Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Acts
  • Conditions of Service) Rules, 1964 thereinafter referred to as 'the Rules').
  • provisions of the rules. rule 2(e) defuses 'Post' as follows:2(e).
  • Act. 16 of the Constitution of India.
  • provisions of sub-rule (a) of rule 6,
  • provision of sub-rule (a) of rule 6,
  • rule 4(2) of the rules (rule 9
  • Rule 4(2)(a) of the Rules,
  • provisions of rule 9,
  • Sub-rule (a) of Rule 6,
  • 5, rule 4(2)(b)
  • rule 4(2)(a)
  • rule 4(2)
  • rule 2(e)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Acts
  • Conditions of Service) Rules, 1964 thereinafter referred to as 'the Rules').
  • provisions of the rules. rule 2(e) defuses 'Post' as follows:2(e).
  • Act. 16 of the Constitution of India.
  • provisions of sub-rule (a) of rule 6,
  • provision of sub-rule (a) of rule 6,
  • rule 4(2) of the rules (rule 9
  • Rule 4(2)(a) of the Rules,
  • provisions of rule 9,
  • Sub-rule (a) of Rule 6,
  • 5, rule 4(2)(b)
  • rule 4(2)(a)
  • rule 4(2)
  • rule 2(e)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Choudhary, S.N. Mishra, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners challenged the legality and validity of appointments made by respondent No.2 (the Speaker of the Bihar Legislative Assembly) to various posts in the Assembly. The appointments in issue occurred between 15.6.1990 and 1.11.1990 and included (initially described) 234 persons appointed to posts such as Assistant, Typist, Personal Assistant, Routine Clerk, Peon and others. Specific office orders appointing certain respondents (Nos. 6 to 17) were identified and annexed to the writ petition. The petitioners alleged that these appointments were made without advertisement, without holding any competitive test, and in contravention of the Bihar Vidhan Sabha (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 1964 ("the Rules"). They also alleged many appointees were related to members, officers or staff of the Assembly, and that some appointees were overage or underage.

Respondents 2 to 5 filed a counter-affidavit accepting basic facts but raising preliminary objections to maintainability (principally non-impleadment of all appointees), contending the Speaker had the power to appoint and relax age limits, and asserting that appointments were made after scrutiny and interview in exercise of powers under the Rules. The pleadings and an ensuing supplementary counter-affidavit (including a chart) showed that, in total, 285 persons were appointed during the period in question (191 vacancies filled plus 94 newly created posts), which the Court examined.

The petition sought quashing of the appointment orders and related appointment letters. The Court heard detailed submissions and finally delivered judgment quashing the appointments.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appointments of the persons made by the Speaker between 15.6.1990 and 1.11.1990 (initially described as 234, later shown as 285) without advertisement and without holding competitive examination were legal and valid under the Bihar Vidhan Sabha (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 1964 and Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
  2. Whether the writ petition was maintainable despite the fact that not all appointed persons were impleaded as respondents.
  3. Whether the Speaker could lawfully dispense with or relax mandatory procedural requirements (such as holding a competitive examination or prescribing minimum academic qualifications) on grounds of exigency or because the Speaker was going abroad.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The appointments of 234 persons (including respondents Nos. 6 to 17) were made without advertisement and without holding any competitive examination, contrary to the Rules and the notification issued under rule 4(2), and thus violated Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
  • No notice specifying requisite qualifications was published; petitioners who were qualified had no opportunity to apply.
  • The recruitment procedure followed by respondent No.2 was arbitrary, politically motivated and amounted to appointments made in a "hush-hush" manner favoring relatives of politicians and Assembly officers/staff.
  • Earlier appointments made by a predecessor Speaker (89 persons) had been cancelled for similar defects; respondent No.2 repeated the same flawed approach.
  • Counsel relied on multiple precedents to support the contention that statutory rules and prescribed procedures for recruitment must be followed and that appointments made by circumventing them are void.

Respondents' Arguments (Nos. 2 to 5)

