Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not present in this excerpt.
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 106 of the Evidence Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not present in this excerpt.
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 106 of the Evidence Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Manoj, a cleaner on Truck No. MP 07 2627, was entrusted with Rs 20,000 and joined the driver (appellant Nizam) and cleaner (appellant Shafique) of Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943 on 23-1-2001 after his own driver was detained by local police. Manoj’s body was discovered on 26-1-2001 near Village Maniya with documents linking him to Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943. The appellants were arrested the next day and charged under Sections 302 and 201 IPC. The Trial Court convicted them and imposed life sentences, which the Rajasthan High Court affirmed on 1-7-2005. The present Supreme Court appeal challenges those concurrent findings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction based solely on circumstantial evidence—principally the “last seen” circumstance—meets the legal standard for proof beyond reasonable doubt.
  2. Whether the prosecution established an unbroken chain of circumstances sufficient to invoke Section 106 of the Evidence Act and shift the burden of explanation to the accused.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The “last seen” theory was inapplicable because of contradictions regarding the date and time Manoj allegedly left with them.
  • No part of the Rs 20,000 was recovered from their possession, undermining the alleged motive.
  • The prosecution failed to establish a complete chain of circumstances; therefore, reasonable doubt persists.

State’s Arguments

  • Manoj, carrying a large sum of money, was last seen alive in the company of the appellants; under Section 106 Evidence Act the appellants had to explain his fate and failed to do so.
  • The circumstantial evidence, when taken cumulatively, justified the concurrent findings of guilt, warranting no Supreme Court interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bodhraj v. State of J&K (2002) 8 SCC 45 Conditions for sustaining conviction on circumstantial evidence Quoted to reiterate that all incriminating facts must be incompatible with innocence
Hukam Singh v. State of Rajasthan (1977) 2 SCC 99 Cumulative effect of circumstances must negate innocence Cited within Bodhraj quotation as supporting authority
Eradu v. State of Hyderabad AIR 1956 SC 316 Need for circumstances to be proved beyond reasonable doubt Referenced in Bodhraj passage
Earabhadrappa v. State of Karnataka (1983) 2 SCC 330 Chain of circumstances doctrine Referenced in Bodhraj passage
State of U.P. v. Sukhbasi 1985 Supp SCC 79 Consistency of circumstances with guilt alone Referenced in Bodhraj passage
Balwinder Singh v. State of Punjab (1987) 1 SCC 1 Standard for inference of guilt from circumstances Referenced in Bodhraj passage
Ashok Kumar Chatterjee v. State of M.P. 1989 Supp (1) SCC 560 Requirement of closely connected circumstances Referenced in Bodhraj passage
Bhagat Ram v. State of Punjab AIR 1954 SC 621 Cumulative impact of circumstances Cited to stress that overall effect must prove guilt
C. Chenga Reddy v. State of A.P. (1996) 10 SCC 193 No gap in chain of evidence Quoted for complete-chain requirement
Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra (2006) 10 SCC 681 Criteria for conviction when no eyewitnesses Invoked to outline benchmarks for circumstantial cases
Sunil Clifford Daniel v. State of Punjab (2012) 11 SCC 205 Reiteration of circumstantial-evidence principles Listed as supporting authority
Sampath Kumar v. Inspector of Police (2012) 4 SCC 124 Same as above Listed as supporting authority
Mohd. Arif @ Ashfaq v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2011) 13 SCC 621 Same as above Listed as supporting authority
State of Rajasthan v. Kashi Ram (2006) 12 SCC 254 Scope of Section 106 Evidence Act and “last seen” doctrine Relied on to explain burden-shifting when accused last seen with deceased
Kiriti Pal v. State of West Bengal (2015) 11 SCC 178 Affirmation of Kashi Ram principles Cited to elaborate limits of “last seen” inference
Naina Mohamed, In re. 1959 SCC OnLine Mad 173; AIR 1960 Mad 218 Failure to explain facts within special knowledge as additional link Referenced within Kashi Ram quotation

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court emphasised that in a purely circumstantial case each circumstance must be firmly established and collectively form an unbroken chain leading only to the accused’s guilt. Applying that yardstick, the Court found multiple deficiencies:

  • Time-gap problem: Manoj allegedly left with the appellants on 23-1-2001, but his body surfaced on 26-1-2001. The three-day interval was too wide to safely invoke the “last seen” inference without corroboration.
  • Non-recovery of incriminating material: Neither the Rs 20,000 nor any murder weapon or other material object was recovered from the appellants.
  • Questionable motive: Evidence showed the prime prosecution witness (PW 2) had earlier lodged a false robbery report, casting doubt on the monetary-motive theory.
  • Possibility of third-party intervention: Injuries to Manoj’s body and the fact that Maniya village is reputed for prostitution suggested potential involvement of others.
  • Investigative lapses: Non-identification of the body initially, failure to explain how Manoj reached Maniya, and absence of medical evidence linking injuries to the accused weakened the prosecution case.

