AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • 7 provisions of Section 14(3)
  • Section 14(3) and (3-A) of the Maharashtra Agricultural Produce Marketing (Development and Regulation) Act, 1963, (hereinafter referred to as the Act),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • 7 provisions of Section 14(3)
  • Section 14(3) and (3-A) of the Maharashtra Agricultural Produce Marketing (Development and Regulation) Act, 1963, (hereinafter referred to as the Act),
Smart Summary

Case Summary: Writ Petition No. 585 of 2017

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are agriculturists and office-bearers of cooperative societies whose societies are members of the Agricultural Produce Market Committee (APMC), Nagpur (Respondent No. 5). Petitioners challenged the State Government's order dated 10.01.2017 issued under Section 14(3) and (3-A) of the Maharashtra Agricultural Produce Marketing (Development and Regulation) Act, 1963, which extended the term of the existing Board of Directors and postponed elections of the APMC (extension up to 07.09.2017).

The petitioners contended that the impugned order mechanically accepted a proposal from subordinates without recording the requisite opinion or reasons under Section 14(3-A), and that the election process had already commenced (objections invited on 01.12.2016; provisional voters list published on 26.12.2016; final list to be published on 13.01.2017), so the elections should not have been interdicted.

Procedurally, the High Court (Coram: B.P. Dharmadhikari & Mrs. Swapna Joshi, JJ.) issued rule and heard the matter finally with consent of parties on 09.03.2017. Counsel appearing included Shri A.A. Naik for petitioners, Shri P. Tembhare, AGP for certain respondents, and Shri S.W. Sambre for respondent No. 5. The Court delivered an oral judgment on 09.03.2017.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government validly exercised its power under Section 14(3-A) of the Maharashtra APMC Act to postpone APMC elections by recording satisfaction that holding simultaneous elections was not in the "public interest".
  2. Whether the impugned order disclosed the requisite application of mind and reasons "to be recorded in writing" as mandated by Section 14(3-A), or whether the absence of such recorded reasons renders the order arbitrary and liable to be quashed.
  3. Whether the stage reached in the electoral process (publication of provisional voters list and imminent publication of final list) precluded the use of power under Section 14(3-A) to postpone elections.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The impugned order dated 10.01.2017 was issued without proper application of mind; the State Government merely accepted a subordinate's proposal mechanically without recording the opinion and reasons mandated by Section 14(3-A).
  • The fact that other local authority elections were being held simultaneously is not, by itself, sufficient to postpone APMC elections—especially when elections of APMC and other local bodies were conducted simultaneously in 2012 without objection.
  • The election process for the APMC had already commenced (objections invited on 01.12.2016; provisional list published 26.12.2016; final list due on 13.01.2017), and therefore could not have been interdicted by the extension/postponement order.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondent No. 5 (APMC) did not dispute that the election process had started and stated it was ready and willing to proceed but would abide by the Court's directions.
  • The State (represented by the AGP) relied on the impugned order and Sections 14(3) and 14(3-A). The AGP submitted that the order expressly mentioned the satisfaction of the State Government and the grounds on which it was based (i.e., simultaneous local body elections), and that the contingencies in Section 14(3-A) were satisfied, so the exercise of power could not be said to be without jurisdiction or erroneous. He argued that postponement was permissible even at the stage when the final voters list was to be published.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory scheme, particularly Section 14(3) and Section 14(3-A) of the Maharashtra APMC Act. It noted:

  • Section 14(3) provides that members of the Marketing Committee hold office for five years and contains a proviso allowing the State Government to extend the term when elections cannot be held for reasons beyond the Committee's control.
  • Section 14(3-A) authorizes the State Government to postpone elections where certain contingencies exist (e.g., scarcity, drought, flood, fire, rainy season, election programme of State Legislature, Parliament or a local authority, or other special reason) and where, in the opinion of the State Government, it is not in the public interest to hold the elections; such postponement must be by order and for reasons recorded in writing, for periods not exceeding six months at a time (aggregate not exceeding one year).
  • The power under Section 14(3-A) is described as overriding in nature ("notwithstanding anything contained in this Act").

