Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Acts
  • Sections 467,468,471,120-BI.P.C. and Section 13(1)(D), read with Section 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • sections 419/420/467/468/469/471/120b/341, ipvc and section 7/12/13 prevention of corruption act.
  • sections 467/468/471/120b, ipc and section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) prevention of corruption act.
  • sections 467/468/471/120b and section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) prevention of corruption act.
  • Section 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. (ix)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Acts
  • Sections 467,468,471,120-BI.P.C. and Section 13(1)(D), read with Section 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • sections 419/420/467/468/469/471/120b/341, ipvc and section 7/12/13 prevention of corruption act.
  • sections 467/468/471/120b, ipc and section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) prevention of corruption act.
  • sections 467/468/471/120b and section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) prevention of corruption act.
  • Section 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. (ix)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Four petitioners (unsuccessful candidates in the 2005 selection for posts of Constable, Civil Police in Uttar Pradesh) filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging an order dated 21 April 2008 (Annexure-2) by respondent No.1 (Union of India). The petitioners alleged large-scale malpractices in the recruitment processes held in 2005–2006 for numerous vacancies advertised by the U.P. Police Headquarters and sought an investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation (C.B.I.).

Administrative steps and inquiries preceding the petition: after numerous complaints and representations (including from Members of the Legislative Assembly), the State Government directed the Director General of Police to inquire. A four-member inquiry committee (headed by Shailja Kant Mishra, ADG) found extensive violations and recommended cancellation of selections at multiple recruitment centres and initiation of criminal and departmental proceedings. The State Government cancelled selections at numerous centres (orders dated 11, 18 and 30 September 2007) and registered criminal cases and departmental proceedings against several officers.

A high-level committee chaired by the Chief Secretary recommended handing the matter to the C.B.I.; the State Government formally requested the Union (respondent No.1) on 4 February 2008 to have the C.B.I. investigate. The Union declined by order dated 21 April 2008 (Annexure-2), giving reasons including lack of substantive manpower and that the C.B.I. was over-burdened. The petitioners challenged the refusal in this writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Union of India's refusal (Annexure-2) to allow the C.B.I. to investigate the alleged large-scale malpractices in the U.P. police constable recruitments (despite a formal request by the State Government) is sustainable in law.
  2. Whether the petitioners (unsuccessful candidates) have locus standi to challenge the refusal and seek direction for C.B.I. investigation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners alleged grave malpractices in the recruitment process (physical test marks altered, improper evaluation of written answers, forgery, tampering of final mark sheets, absence of required signatures, candidates declared passed without appearing in physical tests, etc.).
  • They pointed to inquiry reports and forensic findings showing forgery, rewriting of answer sheets by recruitment board members, tampering of marks and criminal conspiracy by selection board members.
  • They relied on the fact that the State Government itself requested C.B.I. investigation (request dated 4 February 2008), and argued that the Union's refusal on grounds of C.B.I. manpower and workload was not tenable and amounted to an improper refusal to exercise power.
  • The petitioners cited precedent (State of Bihar v. Ranchi Zila Samta Party) and State of West Bengal v. Sampat Lal to support the view that directions for C.B.I. investigation can be appropriate and that the Union's refusal could be quashed.
  • They also filed supplementary affidavit(s) and relied on documents including inquiry reports, cancellation orders and criminal investigation reports submitted to the State Government.