  • The writ was not maintainable because all appointees affected by the challenge had not been impleaded as parties.
  • Petitioner No.1 himself was an appointee and therefore could not challenge the appointments.
  • The Speaker was empowered under the Rules to make appointments and to relax age limits; advertisements and written tests were not necessary where the authority reasonably adopted a different mode of recruitment.
  • The appointments were made after scrutiny of applications and oral interviews, as a response to emergent exigencies (the Speaker was going abroad and a long Assembly session was imminent), so a departure from normal procedure was justified.
  • Some earlier decisions (cited by respondents) supported the proposition that advertising in the press is not invariably essential for direct recruitment and that ad hoc or alternative procedures may be permissible in appropriate circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Krishna Yadav and Anr. (also cited as Krishan Yadav) The text as cited highlights selections motivated by extraneous considerations, systemic irregularities, and that such conduct may amount to fraud and violate fair selection norms. The Court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that appointments showing signs of arbitrariness/extraneous considerations cannot be sustained and to illustrate the gravity of improper appointment practices.
Vijay Kumar … v. The State of Bihar & Ors. (reported 1993 (1) P.L.J.R. 99) This case was cited by petitioners; the opinion does not set out in detail the specific principle from this report within the text. The Court noted it was among authorities relied upon by the petitioners but the judgment itself does not elaborate the particular rule extracted from this citation.
Birendra Prasad Singh and Ors. v. The State of Bihar and Ors. (1993 (1) P.L.J.R. 206) Cited by petitioners; the opinion does not explicate the particular rule or principle drawn from this citation. The case was listed among precedents relied on by petitioners; the Court did not separately analyze its ratio in the body of this opinion.
Probodh Verma and Ors. v. ... [1985] 1 S.C.R. 216 Cited by petitioners; the opinion does not state the specific principle referenced from this report in the text. The Court acknowledged the citation as part of petitioners' authorities but did not extract or elaborate a distinct application from it in this judgment.
K. Public Service Commission etc. v. Dr. Narinder Mohan and Ors. (A.I.R. 1984 S.C. 1808) — referred to as J. & K. Public Service Commission case Principle: Once statutory rules have been made for appointment, appointments must be made in accordance with those rules; executive power cannot be used to override or relax recruitment rules to regularise ad hoc/backdoor appointments. The Court relied on this authority to hold that the Speaker could not ignore or relax fundamental recruitment requirements (such as holding the competitive examination) mandated by the Rules/notification.
Shivaji Rao Nilangekar Patil v. ... [1987] 1 S.C.R. 458 Principle (as quoted): A private litigant's petition may assume public interest character where inquiry into the conduct of public institutions is necessary; court has duty to inquire in public interest. The Court relied on Paragraph 36 of this judgment to reject the maintainability objection based on non-impleadment of all appointees and to justify proceeding in public interest.
Ram Janam Singh v. ... (1994) ILLJ 901 SC Cited by petitioners in support of maintainability; the judgment does not set out the specific extract relied upon in this opinion. The Court noted this precedent in the context of representational/public interest litigation but did not recite a detailed proposition from it in the text beyond reliance.
Sardara Singh and Ors. v. ... (AIR 1991 S.C. 2248) Cited by respondents in support of the proposition that departures from formalities may be acceptable in certain circumstances; the opinion does not reproduce any detailed rule from it. The Court recorded that respondents relied upon this decision but reached a contrary conclusion on the facts because mandatory requirements in the notification had not been followed.
Daljit Singh Minhas and Ors. v. The State of Punjab and Ors. Principle (as quoted in the judgment): It is not an absolute constitutional requirement that direct recruitment must always be by press advertisement; however, the Court interpreted the rule to mean that some form of notice/means of inviting applicants is required. The Court relied on the cited observations to accept that press advertisement is not invariably essential, but used the decision to emphasize that some demonstrable notice is required — and found no evidence of any such notice in the instant case.
Bijay Kumar (referred to in the text) The opinion reproduces an observation used to illustrate that appointments in Bihar were often motivated by extraneous considerations; the precise citation context is limited in the text. The Court cited the passage to underscore systemic problems in appointments and to support its view that the instant large-scale appointments could not be justified as exigent or fair.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a structured manner:

  1. Maintainability: The preliminary objection that the writ was not maintainable because all appointees were not impleaded was rejected. The Court held that the petitioners had challenged the action of the Speaker (a public act) and had added some respondents in representative capacity; invoking public interest principles (citing Shivaji Rao Nilangekar Patil), the Court concluded it could inquire into the propriety of appointments notwithstanding non-impleadment of every appointee.
  2. Statutory framework and notification: The Court examined the Bihar Vidhan Sabha (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 1964, and a notification issued under rule 4(2) (Annexure-4, dated 22.11.1967) which specifically provided that appointments to Class III posts shall be made through competitive examination. The Court emphasized the distinct provisions: method of recruitment (rule 4), appointment authority (rule 6), qualification specification (rule 5), and the power to relax in exceptional cases (rule 10).
  3. Limits of discretion: The Court accepted that the Speaker may relax certain requirements (for example, rule 10 permits relaxation in exceptional cases and age relaxation was conceded) but held that the Speaker could not dispense with or alter fundamental and mandatory procedural requirements prescribed by the notification — specifically the requirement of a competitive examination and the prescribed academic qualifications. The Court drew on J. & K. Public Service Commission authority to underscore that once statutory rules are framed, appointments must conform to them and the executive cannot regularise ad hoc/backdoor appointments under the guise of general executive power.
  4. Evidence on record and prospect of exigency: The Court considered the factual matrix including the supplementary counter-affidavit chart showing total sanctioned strength, number of vacancies, and appointments. The chart indicated 603 sanctioned posts, 191 vacancies, appointments of 191 against these and creation of 94 new posts—yielding 285 appointees in the period. The Court found that appointments on such a large scale could not reasonably be justified as being made to meet emergent exigencies or because the Speaker was going abroad.
  5. Failure to give notice/advertise and absence of competitive test: The respondents asserted that a notice was exhibited on the Assembly notice board and that applications and interviews occurred. The Court observed that no copy or evidence of any such notice or publication was produced. While recognizing the Daljit Singh Minhas authority that press advertisement is not always mandatory, the Court held that some demonstrable method of notice or invitation to applicants must exist; that was absent on the record.
  6. Inference of arbitrariness: Given (a) the admitted absence of competitive examinations where the notification mandated them, (b) absence of evidence of notice or advertisement, and (c) the scale and pattern of appointments (including allegations of relations of politicians/staff receiving appointments), the Court drew the inference that the appointments were made in a manner contrary to the Rules and to the equality mandate of Articles 14 and 16.
  7. Reliance on precedents: The Court relied on several decisions (including J. & K. Public Service Commission, Krishna Yadav, Daljit Singh Minhas and others) to support the legal propositions that statutory recruitment rules must be followed, that appointments made outside prescribed procedures are vulnerable to challenge, and that facts indicative of extraneous considerations cannot be ignored.
  8. Conclusion of analysis: On the combined legal and factual matrix, the Court concluded that the appointments (285 persons as shown on the chart, inclusive of those specifically challenged) were made without compliance with mandatory requirements and were therefore void ab initio.

Holding and Implications

Final Holding: The writ petition is allowed and the appointments of 285 persons (including those contained in Annexures‑2 series) made by respondent No.2 (the Speaker) are quashed as void ab initio.

Consequences and immediate implications:

  • The impugned appointment orders (285 appointments made in the period under challenge) are declared void and are quashed.
  • There shall be no order as to costs in the matter.
  • The Court observed that respondent Nos. 2 to 5, if so advised, may take steps to fill up the vacancies afresh in accordance with law (i.e., following the Rules and any applicable notification).
  • The opinion does not announce a novel legal doctrine; it applies existing principles that once statutory rules for recruitment exist, appointments must conform to them. The judgment's direct effect is to invalidate the specific appointments challenged and to require any future recruitment to follow the prescribed procedure. The Court did not indicate that it was establishing a broader new precedent beyond application of those established principles to the facts before it.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to and based on the material contained in the provided opinion. No information not present in the opinion has been added.

    Harendra Kumar Pandey And Ors. v. State Of Bihar And Ors.

    JUDGMENT

    Choudhary, S.N. Mishra, J.

    1. In this writ application, the petitioners have questioned the legality/validity of the appointments of 234 persons on various posts by respondent No.2, namely, the Speaker of the Bihar Legislative Assembly in between 15.6.1990 and 1.11.1990 and for quashing the Office Order No.l Accounts 15/90-39, Vidhan Sabha, Patna, dated 14.9.1990 by which respondents Nos. 6 to 10 were appointed as Assistants in the Accounts Section of the Bihar Legislative Assembly, Patna, (hereinafter referred to as 'the Assembly') including the letters of appointment of Respondent Nos. 11 to 17, dated 15.11.1990. Copies of he said orders of appointment are made Annexure-2 series to this writ application.