On examination of the impugned order dated 10.01.2017, the Court observed that the order:

  • Recorded the date of expiry of the Board's term (08.03.2017), noted receipt of representations seeking extension because local body elections were scheduled in January and March 2017, and recorded that Respondent No. 3 (District Deputy Registrar) submitted a proposal to the State Government.
  • Stated that the State Government was satisfied that it would be appropriate to grant an extension and, invoking Sections 14(3) and (3-A), extended the term up to 07.09.2017 and directed the existing Board to complete the election process within that period.

The Court found these observations insufficient because:

  • The impugned order did not reveal any process of application of mind by the State Government or an opinion that holding simultaneous elections would not be in the public interest.
  • Section 14(3-A) requires the State Government to find that the contingencies exist and, crucially, that holding the election would not be in the public interest; this bearing on "public interest" must be demonstrated by recorded reasons in the order. Merely mentioning receipt of representations and that other elections were scheduled does not disclose the logical consideration of relevant material necessary to reach a subjective opinion about public interest.
  • Past practice is relevant: in 2012, APMC elections were conducted simultaneously with other local body elections and were not considered contrary to public interest. Therefore, the State Government needed to articulate special reasons or circumstances now that would render simultaneous conduct against public interest; such reasons were absent in the impugned order and in the reply affidavit.
  • Because the fundamental basis for the extension/postponement in the impugned order was Section 14(3-A), the failure to record reasons and demonstrate application of mind rendered the order arbitrary.

Given the absence of recorded reasons and application of mind, the Court concluded that it was unnecessary to decide other contentions raised by the petitioners and proceeded to quash the impugned order.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The impugned order dated 10.01.2017 is QUASHED AND SET ASIDE, and the Rule is made absolute.

Direct consequences mandated by the Court:

  • The State (Respondent No. 1) is directed to proceed further with the election of Respondent No. 5 (APMC, Nagpur) as per law.
  • There shall be no order as to costs in the facts and circumstances of the case.

Broader implications: The opinion emphasizes the statutory requirement that when the State exercises its power under Section 14(3-A) to postpone elections, the State Government must record reasons in writing demonstrating the nexus between the contingencies relied upon and the conclusion that holding elections would not be in the public interest. In this matter the Court declared the particular exercise of power arbitrary due to absence of such reasoning. The opinion does not purport to lay down new law beyond that statutory requirement and does not discuss or announce any broader precedent beyond the decision in this case.


Source: Oral judgment delivered by B.P. Dharmadhikari, J. (Coram: B.P. Dharmadhikari & Mrs. Swapna Joshi, JJ.) dated 09.03.2017 in Writ Petition No. 585 of 2017 (Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench). This summary is compiled exclusively from the text of the provided opinion and does not add or infer information not present therein.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bhagwan Sampatrao Ghodmare And Another Petitioners. v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

    wp585.17 1

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    NAGPUR BENCH

    WRIT PETITION NO. 585 OF 2017

    1. Bhagwan Sampatrao Ghodmare, Director, Vihirgaon Seva Sahakari Samiti, Vihirgaon, Tahsil and District - Nagpur.

    2. Vasantrao marotrao landge, President, Seva Sahakari Sanstha, Bahadura, resident of Bahadura, Post - Vihirgaon, Tahsil and District - Nagpur. ... PETITIONERS Versus

    1. The State of Maharashtra through its Secretary, Department of Co-operation, Madam Cama Road, Mumbai 400 032.

    2. The Director of Marketing, Maharashtra State Agricultural Marketing Board, Multekdi, Pune - 37.

    3. The District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Nagpur.

    4. The Collector, Nagpur.

    5. The Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee, Nagpur, through its Member, having its office at Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru Yard, Kalamna, Nagpur 440 035. … RESPONDENTS Shri A.A. Naik, Advocate for the petitioners. Shri P. Tembhare, AGP for respondent Nos. 1, 3 & 4. Shri S.W. Sambre, Advocate for respondent No. 5. …..

    1

    CORAM : B.P. DHARMADHIKARI &

    MRS. SWAPNA JOSHI, JJ.

    MARCH 09, 2017.

    ORAL JUDGMENT : (PER B.P. DHARMADHIKARI, J.)