Respondent / Union of India Arguments

  • The Union contended that powers under the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act (DSPE Act) are discretionary and that the High Court should not compel the C.B.I. to investigate, particularly where State police authorities are investigating.
  • The Union gave administrative reasons for refusal: non-availability of substantive manpower, the C.B.I. being over-burdened and infeasibility of investigating a large number of cases.
  • The Union's counsel acknowledged that the matter would be decided on the basis of reasons in the impugned order and that filing a counter-affidavit would not improve the respondent's case before the Court.
  • The Union also attempted to challenge the petitioners' locus, an argument addressed by the Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Bihar and another v. Ranchi Zila Samta Party and another, J.T. 1996 (3) S.C. 751 Discusses limits on the High Court's power under Article 226 to direct investigation by the C.B.I. without State consent; refers to Entry 80, List I of the Seventh Schedule and Section 6 of the DSPE Act — i.e., ordinarily an investigating agency other than State police cannot investigate offences in a State without State consent. The Court observed that the objection in State of Bihar (regarding directing C.B.I. without State consent) does not apply here because the State Government itself requested C.B.I. investigation. Consequently, the Union's refusal could not be sustained on that ground.
State of West Bengal and others v. Sampat Lal and others, A.I.R. 1985 S.C. 195 Illustrates circumstances in which the Court appointed a C.B.I. officer to make a special inquiry when there were concerns about adequacy or fairness of State investigation; discusses the High Court's supervisory role and when central investigation may be appropriate. The Court relied on this decision to reject the Union's administrative objections and to support the proposition that a C.B.I. inquiry may be directed where circumstances warrant it; the opinion quotes the decision and notes its use to repel similar arguments by the Union.
Bhagwant Singh v. Commissioner of Police, Delhi, (1983) 3 SCC 344 (AIR 1983 SC 826) Discussed in the context of parameters for appointment of a C.B.I. officer/Special Officer and the High Court's approach to ordering central inquiry; cited within the West Bengal decision. The West Bengal judgment (relied upon by petitioners and the Court) refers to Bhagwant Singh in support of appointing a C.B.I. officer as Special Officer to inquire into allegations where State investigation was in doubt. The present Court cited the West Bengal reasoning which itself relies on Bhagwant Singh.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in the following logical steps, based on the material and authorities placed before it:

  1. Factual foundation: The Court reviewed the inquiry committee's findings and the investigative agency reports which identified extensive irregularities (alteration of marks, rewriting of answer sheets, forgeries, tampering of final mark sheets, chairman's absence during tests, checking of copies at non-designated places, and evidence from forensic experts implicating recruitment board members).
  2. Administrative response: The State Government cancelled selections at multiple centres, registered criminal cases, initiated departmental proceedings and, after a high-level review, formally requested the Union to have the C.B.I. investigate (request dated 4 February 2008).
  3. Respondent's refusal: The Union refused by Annexure-2 (21 April 2008), citing C.B.I.'s lack of manpower and being over-burdened as the principal reasons for declining the State's request.
  4. Legal framing: Petitioners relied on precedents (including State of Bihar and State of West Bengal) to argue that the Union's refusal was legally unsustainable in the circumstances — especially where the State itself sought central investigation.
  5. Application of precedents: The Court considered the State of Bihar decision which addresses the limits of High Court power to direct C.B.I. without State consent, and concluded that the limitation in State of Bihar is inapplicable here because the State had asked for C.B.I. involvement. The Court also relied on State of West Bengal (and the authorities it cites) to reject the administrative reasons given by the Union.
  6. Locus and standing: The Court found that the petitioners, being unsuccessful candidates and complainants about the malpractices, had locus to challenge the refusal to investigate.
  7. Conclusion on refusal: Given the State's formal request and the precedent-based analysis, the Court concluded that the Union's refusal to direct/provide the C.B.I. to investigate the matter could not be sustained.

The Court expressly limited its review to the reasons contained in the impugned order (Annexure-2) and the materials placed before it; it noted the Union's counsel acceptance that additional affidavits would not change the outcome.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

THE ORDER DATED 21ST APRIL, 2008 (ANNEXURE-2) IS QUASHED.

The Court directed respondent No.1 (Union of India) and the C.B.I. to investigate the matters as requested by the State Government vide its request dated 4 February 2008.

Direct consequences and implications:

  • The direct legal effect of the decision is that the Union's refusal (Annexure-2) stands quashed and the C.B.I. is directed to proceed with investigation into the recruitments as requested by the State Government.
  • The Court relied on existing Supreme Court precedents in reaching its conclusion; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new or novel precedent beyond applying those authorities to the facts of this case.

