AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Paramjeet Singh, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

On the demise of Tula Ram, the Lambardar of Village Bitori (Tehsil and District Rewari), the post became vacant and the Assistant Collector II Grade, Rewari initiated proceedings for filling the post with the Collector's approval. A proclamation (munadi) was issued; applications were received from Rangrao, Murari Lal, Hakikat Ram, Umed Singh (petitioner) and Bal Kishan. Bal Kishan was proceeded against ex parte; Rangrao later withdrew; police verification of the remaining candidates' antecedents was found satisfactory.

The Assistant Collector recommended Murari Lal. The Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Rewari concurred and forwarded the matter to the Collector. After comparing candidates, the Collector appointed Umed Singh as Lambardar by order dated 20.09.2005 (Annexure P-1), recording reasons including Umed Singh's residence in the village, educational qualification (B.A.), greater agricultural holding and proximity/relationship to the deceased Lambardar.

Aggrieved, Murari Lal appealed to the Divisional Commissioner, Gurgaon, who set aside the Collector's order by order dated 28.08.2008 (Annexure P-3). Umed Singh then appealed to the Financial Commissioner, Haryana, who dismissed the appeal by order dated 22.04.2010 (Annexure P-5). Umed Singh filed the present writ petition under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India seeking quashing of the two impugned orders and restoration of the Collector's appointment order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the orders dated 28.08.2008 (Divisional Commissioner) and 22.04.2010 (Financial Commissioner), which set aside the Collector's order dated 20.09.2005 appointing the petitioner as Lambardar, are sustainable.
  2. Whether appellate authorities (Divisional Commissioner and Financial Commissioner) may interfere with the Collector's choice in appointment of a Lambardar, and if so, in what circumstances (e.g., perversity or material irregularity).
  3. Whether factual findings recorded by the Divisional Commissioner and Financial Commissioner (including the finding that the petitioner was serving in a stone crusher and was thus an absentee) were supported by acceptable evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Umed Singh)

  • Umed Singh is a permanent resident of Village Bitori; his name appears in the voter list of the village.
  • He is 53 years old, holds a B.A. degree, and owns about 6 acres of land in the village.
  • He has good relations with villagers; his candidature was supported by the Sarpanch, Lambardar and village respectables; he belongs to the Patti of the deceased Lambardar and is nearer to the deceased.
  • Murari Lal resides in Rewari city, appears in Rewari's voter list, is an absentee from the village, is over 60 years of age, and owns less land than the petitioner.
  • The Collector's comparative assessment and choice in appointing a Lambardar is final and should not be lightly interfered with; appellate authorities can only interfere if the Collector's order is perverse.
  • Reliance was placed on authorities including Mahavir Singh v. Khiali Ram, Lila Ram v. Asa Ram, and Phool Kumar v. State of Haryana to support the limited scope of appellate interference.

Respondent No. 4's Arguments (Murari Lal)

  • Murari Lal is a B.A., B.Ed., retired teacher, and about 60 years of age.
  • He has rendered community service: assisted family planning initiatives, motivated villagers to deposit in small saving schemes and personally deposited Rs. 1,00,000 in such a scheme.
  • He had institutional recommendations from the Naib Tehsildar and Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Rewari.
  • The Divisional Commissioner and Financial Commissioner recorded findings after appreciating facts and evidence and their orders are therefore lawful and valid.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahavir Singh v. Khiali Ram, 2009 (3) SCC 439 Affirmed that in appointment of a Lambardar the age of a candidate is a relevant factor and that the Collector's choice should not be lightly interfered with. The court relied on this Apex Court pronouncement to support the proposition that appellate interference is limited and that the Collector's comparative assessment carries primacy unless perverse.
Lila Ram v. Asa Ram, 1995 Lahore Law Times 29 Established that ordinarily there should be no interference with the Collector's choice, but interference is permissible where the Collector's order is based on misrepresentation of facts. The court cited this case to note the exception to non-interference — misrepresentation or material irregularity can justify appellate action — and found no such misrepresentation supporting the impugned orders.
Phool Kumar v. State of Haryana, 2010 (2) RCR (Civil) 819 (Division Bench of this Court) Followed the principle that the Collector's choice in appointment of Lambardar should not be lightly interfered with. The court relied on this Division Bench view as consistent support for non-interference with Collector's comparative assessment unless perversity is shown.
Lt. Malik Abbas Khan v. Ghulam Haidar, 1940 Lahore Law Times 25 Noted that it is generally unwise to appoint, for the first time, an Inamkhor or Zaildar who is about 60 years of age, except in exceptional circumstances. The court referenced this principle in discussing age as a relevant consideration, but ultimately found the Collector's assessment of suitability acceptable in the circumstances.
Kalyan Singh v. Haidar, 1928 Lahore Law Times 33 Held that ordinarily the Collector's choice appointing a Zaildar or Sufedpost should not be interfered with even if the appellate authority thinks another choice might be better. The court used this authority to reinforce that appellate interference is limited and should not supplant the Collector's discretion absent perversity or material irregularity.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by referring to Rule 15 of the Punjab Land Revenue Rules (as applicable in Haryana) which enumerates factors to be considered in first appointments of headman (Lambardar), including hereditary claims, extent of property, services to the State, personal influence and character, services to the community, minimum age (not less than 21), and literacy. The Court emphasized that hereditary claims and comparative merits are relevant considerations under Rule 15.