Because these shortcomings left significant gaps in the evidentiary chain, the Court held that the benefit of doubt must go to the appellants.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The convictions under Sections 302 and 201 IPC are set aside; the appeal is allowed and the appellants are to be released forthwith unless required in another case.

Implications: The decision reinforces that the “last seen” circumstance cannot, by itself and in the presence of material gaps, sustain a conviction. It underscores the Supreme Court’s willingness to intervene under Article 136 when concurrent findings overlook critical evidentiary deficiencies. No new legal principle was created, but the judgment serves as a cautionary precedent on the strict application of circumstantial-evidence standards.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Nizam And Another v. State Of Rajasthan .

    R. Banumathi, J.— This appeal assails the correctness of the judgment dated 1-7-2005 passed by the High Court of Judicature of Rajasthan, Jaipur Bench in Nizam v. State of Rajasthan Criminal Appeal No. 1248 of 2002, whereby the High Court confirmed the conviction of the appellant-accused under Sections 302 and 201 IPC and sentence of life imprisonment imposed on each of them with a fine of Rs 2000 with default clause and also two years' rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 500 with default clause respectively.

    2. The case of the prosecution is that the deceased Manoj was the helper on Truck No. MP 07 2627 and had gone to Pune and thereafter to Barar along with his first driver Raj Kumar (PW 2) and second driver Ram Parkash (PW 1) and from Barar they loaded the truck with pipes for destination to Ghaziabad on 23-1-2001. The appellant-accused Nizam and Shafique who were the driver and cleaner, respectively on Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943 also loaded their truck with pipes from the same company on the same day at Barar and started for Ghaziabad along with Truck No. MP 07 2627. During this period, the drivers and cleaners of both the trucks developed acquaintance with each other. While on the way to Ghaziabad, driver Raj Kumar (PW 2) of Truck No. MP 07 2627 got into quarrel with some local persons and consequently Barar Police detained him along with his truck. Faced with such situation, Raj Kumar (PW 2) instructed his second driver Ram Parkash (PW 1) to hand over the amount of Rs 20,000 to Manoj with instructions to give the money to the truck owner. Accordingly, Manoj left for Gwalior with accused persons by Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943 on 23-1-2001.

    3. The dead body of deceased Manoj was found on 26-1-2001 under suspicious circumstances in a field near Village Maniya. On 26-1-2001, at about 3 o'clock, one Koke Singh (PW 13) went to collect the fodder and found a dead body lying in the field and the same was informed to Shahjad Khan (PW 4). Based on the written information by Shahjad Khan (PW 4), the case was registered in FIR No. 16/2001 under Sections 302 and 201 IPC on 26-1-2001 at Thana Maniya, District Dholpur. Gullu Khan (PW 16), Investigating Officer seized the dead body and prepared a panchnama. One bilty (Ext. P-17) of Uttar Pradesh-Haryana Roadlines (Pune) and one receipt (Ext. P-18) of the Madhya Pradesh Government, Shivpuri Naka pertaining to Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943 were recovered from the pocket of the trouser of deceased Manoj and in the said bilty (Ext. P-17), the name of the driver was mentioned as Nizam and Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943 and some phone numbers. Based on the clues obtaining in the bilty, the accused Nizam and Shafique were arrested on 27-1-2001 and Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943 was recovered. After due investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the appellant-accused under Sections 302 and 201 IPC.

