AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Rajindar Sachar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeks quashing of the impugned order dated 17th April, 1971 (Annexure P-1) issued by respondent No.1 (Union of India), which cancelled an earlier order dated 21st August, 1968 in favour of the petitioners. The cancellation was said by the Union to be occasioned by a mistake of law.

Background facts as set out in the opinion:

  • Prior to 15 August 1947 petitioners and respondent No.2 were employed under the Agent to the Governor General in the centrally administered area of Baluchistan.
  • After migration to India they joined the Ministry of External Affairs on the following dates:
    • Petitioner No.1 (Shri R.D. Joshi) — 28-10-47
    • Petitioner No.2 (Shri B.S. Chatrath) — 21-10-47
    • Petitioner No.3 (Shri H.C. Sharma) — 10-11-47
    • Petitioner No.4 (Shri Amar Singh) — 10-12-47
    • Respondent No.2 (Shri F.C. Pathak) — 22-10-47
  • Initially the Government of India considered the Baluchistan services to be local in character and not equivalent to displaced Central Government servants; later, by an order dated 3rd February 1950, former non-Muslim employees of the Chief Commissioner's Province of Baluchistan who had migrated were treated as displaced Central Government employees.
  • Seniority of the petitioners and respondent No.2 as shown in the Civil List as on 1st October 1962 was recorded numerically in the opinion (e.g., Petitioner No.1 Ramjidas Joshi — 843; respondent No.2 Fateh Chand Pathak — 955).
  • Government initially took the position that benefits and seniority would be effective only from 3rd February 1950, not from 15th August 1947; representations seeking benefits from 15th August 1947 were made by the petitioners and respondent No.2.
  • Respondent No.2's representation of 26th August 1964 led to an order on 3rd December 1966 (Annexure P-9) appointing him substantively to Grade IV of the Central Secretariat Service with effect from 1st November 1951, and his seniority in the Assistant Grade was directed to be fixed at 10-A in the Civil List as on 1st October 1962.
  • Because respondent No.2 obtained such benefits, the petitioners sought similar relief. The Government issued a memorandum dated 8th July 1968 (P-8) directing appointment of ex-Baluchistan employees including the petitioners to the initial stage of Grade IV w.e.f. 1st November 1951 and passed orders on 21st August 1968 appointing the petitioners substantively to Grade IV (Annexure P-4).
  • The Union of India cancelled the petitioners' 21st August 1968 order by the impugned order dated 17th April 1971, relying on a decision in L.P.A. No. 67 of 1968 (Union of India v. Kanti Mani Sharma) decided 4th December 1968, which interpreted Rule 18(1) of the Central Secretariat Service Rules, 1962.
  • The petition before Rajindar Sachar, J. challenges that cancellation and seeks directions to restore the effect of the 21st August 1968 order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned order dated 17th April 1971 cancelling the earlier order of 21st August 1968 can be sustained in view of Rule 18(1) of the Central Secretariat Service Rules, 1962 and the Division Bench decision in Union of India v. Kanti Mani Sharma (L.P.A. No.67/68).
  2. Whether, on the facts of this case, the seniority of the petitioners and respondent No.2 had been "specifically determined" before the appointed day (1st October 1962) so as to preclude subsequent refixation under Rule 18(1)'s mandate and its proviso.
  3. Whether the petitioners were denied an opportunity of hearing before the impugned order of 17th April 1971 was passed.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent No.1 (Union of India) — Justification for cancellation

  • The Union relied on the decision in L.P.A. No. 67 of 1968 (Union of India v. Kanti Mani Sharma) in which the Division Bench held that Rule 18(1) of the CSSR 1962 means that seniority of any person finally determined by the Government before 1st October 1962 is not open to revision.
  • The Union contended that, in compliance with that decision, the earlier order of 21st August 1968 had to be cancelled.
  • The Union sought to distinguish respondent No.2's case from the petitioners' case on the ground that respondent No.2's appointment order of 3rd December 1966 had also refixed and conveyed his seniority in the same order, whereas the petitioners' 21st August 1968 order had not yet fixed their seniority.