    2. In order to appreciate the controversies and submissions raised on behalf of respective parties, It is necessary to mention some relevant faces and the case of the respective parties on the basis of the pleadings. The petitioners are duly qualified for the posts, which were filled up by respondent No.2 in between the aforesaid period. According to the petitioner Nos. 2, 3 and 4, they could not apply for the post of Assistant, Typist, Routine Clerk, Peon etc. in the Bihar Vidhan Sabha nor applications were invited from the prospective candidates through any Employment Exchange. Respondent Nos. 6 to 17 were appointed on 14.9.1990 and 15.9.1990 and he appointment letters were issued accordingly, as per Annexure-2 series, as stated above. That apart, 234 persons were appointed on various posts of Assistant, Typist Hindi Research Assistant, Personal Assistant, Hindi Experts, Security Guard, Darwan, Daftary, Peon and Sweeper, by the Speaker in between the period from 15.6.90 to 1.11.1990 through different appointment letters. All he aforesaid 234 persons including respondent Nos. 6 to 17 were appointment without any advertisement and/or without having held any competitive test. The minimum academic qualification required for appointment to the post of Assistant in the Assembly is a Bachelor's Degree in Arts, Science and Commerce, for the post of Personal Assistant, Bachelor's Degree in the same faculties having knowledge of shorthand and typing with the minimum speed of 80 to 120 words per minute and for the post of Typist, Intermediate having knowledge of typing with the minimum speed of 30 words per minute and for Routine Clerk and Peon, Matriculation and Middle pass, respectively, Similarly, the age limit for the aforesaid posts is 18 to 30 years. The petitioners claim to be duly qualified and eligible for appointment to the posts of Assistant, Personal Assistant and Typist. It has also been alleged that out of 234 persons, who have been appointed in the Assembly on different posts, 20 persons are overage and one person is minor and most of the persons are sons, brothers, daughters-in-law, daughters and relations of the Officers and employees of the Assembly and he Members of the Assembly, Lastly, it has been stated that while making such appointments, the Bihar Legislative Council published advertisement in the Daily Newspaper 'Nav Bharat Times', on 1.11.90; whereas respondents 1 to 5 did not follow the prescribed procedure while making such appointments.

    3. A counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of respondents 2 to 5 wherefrom it appears that they have not denied the aforesaid basic facts alleged by the petitioners in this writ application. What has been alleged, inter alia , is that this writ application is not maintainable in absence of the aforesaid 234 persons, who have not been impleaded as party respondents in this writ application. It is further alleged that Petitioner No.1 was appointed in the Assembly and, as such, he cannot question the validity of such appointments. It is further alleged that the authority has power to condone the age-limit. It is also alleged that all the appointments were made by respondent No.2 after assessing the merit of the respective candidates through the interview. It is also alleged that the Speaker is fully empowered to make such appointments under the Bihar Vidhan Sabha (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 1964 thereinafter referred to as 'the Rules'). So far as Petitioner Nos. 2 to 4 are concerned, their case was also considered by respondent Nos. 2 to 5, but they were not found fit for appointment to the said posts. This statement in the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of respondents 2 to 5 has been controverted by the petitioners in their rejoinder alleging that the petitioners had neither applied for the post at any point of time nor did they join the post and, as such, die question of consideration of their case does not arise at all. Had they ever applied for appointment to the said posts, respondent Nos. 2 to 5 must have produced their applications even at the time of final hearing of this writ application.

    4. On the basis of the aforesaid pleadings, learned Counsel, appearing on behalf of the petitioners, submitted that the appointments of 234 persons including respondents 6 to 17 made by respondent No, 2 without making advertisement and/or holding any test, as required under he Rules and violative of articles 14 and 16 of the constitution, He further submitted that respondent No.2 completely ignored the provisions of the Rules inasmuch as, without inviting applications from the qualified persons like the petitioners, appointed 234 persons, and, as such, the appointments of the aforesaid persons are wholly illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction. learned Counsel further submitted that no notice whatsoever specifying the requisite qualification of the candidates for filling up the aforesaid posts was published anywhere at any point of time by respondents 1 to 5 and no examination for testing the competitive merit of the individual competitors was held before appointing the aforesaid 234 persons. This procedure according to the learned Counsel adopted by respondent No.2 is wholly unknown and contrary to the provisions laid down in the Rules while making such appointments, which has violated the equality Clause enshrined under articles 14 and 16 of the constitution of india, and, thus tie appointments of the aforesaid 234 persons including respondents 6 to 17 are as initio void. In this connection, learned Counsel also submitted that earlier 89 persons were appointed on the posts of Assistant, Typist and Routine Clerk by the then Speaker, but such appointments were cancelled by the successor Speaker on the ground that those appointments had been made directly without advertisement and/or without following the procedures prescribed under the Rules. That order of the Speaker cancelling previous appointments was brought under challenge before this High Court in C.WJ.C. No. 7953 of 1989 disposed of on 6.9.1990 wherein, a counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of the Speaker of the Assembly that those appointments had been made by the then Speaker without any advertisement. Ultimately, the order of cancellation of the appointments of 89 persons made by his predecessor Speaker was confirmed by this Court. learned Counsel, appearing on behalf of the petitioners, accordingly, submitted that respondent No.2 has adopted the same arbitrary procedure while making appointments under challenge in the present writ application without advertisement and without holding any examination for testing the competitive merit of the individual candidates and, therefore, it was not open for the respondents 2 to 5 to make such appointments without following the procedures prescribed under the Rules. learned Counsel, however, submitted that all the 234 appointments including the appointment of respondents 6 to 17 were made purely on political consideration as the appointees are related to the Officers, employees and the Members of the Assembly. It was further alleged that in exercise of the power under rule 4(2) of the rules, a notification was issued by the Assembly wherein it has been categorically stated that the appointment on he posts of Assistant shall be made through the competitive examination, but admittedly in the instant case, no such examination and/or interview was ever held, which is violative of articles 14 and 16 of the constitution as also in contravention of the mandatory provisions mentioned in the aforesaid notification which was issued in exercise of power under rule 4(2) of the rules (rule 9 is a mistake for rule 4(2) of he rules under which the aforesaid notification was issued by the Assembly). The submissions made by the learned Counsel for the petitioners may now be summarised as follows:

