Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — S. Ravindra Bhat, J. (Open Court)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an order of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) dated 06.01.2014 in O.A. No. 1702/2013, which had declined the petitioner's application seeking a direction to respondents/GNCTD to apply a Department of Education circular dated 01.11.1980 (granting 10 years general age relaxation for women candidates for recruitment to teachers' posts) to the post of Librarian.

Relevant events (as recorded in the opinion): GNCTD issued a notification on 21.01.2011 declaring the post of Librarian in its schools "as teaching post for all purpose" and directed that Librarians would avail benefits applicable to the teaching category prospectively. An earlier advertisement for 89 Librarian vacancies dated 24.10.2011 was scrapped by this Court in W.P. (C) No. 3411/2012 dated 01.06.2012 (challenge based on compliance with Section 32 of the Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995); a review was dismissed on 07.09.2012. A fresh advertisement was issued on 20.02.2013 prescribing an age limit of 30 years with certain relaxations (generally up to five years for some categories, up to 10 years for persons with disabilities etc.), but not expressly applying the 01.11.1980 circular’s 10-year relaxation for women to Librarian posts. The petitioner approached CAT seeking application of the 01.11.1980 circular; CAT dismissed the application. The petitioner then filed the present writ petition under Article 226.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Department of Education circular dated 01.11.1980 (granting 10 years general age relaxation for women for recruitment to teachers' posts) applies to the post of Librarian in GNCTD schools in view of the 21.01.2011 notification equating Librarian with teaching posts "for all purpose".
  2. Whether the CAT was correct in declining to direct GNCTD to apply the 1980 circular to the Librarian recruitment, particularly where the respondents had not stated that the 1980 circular had been superseded.
  3. Whether the decision of GNCTD to withhold the gender-based age relaxation (without an express statement that the 1980 circular is inapplicable or superseded) is permissible exercise of policy discretions, or whether it violates Article 14 of the Constitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Once GNCTD had equated the post of Librarian with that of teachers "for all purpose" (by the 21.01.2011 order), incumbents and prospective candidates for Librarian must be treated alike and be eligible for the same benefits given to teachers, including the 10-year general age relaxation for women under the 01.11.1980 circular.
  • The recruitment rules framed (stating age limit 30 years and relaxation up to five years) could not exclude the gender-based age relaxation conferred by the 1980 circular.
  • GNCTD had not alleged, before the Tribunal or by document, that the 1980 circular was superseded; therefore its denial of the benefit was arbitrary.
  • Other miscellaneous/non-teaching posts (e.g., drawing teachers) had been afforded similar 10-year relaxation for women, indicating a GNCTD policy of granting such relief; the petitioner relied on earlier decisions of this Court (Nutan Gulati and Neha Vashisht) recognizing consequences of the 2011 equation.

Respondents' (GNCTD) Arguments

  • The issue of granting age relaxation is a policy decision, and the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to prescribe eligibility conditions such as qualification and age relaxation; accordingly the CAT rightly declined relief.
  • The Recruitment Rules for Librarian (framed in or pertaining to earlier years) do not enable the specific age relaxation claimed by the petitioner.
  • The Tribunal's order was reasonable; reliance was placed on precedents cautioning courts/tribunals against engaging in policy formulation (V.K. Sood v. Secretary, Civil Aviation and State of M.P. v. Dharamveer).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nutan Gulati v. Directorate of Education (W.P. (C) No. 109/2013 decided 09.07.2013) Recognition of consequences flowing from the equation of Librarian with teaching posts (example: parity in extension of retirement age from 60 to 62 for Librarians when equated with teachers). The Court relied on Nutan Gulati to show that prior judgments have given effect to consequences of the 21.01.2011 equation and that those consequences must be respected in the present context of age relaxation.
Neha Vashisht v. GNCT of Delhi (W.P. (C) No. 1840/2013 decided 23.01.2004) Discussion and application of the 2011 equation of Librarian with teaching posts in the context of appointments and terms of service. The Court treated Neha Vashisht as another decision where the consequences of the 2011 equation were addressed, supporting the view that the equation affects various conditions of service applicable to Librarians.
V.K. Sood v. Secretary, Civil Aviation, 1993 Supp (3) SCC 9 Principle that courts/tribunals should not substitute their view for policy decisions or engage in policy formulation regarding terms of recruitment. GNCTD relied on this precedent to argue that CAT and courts should not prescribe eligibility conditions; the Court noted the reliance but found other facts and prior decisions made the GNCTD stance untenable in the present case.
State of M.P. v. Dharamveer, (1998) 6 SCC 165 Similar principle to V.K. Sood cautioning judicial engagement in policy-making or altering recruitment terms. GNCTD cited this authority to support the submission that the Tribunal should not determine policy; the Court acknowledged the precedent but concluded that the combination of the 2011 equation and prior judicial decisions required application of the 1980 circular benefits.
Smt. Promila Dixit v. GNCTD, W.P. (C) No. 1234/2010 decided 26.11.2010 Held an identical contention (equation of TGT with Librarian for purposes of recruitment and age relaxation) in favour of the claimant. The Court observed that the CAT erred in ignoring this directly relevant judgment; Promila Dixit supported the conclusion that age-relaxation benefits flowing from teacher-status should be extended to Librarians.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from the factual finding that the 21.01.2011 notification unequivocally declared the post of Librarian to be a teaching post "for all purpose", and that this equation was a matter of record not disputed by the respondents. The critical question was whether the 01.11.1980 circular granting women a general 10-year age relaxation for recruitment to teachers' posts therefore applied to Librarian posts.

