S. Muralidhar, J.:— This appeal is directed against the impugned judgment dated 14th August 2008 passed by the learned Special Judge, Delhi in CC No. 102 of 1999 convicting the Appellant for the offence under Section 8 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (‘PC Act’) and the order on sentence dated 18 August 2008 whereby he was sentenced to undergo to rigorous imprisonment (‘RI’) for a period of two years and a fine of Rs. 5,000 and in default of fine, to undergo simple imprisonment (‘SI’) for a period of two months.
2. The case of the prosecution is that a complaint was made by Mr. A.K Bhardwaj (PW-13) to the Secretary-cum-Commissioner, Food and Civil Supply on 5 August 1997 regarding the rampant corruption in the Food and Supplies Office, Kalyan Vas, Trans Yamuna Area. He claimed that he had been going to the said office since February 1997 for renewal of his ration card but every time he was turned away after being informed that the last date for renewal of ration card had expired. He had found that outside the said office three touts were sitting and publicly negotiating with the card holders. They were demanding Rs. 700 per ration card for getting the work done.
3. The aforesaid complaint was marked to Mr. Chander Shekhar (PW-6), the Food and Civil Supplies Inspector. On 8 August, 1997 PW-6 visited the office of Food and Civil Supplies at Kalyan Vas. There he met the Appellant herein who inquired from him whether he was in need of a ration card. PW-6 answered in the affirmative.
4. The Appellant is then stated to have demanded a sum of Rs. 1,000 for the job to which PW-6 replied that it was too much. The Appellant is stated to have told PW-6 that he had to pay the amount inside the office also and ultimately agreed to settle for Rs. 700. The Appellant demanded an advance of Rs. 200 and asked PW-6 to pay the balance amount of Rs. 500 at the time of handing over of the ration card. Thereafter, the Appellant asked PW-6 whether he had any proof of residence to which PW-6 answered in the negative. PW-6 gave his name as A.K Bhardwaj (PW-13). He also gave the address of PW-13 at Ganesh Nagar. Thereafter the Appellant got the form filled and PW-6 handed over his photograph to the Appellant. PW-6 told him that he would be coming either on Monday or Tuesday to pay him the advance. Thereafter PW-6 came to his office and disclosed the facts to his senior officials and on their advice he handed over the advance money of Rs. 200 to the Appellant on 12 August 1997.
5. When PW-6 again met the Appellant on 14 August 1997, the Appellant asked him to come back on 19 August 1997 to collect the ration card after paying the balance amount of Rs. 500 as the card was not ready on that day. At this stage, upon the advice of his senior officers, PW-6 went to the office of Anti Corruption Branch (‘ACB’) and got his complaint (Ex.PW-6.A) recorded in the presence of Inspector Prem Chand (PW-11), the Raiding Officer (RO) and panch witness Anil Bhardwaj (PW-9) who was a Senior Mechanic in the Delhi College of Engineering.
6. PW-6 signed the complaint (Ex.PW-6.A). He produced one government currency (‘GC’) of Rs. 500 before PW-11, who noted down the serial number in the pre-raid report (Ex.PW-6.K). Thereafter, PW-11 applied phenolphthalein powder on the GC note and gave a demonstration as to its effect. The treated GC note was then handed over to PW-6 to be given to the Appellant. PW-6 kept the GC note in left pocket of his shirt. PW-9 was directed to remain close to PW-6 so that he could overhear the conversation and give the pre-determined signal when the bribe money was being handed over to the Appellant.
7. At about 11.30 am PW-11 along with Inspector Bir Singh (PW-12), PW-6 and PW-9 and other team members of the raiding party left the ACB for the Kalyan Vas Food and Civil Supplies Office in a government vehicle. While PW-6 and PW-9 went towards the office, the other members of the raiding team followed them by keeping some distance.
8. In his deposition, PW-6 stated that he reached the Food and Civil Supplies Office, Kalyan Vas at about 12.30 pm in the official vehicle where the Appellant met him and PW-9. The Appellant informed PW-6 that his card was ready. He demanded the balance amount of Rs. 500 upon which PW-6 handed over to the Appellant the treated GC note of Rs. 500 which the Appellant accepted in his right hand. In his evidence PW-9 also stated that the Appellant informed PW-6 that his work had been done and then demanded the balance amount from him. Thereafter PW-6 gave the said treated GC note to the Appellant in his right hand and the Appellant handed over one ration card to PW-6. Thereafter PW-9 gave the predetermined signal to the raiding party upon which the members of the raiding party came to the spot and surrounded the Appellant.