    (i) The entire appointments of 234 persons including respondents 6 to 17 in between the period 15.6.90 and 1.11.1990 are in contravention of the mandatory . provisions of the Rules and the notification issued thereunder:

    (ii) No advertisement or any kind of notice was ever issued inviting applications from the prospective candidates nor the names were called from the Employment Exchange and, therefore, such appointments are wholly vitiated;

    (iii) No competitive examination and/or test as envisaged under the aforesaid Rules has ever been held for filling up such posts, and

    (iv) The entire appointments were made purely on political consideration as all the persons appointed on he different posts are closely related to the politicians and the officers and staff of the Assembly and, as such, their appointments cannot be held to be valid.

    Learned Counsel, in support of his contention, has relied upon various decisions, namely, Krishna Yadav and Anr. v. (1995)IILLJ77SC , Vijay Kumar… v. The State Of Bihar & Ors.…, reported in 1993 (1) P.L.J.R. 99, Birendra Prasad Singh and Ors. v. The State of Bihar and Ors. reported in 1993 (1) P.LJ.R. 206, Probodh Verma and Ors. etc., v. [1985]1SCR216 , J and K. Public Service Commission etc. v. Dr. Narinder Mohan and Ors. etc. reported in A.I.R. 1984 S C 1808, Shivaji Rao Nilangekar Patil v. [1987]1SCR458 and Ram Janam Singh v. (1994)ILLJ901SC .

    5. In opposition to the aforesaid submissions, learned Counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 to 5, had argued that this writ application is not maintainable in absence of the persons whose appointments have been challenged. learned Counsel next submitted that the Petitioner No.1 has been appointed by the respondent No.2, and, as such, he cannot challenge the appointments made by respondent No.2. According to the learned Counsel, the Speaker is fully competent under the Rules to make appointments and in making such appointments, advertisements and/or written test are not necessary. According to the learned Counsel, all appointments have been made strictly in conformity with the Rules and hence, the same cannot be challenged in the courts of law. The last submission of the learned Counsel is that all the appointments have been made in order to meet the emergent exigencies as respondent No.2, the Speaker, was going abroad and the long Session of the Assembly .was to commence soon. In that situation, respondent No.2, the Speaker was well within his jurisdiction to relax the provision of he notification made under he Rules, and accordingly, while going abroad, it was not possible for the Speaker to conduct the Assembly Session in absence of sufficient number of staff and, therefore, he made the aforesaid appointments after scrutinising the applications received from the various candidates and taking interview, which cannot be said to be arbitrary and/or in contravention of the Rules. While developing his argument, learned Counsel submitted that the advertisements of the vacancies for appointments on such posts are not necessary if reasonably the authority adopt the mode and method of recruitment, which is by and large just and fair. Then in that event, this Court cannot interfere with the appointments merely on the ground of some hyper-technical infraction. learned Counsel further submitted that respondent No.2, namely, the Speaker, had made appointments of those persons, who had applied for the same came to him, and due to the urgent need of the staff in the Assembly, and, particularly, when he was going out of the country and in view of the ensuing long session, filled up the posts and in such a situation there had been unavoidable departure from the observance of the normal rules. The learned Counsel, in support of his connection, has relied upon two decisions, namely, Sardara Singh and Ors. etc. v. AIR1991SC2248 , and Daljit Singh Minhas and Ors. The State of Punjab and Ors. reported in .

    6. Before I proceed to examine the respective submissions of the parties, 1 feel it worthwhile to quote the relevant provisions of the rules. rule 2(e) defuses 'Post' as follows:

    2(e). 'Post' means a post in the Secretariat and a post shall be deemed to' be a ' pout in Class I, Class II, Class III or Class IV, according as such post is specified as Class II, Class 111 or Class IV, . as the case may be in the Second Schedule ;

    XX XX XX .

    4. Method of Recruitment.--(1) Subject to the provision of Sub-rule (a) of Rule 6, recruitment to a post or class of posts may be made by one of the following methods, namely:

    (a) and (b) XX XX

    (c) by direct recruitment.