The respondents' main contention was that granting such age relaxation is a policy decision and that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to prescribe recruitment eligibility conditions; further, they suggested that the recruitment rules for Librarian (as then framed) did not permit the claimed relaxation. The Court found this argument unsustainable for several reasons, each drawn from the record:

  • The respondents never asserted in their reply before the Tribunal, nor in any document referred to in the proceedings, that the 01.11.1980 circular had been expressly superseded. The absence of any such claim meant that GNCTD's denial of the benefit rested on silence rather than an affirmative justification.
  • The 21.01.2011 equation of posts had been made effective after the recruitment rules were framed; prior judicial pronouncements (Nutan Gulati and Neha Vashisht) had already noticed and given effect to the diverse service consequences of that equation (such as retirement age parity and appointment considerations).
  • Given those prior judicial decisions and the factual equation on record, the Court held that GNCTD's failure to carry out "necessary consequential amendment" to recruitment rules did not absolve it from the obligation to apply benefits flowing from the 1980 circular. Treating similarly situated candidates differently without any stated basis violated Article 14.
  • The Court noted that GNCTD had implemented the 10-year relaxation (based on the 1980 circular or assimilating rules) for other categories of teaching staff, which undermined the position that Librarians should uniquely be denied the same treatment.
  • The Court criticized the CAT for ignoring the directly applicable decision in Promila Dixit, which had upheld an identical contention relating to equation and age relaxation; the CAT's failure in this respect was held to be erroneous.

In sum, the Court concluded that the respondents' reliance on policy-space arguments could not justify denying an established, recorded benefit to persons occupying a post which had been equated with teaching posts; doing so without stating that the foundational circular had been superseded, or without any other rational basis, offended Article 14.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition is allowed; the impugned order of the CAT dated 06.01.2014 in O.A. No. 1702/2013 is set aside. The respondents are directed to accept the petitioner's application and permit her to appear in the competitive examination scheduled on 31.08.2014.

Specific consequential directions given by the Court (direct effect on parties):

  • The petitioner shall be intimated about her examination centre and given the Admit Card on 27.08.2014 by the concerned officer of the DSSSB; she shall appear before that officer on 27.08.2014 at 11:00 a.m.
  • GNCTD is directed to coordinate with DSSSB to ensure issuance of the Admit Card and intimation about the examination centre on 27.08.2014.

Implications: The immediate consequence is that the petitioner receives the benefit of being allowed to participate in the recruitment process for the Librarian post in line with the Court's conclusion that the 01.11.1980 circular applies in the circumstances. The opinion finds the GNCTD's denial of the benefit to be violative of Article 14. The Court did not purport to engage in fresh policy formulation; rather it applied existing facts (the 2011 equation) and prior judicial decisions to require that the benefits flowing from the 1980 circular be extended. The judgment remedies the petitioner's individual grievance; the opinion does not indicate that it is laying down a novel, freestanding legal principle beyond applying earlier authorities and equal-treatment norms.

Order Dasti was directed under the signature of the Court Master. The writ petition was allowed in the terms described above.

    Asha Petitioner v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi & Ors. S

    S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J. (OPEN COURT)

    1. The petitioner challenges an order of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT/Tribunal) dated 06.01.2014 in O.A No. 1702/2013 declining that application, whereby a direction was sought to the respondents/GNCTD that they ought to apply a circular dated 01.11.1980 extending general age relaxation for ten years for women candidates for recruitment to the teachers post, to the post of Librarian.