No additional reliefs or orders (beyond quashing Annexure-2 and directing the C.B.I. to investigate) are recorded in the provided opinion text.

    Amit Kumar Shukla and Others v. Union of India and Others

    By the Court.-

    This writ petition under article 226 of the constitution of india has been filed by four petitioners, who are candidates in the selection for the post of constable civil police held in the year 2005 in the State of U.P., challenging the order dated 21st April, 2008, passed by respondent No.1,Annexure-'2' to the writ petition.

    2. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner, learned Standing Counsel for re­spondents 2 to 5 and Union of India through the counsel.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that they are deeply an­guished due to inaction on the part of respondents 1 and 2 in curbing the malprac­tices which occurred in the selection process of the constables of Civil Police/P.A.C./Radio Police in the State of U.P. The petitioners have challenged their exclusion from the selection for the post of constable in the year 2005 and denied by respondent No.1 to direct the holding of the investigation by C.B.I, in the malpractices in conducting the selection aforesaid.

    4. By the notification dated 6th January, 2005, which has been amended by notification dated 21st January, 2005 for recruitment of civil police constables in State of U.P., 6091 vacancies was advertised by U.P. Police Head Quarter on 23rd July, 2005. Similar identical notification was published on 7th April, 2006 for 5296 vacancies and vide notification dated 4th June, 2006 for 6237 vacancies. It is further asserted by the petitioners that on 6th February, 2005, 10th April, 2006 and 23rd September, 2006, certain instructions/guidelines were issued by the Police Head Quarter, Allahabad for governing the respective recruitment process of constables (Civil Police) and these instructions contained detailed guidelines in respect of the schedule of recruitment and eligibility criteria of recruitment. The aforesaid guidelines prescribed the detailed procedure for preparation of one main register in which the marks obtained by the candidates for each item, such as written examination and interview etc. should be shown. It is further provided that the candidates, who had not qualified the physical eligibility test will not be en-­titled for written examination and for written, examination it was compulsory for the candidate to obtain 50 per cent marks in each event of physical eligibility test and after awarding the marks the examiner will put the signature and mark the seal and the same will be sent under sealed cover to the Chairman of Selection Committee.

    5. During the selection process a number of complaints were made by the candidates as well as representatives of public regarding grave irregularities and malpractices. The complaint in respect to different recruitment centres were also given to the concerned officials of different districts. It is so happened that certain complaints were received in the office of Chief Minister, U.P. sent by Sri Mohd. Irshad Khan; Sri R.P. Jaiswal; Sri Radhey Lal Rawatand Sri Amresh Shukla (all members of Legislative Assembly, U.P.). On receipt of the aforesaid complaint, the State Government issued direction to Director General of Police U.P. to en­quire into the allegations. In pursuant thereto a four member committee headed by Sri Shailja Kant Mishra, Additional Director General of Police was constituted to enquire into the charges of illegalities, corruption, nepotism, procedural irregu- ; larities and violations of Rules and instructions issued by the Headquarters by the Director General of Police, U.P. dated 13th June, 2007. The enquiry commit­tee proceeded to conduct inquiry in respect of procedure and work of the Selec­tion Committee, such as (1) physical efficiency text; (2) written examination; (3) interview and (4) tabulation work. This enquiry committee found that there were clear cut violation of recruitment instructions at large scale and irregularities and/illegalities such as:

    (1) Marks of physical eligibility test were altered and added by the examiner in mark sheet.

    (2) All those answer book of the written examination in which chest num­ber and identification marks were mentioned by the candidate, found to have been checked and declared passed by the selection committee.

    (3) The evaluation wrongly done by the examiner and alteration of the marks in the answer book.

    (4) The hand writing of the names slip of the answer book and hand writing in the answer book both are different and some answer are written in different hand writing.

