dissolved the partnership treating it as one at will because of Clause-29 which according to the respondents meant that the partnership could be dissolved only by consent of the parties.

    8. On 27 November, 2016 the petitioner invoked the arbitration clause by appointing an arbitrator, asking the respondents to concur in the appointment. The respondents did not reply to this letter. The petitioner states that the following disputes have arisen between the parties as tabulated in paragraph 33 of the petition.

    “(i) Whether the respondents have violated the general duties of the partners in operation the Business Account of the Firm, avoiding the petitioner, in violation of the Clause 17 of the Deed of Partnership, wherein it has been clearly mentioned that the account shall be operated by the partners jointly;

    (ii) Whether the respondents have misappropriated funds from the business account of the partnership firm in operating the account in in an unauthorised manner;

    (iii) Whether the respondents have illegally misappropriated the partnership fund keeping the petitioner in dark regarding the business activities of the Firm;

    (iv) Whether the respondents have done an illegality allegedly expelling the petitioner from the partnership firm;

    (v) Whether the alleged expulsion of the petitioner from the Firm is violative to Clause 27 of the Deed of Partnership and Section 33 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932;

    (vi) Whether the partnership firm has been dissolved on delivery of notice dated 22.11.2016 of the petitioner issued under Section 43 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932;

    (vii) Whether the respondents are liable to pay the capital of the petitioner in the said partnership firm as on the date of dissolution of the partnership firm together with interest accrued thereon;

    (viii) Whether the petitioner is entitled to compensation from the respondents;

    (ix) Whether the revocation of registered General Power of Attorney in respect of the petitioner, by the respondent No. 2, is bad in law and not binding upon the petitioner;

    (x) Whether the respondents are debarred from sale out the assets of the firm avoiding the petitioner;”

    9. Learned Counsel for the respondents took a most worthless point based on Section 69 of the Partnership Act. It enacts that unless the firm is registered and shown to be so in the register of firms a partner does not have a right to institute a suit against the firm or any other person. Admittedly, the firm is not registered. Learned Counsel tried to contend that the petitioner being a partner of the firm could not maintain this action against the firm or its other partners. He completely overlooked Section 69(3)(a) of the said Act which provides that Section 69 (1) was not applicable in any suit for dissolution of a firm or for accounts of a dissolved firm or any right or power to realise the property of a dissolved firm.

    10. Now, this is exactly the dispute between the parties. The petitioner claims that the partnership was one at will and hence dissolved by the said notice dated 22 November, 2016. The petitioner wants an account from the respondents of the funds of the partnership firm. The respondents allege that the firm could not be dissolved in this way because of Clause-29 of the agreement which provides for dissolution by a deed. Even if the contention of the respondents is correct the petitioner is entitled to sue for dissolution of the firm, accounts and for other reliefs. The decisions cited by the learned Counsel for the respondents Jagadish Chandra Gupta v. Kajaria Traders (India) Ltd. reported in AIR 1964 SC 1882, Delhi Development Authority v. Kochhar Construction Work reported in (1998) 8 SCC 559 and Mohd. Monirul Hasan v. Mohd. Iftikar Ahmed reported in 2000 Gauhati 108 pronounce the ratio that the bar under Section 69(1) of the Partnership Act applies even to arbitration. In my opinion, there is no dispute with this proposition but in view of Section 69(3)(a) the bar does not apply where a partner sues for dissolution of the firm, accounts or claims a declaration that the firm stands dissolved or asks for any relief connected therewith.

    11. For all those reasons, this is a fit case where the court should use its power to appoint an arbitrator.

    12. In those circumstances, I direct that the disputes which are referred to in the petition and to be raised in the statement of claim and counter statement to be filed by the parties according to the direction given by the learned arbitrator are referred to arbitration. I appoint Dr. H.K Saha Ray, Barrister-at-law as the arbitrator to adjudicate the said disputes, at a remuneration of Rs. 15,000/- per sitting to be shared equally by the parties. The learned Arbitrator may appoint his staff and fix their remuneration which shall also be equally borne by the parties. He is requested to make and publish his award within six months of communication of this order.

    13. This application is accordingly allowed.

    14. Certified photocopy of this Judgment and order, if applied for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Monojit Das v. Sujit Roy Chowdhury & Anr.
    (Apr 27, 2017)