Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition challenges the order dated 28.05.2015 of the Central Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal) in which OA No. 1935/2015 filed by the petitioners was allowed but the Tribunal declined to quash or set aside Advertisement No. 3/2013 dated 12.09.2013 issued for recruitment to the post of Administrative Officer/Assistant Assessor & Collector (AO/AA&C) (Post Code 46/2013).

Petitioner No. 1 is an Association of Ministerial Staff of Corporations; petitioners No. 2 to No. 4 are individual employees who originally joined the Municipal Corporation of Delhi as Lower Division Clerks (in 1979, 1983 and 1995 respectively), were promoted to Upper Division Clerk (in 1989/1990/2001) and later as Head Clerks (in 2003–2004). The petitioners allege that the respondents did not hold Departmental Promotion Committees (DPCs) for filling the posts of Superintendent and AO/AA&C from 2002 to 2011 and made representations on 06.09.2011 and 23.09.2011 requesting filling of posts by promotion as required by the Recruitment Rules.

Despite those representations and the Recruitment Rules, respondents issued Advertisement No. 3/2013 dated 12.09.2013 to fill AO/AA&C vacancies by direct recruitment. Petitioner No. 1 filed OA No. 3883/2013 before the Tribunal, which was dismissed as withdrawn on 08.11.2013 with liberty to file a fresh OA. Respondents issued a notification dated 02.05.2015 stating the recruitment process pursuant to the 12.09.2013 advertisement would continue and a written test would be held on 31.05.2015. The petitioners then filed OA No. 1935/2015 challenging the advertisement.

The Tribunal in its impugned order dated 28.05.2015 disposed of OA No. 1935/2015 but did not quash Advertisement No. 3/2013. The Tribunal observed that the Notification in respect of Administrative Officers was valid and in greater public interest, and that respondents could continue the recruitment process under that Notification, though promotional avenues must not be tampered with. The petitioners challenged the Tribunal's order before this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the advertisement dated 12.09.2013 (Advertisement No. 3/2013) for filling AO/AA&C (Post Code 46/2013) by direct recruitment contravenes the applicable Recruitment Rules which provide that vacancies are to be filled by promotion first, failing which by transfer/deputation, and only thereafter by direct recruitment.
  2. Whether the Tribunal erred in declining to quash the advertisement and in permitting the respondents to continue the recruitment process despite the petitioners' claim that DPCs were not conducted and promotion avenues were not exhausted.
  3. Whether the amended Recruitment Rules dated 17.06.2013 relied upon by the respondents (which provide 50% by promotion failing which by direct recruitment and 50% by deputation failing which by direct recruitment) alter the respondents' obligations under the earlier rules and justify the impugned advertisement.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Behera)

  • The advertisement dated 12.09.2013 is in violation of the Recruitment Rules applicable to the post of AO/AA&C because those Rules mandate that vacancies be filled by promotion first, failing which by transfer or deputation, and only if those modes fail may vacancies be filled by direct recruitment.
  • Petitioners No. 2 to No. 4 had been in service and promoted through lower grades, and their representations requesting filling up of the posts through promotion were ignored.
  • The respondents have not held any DPC since 2007 and have not taken steps to fill the posts by transfer or deputation; therefore the pre-condition to resort to direct recruitment has not been satisfied.
  • The advertisement sought to fill 30 vacancies (breakdown provided in the petition) and was issued while the earlier Recruitment Rules were in force for at least part of the period to which the vacancies relate.

Respondents' Arguments (as advanced by Ms. Biji Rajesh and other counsel)

  • The Recruitment Rules relied upon by the petitioners have been revised by a Notification dated 17.06.2013. Under the revised rules, the method of recruitment is: (i) 50% by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment; and (ii) 50% by deputation, failing which by direct recruitment. Thus the amended rules alter the prior scheme relied upon by petitioners.
  • The Municipal Corporations contend that there are a total of 116 sanctioned posts and that even if appointments are made by direct recruitment pursuant to the advertisement, no prejudice would be caused to the petitioners' rights.
  • One respondent's counsel expressed apprehension that the department might consider further amending the Recruitment Rules, and sought that the Court's order should not obstruct future amendments; however counsel admitted there were no specific instructions or proposals to amend the rules further at that time.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court summarized the dispute as arising from the respondents' issuance of an advertisement for direct recruitment to AO/AA&C despite Recruitment Rules which, both before and after amendment, treat promotion as the primary mode of filling vacancies.