The Court analyzed the administrative sequence: the Assistant Collector and Sub-Divisional Officer had recommended Murari Lal, but the Collector compared candidates' merits and appointed Umed Singh. The Court observed the settled legal principle (supported by the cited precedents) that the Collector's comparative choice in appointing a Lambardar should not be lightly disturbed by appellate authorities, and interference is proper only where the Collector's order is perverse or suffers from material irregularity.

Turning to the substance of the appellate findings, the Court found that the Divisional Commissioner and the Financial Commissioner had recorded the petitioner's alleged service in a stone crusher at Sohana as a reason to treat him as an absentee. The Court held this finding was based on villagers' writings rather than authenticated documentary evidence and thus not sustainable. The Collector had categorically recorded that the petitioner was a resident of Village Bitori and that his name appeared in the village voter list. The Court reasoned that being employed (at a stone crusher) did not inherently disqualify the petitioner from performing Lambardar duties and that employment to earn a livelihood could not be equated with a perverse finding of absenteeism.

The Court further remarked that the Financial Commissioner had incorrectly characterized the record as reflecting concurrent findings by subordinate courts in the petitioner's favour; in reality, the Collector had appointed Umed Singh while the Divisional Commissioner had reversed that appointment and appointed Murari Lal. The Court concluded that the impugned appellate orders lacked cogent reasons and appropriate application of mind.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed: the orders dated 28.08.2008 (Annexure P-3) of the Divisional Commissioner, Gurgaon, and dated 22.04.2010 (Annexure P-5) of the Financial Commissioner, Haryana, are set aside; the Collector's order dated 20.09.2005 (Annexure P-1) appointing Umed Singh as Lambardar is restored.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: Umed Singh's appointment as Lambardar, as made by the Collector on 20.09.2005, is restored by this Court's order.
  • Costs: The Court recorded "No order as to costs."
  • Broader implication: The decision reaffirms the established administrative and judicial principle that appellate authorities should not lightly interfere with the Collector's comparative assessment in Lambardar appointments unless the Collector's decision is perverse or suffers from material irregularity; the opinion applies that principle to the facts and does not announce a novel rule beyond the precedents it follows.

This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond those expressly stated in the text.

    Umed Singh Petitioner v. Financial Commissioner, Haryana And Others S

    Paramjeet Singh, J

    Petitioner Umed Singh has filed the present writ petition under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India for quashing of orders dated 28.08.2008 (Annexure P-3) passed by Divisional Commissioner, Gurgaon Division, Gurgaon and 22.04.2010 (Annexure P-5) passed by Financial Commissioner, Haryana whereby order dated 20.09.2005 (Annexure P-1), appointing petitioner as Lambardar has been set aside.