    (5) In 108 copies of the written examination the extra marks were given by the examiner without any basis and all those candidates were declared passed. It is further submitted that if these extra marks are reduced then the candidate become failed. No merit list was prepared by the selection com­mittee. The over writing on marks made in the answer book were neither signed by the examiner and nor counter signed by the Chairman of selection committee.

    (6) There is no signature of the candidate in the mark sheet of physical eligibility test and some of the candidate declared passed without appearing in the physical eligibility test."

    6. After receiving the report submitted by the enquiry committee, the State Government annulled the selection held at 42 centers and passed cancellation order dated 11th September, 2007 by which-the selection of 14 recruitment cen­ters was cancelled and by 18th September, 2007, the State Government further cancelled selection of 10 recruitment centers and lastly by order dated 30th Sep­tember, 2007 selection of 18 recruitment centers has been cancelled. The com­mittee headed by Sri Shailja Kant Mishra in its report mentioned that procedural instructions and rules were not followed and malpractices and forgery were com­mitted by the selection boards. This enquiry committee apart from recommend­ing cancellation of entire selection also recommended for initiation of criminal proceedings against all those who were responsible to pollute the selection pro­cess and to start departmental action against the erring officers. The State Gov­ernment accepted the enquiry report as stated above and also registered criminal cases against the erring officers and departmental proceeding was also initiated against the responsible persons.

    7. The State Government apart from taking the aforesaid steps has further in order to find out the realities of allegations in respect of the selections in question constituted a high level committee headed by Chief Secretary of State under the orders of the cabinet. The Chief Secretary submitted its report before the Cabinet and has recommended handing over the case to the C.B.I, for detailed investiga­tion. The copy of request letter of the State Government dated 4th February, 2008 is annexed as Annexure-'1' to the writ petition. The Anti Corruption Organization, UP. has submitted its report to the State Government which reveals certain glar­ing and alarming facts which clearly indicates that the entire selection was cov­ered with forgery and was farce. The investigating agency submitted its report in case crime No. 1626 of 2007 on 16th April, 2008 before the State Government with the request to grant sanction for initiation of criminal proceedings in the court. In its report the agency had submitted charge-sheet against erring officers, namely Sri B.B. Bakshi, Deputy Inspector General of Police, Jhansi and the members of selection committee, namely Sri Ramesh, Additional Superinten­dent of Police, Mau, Sri Sushil Kumar Shukla, Assistant Commandant 33rd Bat­talion, P.A.C., Jhansi, Sri Akhlaq Ahmad Khan, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Kanpur Nagar, Sri Harinath Yadav, Deputy Superintendent of Police. All these officers were found involved in the offence and the charge-sheet was submitted under Sections 467,468,471,120-BI.P.C. and Section 13(1)(D), read with Sec­tion 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act. These officers were involved in the malpractices relating to Gorakhpur recruitment center, wherein identical and similar illegalities were committed on almost all the cancelled centers which were tented with corruption such as:

    "(i) Several examination sheets were not in the hand writing of the candi­dates as has been confirmed by the forensic experts in its report.

    (ii) Several examination sheets were written by Mr. -Sushil Kumar Shukla, Deputy Superintendent of Police, who also happened to be one of the mem­ber of the recruitment board.

    (iii) The investigating agency found that one of the members of the re­cruitment board Mr. Sushil Kumar Shukla while examining the written exami­nation sheet had himself written answers to facilitate illegal selection of sev­eral candidates. The investigating agency has also concluded that Mr. Sushil Kumar Shukla thus acted as part of criminal conspiracy to promote illegal selection.

    (iv) In several written examination sheets, correction were made in the given answer by Sri Akhlaq Ahmad, Deputy Superintendent of Police and Sri Sushil Kumar Shukla, Deputy Superintendent of Police and other fellow mem­bers of the recruitment board so that the candidates may get undue advan­tage. This fact again has been corroborated by the hand writing experts of the forensic lab.