The Court compared the unamended Recruitment Rules (which provided that vacancies are to be filled by promotion, failing which by transfer on deputation and failing both by direct recruitment) with the amended Recruitment Rules notified on 17.06.2013 (which specify i) 50% by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment and ii) 50% by deputation, failing which by direct recruitment). The Court observed that, in either formulation, promotion is the first option available to the Department.

Applying the legal principle that an employer must exhaust the primary modes of recruitment prescribed by recruitment rules before resorting to direct recruitment, the Court found as a fact (on the basis of the material before it) that respondents had not held any DPCs since 2007 and had not explored transfer or deputation routes. The Court therefore concluded that the respondents had not exhausted the first available mode (promotion) and were not entitled to publish the advertisement for direct recruitment.

The Court addressed the respondents' contention about the 17.06.2013 amendment and the possibility of future amendments, noting that any future amendment would ordinarily have prospective effect unless expressly made retrospective; but in any event those contentions did not relieve respondents of their obligation to follow the recruitment rules in force for the vacancies in question. The Court also noted the Tribunal's observation about public interest and promotional avenues, but held that the Tribunal's laudable concern did not justify ignoring the recruitment rules.

Based on this analysis, the Court concluded that the advertisement violated the recruitment rules because the prescribed promotional avenue had not been exhausted and therefore quashed the impugned advertisement and set aside the Tribunal's order to the extent it allowed continuation of the recruitment process.

The Court further directed that the respondents must hold the DPC for the post in question within two months. If the respondents failed to do so, the Court warned it would take a serious view (as stated in the order).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed: the impugned advertisement (Advertisement No. 3/2013 dated 12.09.2013) qua Post Code 46/13 (Administrative Officer/Assistant Assessor & Collector) is quashed and the order of the Tribunal in so far as it permitted continuation of the recruitment process is set aside.

Implications and consequences:

  • The direct, immediate consequence is that the advertisement issued for direct recruitment to AO/AA&C (Post Code 46/13) is invalid and recruitment under that advertisement cannot proceed.
  • The respondents are ordered to hold the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) for the post within two months; failure to do so will invite the Court to take a serious view.
  • No broader rule of law or new precedent beyond the parties' dispute is elaborated in the opinion; the decision enforces compliance with the extant recruitment rules and affects the parties directly rather than laying down a novel legal principle.

Writ petition disposed of in the terms set out above.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Mcd Ministerial Staff Association (Regd.) & Ors. Petitioners v. The Director, Local Bodies, New Secretairat & Ors. S

    G.S Sistani, J.:— Challenge in this writ petition is to the order dated 28.5.2015 passed by Central Administrative Tribunal (in short ‘the Tribunal’) by which OA No. 1935/2015 filed by petitioners herein was allowed but the Tribunal has failed to quash and set aside the Advertisement dated 12.9.2013

    2. With the consent of counsel for the parties, present writ petition is set down for final hearing and disposal.

    3. The present petition pertains to the post of Administrative Officer/Assistant Assessor and Collector (hereinafter referred to as ‘AO/AA&C’) (Post Code 46/2013).

    4. The necessary facts, which are required to be noticed for disposal of the present writ petition, are that petitioner no. 1 is an Association of Ministerial Staff of Corporations and petitioners no. 2 and 4 are directly affected person.