    2. Briefly, the facts are that the post to which the petitioner seeks employment is that of Librarian in GNCTD established and managed schools in Delhi. On 21.01.2011, the GNCTD had issued an order to the following effect:

    “The post of Librarian in Govt. Schools of Dte. of Education, Govt. of N.C.T of Delhi is hereby declared as teaching post for all purpose with immediate effect and accordingly the Librarians shall avail all benefits applicable to teaching category in prospective manner only. It is further ordered that the Librarians shall take classes also besides the work of Library as and when required by concerned HOS/any other higher authority. This issue with the prior approval of Director of Education”.

    3. Subsequently, on 24.10.2011, 89 vacancies were notified in the cadre of Librarian. This advertisement was challenged by certain candidates on the allegation that the provisions of Section 32 of the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 had not been followed. By order dated 01.06.2012 (in W.P (C) No. 3411/2012), the advertisement was directed to be scrapped. A review proceeding seeking recall of that order was also dismissed on 07.09.2012

    4. In these circumstances, a fresh advertisement was issued on 20.02.2013 The relevant condition with which the petitioner was aggrieved, and which impelled her to approach the Tribunal was the age limit (of 30 years) prescribed in that advertisement. The age relaxation provision stipulated in the advertisement and applicable to all reads as follows:

    “7. Age Relaxation:

    S. No. Categories Extent of Age Concession 1. Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes 05 years 2. Other Backward Class 03 years 3. Persons with disabilities 10 years 4. SC/ST Persons with disabilities 15 years 5. OBC Persons with disabilities 13 years 6. Departmental candidate with atleast three years service in Central Govt./Govt. of Delhi Upto 05 years for Group ‘B’ posts (which are in the same line or allied cadres and where a relationship could be established that the service already rendered in a particular post will be useful for the efficient discharge of the duties of post.) Upto 40 years of age (45 years for SC/ST for Group ‘C’ post. 7. Meritorious Sports Persons Upto 05 years (10 years for SC/ST and 08 years for OBC candidates) 8. Ex-Serviceman (For Group “C” Posts) Military services plus three years. 06 years and 08 years for OBC and SC/ST candidates respectively.”

    5. The petitioner's grievance was that once the Delhi Government had equated the post of Librarian with that of other teachers in its schools, for all purposes, incumbents and prospective candidates had to be treated in a like manner. In this respect, the petitioner relied upon a general relaxation circular of 01.11.1980 issued by the Department of Education, Delhi Administration, which is to the following effect:

    “1. In exercise of the powers vested in him under Rule 43 of the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973, the Administrator is pleased to prescribe for women candidates a general relaxation for 10 years in the maximum age limits prescribed in the Recruitment Rules for recruitment to various posts of teachers in Delhi Schools.

    2. The Managing Committees shall, while considering women candidates for appointment to vacancies in their schools, consider such candidates as per the revised age limit for women candidates.

    [Delhi Admn., Dte. of Edn., Recruitment Branch, No. F.1/16/3.R & S/79, dt. 1.11.1980]”.

    6. It was pointed out that even though the rules of recruitment for the post of librarian framed with effect from 15.01.2013 stated that the age limit for direct recruitment was 30 years and relaxation was upto five years, the gender based age relaxation circular in favour of women could not be excluded, and that the GNCTDs position denying this benefit was arbitrary.

    7. The respondent/GNCTD, on the other hand, contended that being a policy decision whether such age relaxation ought to be granted, the CAT's jurisdiction did not extend to prescribe the eligibility conditions such as qualification, age relaxation etc. The CAT accepted the GNCTDs position and rejected the petitioner's application.

    8. Learned counsel for the petitioner reiterates the submissions urged in support of the present petition. He also points out that neither in the reply before the Tribunal, nor in any document has it been ever submitted that the 1980 circular stands superseded. It was argued that on a parity of reasoning, non teaching or miscellaneous teaching posts such as drawing teachers etc. have been afforded relief of 10 years relaxation in the age limit at the time of recruitment-on basis of gender. Contending that this was in line with the general policy of GNCTD to grant ten years relaxation to women candidates, it was argued that the benefit of the 21.01.2011 circular equating the post of librarian with that of teaching staff has been judicially recognised. In this respect, he relied upon the decisions of this Court in Nutan Gulati v. Directorate of Education (W.P (C) No. 109/2013 decided on 09.07.2013) and Neha Vashisht v. GNCT of Delhi (W.P (C) No. 1840/2013 decided on 23.01.2004).

