Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 255 of the Indian Penal Code,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 255 of the Indian Penal Code,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, one of the accused in Sessions Case No. 468 of 2005, challenged an order of the Sessions Court dated 31 January 2011 (passed in Miscellaneous Application No. 233 of 2009) that deleted Section 255 of the Indian Penal Code, and sought that the trial be conducted by a Magistrate. The underlying criminal complaint was lodged by the Chief Manager of Bank of Baroda on 3 September 2004 against twenty-five borrowers (C.R. No. 702 of 2004, Goregaon Police Station). The investigation alleged that the petitioner obtained a loan of Rs. 12.50 lakhs by submitting forged documents (purportedly of M/s Regal Enterprises and Hermitage Constructions) to purchase property at Shivling, Kashimira, Mira Road, Thane; that the properties did not exist; and that franking impressions, stamp duty receipts and registration receipts of the sale agreement were forged. The investigation further alleged that the petitioner conspired with co-accused in making bogus franking impressions, opened a bogus Union Bank of India account in the name of M/s Ravi Development, and that a pay order of Rs. 30,00,000/- (belonging to another borrower, Bhushan Goyal) was deposited into that account.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 255 of the Indian Penal Code (counterfeiting Government stamp) is applicable to the petitioner in the facts of this case.
  2. Whether the Sessions Court's deletion of Section 255 and any consequent discharge of the accused should be sustained, or whether the trial must proceed on the charge including Section 255 (and related conspiracy allegations).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that Section 255 of the Indian Penal Code would not be applicable against the petitioner.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by construing Section 255 IPC, noting that it penalises persons who "counterfeit, or knowingly perform any part of the process of counterfeiting, any stamp issued by Government for the purpose of revenue." The court reasoned that liability under Section 255 extends not only to the person who physically performs the counterfeiting but also to one who knowingly performs any part of the process of counterfeiting.

Given that the petitioner and others were charged with criminal conspiracy, the court held it could not be said that only the person who physically carried out the illegal franking (identified in the order as Vijay More) would be responsible for counterfeiting. The court observed that the petitioner (accused no. 5) had used forged stamped franking papers to obtain the loan, and therefore had participated in the counterfeiting process and had conspired in it.

The court articulated the elements of criminal conspiracy: an object to be accomplished, a plan to accomplish that object, and an understanding between persons to cooperate for its accomplishment; the offence is founded on an agreement and is ordinarily complete when the aim is accomplished. The court found that the plot to get documents franked illegally formed part of the agreement and therefore prima facie attracted Section 120B IPC (criminal conspiracy). These observations were described as prima facie and supported by documents showing sufficiency of material against the accused/petitioner.

On this analysis, the court concluded that deleting Section 255 or discharging the accused on that ground could not be permitted at the present stage.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED.

Consequences: The writ petition challenging the Sessions Court's handling of Section 255 was dismissed. The court refused to permit deletion of Section 255 or discharge of the accused on that basis, indicating that the charges under Section 255 (and related conspiracy allegations) remain supported by prima facie material and are to be proceeded with. The opinion does not state or establish any broader precedent beyond the resolution of the petition; its direct effect is limited to denying the petition and leaving the charges intact for trial.

    Himanshu v. State Of Maharashtra

    JUDGMENT:

    The petitioner questions order of the Sessions Court in Sessions Case no. 468 of 2005 dated 31st January, 2011 passed in Miscellaneous Application no. 233 of 2009 deleting Section 255 of IPC and wants that the trial be conducted by the Court of Magistrate. The petitioner is one of the accused in the Sessions Case.

    2. The Chief Manager of Bank of Baroda has lodged complaint against twenty five borrowers on 3rd September, 2004, that such persons produced forged documents with the bank and obtained loan giving rise to C.R no. 702 of 2004 of Goregaon Police Station. On examination of the accounts, it reveals that the petitioner has availed loan of Rs. 12.50 lakhs from the said bank by submitting forged documents of M/s. Regal Enterprises and Hermitage Constructions to purchase the property at Shivling, Kashimira, Mira Road, Thane. The investigation indicates, the properties were not in existence. The franking impressions, stamp duty receipts, registration receipts of sale Agreement were forged/bogus. The investigation indicates, that the accused-petitioner has conspired with co-accused and made bogus franking impressions on the sale agreement for commission of crime. The investigation also reveals, the petitioner opened bogus account in Union Bank of India in the name of M/s. Ravi Development and in the said account Pay order of Rs. 30,00,000/- was deposited, which was in fact of another borrower Bhushan Goyal, who played identical deceiving renegation without remorse.

    3. The learned Counsel for petitioner submits that Section 255 of the Indian Penal Code, would not be applicable against the petitioner.

    Section 255 of Indian Penal Code reads as under:-

    “255. Counterfeiting Government stamp.-- Whoever counterfeits, or knowingly performs any part of the process of counterfeiting, any stamp issued by Government for the purpose of revenue, shall be punished with [imprisonment for life], or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.

    Explanation.- A person commits this offence who counterfeits by causing a genuine stamps of one denomination to appear like a genuine stamp of a different denomination.”

    4. Analysis of Section 255 of IPC indicates that the person who either counterfeits or knowingly performs any part of the process of counterfeiting, would render himself liable for his prosecution with the aid of Section 255 of IPC. The petitioner and other accused are facing charge of conspiracy, therefore, it cannot be said, for breach of Section 255 of IPC it was only Vijay More who carried illegal franking would alone be responsible for illegal counterfeiting. One cannot be oblivious, the petitioner-accused no. 5 has used the forged stamped franking papers in obtaining loan and naturally had conspired the stamp counterfeiting.

    5. The element of criminal conspiracy conceive an object to be accomplished, a plan to accomplish that object and understanding between two persons to co-operate for accomplishment of the object. Thus essence of criminal conspiracy is unlawful combination and ordinarily the offence is complete when the aim is accomplished. The offence has its foundation in an agreement to commit offence. In this case the very plot of getting the document franked illegally, is a part of act forming an agreement which could be a promise against the promise and naturally invites infraction of Section 120B of IPC. These are prima facie observations which flows from documents, showing sufficiency of material against the accused/petitioner.

    6. In the situation, deleting Section 255 of IPC or discharging the accused thereof, cannot be permitted.

    7. Writ Petition lacks merit. Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Himanshu v. State Of Maharashtra
    (Aug 17, 2012)