    4. To bring home the guilt of the appellant-accused, the prosecution has examined twenty-one witnesses. Incriminating evidence and circumstances were put to the appellant-accused under Section 313 CrPC and the accused denied all of them and the accused stated that Manoj had never travelled in their truck, No. DL 1 GA 5943. The Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court No. 2, Dholpur held that the appellant-accused committed the murder of deceased Manoj to grab Rs 20,000 and the prosecution has established the circumstances proving the appellant-accused guilty under Sections 302 and 201 IPC and sentenced each of them to undergo life imprisonment with a fine of Rs 2000 with default clause and two years' rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 500 with default clause, respectively. Aggrieved by the verdict of conviction, the appellant-accused preferred appeal before the High Court of Rajasthan, which vide the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 1248 of 2002 dismissed the appeal thereby confirming the conviction of the appellant-accused and also respective sentence of imprisonment and fine amount imposed on each of them. Being aggrieved, the appellants have preferred this appeal.

    5. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the “last seen theory” is not applicable to the instant case as there were serious contradictions as to the date and time in which Manoj allegedly left with the appellants. It was further argued that the amount of Rs 20,000 which was allegedly taken by deceased Manoj was not recovered from the possession of the appellants. The learned counsel submitted that the circumstances relied upon by the prosecution are not firmly established and the circumstances do not form a complete chain establishing the guilt of the accused and the appellants are falsely roped in.

    6. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent State contended that the deceased having huge amount of money travelled in the company of the appellant-accused and when the prosecution has established that the deceased Manoj was last seen alive in the company of the appellant-accused, it was for the accused to explain as to what happened to the deceased and in the absence of any explanation from the accused and based on the circumstantial evidence, the courts below rightly convicted the appellants and the impugned judgment warrants no interference.

    7. We have considered the rival contentions and perused the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 1248 of 2002 and material on record.

    8. The case of the prosecution is entirely based on the circumstantial evidence. In a case based on circumstantial evidence, settled law is that the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is drawn should be fully proved and such circumstances must be conclusive in nature. Moreover, all the circumstances should be complete, forming a chain and there should be no gap left in the chain of evidence. Further, the proved circumstances must be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused and totally inconsistent with his innocence.

    9. The principle of circumstantial evidence has been reiterated by this Court in a plethora of cases. In Bodhraj v. State of J&K (2002) 8 SCC 45, wherein this Court quoted a number of judgments and held as under:

    “10. It has been consistently laid down by this Court that where a case rests squarely on circumstantial evidence, the inference of guilt can be justified only when all the incriminating facts and circumstances are found to be incompatible with the innocence of the accused or the guilt of any other person. (See Hukam Singh v. State of Rajasthan (1977) 2 SCC 99, Eradu v. State of Hyderabad AIR 1956 SC 316, 1956 Cri LJ 559, Earabhadrappa v. State of Karnataka (1983) 2 SCC 330, State of U.P. v. Sukhbasi 1985 Supp SCC 79, Balwinder Singh v. State of Punjab (1987) 1 SCC 1 and Ashok Kumar Chatterjee v. State of M.P. 1989 Supp (1) SCC 560) The circumstances from which an inference as to the guilt of the accused is drawn have to be proved beyond reasonable doubt and have to be shown to be closely connected with the principal fact sought to be inferred from those circumstances. In Bhagat Ram v. State of Punjab AIR 1954 SC 621, 1954 Cri LJ 1645 it was laid down that where the case depends upon the conclusion drawn from circumstances the cumulative effect of the circumstances must be such as to negative the innocence of the accused and bring home the offences beyond any reasonable doubt.
    11. We may also make a reference to a decision of this Court in C. Chenga Reddy v. State of A.P. (1996) 10 SCC 193, wherein it has been observed thus:
    ‘21. In a case based on circumstantial evidence, the settled law is that the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is drawn should be fully proved and such circumstances must be conclusive in nature. Moreover, all the circumstances should be complete and there should be no gap left in the chain of evidence. Further, the proved circumstances must be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused and totally inconsistent with his innocence.’”

    10. In Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra (2006) 10 SCC 681, this Court held as under:

    “12. In the case in hand there is no eyewitness of the occurrence and the case of the prosecution rests on circumstantial evidence. The normal principle in a case based on circumstantial evidence is that the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn must be cogently and firmly established; that those circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of the accused; that the circumstances taken cumulatively should form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probability the crime was committed by the accused and they should be incapable of explanation on any hypothesis other than that of the guilt of the accused and inconsistent with their innocence.”

    The same principles were reiterated in Sunil Clifford Daniel v. State of Punjab (2012) 11 SCC 205, Sampath Kumar v. Inspector of Police (2012) 4 SCC 124, and Mohd. Arif v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2011) 13 SCC 621 and a number of other decisions.