    Considering the nature of controversy, by issuing rule and making it returnable forthwith, we have heard the matter finally with the consent of Shri Naik, learned counsel for the petitioners, Shri Tembhare, learned AGP for respondent Nos. 1, 3 & 4 and Shri Sambre, learned counsel for respondent No. 5.

    2. The petitioners are agriculturists in the jurisdiction of Respondent No. 5 - Agricultural Produce Market Committee (APMC). Petitioner No. 1 is the Director of Vihirgaon Seva Sahakari Sanstha, Vihirgaon, Tahsil and District - Nagpur and Petitioner No. 2 is the President of Seva Sahakari Sanstha, Bahadura, Post - Vihirgaon, Tahsil and District - Nagpur. Their societies are members of Respondent No. 5 - Agricultural Produce Market Committee, Nagpur, and the petitioners claim that they are voters in the elections of APMC i.e. for electing its

    2

    Directors. The order dated 10.01.2017 passed under Section 14(3) and (3-A) of the Maharashtra Agricultural Produce Marketing (Development and Regulation) Act, 1963, (hereinafter referred to as the Act), is questioned on the ground that without recording any opinion properly, as mandated by those provisions, mechanically proposal put up by the subordinates has been accepted and elections are postponed.

    3. Shri Naik, learned counsel in addition submits that in 2012 elections of local authorities like Nagpur Municipal Corporation, Zilla Parishad, Nagpur and Respondent No. 5 - APMC were simultaneously conducted. As such, the fact that the elections of these local authorities are being held, cannot be sufficient to postpone elections of Respondent No. 5 - APMC. By reading out impugned order and legal provisions, he submits that non application of mind by respondent No. 1 is apparent because the grounds prescribed in the statute and the reasons expected in support thereof, do not find any evaluation in the impugned communication. Lastly, it is submitted that the election process has already started inasmuch as on

    3

    01.12.2016, objections were invited and thereafter provisional list of voters was published on 26.12.2016. The final list of voters was also ready thereafter and it was to be published on 13.01.2017. Thus, election process had already commenced and it could not have been interdicted.

    4. Shri Sambre, learned counsel for respondent No. 5 - APMC does not dispute the fact that the election process had already started. He submits that Respondent No. 5 - APMC was ready and willing to proceed further with the election process. He, however, adds that respondent No. 5 has no particular say in the matter and it will abide by the directions of this Court.

    5. The learned AGP is relying upon the impugned order and provisions of Section 14(3) and (3-A) of the Act. According to him, the order expressly mentions satisfaction of the State Government and the grounds on which it is based. He submits that in present facts, distinction sought to be drawn between the reasons and ground is non existent. According to

    4

    him, as the elections of local body viz. Nagpur Municipal Corporation and Zilla Parishad, Nagpur, were also simultaneously announced, the contingencies contemplated in Section 14(3-A) are satisfied and hence action cannot be said to be either without jurisdiction or erroneous. He, therefore, prays for dismissal of writ petition. According to him, in this situation, as election can be postponed, the fact that stage of publication of final list of voters was reached, is itself not decisive.

    6. Shri Naik, learned counsel, in reply, submits that today only in Writ Petition No. 6676 of 2016, this Court has taken note of status quo order passed by the Hon'ble Apex Court. Because of those orders, election of Zilla Parishad, Nagpur, cannot be conducted in near future. He adds that when in last election of APMC, simultaneous conduct of other elections was not found to be an obstacle, the impugned order passed on 10.01.2017, is unwarranted.

    7. Section 14(3) of the Act stipulates that the members

    5

    of Marketing Committee hold office for a period of five years. Second proviso thereto mentions that when elections to elect new Board of Directors cannot be held for reasons beyond the control of Committee before expiry of such term, the State Government may from time to time extend the term of office of such Committee. Section 14(3-A) envisages a situation where due to Election programme of local body coincides with the election of Market Committee and in the opinion of the State Government, it is not in "public interest" to hold election to Market Committee, the State Government can by a general or special order, for the reasons to be recorded in writing, postpone the elections of Market Committee for a period not extending six months. The power of State Government under Section 14(3-A) is overriding in nature because it operates notwithstanding anything contained in APMC Act.

