AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — PREM CHAND JAIN, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a reference made by the learned Single Judge by an order dated May 3, 1978, posing the following question of law:

"Whether revision lies against an order passed under O.26, R.9 of the Civil P.C. refusing to appoint a Local Commissioner?"

The matter was referred to the larger Bench because the learned Single Judge perceived a conflict of judicial opinion on the point. The proceedings before the trial Court involved an application for issuance of a commission (a local commissioner) which the trial Court refused. The trial Court's stated reason for refusal was that issue No. 3 could be proved by producing the relevant record and that demarcation was not necessary. A revision petition challenging that interlocutory order was filed, leading to this reference and determination by the High Court. The judgment dismisses the revision petition and contains directions that the parties appear before the trial Court on November 7, 1978; no order as to costs was made.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether revision under Section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code lies against an order passed under Order 26, Rule 9 (refusing to appoint a Local Commissioner).
  2. What is the scope of the explanation added to Section 115 (by the 1976 Amendment) — specifically, whether the expression "any case which has been decided" (as explained) makes interlocutory orders such as refusal to issue a commission revisable.
  3. If interlocutory orders are potentially revisable, what is the test to determine which interlocutory orders are revisable under Section 115?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Applicant's) Arguments

  • Mr. Sarin, counsel for the petitioners, argued that a revision lies against an order refusing to appoint a Local Commissioner under O.26, R.9.
  • He relied on the decision in M/s. Goverdhan Das Gopi Nath v. Smt. Amolak Raj (1975 Cur LJ 744 (Punj)) which held that such an order is revisable under Section 115.
  • He further relied on the explanation added to Section 115 by the 1976 Amendment: "In this Section, the expression any case which has been decided includes any order made, or any order deciding an issue, in the course of a suit or other proceeding." On that basis he contended that an order declining to appoint a commission is an order made in the course of a suit and thus falls within the expression "case decided".
  • During argument, Mr. Sarin did not contend that every interlocutory order made in the course of a suit should be revisable; his contention was limited to orders of the kind refusing appointment of a commission.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dalmir Singh alias Dalmira v. Sant Parkash, Civil Revision No. 1459 of 1975 (decided Sept. 21, 1976) (reported 1976 Rev LR 654 (Punj & Har)) Held (by R.S. Narula, C.J.) that no revision lay against an order refusing to appoint a local commissioner. The Court cites this decision as part of the line of authorities supporting the proposition that revision does not lie against such an order and treats it as laying down the correct law on that question.
Mohinder Kumar Rajinder Parkash v. Basheshar Nath, (1976) 78 Pun LR 280 Judgement of Pattar J. used as a basis for the view that no revision lies against an order refusing a commission. Referenced as one of the decisions (along with Dalmir Singh and Mangal Singh) that lay down the correct law that revision does not lie against an O.26 R.9 order refusing a commission.
M/s. Goverdhan Das Gopi Nath v. Smt. Amolak Raj, 1975 Cur LJ 744 (Punj) Held that an order refusing to issue a commission is revisable under Section 115 of the Civil P.C. The Court considered and respectfully disagreed with this decision; the opinion states that this was the only judgment relied upon by Mr. Sarin that necessitated the reference to the larger Bench, but concludes it is not the correct view in law.
S.S. Khanna v. F.J. Dhillon, AIR 1964 SC 497 Resolved earlier conflict over whether "case decided" includes interlocutory orders; however, it did not hold that every order in the course of a suit is a "case decided". The Court notes that S.S. Khanna resolved a conflict but that further clarification was needed; the decision is foundational to the subsequent test adopted (as later clarified by Baldevdas Shivlal).
Baldevdas Shivlal v. Filmistan Distributors (India) Pvt. Ltd., AIR 1970 SC 406 Held that a "case may be said to be decided, if the Court adjudicates for the purposes of the suit some right or obligation of the parties in controversy"; not every order in the suit is a "case decided". The Court adopts the test from this decision to interpret the explanation to Section 115 — an interlocutory order is revisable only if it determines or adjudicates some right or obligation of the parties in controversy.
M/s. Sadhu Ram Bali Ram v. M/s. Ghansham Dass Madan Lal, AIR 1975 Punj & Har 174 (Full Bench) Discussed in the opinion; in that case an order was held revisable because the onus of an issue had been wrongly placed and deciding that question affected rights/obligations. The Court distinguishes that decision on its facts and notes it concerned a different situation (wrongly placed onus and consequent adjudication of rights), therefore it does not support revisionability of an O.26 R.9 refusal of commission of the type in the present case.
Mangal Singh v. Piara Lal, (1971) 73 Pun LR 531 Cited as one of the cases supporting the rule that no revision lies against an order under O.26, R.9 refusing a commission. The Court groups this case with Mohinder Kumar, Dalmir Singh, and others as laying down the correct law on non-revisionability in the circumstances before the Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds in discrete steps, grounded in the text of Section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code, the 1976 explanation to that section, and binding Supreme Court authority:

  1. Structure of Section 115: The Court explains Section 115 as having two parts — (a) conditions under which the High Court's revision jurisdiction arises (a "case decided" by a subordinate court in which no appeal lies), and (b) the circumstances in which the High Court may exercise that jurisdiction. The power is expressly exercisable only in respect of "any case which has been decided".
  2. Purpose of the Explanation (1976 Amendment): The explanation was added to clarify whether "case decided" includes interlocutory orders made during the course of a suit, in view of earlier conflicting judicial decisions. The Court emphasizes that the explanation defines the phrase to include "any order made, or any order deciding an issue, in the course of a suit or other proceeding."
  3. Limited Meaning of the Explanation: The Court rejects an expansive reading that would make every order made in the course of a suit revisable. The explanation does not, by itself, render every interlocutory order revisable. The Court notes that even the petitioners' counsel did not argue that all interlocutory orders should be revisable.
  4. Adoption of Test from Baldevdas Shivlal: The Court adopts the Supreme Court's test in Baldevdas Shivlal (AIR 1970 SC 406), which clarified that "a case may be said to be decided, if the Court adjudicates for the purposes of the suit some right or obligation of the parties in controversy." Thus, an interlocutory order is revisable under Section 115 only if it determines or adjudicates some right or obligation of the parties in controversy.
  5. Application to the Facts: Applying that test to the present facts, the Court finds that the trial Court's refusal to appoint a commission (O.26, R.9) was based on the finding that issue No. 3 could be proved by producing the relevant record and that demarcation was not necessary. Those observations did not amount to an adjudication of any issue nor did they determine any right or obligation of the parties for the purposes of the suit. Accordingly, the refusal did not satisfy the Baldevdas test.
  6. Consideration of Conflicting Decisions: The Court reviews earlier conflicting judgments. It expresses respectful disagreement with M/s. Goverdhan Das Gopi Nath (which held that refusal to issue a commission is revisable). The Court upholds the contrary line of authorities (including Mohinder Kumar Rajinder Parkash, Dalmir Singh, and Mangal Singh) as correctly stating the law. The Court distinguishes M/s. Sadhu Ram Bali Ram on its facts since that case involved misplacement of onus that affected substantive rights.
  7. Residual and Limiting Observations: The Court cautions that it is not laying down a blanket rule that no interlocutory order under any provision of O.26 is ever revisable. Whether a particular interlocutory order is revisable under Section 115 depends on whether it adjudicates some right or obligation of the parties in controversy; each case must be decided on its facts. The exercise of revision is also subject to the restrictions and provisos contained in sub-section (1) and the proviso to Section 115.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that no revision lies against an order passed under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code refusing to appoint a Local Commissioner in the circumstances of this case because the order did not adjudicate any right or obligation of the parties for the purposes of the suit.

Consequences and Directions:

  • The revision petition challenging the trial Court's refusal to appoint a local commissioner is dismissed. (The judgment states: "Revision dismissed.")
  • No order as to costs was made.
  • The parties were directed through their counsel to appear before the trial Court on November 7, 1978.