    (2) Subject to the provisions of Sub-rule (a) of Rule 6, the Speaker may, by order, from time to time:

    (a) specify the method or methods by which a post or class of pose may be filled:

    5. Qualifications for recruitment, --Subject to the provisos of Sub-rule (a) of Rule 6, the qualifications for recruitment to any post or class of posts shall be such as Speaker may, from time to time, by general or special order, specify.

    6. Appointing Authority.--(a) The appointment to the post of Secretary or Join Secretary shall be made by the Governor in consultation with the Speaker amongst persons serving in the Bihar Superior Judicial Service.

    (b) Appointment to all other posts shall be made by the Speaker:

    Provided that the Speaker may, by general of special order delegate to the Secretary or any other officer of the Secretariat his power to make appointment to any post or class of posts in Class III or Class IV as may be specified in such order.

    7. XX XX XX

    8. XX XX XX

    9. Other Conditions of Services.--In respect of other matters regulating the conditions of service of officers for which no specific provision has been made in these rules, officers shall be governed by such rules, order or directions as are applicable to the officers of the corresponding rank in he Civil Secretariat of the State Government, subject to such modifications, variations or exceptions, if any, in such rules as the Speaker may, after consultation with the Finance Department, by order, from time to time, specify.

    Explanation.--For the purposes of this rule and the preceding rule the Speaker may, after consultation with the Finance Department, by order, specify the posts in the Civil Secretariat which shall correspond to the post in this Secretariat.

    10. Relaxation in exceptional cases.--Where the Speaker is satisfied that the operation of any rule or provision in the matter of the conditions of service of an officer causes undue hardship in any particular case, the Speaker may, after consultation with the Finance Department, by order, dispense with or relax the requirements of that rule or provision to such conditions as may be considered necessary for dealing with the case in a just and equitable manner.

    11. to 14. XX XX XX

    15. Disciplinary action against an officer on deputation to the Secretariat.--If in the case of an officer on deputation to the Secretariat, and without prejudice to the provisions of the foregoing rules, the Speaker or the Secretary or any other officer, as the case may be, is of opinion that any of the penalties referred to in Rule 13 should be imposed upon the said officer, his services shall be replaced at fee disposal of the lending authority and the relevant papers connected with the inquiry, if any held, shall also be seat to that authority. Final orders in the disciplinary matter shall be passed by lending authority which shall forward a copy thereof to the Secretariat.

    16. to 19. XX XX XX

    20. Residuary powers.--Subject to the provisions of rule 9, all matters not % specifically provided for in these rules, whether incidental or ancillary to the provisions of these rules or otherwise, shall be regulated in accordance with such orders as the Speaker may, from time to time, make.

    7. In reply to the submission that the writ application is not maintainable in absence of the 234 persons, who were appointed by respondent No.2, learned Counsel for the petitioners, firstly, submitted that this writ application has been filed adding respondent Nos. 6 to 17 in the representative capacity and, as such, it is not necessary to implead all those persons, who have been illegally appointed, as party-respondents in this writ application. Secondly, it was submitted that the petitioners have not sought any relief against any individual, but they have sought intervention of this Court to declare the actions of the respondent No.2, namely, the Speaker, as arbitrary and without jurisdiction and, as such, the petitioners are not required to implead all the persons, who have been appointed even though they may be affected by the result of this writ application. He submitted that if anyone is going to be affected by the verdict of this Court, he or they can challenge the verdict of this Court in an appropriate proceeding. learned Counsel, in support of his contention, relief upon the decision in Ram Janam Singh (supra) and Prabodh Verma and Ors. etc. etc. (supra). It is true that all the persons, who have been appointed, have not been made party-respondents in this writ application because of the reasons, firstly, that their whereabouts and parentage are not known to the petitioners, as they have not been appointed through the prescribed procedure and, secondly, that in the facts and circumstances of this case, it is not either necessary for the petitioners to implead those persons as party-respondents, who have been appointed during the aforesaid period by respondent No.2. Since, however, the matter has been brought to the notice of this Court, this Court irrespective to the fact whether those appointees have been impleaded as party-respondents in this writ application or not, can very well examine the propriety of the orders making appointments on different posts in Government/public office. In an almost identical situation, in Shivaji Rao Nilangekar Patil's case (supra), their Lordships of the Supreme Court have observed in Paragraph 36 of the judgment as follows:

    36. The allegations made in the petition disclose a lamentable state of affairs in one of the Premier Universities of India. The petitioner might have moved in his private interest but enquiry into the conduct of he examiners of the Bombay University in one of the highest medical degrees was a matter of public interest. Such state of affairs having been brought to the notice of the court, it was the duty of court to the public that the truth and the validity of the allegations made be inquired into. It was in furtherance of public interest that an enquiry into the state of affairs of public institution becomes necessary and private litigation assumes the character of public interest litigation and such an enquiry cannot be avoided. If it is necessary and essential for the administration of justice.