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners (through their counsel) contended that the proviso to Rule 18(1) applied because their seniority had not been "specifically determined" prior to the appointed day; therefore, under the proviso their seniority could be determined by the appropriate authority later.
  • They argued that the Civil List entries (dated 1st October 1962) were provisional because the question of absorption and the correct date of their entitlement (15th August 1947 v. 3rd February 1950) was not finally settled until the mid-1960s, so Rule 18(1) did not bar giving them benefits from 15th August 1947.
  • They also raised a grievance that no opportunity of hearing had been provided before passing the impugned order of 17th April 1971.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Kanti Mani Sharma (L.P.A. No.67/68) — Division Bench decision dated 4th December 1968; reference also to the Single Judge judgment dated 11th September 1968 The Division Bench interpreted Rule 18(1) of the Central Secretariat Service Rules, 1962 to mean that where seniority had been specifically determined before the appointed day (1st October 1962) it could not be refixed. The judgment also recognized that where seniority had not been specifically determined prior to the appointed day, the relevant authority could determine relative seniority thereafter. The court relied on and analysed that decision, concluding that Kanti Mani Sharma did not conclusively bar the Government from determining or affording benefits to employees whose seniority had not been specifically determined prior to the appointed day. The court read Kanti Mani Sharma as recognizing that civil list entries are not necessarily conclusive of specific determination of seniority and applied that reading to reject the Union's basis for cancelling the petitioners' 21st August 1968 order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeds in stages:

  1. Examination of the Union's stated basis: the impugned cancellation was justified by the decision in Kanti Mani Sharma which, according to the Union, precluded refixation of seniority finally determined before 1st October 1962 under Rule 18(1) of the CSSR 1962.
  2. Textual and contextual reading of Rule 18(1): the rule provides that relative seniority of members appointed before the appointed day shall be regulated by their relative seniority as determined before that day; the proviso provides that if seniority of any such officer had not been specifically determined before that day, it shall be determined by the Department of Personnel in the Cabinet Secretariat. The court treated those two limbs distinctly and emphasized the proviso's operation where there was no specific determination pre-appointing day.
  3. Application to facts — whether seniority had been "specifically determined": the court found that the factual history showed ongoing representations and unsettled questions about the date from which petitioners were to be treated as Central Government employees (3rd February 1950 v. 15th August 1947). Although the petitioners and respondent No.2 appeared in the Civil List of 1962, that appearance was provisional because the absorption and date-of-entitlement issue was still under consideration. The court considered that a specific determination of seniority in the sense contemplated by Rule 18(1) had not occurred prior to the appointed day.
  4. Use of Kanti Mani Sharma: the court quoted passages from the Kanti Mani Sharma decision to show that the Division Bench itself accepted that civil list entries do not necessarily demonstrate that seniority had been specifically determined; the court therefore concluded that the Union's reliance on Kanti Mani Sharma amounted to a misapprehension of its correct ratio when applied to the petitioners' factual position.
  5. Distinction drawn by the Union between respondent No.2 and the petitioners: the court rejected the Union's asserted distinction (that respondent No.2's seniority had been refixed and conveyed at the time of his appointment while the petitioners' seniority was not fixed by the 21st August 1968 order) as unsubstantial given the common factual matrix and the fact that the crucial decision was that the petitioners and respondent No.2 were to be treated as optees from 15th August 1947.
  6. Opportunity of hearing: the court examined the contention that petitioners were not heard before the impugned order and found no merit in that objection, observing that documents in the file (Annexures P-15/1 and P-15/2) and meetings with officials showed petitioners had been heard and their views placed before the Law Ministry and other officials.
  7. Conclusion on legal effect: because the impugned order was based on a misreading of the ratio in Kanti Mani Sharma and because the petitioners' seniority had not been specifically determined prior to the appointed day, the Union was not precluded by Rule 18(1) from giving the benefits it had conferred on 21st August 1968; accordingly the cancellation was unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ petition was allowed. The court quashed the impugned order dated 17th April, 1971 (Annexure P-1) and issued a mandamus directing respondent No.1 to fix the seniority of the petitioners on the basis of the order dated 21st August, 1968 (Annexure P-4) in accordance with law and rules.

Consequences and implications spelled out in the opinion:

  • Direct effect: the cancellation of the petitioners' substantive appointments (by the 17th April 1971 order) was set aside and the Union was directed to give effect to the 21st August 1968 order by fixing the petitioners' seniority accordingly.
  • Procedural finding: the court found no deprivation of hearing in the passing of the impugned order on the material before it.
  • Precedential effect: the court's decision rests on its reading of the facts against the ratio of Kanti Mani Sharma; the opinion does not state that a new broad legal precedent was created beyond this application of Rule 18(1) and the proviso to the specific facts at hand. (The court described the Union's reliance on Kanti Mani Sharma as a misapprehension of that decision's correct ratio in the context of these facts.)
  • Costs: there was no order as to costs.

Note: This summary is confined to the matters expressly stated in the provided opinion. Where the opinion did not provide detailed material (for example, wider policy reasoning beyond the immediate legal issues and relief), no inference has been made beyond the text.

    Ram Ji Das Joshi And Ors. (Petitioners) v. Union Of India And Anr. (S).

