Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 126 of the Act which is part of Chapter VII
  • Chapter V of the MRTP Act
  • Section 126(1) of the MRTP Act
  • Section 126, MRTP Act
  • Section 127 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 126 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 2(30) of the MRTP Act
  • The Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 127 of the Act
  • Section 88 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 2(9) of the MRTP Act
  • Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short “the MRTP Act”)
  • Section 127, MRTP Act
  • Chapter III of the MRTP Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 126 and 127 of the MRTP Act
  • Chapter VII of the MRTP Act
  • The Bombay Town Planning Act
  • Section 88(a) of the MRTP Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 126 of the Act which is part of Chapter VII
  • Chapter V of the MRTP Act
  • Section 126(1) of the MRTP Act
  • Section 126, MRTP Act
  • Section 127 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 126 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 2(30) of the MRTP Act
  • The Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • Section 127 of the Act
  • Section 88 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 2(9) of the MRTP Act
  • Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short “the MRTP Act”)
  • Section 127, MRTP Act
  • Chapter III of the MRTP Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 126 and 127 of the MRTP Act
  • Chapter VII of the MRTP Act
  • The Bombay Town Planning Act
  • Section 88(a) of the MRTP Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants are owners of Survey Nos. 431.A-1, 431.A-2, 431.A-3 and 431.B situated in the Mehrun area within the limits of the Jalgaon Municipal Council, Maharashtra. A draft development plan published on 15-12-1971 and brought into force on 16-12-1974 reserved their lands—re-numbered as Plot No. 287 (library, maternity home, dispensary) and Plot No. 288 (garden)—for public purposes under the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (MRTP Act).

Parallel to this, a separate Town Planning Scheme III covering a larger area, including the disputed plots, was initiated on 09-09-1976. An arbitrator appointed under Chapter V of the MRTP Act determined compensation on 20-03-1980; appeals to the Tribunal were dismissed in 1987. The State Government finally sanctioned the scheme on 29-05-/31-05-1993.

Contending that no acquisition proceedings under Section 126 had commenced within ten years of the development plan, the appellants served a notice dated 07-10-1986 under Section 127, claimed the reservation had lapsed after six months, and sought deletion of the reservation. When the Municipal Council took no action, they filed Writ Petitions Nos. 1924 & 1925 of 1992 (and later 1228 of 2001) before the Bombay High Court. By judgment dated 23-12-2004 the High Court dismissed the petitions, holding that Sections 126 and 127 do not apply to land reserved under a town-planning scheme. The present civil appeal challenges that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether land reserved for public purposes under a Town Planning Scheme is subject to the ten-year lapse provision and notice mechanism in Section 127 of the MRTP Act.
  2. Whether steps taken within the framework of Chapter V (town-planning schemes) constitute sufficient “acquisition” so as to render Sections 126 and 127 inapplicable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The ten-year period from the final development plan (16-12-1974) expired on 15-12-1984 without acquisition; hence, under Section 127, service of notice on 07-10-1986 released the land from reservation after six months.
  • The Town Planning Scheme was sanctioned only in January 1993, i.e. after the reservation had already lapsed.
  • Relied on Girnar Traders v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 7 SCC 555 to assert that failure to act within six months of the Section 127 notice leads to automatic lapse.

Respondents' Arguments (Planning Authority/Municipal Council)

  • The lands formed part of Town Planning Scheme III from 09-09-1976; therefore Sections 126 and 127, which govern development plans, are inapplicable.
  • The arbitrator awarded compensation in 1980 (Rs 1,20,000 for Plot 287 and Rs 1,51,700 for Plot 288); appeal was dismissed; land vested in the Planning Authority under Section 88 and advance possession was delivered on 21-02-1981.
  • Chapter V of the MRTP Act is a self-contained code; once the scheme process commences, acquisition under Section 126 is unnecessary.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Girnar Traders v. State of Maharashtra, (2007) 7 SCC 555 Land reserved in a development plan lapses if not acquired within six months of notice under Section 127. The Court distinguished the case, noting it concerned reservations under a development plan, whereas the present dispute involves land within a duly processed town-planning scheme; hence the principle was held inapplicable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Statutory Framework: The Court contrasted Chapters III (development plans) and V (town-planning schemes) of the MRTP Act. Section 127 expressly addresses lands “reserved, allotted or designated” in a development plan, not in a town-planning scheme. Conversely, Section 88, triggered when a final scheme comes into force, provides for automatic vesting of required lands in the Planning Authority.