    Accordingly, the preliminary objection as to the maintainability of this writ application raised by the learned Counsel for the respondents is rejected.

    8. It is now a well settled principle of law that once the Rules have been framed for appointment on the different posts, that have to be strictly followed. In this connection, reference may be made to the notification, dated the 22nd of November, 1967, as contained in Annexure-4 to this writ application, which, has been issued in exercise of the power conferred under rule 4(2) of the rules, which specifically provides that the appointments 10 Class III posts shall be made through competitive examination. Admittedly, in the instant case, no examination whatsoever has ever been held before making the aforesaid appointments.

    9. According to the learned Counsel for respondents 2 to 5, rule 4(2)(b) empowers the Speaker to make appointments in the Assembly and, accordingly, respondent No.2 the Speaker, has made 234 appointments after scrutinising the applications and taking oral interview. The same cannot be interfered with. The learned Counsel further relied upon rule 10 of the rules and submitted that in the given situation, the Speaker can relax the provision of the Rules, since he was going abroad and in order to ensure smooth functioning of the Assembly, the Speaker filled up the vacant posts and in that unavoidable situation, the usual rules of procedure have been relaxed. The submission of the learned Counsel for respondents Nos. 2 to 5 cannot be accepted for the simple reason that once the Rules prescribe the procedure that cannot be relaxed and/or overlooked. As has been stated above, the notification has been issued in exercise of the power conferred under the Rules, which categorically fixes the qualification, age and the procedure for appointments to the different posts. One of such procedure is that appointments to Class ' III posts shall be mace through the competitive examination. Admittedly, that has not been done in this case. Therefore, in my considered view, the procedure prescribed under the Rules cannot be subsequently altered and appointments cannot be made through backdoor. It is true that the Speaker can relax the age-limit in a suitable case, but cannot alter the academic qualification fixed for appointment to such posts and also the fundamental requirement of the examination fixed under the notification as well as holding of the competitive examination in order to judge the comparative merit of the individual candidates. The Supreme Court in J. and K. Public Service Commission's case (supra) has held as follows:

    Existence of Statutory Rules is not a condition precedent to appoint an eligible and fit person to a post. The executive power is co-extensive with legislative power of the State and under Article 162, the State can create civil posts and fill them according to executive instructions consistent with articles 14 and 16 of he constitution. It is settled law that once statutory rules have been made, the appointment shall be only in accordance with the rules.

    XX XX XX .

    No express power was conferred and, in fact, cannot be conferred to relax he rules of recruitment. Having made he rules, the executive cannot fall back upon its general power under Article 162 to regularise he Ad hoc appointments under the Rules.

    Backdoor Ad hoc appointments at the behest of power, source or otherwise and recruitment according to rules are mutually antagonistic and strange bed partners. They cannot co-exist in the same sheath. The former is in negation of fair play, the latter are the products of order and regularity. Every eligible person no necessarily be appointed to a post of office under the Sate, selection according to rules by a properly constituted commission and fitment for appointment assures fairness in selection and inhibits arbitrariness in appointments.

    If, therefore, the notification issued in exercise of the power conferred under the Rules prescribes that the appointment shall be made through the competitive examination, the appointments made without holding such examination, and in some cases even persons do not fulfill the minimum requirement as envisaged in the notification, in my view, are violative of articles 14 and 16 of the constitution and, thus, the appointments of 234 persons including respondent Nos. 6 to 17 dehors the Rules and, accordingly, cannot be held to be valid appointments. In this case, admittedly, no advertisement and/or notice even worth the name, for the aforesaid appointments has at all be published or exhibited. The contention of the learned Counsel for the petitioners that had there been an advertisement issued/published for appointments to the aforesaid posts, petitioner Nos. 2 to 4, being properly qualified, must have applied for the same, but in absence of such advertisement and/or publication of notice, they could not apply, though they fulfilled the requisite qualification for appointment o the different posts in Class III. learned Counsel for the respondent Nos.2 to 5, on the other hand, submitted that for appointment to public posts, in every case, advertisement is not necessary. He further submitted that a notice to that effect was exhibited on the Notice Board of the Assembly office and in pursuance thereof, applications were made and after scrutinising the same, respondent No.2 namely, the Speaker, appointed suitable candidates out of those applicants to the different posts on the basis of the interview held by him. In support of his contention, learned Counsel relied upon the decision in the case of Daljit Singh Minhas (supra). In that case, the constitutional validity of the Sate Government's notification authorising regularisation of services of the teachers appointed on Ad hoc basis, if they satisfied he conditions specified therein, was the subject-matter of challenge wherein different questions were raised including the appointment as being not in accordance with laws and the procedures prescribed under the rules. In that case, while interpreting rule 2(e) of the punjab educational service class hi school cadre rules, 1955, their Lordships have held as follows :

    11. I would therefore, hold on principle that it is hot the requirement of the Constitution under Article 16 that for direct recruitment to an office under the State, there must be an advertisement in the public press, so as to reach every conceivable candidate within the country. Indeed, such a requirement appears to me as both doctrinaire and also impossible of actual implementation. Nor do I find anything in the particular rules, which are under consideration which may warrant a similar requirement.