Broader Implications:

The Court affirms the narrower reading of the explanation to Section 115: an interlocutory order made in the course of a suit will be revisable only if it determines or adjudicates some right or obligation of the parties in controversy (applying Baldevdas Shivlal). The judgment endorses the line of authorities that refuse to permit revision against an O.26, R.9 refusal to issue a commission where the order does not adjudicate any such right or obligation. The Court, however, refrains from establishing a categorical rule excluding all interlocutory orders under O.26 from revision; each interlocutory order must be assessed on its facts against the adopted test.

Source: Extracted and summarized exclusively from the provided opinion delivered by PREM CHAND JAIN, J.

    Harvinder Kaur Etc., Petitioners. v. Godha Ram, Etc.,

    Judgement

    PREM CHAND JAIN, J. :- On the reference that has been made by the learned single Judge vide his order dated May 3, 1978, the question of law that requires determination may be formulated thus :-

    "Whether revision lies against an order passed under O.26, R.9 of the Civil P.C. refusing to appoint a Local Commissioner ?"

    2. The reference has been made as in the opinion of the learned Judge there appeared to be a conflict of opinion on this aspect of the matter. In Dalmir Singh alias Dalmira v. Sant Parkash, Civil Revision No. 1459 of 1975, decided on Sept. 21, 1976,* R.S. Narula, C.J. (as he then was), on the basis of the judgement of Pattar J., in Mohinder Kumar Rajinder Parkash v. Basheshar Nath, (1976) 78 Pun LR 280, held that no revision lay against such an order. On the contrary, S.C. Mital J., in M/s. Goverdhan Das Gopi Nath v. Smt. Amolak Raj, 1975 Cur LJ 744 (Punj), has held that an order refusing to issue a commission is revisable under S.115 of the Civil P.C.

    *Reported in 1976 Rev LR 654 (Punj and Har)

    3. Mr. Sarin, learned counsel for the petitioners, contended that a revision lay against an order refusing to appoint a local Commissioner and that the view taken in M/s. Goverdhan Das Gopi Naths case was the correct view and deserved to be upheld. Besides relying on the reasoning given in M/s. Goverdhan Dass Gopi Naths case, the learned counsel relied on the explanation added to section 115 of the civil p.c., which is in the following terms :-

    "In this Section, the expression any case which has been decided includes any order made, or any order deciding an issue, in the course of a suit or other proceeding."

    On the strength of the aforesaid explanation, it was contended by Mr. Sarin that the order declining to appoint a commission was passed in the course of a suit and such an order fell within the expression case decided.

    4. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, we find ourselves unable to agree with the contention of the learned counsel.

    5. S.115 consists of two parts, the first prescribes the conditions in which jurisdiction of the High Court arises, i.e. there is a case decided by a Subordinate Court in which no appeal lies to the High Court; the second, sets out the circumstances in which the jurisdiction may be exercised. But the power of the High Court is exercisable in respect of "any case which has been decided". The expression case decided was not defined in the Code, with the result that there was a conflict of judicial decisions on the question whether the expression case decided included interlocutory orders or not. Though this conflict was resolved by the Supreme Court in S.S. Khanna v. F.J. Dhillon, AIR 1964 SC 497, yet in order to clear all doubts about the maintainability of a revision against an interlocutory order, the explanation has been added by the Amendment Act in the year 1976. However, in the instant case, the explanation by itself is of no help as it has still to be decided whether in view of the provision of the explanation an order declining to appoint a commission would be revisable or not ? In our view, in the circumstances of this case, the answer has to be in the negative.

    6. Before the amendment of S.115 in the year 1976, the power of revision was exercisable subject to the restriction imposed in cls. (a), (b) and (c) of Sub-Sec. (1). As earlier observed, the words case decided had not been defined and for that reason, a conflict of judicial decisions in respect of interpretation of these words had crept in. The intention of adding the explanation was only to define the words case decided, i.e., that a revision would lie against an order passed during the course of a suit or other proceeding. But the explanation cannot be given this meaning that every order made in the course of a suit or other proceeding would be revisable. Even, Mr. Sarin, learned counsel, during the course of arguments, did not go to that extent that every order passed in the course of a suit or other proceeding would be revisable under S.115 of the Code.