    The brief facts of the case are that on the demise of Tula Ram, Lambardar of Village Bitori, Tehsil and District Rewari, post of Lambardar fell vacant. The Assistant Collector IInd Grade, Rewari initiated the proceedings for filling up the said post after getting approval from the Collector. Munadi/proclamation was got conducted in the village by the Assistant Collector IInd Grade. In pursuant to the proclamation S/Sh. Rangrao, Murari Lal, Hakikat Ram, Umed Singh and Bal Kishan residents of Village Bitori submitted their applications for the said post within stipulated period. During the course of the proceedings, Bal Kishan was proceeded against ex parte. The conduct and antecedents of the remaining candidates were got verified from the local police which were found in order. One of the candidates Rangrao withdrew his name. After considering the candidatures of other applicants, Assistant Collector IInd Grade, Rewari recommended the name of Murari Lal and forwarded his case to the Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Rewari, who concurred with the Asstt. Collector IInd Grade and recommended the name of Murari Lal for the post of Lambardar and sent it to the Collector. The learned Collector after appreciating the merits of the respective candidates appointed Umed Singh-petitioner as Lambardar of Village Bitori, Tehsil and District Rewari and observed as under:

    “…After hearing all the candidates properly and after perusal of the file, I have come to the conclusion that candidate Murari Lal resides at Rewari and he remain absent from the village. His name is entered in the voter list of Rewari. It is necessary for a Lambardar to reside in the village. Candidate Hakikat Ram is 10th Class pass whereas Umed Singh is B.A pass. Umed Singh is having more agricultural land. Therefore, considering Umed Singh son of Uttam Singh as better candidate for the post of Lambardar, he is appointed as Lambardar of Village Bitori in place of deceased Lambardar Tula Ram. Copy of order be sent to Tehsildar Rewari…”

    Respondent Murari Lal being aggrieved against the order of Collector dated 20.09.2005 (Annexure P-1) preferred an appeal before the Divisional Commissioner, Gurgaon. The Divisional Commissioner, Gurgaon set aside the order of Collector dated 20.09.2005 (Annexure P-1) vide his order dated 28.08.2008 (Annexure P-3). Petitioner-Umed Singh preferred an appeal before the Financial Commissioner against the order of Divisional Commissioner that too had been dismissed vide order dated 22.04.2010 (Annexure P-5). Hence, this writ petition.

    I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have perused the record as well as the orders of learned Collector, Commissioner and Financial Commissioner.

    A reference to the relevant Rule 15 of The Punjab Land Revenue Rules as applicable in the State of Haryana (‘Rules’- for short) for appointment of Village Headman, would be beneficial to decide the controversy. The said rule reads as under:-

    “15 Matters to be considered in first appointments- In all first appointments of headman, regard shall be had among other matters to-

    (a) his hereditary claims;

    (b) extent of property in the estate possessed by the candidate;

    (c) services rendered to the State by himself or by his family;

    (d) his personal influence, character, ability and freedom from indebtedness;

    (e) the strength and importance of the community from which selection of a headman is to be made;

    (f) services rendered by himself or by his family in the national movements to secure freedom of India.

    [In case of an ex-headman of an estate or sub-division thereof in the territory now comprising the State of [Haryana] who had resigned or was dismissed on account of his participation in a national movement before partition and another headman was appointed in his place, the present incumbent of the post shall be removed irrespective of the provisions of rule 16 and the exheadman would be appointed in his place if he has not rendered himself unfit for appointment for any of the reasons given in Rule 16 except imprisonment for a political offence before 15 August, 1947. In case the exheadman is no longer alive, a person of his family who would under the Rules have been entitled to be headmen if the resignation or dismissal had not intervened, would be appointed as headman. But when no such person exist there would be no need to remove the existing Lambardar]

    (g) services rendered by himself to the community and development programmes;

    (h) he shall be not less than 21 years of age at the time of inviting the application for the appointment of Lambardar;

    (i) he should be literate, preferably middle pass.]”

    A perusal of the above Rule 15 of the Rules shows that in first appointment of Headman i.e Lambardar regards shall be had among others to hereditary claims.

    Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that Umed Singh is a permanent resident of Village Bitori, and 53 years of age, and having an B.A Degree, besides 6 acres of land in the village. He has good relations with the villagers and his candidature has also been supported by the Sarpanch, Lambardar and respectable of the village. Besides this, he belongs to the Patti of the deceased Lambardar and is also nearer to the deceased Lambardar. It is further submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that Murari Lal resides in Rewari City and his name appears in the voter-list of Rewari City. He is an absentee person from the village and also more than 60 years of age and having less land than the petitioner. He further contended that the choice of the Collector is final and cannot be set aside. The Collector has compared the merits of the candidates and thereafter appointed the petitioner.