    5. As per the petition, petitioners no. 2 to 4 have initially joined Municipal Corporation of Delhi as Lower Division Clerks in the year 1979, 1983 and 1995, respectively. Thereafter petitioners no. 2 to 4 were promoted to the post of Upper Division Clerk in the years 1990, 1989 and 2001, respectively. In the years 2003 to 2004, petitioners no. 2 to 4 were promoted as Head Clerk. Since the respondents did not conduct DPC for filling up the post of Superintendent and AO/AA&C from the year 2002 to 2011, on 6.9.2011 the petitioners submitted representations for filling up the said post. On 23.9.2011, petitioners no. 2 to 4 submitted another representation challenging the action of respondents in resorting to direct recruitment by violating the statutory Recruitment Rules and not holding DPC for promotion to the said post of AO/AA&C. On 12.9.2013, the respondents while ignoring the aforesaid representations and statutory Recruitment Rules, issued advertisement for filling up the vacancies of AO/AA&C by way of direct recruitment despite the fact that in the Recruitment Rules, it has been clearly mentioned that the vacancies of AO/AA&C are to be filled up by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment. Thus, the respondents are not justified in not resorting to promotion by holding DPCs and proceeding further to second mode of recruitment i.e direct recruitment. Aggrieved by the aforesaid, the petitioner no. 1 filed OA No. 3883/2013 before the Tribunal, however, the said OA was dismissed as withdrawn on 8.11.2013 with liberty to file a fresh OA. In the meanwhile, respondents have issued a notification dated 2.5.2015 wherein it has been stated that the recruitment process pursuant to the advertisement dated 12.9.2013 would continue and the written test would be held on 31.5.2015 Aggrieved by the advertisement, the petitioners filed OA No. 1935/2015 before the Tribunal. The Tribunal vide impugned order dated 28.5.2015 disposed of the OA but did not quash and set aside the advertisement no. 3/2013 dated 12.9.2013 The Tribunal while passing the impugned order has also observed that the Notification in respect of Administrative Officers under challenge is valid and in greater public interest. It was also observed that the respondents could continue with their recruitment process under the said Notification as the same was not against the constitutional provisions but it was made clear that the promotional avenues must not be tampered with. Aggrieved by the impugned order, the petitioners filed the present writ petition.

    6. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the learned Tribunal has failed to take into consideration the Recruitment Rules for the post of AO/AA&C. Counsel further submits that the respondents had published the vacancy notice advertisement no. 3/13 dated 12.9.2013 with respect to AO/AA&C (Post Code 46/13) ignoring the representations of petitioners no. 2 to 4 and the Recruitment Rules. It is contended that by the said advertisement the respondents intended to fill-up 30 vacancies, the break-up of which is as under:

    Post CodeName of PostName of DepartmentUROBCSCSTTOTALPHEX SMSPORTS46/13Administrative Officer/Asstt. Assessor and CollectorMunicipal Corporatio ns of Delhi160804023001--

    7. Mr. Behera, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the main grievance of the petitioners is that the vacancy advertisement dated 12.9.2013 is against the Recruitment Rules. Counsel further submits that as per the Recruitment Rules, the posts are to be filled up by promotion, failing which by transfer or deputation and failing both by direct recruitment. In support of this submission counsel has drawn the attention of the Court to the Recruitment Rules, relevant portion of which reads as under:

    “RECRUITMENT REGULATION FOR THE POST OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER/ASSISTANT ASSESSOR & COLLECTOR

    11Method of recrtt. Whether by direct rectt. or by promotion or by deputation/transfer & percentage of the vacancies to be filled by various methods”.By promotion failing which b y transfer on deputation and failing both by direct recruitment.

    8. Mr. Behera further submits that the respondents have failed to hold any DPC since the year 2007. It is further submitted that no steps have been taken by the respondents for filling up the posts through transfer or deputation and in the absence thereof this advertisement published is liable to be quashed.

    9. Ms. Biji Rajesh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent no. 2.North Delhi Municipal Corporation, submits that the Recruitment Rules sought to be relied upon by counsel for the petitioners have since been revised and as per the revised Recruitment Rules dated 17.6.2013, the method of recruitment is 50% by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment and 50% by deputation failing which by direct recruitment.

    10. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of respective Municipal Corporations submit that there are total 116 sanctioned posts and even if the appointments are made by direct recruitment, no prejudice would be caused to the rights of the petitioners.

    11. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered their rival submissions.

    12. In this case, the petitioners are aggrieved by the advertisement published by the respondents for filling up the vacancies of AO/AA&C by way of direct recruitment despite the fact that the existing Recruitment Rules provide that the vacancies are to be filled up by promotion at the first instance and failing which by transfer or deputation and in the eventuality that the post cannot be filled up either by promotion, transfer or deputation, the vacancies are to be filled up by direct recruitment. The petitioners have, thus, prayed for quashing of advertisement so published.