    7. In this situation, it has now to be found out as to which type of interlocutory orders would be revisable by this Court in exercise of its powers under S.115 of the Civil P.C. ? To this question, the answer is available from the judgement of their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Baldevdas Shivlal v. Filmistan Distributors (India) Pvt. Ltd., AIR 1970 SC 406, wherein after considering S.S. Khannas case (AIR 1964 SC 497) it was observed thus (at p. 410) :-

    "But it was not decided in S.S. Khannas case, (1964) 4 SCR 409 : (AIR 1964 SC 497) that every order of the Court in the course of a suit amounts to a case decided. A case may be said to be decided, if the Court adjudicates for the purposes of the suit some right or obligation of the parties in controversy; every order in the suit cannot be regarded as a case decided within the meaning of S.115 of the Civil P.C."

    8. In the light of the aforesaid observation, without dilating any more on this subject, the meaning that can be given to the explanation is that an order made in the course of a suit or proceeding would be revisable only when it determines or adjudicates some right or obligation of the parties in controversy. Thus, a revision would lie against an interlocutory order only if it determines or adjudicates some right or obligation of the parties in controversy. However, even after the satisfaction of the aforesaid test the power of revision would be exercisable by this Court subject to the limitations put under Sub-Sec. (1) and the proviso to S.115 of the Civil P.C.

    9. Adverting to the facts of the present case, we find that the trial Court has only rejected the application for the issuance of a commission on the ground that issue No. 3 could be proved by producing the relevant record and that demarcation was not necessary. From these observations, it is clear that the learned Subordinate Judge did not decide any issue nor did he adjudicate for the purposes of the suit some right or obligation of the parties in controversy.

    10. Adverting to the case law, reference may be made to M/s. Goverdhan Das Gopi Naths case (1975 Cur LJ 744) (Punj) the only judgement on which reliance had been placed by Mr. Sarin and which decision necessitated the reference to the larger Bench. In view of our aforesaid discussion, we are, with utmost respect, unable to agree with the view taken in that decision. The learned Judge, on the basis of the judgement of the Supreme Court in S.S. Khannas case (AIR 1964 SC 497) and a Full Bench judgement of this Court in M/s. Sadhu Ram Bali Ram v. M/s. Ghansham Dass Madan Lal, AIR 1975 Punj and Har 174, arrived at the conclusion that the order rejecting the application of the defendant for examining two witnesses residing in Bombay on commission falls within the expression case decided.

    11. As has already been observed in the earlier part of the judgement, S.S. Khannas case stands explained by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Baldevdas Shivlals case (AIR 1970 SC 406) and in view of the test laid down therein, the order of the Court should result into adjudication of some right or obligation of the parties in controversy during the course of a suit or other proceeding. The order declining to issue a commission of the type mentioned in M/s. Goverdhan Das Gopi Naths case does not satisfy that test. It may further be observed that the facts of M/s. Sadhu Ram Bali Rams case were different as in that case the onus of an issue had been wrongly placed and while deciding that question it was held that such an order would be revisable.

    12. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we hold that no revision would lie against an order passed under O.26, R.9 and the view taken in M/s. Mohindier Kumar Rajinder Parkash ((1976) 78 Pun LR 280); Dalmir Singh alias Dalmira 1976 Rev LR 654 (Punj and Har) and Mangal Singh v. Piara Lal, (1971) 73 Pun LR 531 cases lays down the correct law.

    13. Before parting with the judgement, it may, however, be made clear that it cannot as a general rule be laid down that in no case a revision would lie against an interlocutory order passed under any other provision of O.26, and that it would be on the facts of each case that it will have to be found out whether the interlocutory order, against which a revision is sought to be filed, has adjudicated for the purposes of the suit some right or obligation of the parties in controversy or not.

    14. For the reasons recorded above, this revision petition fails and is dismissed, but in the circumstances of the case, we make no order as to costs. The parties, through their learned counsel, have been directed to appear before the trial Court on Nov. 7, 1978.

    Revision dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harvinder Kaur Etc., Petitioners. v. Godha Ram, Etc.,
    (Aug 24, 1978)