    Learned counsel for the petitioner further contended that the Divisional Commissioner and the Financial Commissioner have no jurisdiction to interfere in the choice of the Collector. They can only interfere, if the order passed by the Collector is perverse. In support of his arguments, learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance upon judgments in case of Mahavir Singh v. Khiali Ram, 2009 (3) SCC-439, Lila Ram v. Asa Ram, 1995 Lahore Law Times-29 as well as judgment of Division Bench of this Court in case of Phool Kumar v. State of Haryana, 2010 (2) RCR (Civil) 819.

    Learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 4 vehemently argued that the orders of the Divisional Commissioner and the Financial Commissioner are legal and valid and they have recorded finding after appreciating the facts and evidence on record. Murari Lal is a B.A B.Ed and retired as a teacher and is 60 years of age. He has been helping in family planning scheme and motivated the villagers for depositing money in Small Saving Scheme. He himself deposited Rs. 1,00,000/- in the small saving scheme. Besides above, Naib Tehsildar and Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Rewari have recommended his name.

    After considering the rival contentions of the parties, I am of the considered view that the choice of the Collector cannot be set aside lightly. This view has been affirmed by the Apex Court in case of Mahavir Singh v. Khiali Ram, 2009 (3) SCC-439, wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court has considered the controversy relating to appointment of Lambardar under Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887 and Rules framed thereunder. The Apex Court held that with regard to the appointment of a Lambardar the age of a candidate is a relevant factor. The Apex Court noticed few old cases of Lahore High Court which throw some light on the subject matter are as under:-

    “In Lt. Malik Abbas Khan v. Ghulam Haidar (1940 Lahore Law Times 25), it was stated:

    “…It is certainly not wise, save in very exceptional circumstances, to appoint for the first time, an Inamkhor or Zaildar whose age is 60.”

    In Kalyan Singh v. Haidar (1928 Lahore Law Times, 33), the Financial Commissioner held that ordinarily the Collector's choice appointing a Zaildar or Sufedpost should not be interfered with even though the appellate authority believes that his choice was not the best choice.

    Similar view was expressed in Lila Ram v. Asa Ram (1995 Lahore Law Times, 29), in the following terms:

    “…While it is now an established principle that there should be no interference with the choice made by the Collector, it does not follow that where the Collector's order is based on a misrepresentation of facts, there should still be no interference.”

    The above view has also been followed by the Division Bench of this Court in Phool Kumar's case (supra).

    It has been observed that there should be no interference with the choice made by the Collector in the matter of appointment of Lambardar even if two views are possible. It is only the prerogative of the Collector to compare the merits of the candidates for the post of Lambardar. The Commissioner/Financial Commissioner has only limited right to interfere that too when the choice of the Collector is found to be perverse, suffers from material irregularity, only then the order of the Collector can be set aside. The learned Commissioner and the Financial Commissioner have not recorded any finding specifically that the finding of the Collector was perverse, rather they have recorded finding that the petitioner is serving in a stone crusher in Sohana for the last twenty years. This finding is based on the writing of the villagers and not on any authenticated documentary evidence. Therefore, this finding is not sustainable. The Collector had categorically recoded that the petitioner is a resident of Village Bitori and his name is in the voter list of the village. Merely, because the petitioner is working at Haryana Stone Crusher Company, Sohana, does not deprive him from performing his duties as Lambardar, rather it should be appreciated that the person is working and earning livelihood of his family. This cannot be treated as a perverse finding as has been recorded by the Divisional Commissioner, Gurgaon and affirmed by the Financial Commissioner. Similarly, the Financial Commissioner, Haryana has also wrongly recorded that there are concurrent findings by the Courts below with regard to the contentions raised at that time before the Financial Commissioner by Umed Singh. In fact, the finding before the Financial Commissioner was finding of reversal. The Collector has appointed Umed Singh-petitioner as Lambardar, whereas the Divisional Commissioner set aside the order of the Collector and appointed Murari Lal as Lambardar. The order of Financial Commissioner, Haryana is without application of mind and is not based on cogent reasons.

    For the reasons recorded above, I am of the considered view that order dated 28.08.2008 (Annexure P-3) passed by the Divisional Commissioner, Gurgaon and order dated 22.04.2010 (Annexure P-5) passed by the Financial Commissioner, Haryana are not sustainable. The impugned orders of Divisional Commissioner and Financial Commissioner are hereby set aside and order dated 20.09.2005 (Annexure P-1) passed by the Collector is restored. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Umed Singh Petitioner v. Financial Commissioner, Haryana And Others S
    (Jan 2, 2012)