    (v) The final mark sheet was tampered with and wrong entries were made therein to facilitate selection of several candidates. In all 34 candidates who were not eligible to be selected got selected because the final mark sheet containing the marks for physical examination were deliberately increased as part of a criminal conspiracy.

    (vi) As per instructions governing the examination, chairman should re­main physically present on the site of examination but the investigating agency has detected on the basis of available authentic records that Chairman namely Sri B.B. Bakshi was not physically present during the physical test, written examination and also during the interview. A copy of the car diaries of Mr. B.B. Bakshi is being enclosed, a perusal whereof would reveal that during the course and the time of examination, he made a visit not only to far distant places in the district but to Lucknow also.

    (vii) The checking of copies were not carried out at the designated place and forgeries were committed in a well organized manner at the camp office of the Chairman of the recruitment board against the rules and instructions governing the examination.

    (viii) That in its conclusion the investigating agency has found Mr. B.B. Bakshi, Chairman of the recruitment board, Mr. Ramesh, Additional Superin­tendent of Police, Mr. Sushii Kumar Shukla, Deputy Superintendent of Po­lice, Mr. Akhlakh Ahmad, Deputy Superintendent of Police and Mr. Harinath Yadav, Deputy Superintendent of Police, criminally guilty and has sought to launch prosecution against them under Section 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

    (ix) The investigating agency has also concluded that the Chairman and the members of the board criminally colluded to ensure the selection of ineli­gible candidates."

    8. That the investigating agency submitted its report in case crime No. 435 of 2007 on 29.4.2008 before the State Government with the request to grant sanc­tion for initiation of criminal proceedings in the court. In its report the agency had submitted charge-sheet against erring officers namely Sri Akhilesh Mehrotra, the then Deputy Inspector General of Police, Allahabad Region, Allahabad and Chair­man Selection Board and the members of the Selection Committee namely Sri Surendra Bahadur, the then Additional Superintendent of Police, Reserve Police Line, Sitapur, Sri Arun Kumar Gupta, the then Additional Superintendent of Po­lice, Siddharthnagar, Sri Mannaj Lal, the then Deputy Superintendent of Police, Allahabad and Mohd. Irfan Ansari, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Uttar Pradesh Police Headquarters, Allahabad. All these officers were found involved in the of­fence and the charge sheet was submitted under sections 419/420/467/468/469/471/120b/341, ipvc and section 7/12/13 prevention of corruption act. It is rel­evant to point out here that all these officers were involved in the malpractices relating to Etawah Recruitment Center (Third Recruitment) in the recruitment held in the year 2006.

    9. That the investigating agency submitted its report in case crime No. 430 of 2007 on 29.4.2008 before the State Government with the request to grant sanc­tion for initiation of criminal proceedings in the court. In its report the agency had submitted charge-sheet against erring officers namely Sri Daljeet Singh Chaudhary, the then Deputy Inspector General of Police; Kanpur Region, Kanpur and Chair­man Selection Board and the members Sri Mahendra Yadav, the then Superin­tendent of Police, Sitapur, Sri Ajit Kumar Sinha, the then Deputy Superintendent of Police, Faizabad, Sri Mansha Ram Gautam, the then Deputy Superintendent of Police, Aligarh and Sri Amarjeet Singh Shahi, the then Deputy Superintendent of Police, Shahjahanpur. All these officers were found involved in the offence and the charge-sheet was submitted under sections 467/468/471/120b, ipc and section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) prevention of corruption act. It is relevant to point out here that all these officers were involved in the malpractices relating to Kanpur Dehat Recruitment Center (Second Recruitment) in the recruitment held in the year 2006.