    13. The respondents have opposed this petition, firstly, on the ground that the Recruitment Rules, sought to be relied upon by the petitioners, already stand amended. Another objection, which is sought to be raised, is that there are total 116 sanctioned posts and even if appointments are made by direct recruitment based on the advertisement, no prejudice would be caused to the rights of the petitioners.

    14. Mr. Virender Pratap Singh Charak, learned counsel for respondent No. 3.SDMC has also expressed an apprehension that the department may consider amending the recruitment rules again and thus this order should not come in the way of the department. We have asked Mr. Singh as to whether he has any specific instructions or as to whether there is any proposal on behalf of the respondents to further amend the recruitment rules, the answer is in the negative. We may also add at this stage that even if the respondents propose to amend the recruitment rules to which there can be no bar and the recruitment rules, if amended, would obviously be prospective in nature unless a specific provision is made that the rules would be retrospective in nature. In any case, this issue cannot hold us in passing the order as the writ petition is premised on the existing Recruitment Rules.

    15. The Recruitment Rules relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioners have been extracted in paragraph-7 aforgoing. The amended Recruitment Rules sought to be relied upon by learned counsel for the respondents read as under:-

    “Govt. of NCT of Delhi

    (Urban Development Department)

    9th level, C-Wing, Delhi Secretariat

    IP Estate, New Delhi.

    No. 13(97)/MB/UD/CC/2011/3065-3074 Delhi dated the 17/6/2013

    NOTIFICATION

    …………………………………………………….

    ‘SCHEDULE’

    RECRUITMENT REGULATIONS FOR THE POST OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER/ASSISTANT ASSESSOR AND COLLECTOR IN NORTH, SOUTH AND EAST DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATIONS.

    1.Name of the PostAdministrative Officer/Assistant Assessor and Collector2.…………………………..…………………………3.…………………………..………………………..4.…………………………..………………………..5.…………………………..………………………..6.…………………………..………………………..7.………………………….……………………….8.………………………….……………………….9.………………………….……………………….10.Method of recruitment whether by direct recruitment or by promotion or by deputation/absorption and % of the vacancies to be filled by various method.i) 50% by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment. ii) 50% by deputation, failing which by direct recruitment.”

    16. Reading of both, the unamended Recruitment Rules and the amended Recruitment Rules, makes it abundantly clear that the vacancies are to be filled up by promotion. As per the unamended Recruitment Rules all the vacancies are to be filled up by promotion, however, as per the amended Recruitment Rules 50% of the vacancies are to be filled up by promotion failing which by direct recruitment and remaining 50% by deputation failing which by direct recruitment.

    17. Looking at both the Recruitment Rules would show that the first option available with the Department is to fill up the vacancies by promotion. Since the respondents have not exhausted the first option available to them it is not open to the respondents to publish an advertisement for direct recruitment.

    18. Learned counsel for the petitioners has also drawn attention of this Court to the fact that the advertisement published by the respondents was made on the basis of old recruitment rules for the reason that it pertains to vacancies during the period the old recruitment rules were in force.

    19. A reading of the recruitment rules relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioners as also the existing recruitment rules make it abundantly clear that the respondents have failed to comply with the recruitment rules and only after the respondents have been unable to fill up the vacancies either by promotion or by transfer or deputation would the department be entitled to publish the advertisement to fill up the vacancies. Admittedly, the respondents have not complied with the existing recruitment rules. They have also not made any effort to hold any DPC to carry out the promotions. The respondents have also not explored the possibility of recruiting and filling up the vacancies either by transfers or deputation for the reason that the said stage has not arisen as of now.

    20. Consequently, the impugned advertisement issued by the respondents qua the post code 46/13 is quashed. The order passed by the Tribunal is set aside. The present writ petition is allowed. We may add here that the Tribunal has highlighted that the notification/advertisement is of grave public interest and promotional avenues must not be tempered with. The thought, no doubt, is laudable, but is not applicable to the facts of the present case as the recruitment rules cannot be ignored. The respondents are bound by their own recruitment rules which have not been complied with by them. We may also add here that the Tribunal has granted two months time to the respondents to hold DPC for the post in question and if no DPC has been held by the respondents for the said post, the same shall be held by them positively within two months, failing which the Court would be compelled to take a serious view in the matter.

    21. Writ petition stands disposed of in the above terms.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mcd Ministerial Staf... v. The Director, Local ...
    (Sep 1, 2016)