    11. By perusal of the testimonies of PWs 1, 2 and 3, it is seen that PW 1, Ram Parkash and PW 2, Raj Kumar along with deceased cleaner Manoj got their Truck No. MP 07 2627 loaded with pipes at Barar and at the same time another Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943 of the accused Nizam and Shafique was also loaded with pipes. On the way to Ghaziabad, a quarrel took place between the drivers of Truck No. MP 07 2627 and some local persons and Raj Kumar (PW 2) was detained by the police. Raj Kumar (PW 2) instructed Ram Parkash (PW 1) to hand over the amount of Rs 20,000 to Manoj with instructions to give this money to the truck owner and he was sent along with accused Nizam and Shafique in the other truck, DL 1 GA 5943. PWs 1 and 2 further stated that after being released from the police station, they went to Gwalior and enquired about Manoj from their owner Rajnish Kant (PW 3) who had no knowledge about Manoj. In the meanwhile, based on the bilty and the receipt recovered from the pocket of the trouser of deceased Manoj, Maniya Police contacted PW 3, owner of the truck and on being so contacted, PWs 1 to 3 went to Maniya Police Station and identified the deceased person as Manoj through his clothes and photographs.

    12. Based on the evidence of PWs 1 and 2, the courts below expressed the view that the motive for murder of Manoj was the lust for the money which Manoj was carrying. The courts below based the conviction of the appellants on the circumstances “last seen theory” as stated by PWs 1 and 2 along with the recovery of bilty and receipt by PW 6 on which the name of the accused person (Nizam) was printed. The appellants are alleged to have committed the murder of Manoj for the amount which Manoj was carrying. But neither was the amount of Rs 20,000 nor any part of it recovered from the appellants. If the prosecution is able to prove its case on motive, it will be a corroborative piece of evidence lending assurance to the prosecution case. But even if the prosecution has not been able to prove the motive, that will not be a ground to throw away the prosecution case. The absence of proof of motive only demands careful scrutiny and deeper analysis of evidence adduced by the prosecution.

    13. Apart from non-recovery of the amount from the appellants, serious doubts arise as to the motive propounded by the prosecution. By perusal of the evidence of Sudama Vithal Darekar (PW 17) it is clear that driver Raj Kumar came to the police station complaining that by five to seven people of other vehicle had robbed him of the money. However, after the investigation, it was discovered that Raj Kumar gave false information and a case under Section 182 IPC was registered against him. Raj Kumar was produced before the Court and the Court imposed a fine of Rs 1000 on him. This fact was also verified from PW 16, investigating officer during his cross-examination.

    14. The courts below convicted the appellants on the evidence of PWs 1 and 2 that the deceased was last seen alive with the appellants on 23-1-2001. Undoubtedly, the “last seen theory” is an important link in the chain of circumstances that would point towards the guilt of the accused with some certainty. The “last seen theory” holds the courts to shift the burden of proof to the accused and the accused to offer a reasonable explanation as to the cause of death of the deceased. It is well settled by this Court that it is not prudent to base the conviction solely on “last seen theory”. “Last seen theory” should be applied taking into consideration the case of the prosecution in its entirety and keeping in mind the circumstances that precede and follow the point of being so last seen.

    15. Elaborating the principle of “last seen alive” in State of Rajasthan v. Kashi Ram (2006) 12 SCC 254, this Court held as under:

    “23. It is not necessary to multiply with authorities. The principle is well settled. The provisions of Section 106 of the Evidence Act itself are unambiguous and categorical in laying down that when any fact is especially within the knowledge of a person, the burden of proving that fact is upon him. Thus, if a person is last seen with the deceased, he must offer an explanation as to how and when he parted company. He must furnish an explanation which appears to the court to be probable and satisfactory. If he does so he must be held to have discharged his burden. If he fails to offer an explanation on the basis of facts within his special knowledge, he fails to discharge the burden cast upon him by Section 106 of the Evidence Act. In a case resting on circumstantial evidence if the accused fails to offer a reasonable explanation in discharge of the burden placed on him, that itself provides an additional link in the chain of circumstances proved against him. Section 106 does not shift the burden of proof in a criminal trial, which is always upon the prosecution. It lays down the rule that when the accused does not throw any light upon facts which are specially within his knowledge and which could not support any theory or hypothesis compatible with his innocence, the court can consider his failure to adduce any explanation, as an additional link which completes the chain. The principle has been succinctly stated in Naina Mohamed, In re. 1959 SCC OnLine Mad 173, AIR 1960 Mad 218”