    10. That the investigating agency submitted its report in case crime No. 2243 of 2007 on 30.4.2008 before the State Government with the request to grant sanc­tion for initiation of criminal proceedings in the court. In its report the agency had submitted charge-sheet against erring officers, namely, Sri K. Satyanarayan, IPS, presently posted as Commandant 34th Bn. PAC Varanasi and Chairman Selec­tion Board and Sri Ram Bahadur Yadav, Additional Superintendent of Police, ISBF Chandauli, Varanasi, Sri Diwakar Kumar Additional Superintendent of Police, Mahoba, Sri Piyush Ranjan Srivastava, Deputy Superintendent of Police, District Kushinagar and Sri Akhlaq Ahmad, Deputy Superintendent of Police (Retired). All these officers were found involved in the offence and the charge-sheet was sub­mitted under sections 467/468/471/120b and section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) prevention of corruption act. It is relevant to point out here that all these officers were involved in the malpractices relating to Mainpuri Recruitment Center (First Recruitment) in the recruitment held in the year 2005.

    11. That the investigating agency submitted its report in case crime No. 1470 of 2007 on 30.4.2008 before the State Government with the request to grant sanc­tion for initiation of criminal proceedings in the court. In its report the agency had submitted charge-sheet against erring officers namely Sri Ramendra Vikram Singh IPS, Deputy Inspector General of Police and Chairman Selection Board, SriManoj Kumar Sonkar, Additional Superintendent of Police, Hardoi, Sri Om Prakash Yadav, Deputy Superintendent of Police Vigilance Organization, Lucknow, Sri Rameshwar Dayal Pathak, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Badaun, Sri Abdul Jabbar Khan, Deputy Superintendent of Police (Retired). All these officers were found involved in the offence and the charge-sheet was submitted under sections 467/468/471/120b, ipc and section 13(1 )(d) read with 13(2) prevention of corruption act. It is relevant to point out here that all these officers were involved in the malpractices relating to Moradabad Recruitment Center (Second Recruitment) in the recruit­ment held in the year 2006.

    12. That the investigating agency submitted its report in case crime No. 2244 of 2007 on 18.1.2008 before the State Government with the request to grant sanc­tion for initiation of criminal proceedings in the court. In its report the agency had submitted charge-sheet against erring officers namely Sri Mukul Goel IPS, Deputy Inspector General of Police, ITBP, New Delhi and Chairman Selection Board and the members of the Selection Board namely, Sri Shiv Sagar Singh, Additional Superintendent of Police, (R) Information Bureau, Moradabad, Sri Prahlad Singh Yadav, Deputy Superintendent of Police, PTC Moradabad, Sri Hafizurram, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Hardoi, Sri Sukhbir Singh, Deputy Superintendent of Police Lucknow. All these officers were found involved in the offence and the charge sheet was submitted under sections 467/468/471/120b, ipc and section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) prevention of corruption act. It is relevant to point out here that all these officers were involved in the malpractices relating to Mainpuri Recruitment Center (Third Recruitment) in the recruitment held in the year 2006.

    13. That in spite of the full knowledge of the fact that whole selection process involving recruitment on more than 18000 posts has been tainted with nepotism, favouritism and rampant corruption, the State Government has revoked the sus­pension orders of the erring officers and reinstated them on lucrative posts. This has been done by the State Government even on the face of the admission that these persons are guilty and also acceptance of guilt in writing by the official themselves.

    14. That ultimately the State Government made a formal request to respon­dent No.1 to get the investigation conducted by C.B.I, into all the cases regis­tered in different districts of Uttar Pradesh relating to the recruitment of con­stables of U.P. Police and U.P. PAC and different posts in Radio Wing of U.P. Police in the year 2005-06.The respondent No. 1, namely, Union of India vide order dated 21.4.2008 has formally refused to get the enquiry conducted by the C.B.I, on the pretext of non-availability of substantive manpower and resources. It further gives the reason that the agency is over burden and it is not feasible to get the investigation conducted of such a large number of cases. A true copy of the order dated 21.4.2008 is attached to the writ petition and marked as Annexure 2.

    15. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the Union of India and the State Government are hand in gloves with each other in shielding the erring officers and consequentially supporting the candidates who had entered into the services by adopting unfair means. The State Government has delayed in making the request of C.B.I, investigation to the respondent No.1 intentionally with a view to lighten the gravity of the matter and in turn the respondent No. 1 has shirked from its responsibility by refusing the enquiry on non-existing grounds. Thus, this writ petition.