9. The evidence of PW-6 and PW-9, corroborated by PW-11, is to the effect that PW-9 informed PW-11 that the Appellant had accepted the bribe of Rs. 500 and had given a ration card to PW-6. PW-11 disclosed his identity and challenged the Appellant that he had accepted the bribe of Rs. 500 from PW-6 upon which the Appellant became perplexed. Then on the instruction of PW-11, PW-9 recovered the treated GC note from the right hand of the Appellant. The serial number on the recovered GC note was tallied with that noted in the pre-raid report. The right hand wash of the accused turned pink and was transferred to two small, empty and clean bottles which were sealed and marked as RHW-I and II.
10. At this stage it may be noted that there were two accused. The Appellant was Accused No. 1 (A-1) and Manju Mathur who was employed as an Inspector in the Department of Food and Civil Supplies was arraigned as Accused No. 2 (A-2).
11. In his statement under Section 313 Cr PC the Appellant, i.e, A-1, denied all the allegations. He denied that PW-6 had met him on 8 August 1997 or 12 August 1997 and that there had been any transaction between them. He also denied having demanded or accepted any bribe money. He claimed that non-recovery of envelope from which he had taken out the ration card was fatal to the case of the prosecution. He denied the raid proceeding and recovery of the treated GC notes from him. He further denied that his hand wash was taken or that it turned pink or that it was transferred to bottles. He claimed that all the documents including reports containing the pre-raid and post raid proceedings were prepared after registration of the FIR, contrary to the claim of the prosecution. He also denied the CFSL report. When asked by the Court whether he had anything else to say, the Appellant stated that there exists no record to prove that the complaint (Ex.PW-6.G) was ever entrusted to PW-6 officially after 9 August 1997 and that in order to achieve name and fame as well as out of turn promotion PW-6 had acted in an illegal manner. The Appellant further claimed that PW-9 was a stock witness who made false statements at the instance of the ACB.
12. The Appellant examined Shyam (DW-1), his landlord. He claimed that the Appellant was running his PCO booth, through which he was earning his bread and butter. He had no other means of livelihood. Mr. Vinod Batra (DW-2) stated that he used to visit DW-1 who was the Appellant's landlord. Mr. Ajay Kumar, (DW-3) claimed to know the Appellant for the last 20-25 years and that he was running STD/PCO. DW-4, Rajinder Prasad and DW-5, Bhagwati Prasad also stated the same.
13. The trial Court on analysing the evidence concluded that the case had been proved against the Appellant beyond reasonable doubt and convicted the Appellant for the offence under section 8 of the pc act. However, the trial Court found that the case has not been proved against A-2 and acquitted her for the offence under Sections 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the PC Act. The trial Court sentenced the Appellant in the manner indicated hereinabove.
14. Learned counsel for the Appellant first submitted that the very genesis of the case was extremely doubtful since PW-13 was residing in Ganesh Nagar, Ward No. 39 whereas the Kalyan Vas office dealt with the ration cards issued for persons residing in Ward No. 37. It was unlikely that on receiving the complaint from PW-13, PW-6 would go to the office of the Food and Civil Supplies in Ward No. 39 and not Ward No. 37. Secondly, there was no entry in the register of receipt of the application (Ex PW1.C) for 8 August 1997. The entry showed that the application was received on 7 August 1997. Therefore, the very foundation of the case of the prosecution was doubtful.
15. As noticed by the trial Court, the complaint of PW-13 was of a general nature regarding the actions of touts sitting outside the Kalyan Vas office of the Food and Civil Supplies. PW-13 confirmed that he had noticed that three touts were sitting under trees and they were negotiating with the persons for issuance of ration cards. When a suggestion was made to this witness, PW-13 denied that ‘when I visited Kalyanvas office my identity card was not having the required address. I was not knowing whether that Bhardwaj was inspector of Circle 39. May be my house fell under Circle No. 39. It is wrong to suggest that I made an imaginary complaint.’ The fact of PW-13 visiting Kalyanvas was not denied by the Appellant. There was no need for PW-13 to falsely implicate anyone. He was concerned about the corrupt practice taking place at the Kalyanvas and his complaint has been proved to be genuine.