    Rajindar Sachar, J.:— This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeks the quashing of the impugned order dated 17th April, 1971 (Annexure P-1) by respondent No. 1, Union of India by which the earlier order of the Ministry of Home Affairs dated of 21st August, 1968 in favour of the petitioner has been cancelled as the same is said to have been issued due to mistake of law.

    2. Prior to 15th of August, 1947, the petitioners as well as respondent No. 2 were employees under the Agent to the Governor General in the then centrally administered area of Baluchistan. After August 1947, the petitioners and respondent No. 2 migrated to India and were employed in the Ministry of External Affairs where they joined duties as follows:

    Petitioner No. 1 Shri R.D Joshi Miny of E.A 28-10-47 Petitioner No. 2 Shri B.S Chatrath, Miny of E.A 21-10-47 Petitioner No. 3 Shri H.C Sharma Miny of E.A 10-11-47 Petitioner No. 4 Shri Amar Singh Miny of E.A 10-12-47 Respondent No. 2 Shri F.C Pathak Miny of E.A 2210-47

    3. It appears that Government of India was originally taking the view that the services in the Chief Commissioner's Province were local in character and that those employes like the petitioners were comparable to Government servants from Sind & NWFP and not as displaced Central Government servants. Accordingly the ex-Baluchistan employees were not treated as eligible for exercising option and the option exercised by the partition of the country was not given effect to. The petitioners, however, represented that they were entitled to claim option like other Central Government employees. After sometime the Government of India took a decision to treat the former non-Muslim employees of the Chief Commissioner's province of Baluchistan who had already migrated to the Dominion of India as displaced Central Government employees, who opted for India for the purpose of certain benefits, and orders in that behalf were issued on 3rd of February, 1950. The result of this order of 3rd February 1950, was that the petitioner as well as respondent No. 2 were treated at par with other displaced Central Government employees. The seniority of petitioners as well as respondent No. 2 in the Civil List as on 1st October, 1962 was accordingly shown as under:

    Petitioner No. 1 Shri Ramjidas Joshi 843 Petitioner No. 2 Shri Baldev Singh Chatrath 965 Petitioner No. 3 Shri Hukam Chand Sharma 985 Petitioner No. 4 Shri Amar Singh 983 Respondent No. 2 Shri Fateh Chand Pathak 955

    4. It appears that Government was taking the position that the persons like the petitioner and respondent No. 2 were entitled to the benefits of seniority and others only from 3rd February, 1950 and not from 15th of August, 1947. It was apparently due to this position that the seniority in the Civil List as mentioned above was assigned to the petitioners and respondent No. 2 on 1st of October, 1962. The matter of giving benefits to ex-Baluchistan employees was raised not only with the Government of India but also on the floor of the Parliament. The petitioners and respondent No. 2, also had been representing that full justice has not been done to them and that they were entitled to all the benefits which would have accrued to them and they been treated as Central Government employees from 15th of August, 1947 and not from 3rd February, 1950. At last the representation of respondent No. 2 dated 26th of August, 1964 pointing out that he was entitled to hold a regular permanent post in the Government of India from 15th of August, 1947 found favour with the Government and it ordered on 3rd December, 1966 (Annexure P. 9) appointing respondent No. 2 substantively to Grade IV of the Central Secretariat Service with effect from 1st November, 1951. In the endorsement to this very order the seniority of respondent No. 2 in the Assistant Grade was directed to be fixed at 10-A in the Civil List as on 1st October, 1962 As the petitioners were similarly situate as respondent No. 2, they naturally represented to the Government requesting that the same benefits should be given to them as had been granted to respondent No. 2. The Government after considering their representation and in view of the fact that similar benefits had already been granted to respondent No. 2 issued a memorandum dated 8th July, 1968 (P-8) that Ex-Baluchistan employees including the petitioner be appointed at the initial stage of Grade IV of the Central Secretariat Service with effect from 1st November, 1951 and given consequential benefits. An order dated 21st August, 1968, appointing the petitioners substantively to Grade IV of the Central Secretariat Service with effect from 1st November, 1951, was also passed in pursuance of the decision (P-4). It is the cancellation of this order by the impugned order dated 17th April, 1971 (P-1) which has led to the filing of the present petition.