2. Effect of Town Planning Scheme III: The disputed plots were included in the draft scheme of 1976; an arbitrator determined compensation in 1980, and appeals concluded in 1987. These proceedings satisfied the statutory acquisition mechanism embodied in Chapter V; therefore acquisition under Section 126 was unnecessary.

3. Distinguishing Girnar Traders: That decision dealt with lapsing of reservations in a development plan where no steps under Section 126 were taken. Here, acquisition occurred through the scheme route, making the appellants’ reliance misplaced.

4. Lapse Argument Rejected: Because Section 127 is silent on town-planning schemes and the scheme process had substantially progressed before the appellants’ notice, the reservation never lapsed. The land had already vested in the Planning Authority under Section 88.

5. No Procedural Irregularity: The High Court correctly concluded that Sections 126/127 apply only in circumstances excluded from Section 88(a). The Supreme Court found no error in that interpretation or in the factual findings regarding compensation and vesting.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Consequently, the reservation of the appellants’ land for public purposes under Town Planning Scheme III remains intact, and the compensation determined by the arbitrator stands. The decision reinforces the statutory distinction between reservations under a development plan and those under a town-planning scheme; it clarifies that Section 127’s lapsing mechanism does not apply once land is subjected to the scheme process under Chapter V. No broader precedent beyond this clarification was set, and no costs were awarded.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Pukhrajmal Sagarmal Lunkad (Dead) Through His Legal Representatives And Others v. Municipal Council, Jalgaon And Others

    Prafulla C. Pant, J.— This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 23-12-2004 2004 SCC OnLine Bom 1161, passed by the High Court of Judicature of Bombay, Bench at Aurangabad, whereby the said Court has dismissed Writ Petition No. 1924 of 1992. And for the reasons given in the said order, the other two Writ Petitions Nos. 1925 of 1992 and 1228 of 2001 were also dismissed.

    2. In the above writ petitions (Nos. 1924 and 1925 of 1992), town planning scheme in respect of Survey No. 431.A (new Plot No. 287) and Survey No. 431.B (new Plot No. 288) situated at Mehrun area within the limits of Municipal Council, Jalgaon, was sought to be quashed.

    3. The brief facts of the case are that appellants were admittedly owners of Survey Nos. 431.A-1, A-2 and A-3 and Survey No. 431.B. On 15-12-1971, Jalgaon Municipal Council which is a Planning Authority under the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short “the MRTP Act”), published draft development plan in respect of certain lands including the aforementioned plots owned by the appellants and reserved the same for public purpose, renumbering them as Plot No. 288 in Reservation Site No. 107 (for garden) and Plot No. 287 reserved in Site Nos. 104 and 105 (for the purposes of construction of library, maternity home and dispensary). Final development plan was sanctioned in respect of above area which came into operation on 16-12-1974. According to the appellants, this date is the starting point for taking steps for acquisition within a period of ten years under the MRTP Act, as the owners got restricted/prevented from carrying out any developmental activities over their land. It is pleaded by them that the procedure for acquisition of the land reserved for public purpose is provided under Chapter VII, which allowed at the relevant point of time only two modes of acquisition under Section 126(1) of the MRTP Act, namely — (i) by agreement, and (ii) by making an application to the State Government for acquiring such land under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.

    4. Section 127 of the MRTP Act, provides that if any land reserved, allotted or designated for any purpose specified in any plan under the Act, is not acquired by agreement within ten years from the date on which the final regional plan or final development plan came into force or if proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, are not commenced within such period, the owner or any person interested in the land, may serve notice on the Planning Authority, Development Authority or appropriate authority, as the case may be, and if within six months of such notice, the land is not acquired or no steps, as aforesaid, are commenced for the acquisition, the reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have lapsed, and thereupon the land shall be deemed to be released from the reservation, allotment or designation, and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.