16. As regards the complaint (Ex.PW6.G), the evidence of PW-6 is clear and cogent. Learned counsel for the Appellant pointed out that there were inconsistencies in the dates since the application for renewal of ration card (Ex. PW1.C) purportedly received by PW-6 though dated 8 August 1997 was shown to have been received vide entry No. 2711 in the register (EX.P4/3) dated 7 August 1997. As noticed by the trial Court, although the application is shown at Serial No 2711 dated 7 August 1997, it was the last application shown to have been received on that date. It was recorded with a different pen. The application was received by A-2 on 8 August 1997 and on that date, i.e, 8 August 1997 she had received 18 applications as per the entry made by her at point B in the register whereas in fact she had received 19 applications on that date. Application No. 2711 had been added subsequently by Sohan Pal Singh (PW-5) who was Food Supply Officer (‘FSO’) at the relevant time. He admitted that the application (Ex.PW-1.C) was received in the office on 8 August 1997. The verification report was received on 14 August 1997 and the ration card was issued on 18 August 1997. In the circumstances, the trial Court has rightly convicted the Appellant, i.e, A-1 and there is no occasion for disbelieving the testimony of PW-6 that he had met the Appellant on 8 August 1997.
17. Learned counsel for the Appellant then submitted that there was no verification of the complaint given by PW-13 and that this was an essential part of the entire exercise. The fact remains that PW-13 was examined as a witness and he confirmed that the complaint given by him was genuine. The events following the date of this complaint vindicated his position as stated in the complaint.
18. Learned counsel for the Appellant then submitted that the ration card purportedly handed over to PW-6 by the Appellant was issued by following all the procedures. He submitted that the source of a sum of Rs. 200 purportedly given by PW-6 to the Appellant has not been proved. There is no proof of Appellant standing outside the office of Food and Civil Supplies at Kalyan Vas.
19. As regards the above submissions, the pre-raid and post raid proceedings have been fully established by the evidence of PW-6, PW-9 and PW-11. Nothing has been elicited in their cross-examination to doubt the veracity of their versions. In fact in the cross-examination of PW-9 a suggestion had been made that the ration card (Ex.PW-2.A) was recovered by the raiding team of the ACB from the bag of the Appellant. This suggestion was negatived by PW-9. The Appellant was not an employee of the Food and Civil Supplies Department. It was incumbent on him to explain why he was carrying a new ration card issued in someone else's name. The Appellant was unable to do so. On the other hand, the prosecution has been able to prove beyond reasonable doubt the pre-raid, the raid as well as the post-raid proceedings.
20. It is next submitted that PW-9 was a stock witness. This submission is without merit. The mere fact that PW-9 was a panch witness on three previous occasions cannot automatically lead to the inference that he is a ‘stock’ witness. The fact that, a ration card was issued, although following the correct procedure, in the name of a person who was able to impersonate someone else showed how the touts were successful in manipulating the system to get work done for consideration.
21. Learned counsel for the Appellant submitted that one of the hand wash samples produced in the Court, i.e, RHW-II was white in colour. In this regard, the trial Court has rightly relied on the report of the FSL which has confirmed the presence of phenolphthalein in the hand washes. In any event the evidence of PWs 6, 9 and 13 in this regard is clear and cogent.
22. It was then submitted that it was necessary for the prosecution to prove that the Appellant had demanded the bribe amount in order to pay a named official in the office of the Food and Civil Supplies whereas in the present case the testimony of PW-6 does not indicate that he had named any such official. The Court is unable to accept the above submission. The wording under section 8 of the pc act is wide enough to cover a situation where a person demands illegal gratification for getting the work done although he himself may not be a public servant. He does not himself have to be the beneficiary of the bribe.
23. For the aforementioned reasons, this Court upholds the conviction of the Appellant under section 8 of the pc act.
24. On the question of sentence it is seen that the incident is of 1997 and the Appellant has faced the ordeal of litigation for over 17 years. In the circumstances, the sentence awarded to the Appellant is modified and he is sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for one year with no change to the fine amount and the default sentence as awarded by the trial Court.
25. The appeal is dismissed. The bail bond of the Appellant is hereby cancelled. He is directed to surrender forthwith to serve out the remainder sentence.
26. The trial Court record along with a certified copy of this judgment be delivered forthwith to the trial Court.