    16. Learned counsel for the petitioners has also filed supplementary affidavit annexing therewith the relevant documents, which have been referred to and re­lied upon by the petitioners and the copies whereof could not be filed along with the writ petition. Learned counsel for the petitioners further submitted that this police recruitment scam at such a large scale and refusal by the respondents to investigate, particularly on the flimsy ground mentioned in the order deserves to be quashed and the direction be issued to respondent No. 2 to conduct the enquiry expeditiously. Learned counsel for the petitioners has relied upon a deci­sion in the case of State of Bihar and another v. Ranchl Zila Samta Party and another, J.T. 1996 (3) S.C. 751, wherein on a similar direction by the High Court in the case of Gwala Scam, the matter was taken up by the State Government to the Apex Court against the direction issued by the High Court.

    17. The main argument advanced by the State Government in the case of State of Bihar (supra), which has been repelled by the Apex Court by reason of Entry 80 of List I of the Seventh Schedule to the constitution and section 6 of the delhi special police act, 1946, without the consent of the appropriate State Gov­ernment no investigating agency other than the State police could investigate an offence committed in the State. The High Court while exercising power under article 226 of the constitution, should have kept in mind this limitation.

    18. On the basis of the aforesaid decision, it has been argued by learned counsel for the petitioners that the State Government itself should have investi­gated the matter and should not have requested the C.B.I, to investigate the matter, therefore refusal by the respondents to proceed with the investigation by C.B.I, cannot be called in question. In the present case, since the State Govern­ment itself had requested the respondents to get the matter investigated through C.B.I., therefore it is open to the respondents to say that since C.B.I, is over burden and with limited manpower, they cannot investigate this matter. This in fact according to learned counsel for the petitioners amounts to refusal of exer­cising power. The direction issued by the High Court for investigation by the C.B.I, to the scam has been upheld by the Apex Court in the case of State of Bihar (supra), which reads thus:

    ".................The parameters of the power of the High Court under article 226 of the constitution to direct an investigation by the C.B.I, though without the consent of the concerned State, is the subject matter of reference pend­ing consideration of a Constitution Bench of five Judges of this court. There­fore, the frontiers of the power of the High Court under Article 226 to give directions to the C.B.I, to investigate into offences without the State's con­sent, are already before this Court and shall be gone into."

    19. However, in the present case since the State Government itself has made a request for investigation by the C.B.I., therefore this objection of C.B.I, would not apply and this argument is not open to the respondents. From the above law laid down by the Apex Court it appears that the view taken by the respondent No. 2 not to proceed/depute the C.B.I, for investigation in this scam, the matter can­not be sustained.

    20. Learned counsel for the petitioners further relied upon a decision in the case of State of West Bengal and others v. Sampat Lal and others, A.I.R. 1985 S.C. 195. Relying upon the aforesaid decision in the case of State of West Ben­gal (supra), learned counsel for the petitioners contended that the order Annex-ure-'2' to the writ petition passed by the respondent No.2 deserves to be quashed and a direction be issued to the respondent No. 2 to conduct the investigation as requested by the State Government.

    21. On the other hand, the counsel for Union of India submitted that the power under the delhi police special establishment act are discretionary, the High Court should not thrust upon its direction to get the matter investigated through the agency of C.B.I., particularly when the matter is under investigation by the State Government. The counsel has agreed that since there is no dispute of the fact and further that the matter has to be decided on the basis of reasons given in the impugned order even the filling of the counter affidavit will not improve the case of the respondent as this court will not look into the files or noting or go into the statement made in the counter affidavit other than what is stated in the impugned order. The reasons given by the respondents to refuse to conduct the investigation through C.B.I, are justified, but the similar argument has been re­pelled in the case of State of West Bengal (supra), which reads thus:-