    8. In this background, when the impugned order dated 10.01.2017 is looked into, it takes note of the fact that the date of expiry of term of body of Board of Directors is 08.03.2017. Thereafter it points out representation received by the State

    6

    Government for grant extension to Board of Directors as election to local bodies were scheduled in January and March 2017. As per those representations, Respondent No. 3 - District Deputy Registrar submitted a proposal to the State Government. After mentioning these developments, the impugned order observes that considering the grounds mentioned above, the State Government was satisfied that it would be appropriate to give extension to the Board of Directors. In view of this, in the operative order after mentioning Section 14(3) and (3-A) of the Act, extension of six months up to 07.09.2017 has been allowed. The existing Board of Directors have been asked to complete the process of election during that period. Thus, the existing Board of Directors of respondent No. 5 - APMC is permitted to continue till

    07.09.2017.

    9. This order, therefore, nowhere reveals the process of application of mind for satisfaction reached by the State Government or even a opinion by it that holding of simultaneous elections would not be in public interest. The

    7

    provisions of Section 14(3) and second proviso are attracted consequently because APMC cannot be held to be at fault for not completing the election process within time. However, the basic extension granted under Section 14(3-A) is the reason for not holding elections within that time. Thus, the backbone of order is only Section 14(3-A). Section 14(3-A) reads as under :

    "Where due to scarcity, draught, flood, fire or any other natural calamity or rainy season or any election programme of the State legislature or the Parliament or a local authority, coinciding with the election programme of any Market Committee or such other special reason, in the opinion of the State Government, it is not in the public interest to hold elections to any Market Committee, the State Government may, notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in any rules, or bye-law made thereunder, or any other law for the time being in force, for the reasons to be recorded in writing, by general or special order, postpone the election of any Market Committee for a period not exceeding six months at a time which period may further be extended, so, however, that the total period shall not exceed one year in the aggregate." Thus, scarcity, draught or election programme are

    8

    the contingencies / grounds envisaged therein. If these contingencies / circumstances are prevailing, and the State Government finds that it would not be in public interest to hold elections of Market Committee, then only the powers under Section 14(3-A) can be invoked. Thus, grounds or contingencies mentioned in sub-section (3-A) of the Act, by itself are not sufficient to postpone the elections. Those grounds must be found sufficient by the State Government to postpone elections because of public interest involved in the matter. Thus, bearing of those grounds on public interest is required to be demonstrated by the State Government in the impugned order. This exercise of application of mind will constitute reasons for postponing the elections. In the impugned order, except for mentioning receipt of representation demanding extension and simultaneous holding of elections of Municipal Corporation and Zilla Parishad, there is no such application of mind. This assumes importance because in 2012 when last elections of APMC were conducted, the exercise was undertaken simultaneously. This exercise which then could be undertaken simultaneously and was not

    9

    against public interest, cannot be now presumed to be against public interest. Special reasons or circumstances prevailing now which do not permit simultaneous conduct of elections or then which render it against public interest, therefore, ought to have been mentioned in the order dated 10.01.2017. Same are lacking even in the reply affidavit. Those reasons and application of mind accordingly is conspicuously absent in present matter.

    10. Co-relationship between elections of local body and

    "public interest" has to emerge only through reasons to be

    "recorded". Unless such reasons are recorded, impact of

    "grounds" adverse to public interest cannot be appreciated by anybody. Though "opinion" or satisfaction to be reached by the State Government may be subjective, still logical consideration of relevant material having nexus with the object i.e. public interest is the sine-qua-non to take recourse to power under section 14(3-A) of the Act. Bare perusal of impugned order dated 10.01.2017 here reveals failure to adopt this procedure and render it arbitrary.

    10

    11. In this situation, it is not necessary for us to look into other contentions raised by the petitioners. We, therefore, quash and set aside the impugned order dated 10.01.2017. We direct respondent No. 1 to proceed further with the election of Respondent No. 5 - APMC as per law.

    12. Rule is made absolute accordingly. However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

    JUDGE JUDGE

    ******

    *GS.

    11

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhagwan Sampatrao Ghodmare And Another Petitioners. v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
    (Mar 9, 2017)