    9. Counsel for GNCTD argued that the order of the Tribunal is reasonable and does not call for interference. He relied upon the judgment taken note of by the Tribunal. i.e V.K Sood v. Secretary, Civil Aviation, 1993 Supp (3) SCC 9, as well as State of M.P v. Dharamveer, (1998) 6 SCC 165, and submitted that the Tribunal or, for that matter, the Court would not engage itself in a policy exercise to work out the appropriate terms - to be applied for the purposes of recruitment.

    10. It is evident from the above discussion that the petitioner's contention hinges on the applicability of the 01.11.1980 circular in the light of the equation of post of Librarian with that of other teachers - made effective by a later notification on 21.01.2011 The respondents did not contest - nor indeed can they - that the equation is matter of fact. Their only contention appears to be that in the absence of an appropriate amendment reflecting this equation, no right accrues to a prospective candidate to demand that they ought to be given age relaxation in line with the 01.11.1980 circular. Significantly, the GNCTD's reply in the application before the Tribunal nowhere states that the circular of 1980 was superseded either in letter or in effect. At best, its argument appears to be that the Recruitment Rules pertaining to Librarian framed in 2003 do not enable such age relaxation.

    11. In the opinion of this Court, that argument is fallacious; it does not meet the subsequent development of equation of the two posts made effective from 21.01.2011 The compelling consequences of that event were noticed for varied and diverse conditions of service in the judgments of this Court (i.e Nutan Gulati (supra) and Neha Vashisht (supra). No doubt, in both those cases, what occasioned the legal proceedings was a demand by unaided school teachers to equate the terms and conditions of Librarian, given the mandate of Section 10(1) of Delhi Schools Education Act. However, this Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the discussion in these judgments, like in the present case, centred around the equation which occurred between the post of Librarian and teaching posts. In the first case, Nutan Gulati (supra), the equation of parity with respect to extension of retirement age from 60 to 62 was in issue; in the second case, Neha Vashisht (supra), it was the appointment to the post of Librarian in the light of 2011 equation circular was in issue.

    12. This Court is conscious of the fact that in the realm of executive decision making, where policy formulation is involved, Article 226 hardly affords any room to spell out, much less direct the Government or the State Agency, to behave in any particular manner. Yet, at the same time, when facts - such as those presented before this Court in the case, stare on the face of record, i.e equation of posts had occurred after the Recruitment Rules are framed, and the subsequent two judgments directing the diverse conditions of service to be equated with that of teachers for librarian, the mandate of Article 14 cannot be ignored.

    13. In view of the GNCTD's silence as to the supersession or inapplicability of the 01.11.1980 circular - clearly its position that age relaxation for women candidates cannot be granted, is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution; it amounts to not giving effect to the discretion vested in it for no reason except that it has failed to carry out the necessary consequential amendment to the recruitment rules giving effect to the equation which occurred. The GNCTD also does not dispute that for other categories of teaching staff or teachers in its schools, the 10 year relaxation, based upon 01.11.1980 circular or rules-which assimilated its mandate, have been given effect to.

    14. The impugned order of the Tribunal also has noticed a judgment of this Court in Smt. Promila Dixit v. GNCTD in W.P(C.) No. 1234/2010 decided on 26.11.2010, where an identical contention with respect to the equation of TGT with librarian for the purposes of recruitment and age relaxation was upheld. This Court is of the opinion that this being the position even before the issuance of 21.01.2011 circular, the GNCTD's stand in this case appears to be obstinate to put it mildly. Furthermore, the CAT, in our opinion, fell into error in ignoring a direct judgment on the issue even after noticing its effect and purport.

    15. For the foregoing reasons, the petition has to succeed. The impugned order of the CAT is, accordingly, set aside. The respondents are hereby directed to accept the petitioner's application and allow her to appear in the competitive examination scheduled on 31.08.2014

    16. The petitioner shall be intimated about her examination centre etc. on 27.08.2014 by the concerned officer of the DSSSB. For that purpose, she shall appear before the concerned officer of the DSSSB on 27.08.2014 The respondent GNCTD is directed to coordinate with the DSSSB and ensure that the petitioner is given the Admit Card as well as intimation about the examination centre etc. on 27.08.2014 The petitioner shall present in the office of the respondent/DSSSB at 11:00 a.m on that day.

    17. The writ petition is allowed in the aforesaid terms.

    18. Order Dasti under the signatures of the Court Master.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Asha Petitioner v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi & Ors. S
    (Aug 22, 2014)