    5. The appellants' case is that on 15-12-1984 ten years stood expired from the date of coming into operation of final development plan, and the respondents failed to acquire the land. As such, the original appellants/landowners sent a notice under Section 127 of the MRTP Act to the Planning Authority, Jalgaon Municipal Council on 7-10-1986, but even after receipt of such notice, the Municipal Council failed to take steps for acquisition of the appellants' land reserved for public purpose within the period of six months, and consequently, the land stood released from the reservation. But when in spite of repeated representations no orders were passed by the Planning Authority releasing the land, the appellants filed Writ Petitions Nos. 1924 and 1925 of 1992 qua Survey Nos. 431.A and 431.B respectively, seeking writ of mandamus to quash the reservation of the appellants' land for town planning scheme.

    6. On the other hand, on behalf of the Planning Authority/Jalgaon Municipal Council, it is stated that larger area of land including the land in question was subsequently reserved on 9-9-1976 for public purposes under the Town Planning Scheme III, and Sections 126 and 127 of the MRTP Act have no application in the present case. The scheme started way back in year 1976 and arbitrator was appointed under the Act and he passed award on 20-3-1980 and compensation of Rs 1,20,000 for Plot No. 287 (old No. 431-A) and Rs 1,51,700 for Plot No. 288 (old No. 431-B) was determined. The appeal to the Tribunal regarding compensation was dismissed. It is further stated that the land stood vested under Section 88 of the MRTP Act. On behalf of the respondents, it is also pointed out that advance possession of the land was voluntarily delivered by the appellants to the Municipal Council on 21-2-1981 and compensation determined by the arbitrator was deposited. (The appellants have responded to the above plea by stating that the advance possession was delivered only in respect of a small strip of land used for twenty feet wide road.)

    7. It is not out of context to mention here that the revised development plan for Town Planning Scheme III was submitted by the Municipal Council on 1-3-1988, which the State Government sanctioned on 6-1-1993 and in said scheme the land in question was reserved for “civic centre”. The State Government approved the said final town planning scheme on 29-5-1993/31-5-1993. It has also come on record that at one stage, on the representation of the appellants in the year 1984, the Municipal Council submitted proposal for deletion of land from reservation for development plan, but the same was rejected by the State Government.

    8. The High Court, after hearing the parties, opined that the development plan proposals are executed by the local authority either by compulsory land acquisition, or by preparing and executing town planning scheme for different parts of the town so that when all proposals are carried out, there would be harmony and the town is developed in planned manner. The High Court further observed that in making a town planning scheme the lands of all persons covered by the scheme are treated as if they are to be in a pool. The town planning officer then proceeds to reconstitute the plots for residential buildings and reserves certain lands for public purposes. The reconstituted plots are allotted to landowners with change in shape and size. The arbitrator under the MRTP Act lays out new roads, reserves land for recreation grounds, schools, markets, green-belts and similar public purposes. The object of the scheme being so to provide amenities and benefit to the residents, the area in occupation of individual landholders is reduced. The result is that there is shifting of plots of land, roads, means of communication. As such, the rearrangement of titles in the various plots requires financial adjustments to be made and the owners who are deprived of their land are compensated.

    9. The High Court, discussing the provisions of the Bombay Town Planning Act and that of the MRTP Act, has held that Section 126 of the MRTP Act providing for acquisition could only be resorted to, in relation to the cases covered by exclusionary clause used in Section 88(a) of the Act, and it further held that Section 127 does not apply to lands reserved for public purpose under Town Planning Scheme, and, as such, there is no lapsing of reservation of land under Section 127 of the Act, and dismissed the writ petitions.

    10. We have examined the matter and considered the rival submissions of the learned counsel for the parties.

    11. Before further discussion, we think it just and proper to look into the definitions of “development plan” and “town planning scheme”. Section 2(9) of the MRTP Act defines the term “development plan” and reads as under:

    “2. (9) “Development plan” means a plan for the development or re-development of the area within the jurisdiction of a Planning Authority and includes revision of a development plan and proposals of a Special Planning Authority for development of land within its jurisdiction.”