    5. In the return filed by respondent No. 1, the justification for passing the impugned order given is that there has been a decision in L.P.A No. 67 of 1968 decided on 4th December, 1968 wherein Division Bench of this Court has taken the view that Rule 18(i) of the Central Secretariat Service Rule (CSSR) 1962 lays down that seniority of any person finally determined by the Government before 1st October, 1962 when the Rules came into force is not open to revision. It is stated that in view of this decision the order dated 21st August, 1968 had to be canceled because the Union of India has no other option but to act in accordance with the decision of this Court. The reason given thus is that the provision of Rule 18(i) of the CSSR 1962 had not been properly interpreted earlier and that the impugned order dated 17th April, 1971 was necessitated because of this decision by the Court. Grievance had also been made in the Writ Petition that though justification by the respondent No. 1 for canceling the order of 21st August, 1968 was on the plea of complying with the decision was not taken in the case of respondent No. 2 who was similarly situate like the petitioners. In the return the distinction is sought to be justified by pointing out that in the case of respondent No. 2 while appointing him substantively to Grade IV, his seniority was also revised, refixed and conveyed by the same order and, therefore, his case is distinguishable from that of the petitioners. It is pointed out that in the case of petitioners order dated 21st August, 1968 which though had appointed the petitioners substantively had yet to fix the seniority of the petitioner and therefore the case was distinguishable from that of respondent No. 2. I am not satisfied that the reason given to distinguish the case of petitioners and respondent No. 2 can bear scrutiny. It is not denied that the case of petitioners and respondent No. 2 is identical; and all of them are Ex-Baluchistan employees and were absorbed in the Central Secretariat Service. The reason given in the impugned order (Annexure P-1) for canceling the order of 21st August, 1968 is stated to be the decision given in Union of India v. Kami Mani Sharma, L.P.A No. 67/68, decided on 4th December, 1968. The judgment of the learned Single Judged allowing the writ petition was given on 11th September, 1968. It is thus apparent that if the basis of the impugned order is the decision in Kanti Mani Sharma's case, then the decision of the learned single judge in September, 1968 and of L.P.A in December, 1968 are both subsequent to the order passed in the petitioner's favour on 21st of August, 1968. If, therefore, the decision in Kanti Mani Sharma's case considered not to the affect the decision falser by the ??? in the case of ??? No. 2 on 3rd December, 1966, it is not understood why the decision in the case of the petitioners which was also taken earlier to the decision in the writ petition as well as L.P.A should lead to a separate result I am therefore not satisfied that there was any such distinguishing feature between the case of petitioners and respondent No. 2. But that by itself is not of much assistance to the petitioners because of the Government is prevented in law from upholding the order of 21st August 1968 in favour of the petitioners it cannot be so restrained merely because it may have taken a wrong view in the case of respondent No. 2. After all two wrongs do not make ane right. The petitioners will therefore have to succeed on the inherent strength of their own case.

    6. Now turning to the merits of the case, the only reason for passing the impugned order of 17th April, 1971 is because of the decision in Kanti Mani Sharma's case. No doubt Division Bench has held that if before the appointed date i.e 1st October, 1962, seniority has been specifically determined the same cannot be refixed in view of the mandate of Rule 18(1). But in the same judgment the Division Bench found that in the case of Stenographers whose seniority had not been specifically determined, it was open to the Ministry of Home Affairs to determine their relative seniority. Rule 18 of the Central Secretariat Service reads as follows:—

    “Seniority (1) The relative seniority of members of the Service appointed to am Grade before the appointed day shall be regulated by their relative seniority as determined before that day;

    Provided that, if the seniority of any such officer has not been specifically determined before that ??? it shall be as determined by the Department of Personnel in the Cabinet Secretariat.”

    7. The contention of the counsel for the petitioners is that the case of the petitioners to covered by the proviso to the Rule as there has been no specific determination of the seniority, and it is thus permitted by the judgment of this Court. The facts of the present case show that the petitioners were treated as Central Government employees and were given certain benefits w.e.f 3rd February, 1950. Baluchistan employees like the petitioners were apparently not satisfied with it and went on representing to the Government that once having accepted their case that they should be treated as Central Government employees, benefits should accrue to them from 15th August, 1947 and not from 3rd February, 1950. There was obviously force in this plea because it stands to reason that once ex-Baluchistan employees were accepted as Central Government employees benefits had to be given to them from 15th of August, 1947, which was the date on which partition of India took place and not from 3rd February, 1950. These representations were subsequently accepted and benefits for the first time given to respondent No. 2 in 1966 on the basis as has been admitted in the return filed by the respondent, that they were entitled to benefits from 15th of August 1947 and not merely from 3rd February, 1950. It was precisely because this plea was accepted that orders were passed substantively appointing respondent No. 2, and subsequently the petitioners to Grade IV of the Central Secretariat Service w.e.f 1st of November, 1955. These orders could only have been passed on the basis that the petitioners and respondent No. 2 should be taken to be optees in the service of the Central Government from 15th of August, 1947 and entitled to all the consequential benefits. No doubt in the Civil List which was prepared in 1962, a seniority was assigned to the petitioners and respondent No. 2. But that seniority was in the very nature provisional because the matter of absorption of the Baluchistan employees was still in melting pot. Obviously some sort of seniority had to be assigned to the petitioners and respondent No. 2 but so long an the matter of their absorption was not finally settled there could be no specific determination of seniority in terms of Rule 18.

