Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision application arises from a civil suit filed by Kanji Hirjibhai Gondaliya, manager of the Rajkot Halari Vanand Community, against a tenant for possession of residential premises on Hathikhana Road, Rajkot, and arrears of rent. The tenant contested the suit, challenging the validity of the eviction notice. The trial Court framed a preliminary issue on the validity of the suit notice and held it to be invalid, thereby declaring the suit for possession incompetent and unmaintainable. The suit was allowed to proceed only on the claim for monetary relief. The petitioner appealed but did not file a certified copy of the decree because no decree had been drawn up following the trial Court’s order. The petitioner then applied to the trial Court to draw up a decree based on the preliminary issue judgment, which was dismissed on the ground that the suit was not finally decided. This order is challenged in the present revision application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of the trial Court on the preliminary issue regarding the invalidity of the eviction notice amounts to a decree within the meaning of Section 2(2) of the Civil Procedure Code.
  2. Whether the trial Court erred in refusing to draw up a decree pursuant to its judgment on the preliminary issue.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
V. Adinarayan Chetti v. Kopparam Narasinha Chetti, ILR 54 Mad 337 (AIR 1931 Mad 471) Determination of whether an order passed by a Court amounts to a decree under Section 2(2) CPC. Supported the view that a formal expression of adjudication conclusively determining rights is a decree, regardless of the Court’s labeling of the order.
Kasi v. Rm. A. R. M. V. Ramanathan Chettiar (1947) 2 Mad LJ 523 Clarification on the nature of finality and decree under Section 2(2) CPC. Reinforced the principle that a conclusive adjudication on rights constitutes a decree.
Jagat Dhish Bhargava v. Jawahar Lal Bhargava, AIR 1961 SC 832 Formal drawing up of decree is a duty of the Court but failure to do so does not negate the existence of a decree. Confirmed that an order adjudicating rights finally is a decree even if not formally drawn up.
Parashuram Rajaram Tiwari v. Hirabai Rajaram Tiwari, AIR 1957 Bom 59 Same principle as above regarding decree and formal drawing up. Supported the position that failure to draw up a decree does not prevent an order from being a decree.
Fatmabai W/o Rasim v. Abubaker Tarmahmed, AIR 1946 Sind 58 Permissibility of multiple final decrees in a composite suit involving multiple causes of action. Applied to justify that the suit could have more than one final decree, including one on possession and another on monetary claims.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the definition of "decree" under Section 2(2) of the Civil Procedure Code, which requires a formal expression of adjudication conclusively determining the parties' rights on any matter in controversy. The trial Judge had held the eviction notice invalid, thereby deciding the suit for possession was not maintainable, but allowed the suit to proceed on rent claims. The Court found that this decision on possession was a substantive, final adjudication on that matter and thus amounted to a decree, notwithstanding the trial Judge's characterization as merely a "finding" or "order." The Court emphasized that the label given by the trial Court is not determinative; the decisive test is whether there is a conclusive adjudication of rights. The Court relied on established precedents to affirm that failure to draw up a formal decree does not negate the existence of a decree. Furthermore, the Court recognized that multiple final decrees could exist in a composite suit addressing distinct causes of action. Accordingly, the trial Court's refusal to draw up a decree on the possession claim was erroneous and was set aside. The trial Court was directed to draw up such a decree in accordance with its judgment on the preliminary issue.

Holding and Implications

The revision application is allowed and the order of the trial Court refusing to draw up a decree is set aside.

The trial Court is directed to draw up a decree pursuant to its judgment on the preliminary issue concerning the possession claim. This decision clarifies that a conclusive adjudication on a preliminary issue can amount to a decree under Section 2(2) CPC, even if the suit is not finally disposed of in entirety. No new precedent is created beyond the application of existing legal principles. The direct effect is to enable the petitioner to proceed with the appeal by obtaining a decree on the possession issue.

    Kanji Hirjibhai Gondalia v. Jivaraj Dharamshi

    Judgement

    ORDER:- This revision application raises a short but interesting question. The pertinent facts are that the suit residential premises situated on Hathikhana Road, Rajkot belong to Rajkot Halari Vanand Community. The opponent is a tenant of the suit premises. Kanji Hirjibhai Gondaliya, as a manager of Halari Vanand Community filed Civil Suit No. 152 of 1970 in the Court of the Joint Civil Judge Junior Division, Rajkot for possession of the suit premises as well arrears of rent. The suit for possession was filed on the ground that the tenant was in arrears of rent. The tenant contested the suit and raised a plea that the notice for eviction was not valid. The learned trial Judge raised issue No. 1 which is as under:

    "Whether the suit notice is valid and legal?"

    The learned trial Judge tried this issue as preliminary issue since in his opinion a part of the suit could be disposed of by a finding on that issue. The learned trial Judge came to the conclusion that the notice of eviction was not legal. The learned Judge has observed in his judgment that before passing the final order he may clarify that the suit for possession could not proceed because of the defective notice, but there could be no hitch to the plaintiffs claim for rent. The learned trial Judge passed the following order:

    "The suit notice (Exh. 4/1) is held to be not valid and legal and as such, the suit for recovery of possession of the suit premises is held incompetent and unmaintainable. The suit is, therefore, ordered to proceed only in respect of the claim for the monetary reliefs."

    Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and order the petitioner has preferred Appeal No. 88 of 1972 in the District Court, Rajkot. However in that appeal a certified copy of decree of the Court has not been filed because the decree has not been drawn up in pursuance of the aforesaid judgment and order of the trial Court. According to the petitioner the appeal is likely to fail on the technical ground of its maintainability in absence of a decree. The petitioner, therefore, made an application to the trial Court to draw up a decree in pursuance of the judgment given by the learned trial Judge on the preliminary issue. The learned trial Judge by his order dated January 19, 1973, dismissed the application for drawing up a decree observing that the suit was not yet finally decided and only point so far decided was that the plaintiffs suit for possession was not maintainable in law and the suit for other reliefs was yet to proceed on merits. It is this order of the learned trial Judge which is sought to be challenged in this revision application.

    2. Now the question is whether the order of the Court on the preliminary issue amounts to a decree. section 2 (2) of the civil procedure code defines what a decree is. According to the said definition a decree is a formal expression of an adjudication which, so far as regards the Court expressing it, conclusively determines the rights of the parties with regard to all or any of the matters in controversy in the suit and, may be either preliminary or final. Now the learned trial Judge has held that the; notice of eviction was defective and the; plaintiff was not entitled to a relief for recovery of possession of the suit premises because of the defective notice. The learned Judge has held that the suit for eviction was not competent and maintainable. He further directed that the suit should proceed only with respect to the claim for monetary relief. Now so far the relief for possession is concerned there is a substantive decision or determination. The decision of the learned trial Judge on the point is clearly a final adjudication between the parties in respect of the suit for possession. The order of the learned trial Judge conclusively determines the rights of the parties on the question of eviction. The determination for the relief of possession is final and conclusive so far as the trial Court is concerned. The question whether the adjudication is a decree or not has to be determined with reference to the definition of decree given in section 2 (2) of the civil procedure code The trial Court has undoubtedly adjudicated on the substantive rights of the parties with regard to the controversy for recovery of possession of the suit premises. The order of the trial Judge is clearly indicative of the fact that he has finally determined the issue relating to possession and there is formal expression of the said adjudication It is true that the learned trial Judge has taken the view that only finding on the issue has been given by him and he has passed only a formal order and, therefore, no decree need be drawn as there had been no final disposal of the suit. There is obvious difference between a simple finding and a finding which terminates the suit. To determine the exact nature and extent of a finding reference to the definition of decree given in S.2 (2) of the Civil Procedure Code is essential. Merely because the trial Court heads his finding as an order is not determinative of its nature nor his conclusion to that effect is conclusive. The question whether an order passed by a Court amounts to a decree or not has to be determined with reference to the definition of decree given in section 2 (2) of the civil procedure code and the test to be applied is whether there is a formal expression of adjudication, which as regards the Court expressing it, conclusively determines the rights of the parties with regard to any of the matters in controversy in the suit. In the aforesaid view of mine I am supported by the decisions of the Madras High Court in V. Adinarayan Chetti v. Kopparam Narasinha Chetti, ILR 54 Mad 337 = (AIR 1931 Mad 471) and Kasi v. Rm. A. R. M. V. Ramanathan Chettiar (1947) 2 Mad LJ 523. Whether an order passed by a Court is a decree or not cannot depend on the drawing up of a decree by the Court as formal drawing up of a decree is the duty of the Court; vide Jagat Dhish Bhargava v, Jawahar Lal Bhargava, AIR 1961 SC 832 and Parashuram Rajaram Tiwari v. Hirabai Rajaram Tiwari, AIR 1957 Bom 59. If a Court does not draw up a decree it cannot be said that the order of the Court by which rights of the parties are finally adjudicated upon is not a decree. There can be more than one final decree in a suit where two or more causes of action are joined together. There is no provision in the Civil Procedure Code which prevents the Court from passing two final decrees, it the circumstances of the case so require, vide Fatmabai W/o Rasim v. Abubaker Tarmahmed, AIR 1946 Sind 58. The present suit is a composite suite - being a suit for possession and a suit for arrears of rent-; and the issue between the parties with regard to possession of the suit premises is finally decided by the trial Court. Thus there is final adjudication on the issue of possession and this determination amounts to a decree within the meaning of section 2 (2) of the civil procedure code. The impugned order of the learned trial Judge refusing to draw up a decree, therefore, is erroneous and the same is set aside. It is directed that the trial Court should draw up a decree in pursuance of the judgment and decision passed by it with respect to the claim for possession of the suit premises.

    3. The result is the rule issued in this revision application is made absolute with no order as to costs.

    Application allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kanji Hirjibhai Gondalia v. Jivaraj Dharamshi
    (Sep 20, 1974)