    The expression town planning scheme is not defined in the Act but under Section 2(30) the word “scheme” is defined as:

    “2. (30) “Scheme” includes a plan relating to a town planning scheme.”

    12. According to Concise Oxford English Dictionary “scheme” means a systematic plan or arrangement for attaining some particular object or putting a particular idea into effect. In the same dictionary, the term “planning” means planning and control of the construction, growth, and development of a town or other urban area. As such, we may say that the term “planning scheme” means, a systematic plan with an object of planning and control of the construction, growth and development of a town. We also think it relevant to mention here that development plans are dealt with under Chapter III, and town planning schemes are dealt with under Chapter V of the MRTP Act. Section 126 of the Act which is part of Chapter VII, deals with plans as well as schemes, but Section 127 does not refer to town planning schemes.

    13. Effect of final town planning scheme is provided in Section 88 of the MRTP Act which reads (as it existed before 2014), as under:

    “88. Effect of final scheme.—On and after the day on which a final scheme comes into force—
    (a) all lands required by the Planning Authority shall, unless it is otherwise determined in such scheme, vest absolutely in the Planning Authority free from all encumbrances;
    (b) all rights in the original plots which have been reconstituted shall determine, and the reconstituted plots shall become subject to the rights settled by arbitrator;
    (c) the Planning Authority shall hand over possession of the final plots to the owners to whom they are allotted in the final scheme.”

    14. It is stated that draft development plan relating to plots in question was initially published on 15-12-1971 which was sanctioned by the State Government on 11-4-1974 and finally development plan was operationalised on 16-12-1974. But the town planning scheme based on the said development plan relating to the plots in question is stated to have been prepared on 9-9-1976, and thereafter finalised and sanctioned on 29-5-1993/31-5-1993.

    15. The learned counsel for the appellants argued that the town planning scheme was approved by the State Government in January 1993, based on a revised development plan submitted by the Municipal Council in 1988 i.e after reservation of land in question already stood lapsed as the landowners had served the notice under Section 127 of the MRTP Act on 7-10-1986 and six months' period had passed thereafter. This argument on scrutiny lacks substance for the reason that the land in question was reserved in 1976 under Town Planning Scheme III. We have already discussed above that Section 127 does not refer to town planning schemes.

    16. In the present case the prayer is made by the appellants in the writ petitions specifically in respect of Town Planning Scheme III, which was finally sanctioned, as such, we find no error in the impugned judgment passed by the High Court dismissing the writ petitions. From the copy of special notice dated 25-4-1980 in Form 4 issued under the Town Planning Scheme Rules (filed as Annexure B with the additional documents) and copy of order dated 16-5-1980 passed by the arbitrator in the aforesaid Rules, it is clear that the compensation was determined in respect of land in question under town planning scheme. The decision of the arbitrator appears to have been published in the Official Gazette dated 20-8-1980, and appeal was dismissed. In the circumstances, we find no error in the order passed by the High Court.

    17. The landowners further relied on Girnar Traders v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 7 SCC 555 to contend that the land is deemed to have been released after 6 months of the issue of notice under Section 127 of the MRTP Act. The contention of the landowners cannot be accepted for the reason that the decision relied on by the landowners to contend that no steps were taken relates to the “development plan” for which the steps for acquisition had to be taken as per Section 126. In the present case, before the scheme is implemented, the procedure contemplated under Chapter V is followed to finalise the scheme. The procedure includes the sanctioning of draft scheme, appointment of arbitrator, issuing notices to persons affected by the scheme, determination of compensation by the arbitrator and then the final award made by the arbitrator. In respect of the land required under town planning scheme except the development plan, the steps under Section 126 may not require to be resorted to at all. It is clear from the record that the draft town planning scheme was published in 1976, arbitrator determined the compensation in 1980, the appeal filed before the Tribunal was dismissed in 1987 and the scheme was sent to the Government for sanction in 1988 and it was finally sanctioned in 1993 by following the procedure under Chapter V which is a self-contained code for the implementation of the town planning scheme.

    18. For the reasons as discussed above, we do not find any force in this appeal. Accordingly, the same is dismissed. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pukhrajmal Sagarmal ... v. Municipal Council, J...
    (Feb 3, 2017)