    "On June 9, 1983, an oral prayer was made on behalf of the State of West Bengal for staying operation of the orders and on the following day an appeal was preferred against the order of Borooah, J. and the appeal was placed before a Division Bench consisting of Mr. Justice Pyne and Mr. Justice S.C. Sen. Grievance was made on behalf of the State of West Bengal that Borooah, J. had made his order without giving any notice to it and without finding out if the investigation conducted by the police authorities under the law was not ad­equate, and as to whether the manner of investigation was such that it re­quired the Deputy Inspector General of the Central Bureau of Investigation at Calcutta to be appointed to enquire into the incident. At the appellate stage on behalf of the State Government materials were placed before the Court in support of its contention that adequate investigation had been undertaken a would be expected in the ordinary course over an incident of the type under consideration. Long arguments were advanced before the Division Bench and the two learned Judges devoted considerable attention to the matter and wrote out two separate and lengthy judgments-Pyne, J. held that:

    "I respectfully agree with the observations made by the Supreme Court in the facts and circumstances of the above case (Bhagwant Singh v. Commr. of Police, Delhi, (1983) 3 SCC 344: (AIR 1983 SC 826). I am also of the view that in the facts and circumstances of the instant case it would not be proper for me to speculate as to whether the unnatural death of the two boys was caused by suicide or murder. I am, however, very much concerned with the question whether the investigation into the cause of the unnatural death of the two boys by appellants is being conducted fairly and properly and after taking all materials, evidence and circumstances into consideration in accor­dance with law...........In the instant case the Deputy Inspector General, Cen­tral Bureau of Investigation is not called upon to exercise any power or to investigate into any matter under delhi special police establishment act or any other statute. In view of what has been stated hereinbefore and in the fact and circumstances of the case, I appoint Deputy Inspector General, Central Bureau of Investigation as the Special Officer in this case. The Special Officer will make the enquiry about the correctness of the facts, allegations and inferences contained in the reports of Secret Eye' dated 8th and 14th May, 1983, as well as those in the two letters of the respondents both dated 1st June, 1983, copies whereof are Annexures-'A' and 'B', respectively to the affidavit of Bappaditya Roy affirmed on 20th June, 1983 and in the reports affirmed on 20th June, 1983 and in the reports published in the two issues of Ananda Bazar Patrika dated May 12 and 18,1983.1, therefore direct Deputy Inspector General, Central Bureau of Investigation to make necessary en­quiry along the line aforesaid. For the purpose of making such enquiry and report Deputy Inspector General, Central Bureau of Investigation will be en­titled to take into consideration fresh evidence, oral or documentary, materi­als and statements, if any, offered to him. The report of the Deputy Inspector General, Central Bureau of Investigation will be submitted to the trial Court within three weeks from date. The police authorities of the State and the respondents will extend all possible help as required by the Deputy Inspector General, Central Bureau of Investigation in the matter of enquiry."

    22. The counsel for the respondent has also tried to raise the argument re­garding the locus of petitioners to file this writ petition.

    23. We have already stated the facts which shows that petitioners are unsuc­cessful candidates and are complainants regarding malpractices adopted in the impugned selection. We are therefore, of the opinion that locus of the petitioners cannot be questioned.

    24. Thus, we are of the opinion, particularly in the facts and circumstances of the case that the State Government itself has made a request to get the investi­gation conducted by the C.B.I, and the refusal by the respondent No. 2 to con­duct the investigation through C.B.I, cannot be sustained in law for the reasons stated in the impugned order and the order dated 21st April, 2008, Annexure-'2' to the writ petition deserves to be quashed and is hereby quashed.:

    25. In the result, the writ petition succeeds and is allowed. The order dated 21st April, 2008, Annexure-'2' to the writ petition is quashed. The respondent No. 1 and the C.B.I, are directed to investigate the matter as requested by the State Government vide order dated 4th February, 2008.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Amit Kumar Shukla and Others v. Union of India and Others
    (Jun 5, 2008)