    8. The said rule would apply only when there was no dispute regarding the absorption of an employee in service and seniority is determined inter se amongst employees whose absorption in service from any particular date is not a subject matter of investigation Obviously the case of the petitioners and respondent No. 2 was different because first the matter of date of absorption in service had to be finally settled and it is thereafter that the question of senility would be determined. As the main matter was admittedly decided in 1966 and 1968, it is apparent that the suggestion that seniority of petitioners and respondent No. 2 was finally determined in 1962 has no validity and mu it be rejected. I do not see how the mere fact that seniority portion was not mentioned in the same order of 21-8-1968 would make any difference. The crucial print was the decision whether to give benefits to petitioners and respondent No. 2 from 15th August, 1947. Once that decision was taken and they were appointed substantively to Grade IV of Central Secretariat Service w.e.f 1st of November, 1951, the matter of fixing seniority was more or less a consequential and of routine nature. The fact that in the very order of appointment in the case of respondent No. 2, seniority was indicated but the same was not indicated in the case of petitioners is a difference without any substance. Nor do I find that Rule 18 as such bars the Central Government from giving the benefits to the petitioners which the Government had given to them by the order of 21st August, 1968. In this case a reference may be made to the following observations in the Kanti Mani Sharma's case:

    “That takes me to the question as to whether or not the seniority of the Stenographers had also been determined. The affidavit on behalf of the Union of India has in this behalf been couched in somewhat ambiguous language. The reading of paragraphs 3 to 6 therefore, however, shows that their relative seniority vis-a-vis Group A and B employees had not been determined. I read the said paragraphs to mean that on representations from the Stenographers the Central Secretariat Service Selection Board decided that their seniority should be counted with effect from 1-5-1958. Representations were made be the Stenographers against the determination of the Board but pending decision by the Government they were assigned seniority below 65 plus 12) officers in the combined seniority list of Grade III officers promoted to Grade II (14 of the Group B employees having become eligible subsequently). It appears, however, that the Government took no final decision in pursuance of the recommendations made by the Board and this fact is clear from paragraph 6 of Mr. Thyagarajan's affidavit. It must be for that reason only that the Stenographers continued to be shown in that position even in the Civil Lists. In that view the Civil Lists would not be inconsistent with the position taken by the Union of India and the Stenographers that their seniority had never been determined”.

    9. This authority itself has clearly laid down that simply because persons are shown in the civil list does not mean that seniority had been specifically determined. It will depend on the facts of each case. So in the present case the mere fact that the petitioners and respondent No. 2 were shown in the civil list is not conclusive of the fact that their seniority had been specifically determined earlier to 1962. From the admitted facts that representations were being made all the times and the matter was being considered by the Government from time 10 time the result is inescapable that though the petitioners and respondent No. 2 were placed in the civil list in 1962, their specific determination of the seniority could only be made when a final decision was taken in 1966–1968 to give them the benefits of service with effect from 15th August, 1947. In my view, therefore, the assumption on the basis on which the impugned order of 17th April, 1971 has been passed is not supported by a proper reading of decision of the Division Bench in Kanti Mani Sharma's case. Grievance had also been made in the petition that no opportunity had been given to the petitioners before the impugned order of 17th April, 1971 was passed. I do not think there is any merit in this contention because a reference to Annexure P-1.5/1 and P. 15/2 will show that immediately after the passing of order dated 21st August, 1963, doubts had been expressed in the Government departments whether petitioners could be given benefits.

    10. The petitioners had occasion to meet the official of the Law Ministry and other officials and they placed their point of view before them. It is, therefore, not possible to hold that the impugned order was passed without giving them any hearing.

    11. But as I have taken the view that the impugned order is based on mis-apprehension of the correct ratio in Kanti Mani Sharma's case, this writ petition has to be allowed. I would, therefore, quash the impugned order dated 17th April, 1971 (P-1) and also issue a mandamus directing respondent No. 1 to fix the seniority of the petitioners on the basis of order dated 21st August, 1968 (Annexure-P-4) in accordance with law and rules.

    12. In the circumstances, there would be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Ji Das Joshi And Ors. (Petitioners) v. Union Of India And Anr. (S).
    (Jan 9, 1973)