    The above judgment was relied upon and reiterated in Kiriti Pal v. State of W.B. (2015) 11 SCC 178, (2015) 5 Scale 319

    16. In the light of the above, it is to be seen whether in the facts and circumstances of this case, the courts below were right in invoking the “last seen theory”. From the evidence discussed above, deceased Manoj allegedly left in the truck DL 1 GA 5943 on 23-1-2001. The body of deceased Manoj was recovered on 26-1-2001. The prosecution has contended that the accused persons were last seen with the deceased but the accused have not offered any plausible, cogent explanation as to what has happened to Manoj. Be it noted, that only if the prosecution has succeeded in proving the facts by definite evidence that the deceased was last seen alive in the company of the accused, a reasonable inference could be drawn against the accused and then only onus can be shifted on the accused under Section 106 of the Evidence Act.

    17. During their questioning under Section 313 CrPC, the appellant-accused denied Manoj having travelled in their Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943. As noticed earlier, the body of Manoj was recovered only on 26-1-2001 after three days. The gap between the time when Manoj is alleged to have left in Truck No. DL 1 GA 5943 and the recovery of the body is not so small, to draw an inference against the appellants. At this juncture, yet another aspect emerging from the evidence needs to be noted. From the statement made by Shahzad Khan (PW 4) the internal organ (penis) of the deceased was tied with rope and blood was oozing out from his nostrils. Maniya Village, the place where the body of Manoj was recovered is alleged to be a notable place for prostitution where people from different areas come for enjoyment.

    18. In view of the time gap between Manoj being left in the truck and the recovery of the body and also the place and circumstances in which the body was recovered, possibility of others intervening cannot be ruled out. In the absence of definite evidence that the appellants and the deceased were last seen together and when the time gap is long, it would be dangerous to come to the conclusion that the appellants are responsible for the murder of Manoj and are guilty of committing murder of Manoj. Where time gap is long it would be unsafe to base the conviction on the “last seen theory”; it is safer to look for corroboration from other circumstances and evidence adduced by the prosecution. From the facts and evidence, we find no other corroborative piece of evidence corroborating the last seen theory.

    19. In case of circumstantial evidence, the Court has to examine the entire evidence in its entirety and ensure that the only inference that can be drawn from the evidence is the guilt of the accused. In the case at hand, neither was the weapon of murder nor the money allegedly looted by the appellants or any other material recovered from the possession of the appellants. There are many apparent lapses in the investigation and missing links: (i) Non-recovery of stolen money; (ii) The weapon from which abrasions were caused; (iii) False case lodged by PW 2 alleging that he was robbed by some other miscreants; (iv) Non-identification of the dead body; and (v) Non-explanation as to how the deceased reached Maniya Village and injuries on his internal organ (penis). Thus, we find many loopholes in the case of the prosecution. For establishing the guilt on the basis of the circumstantial evidence, the circumstances must be firmly established and the chain of circumstances must be completed from the facts. The chain of circumstantial evidence cannot be said to be concluded in any manner sought to be urged by the prosecution.

    20. Normally, this Court will not interfere in the exercise of its powers under Article 136 of the Constitution of India with the concurrent findings recorded by the courts below. But where material aspects have not been taken into consideration and where the findings of the Court are unsupportable from the evidence on record resulting in miscarriage of justice, this Court will certainly interfere. The “last seen theory” seems to have substantially weighed with the courts below and the High Court brushed aside many loopholes in the prosecution case. None of the circumstances relied upon by the prosecution and accepted by the courts below can be said to be pointing only to the guilt of the appellants and to no other inference. If more than one inferences can be drawn, then the accused must have the benefit of doubt. In the facts and circumstances of the case, we are satisfied that the conviction of the appellants cannot be sustained and the appeal ought to be allowed.

    21. The conviction of the appellants under Sections 302 and 201 IPC is set aside and the appeal is allowed. The appellants are in jail and they are ordered to be set at liberty forthwith if not required in any other case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nizam And Another v. State Of Rajasthan .
    (Sep 4, 2015)