    It is true that in all cases, the advertisement through press is not essential, but for the purpose of appointment on public posts, some sort of notice must be issued/published in order to invite applications from suitable candidates. In this case though it was submitted by the learned Counsel for respondents 2 to 5 that a notice was published on the Notice Board of the Assembly office, but neither a copy of any such notice nor any sort of notice inviting application has been produced before this Court except the oral submission made in this behalf in course of arguments that such a notice was exhibited on the Notice Board of the Assembly office. The decisions, which have been relied upon by the learned Counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 to 5 will not help him for simple reason that their Lordships, while interpreting rule 2(e) of the aforesaid rules have held as follows:

    Therefore, cm the particular language of rule 2(e) as also the general import of the rules, there seems to be nothing to warrant that direct appointments here necessarily require a resort to the public a large and, therefore, an advertisement in the press in resorting to this source of recruitment either.

    10. The next submission of the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners was that the appointments were made by respondent No.2 namely, the Speaker, not in accordance with the Rules, but on political considerations. This submission on behalf of the petitioners has to be considered in the backgrounds, as mentioned above. As has been stated above, no advertisement and/or notice was ever published nor any competitive examination was ever held in terms of the notification made under the Rules, the only reasonable inference would be that such appointments on large scale were made in a hush-hush manner only to get the near and dear ones of the politicians as well as the relation of the officers and staff of the Assembly. On the other hand, learned Counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 to 5 submitted that in order to meet the emergent situation, the provisions of the Rules have been unavoidably relaxed. In course of arguments, I wanted to ascertain the total sanctioned strength of Class III and Class IV employees of the Assembly including the vacant posts and the number of appointments made during the period in question by respondent No. 2. By a supplementary counter-affidavit enclosing a chart therewith showing the total sanctioned posts including the total sanctioned vacant posts and the appointments made against such posts, the information has been furnished. The Chart shows the total strength of different Class III and Class IV posts numbering 603; number of vacant posts shown as 191 and the appointments made as 191, it is also mentioned in the Chart that as many as 94 posts were newly created, meaning thereby 191+94 = 285 persons were appointed during the aforesaid period although the petitioners have, no doubt, stated that apart from 234 persons including respondent Nos. 6 to 17, some other persons have also been appointed. Such a submission has not been denied by the respondent Nos. 2 to 5. From the Chart furnished annexed with the supplementary counter-affidavit, it is almost clear that 285 persons have been appointed by respondent No. 2 during the aforesaid period. Appointments in such a large scale, in my view, cannot be held to have been made to meet the emergent situation. Obviously, therefore, the connection of the learned Counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 to 5 is no acceptable that the appointments were made in order to ensure smooth functioning of he Assembly in absence of respondent-No. 2, the Speaker. this Court, while dealing with such a question, has held in the case of Bijay Kumar (supra) as follows:

    20. this Court, times without number, have pointed out that appointments in the State of Bihar are made either for monetary consideration or for other extraneous consideration. Frequently, appointments are made in violation of the recruitment rules and/or guidelines given by the State from time to time. Even the reservation policies are not followed in such cases. Taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of this case, we are of the view that the appointment of the petitioner has been made in a hush-hush manner and in violation of he recruitment rules as also Act. 16 of the Constitution of India.

    11. Learned Counsel for the respondents 2 to 5, with reference to the various provisions of the Rules quoted above, submitted that the Speaker, respondent No.2 while making appointments on different posts, has followed the procedure prescribed in rule 4(2)(a) of the rules. He also relied upon rules 15 and 20 of the rules and submitted that in the given situation, the Speaker is fully empowered to exercise his discretion in such matters. The submission of the learned Counsel seems to be misconceived inasmuch as these rules do not, in any way, confer power on the Speaker to make appointments in such a large scale without following the normal procedure, as has been stated above, in exercise of his power. Under rule 4(2)(a) of the Rules, the aforesaid notification was issued wherein a definite procedure for appointment to Class HI posts has been laid down, which has, admittedly been not followed. Therefore, in that view of the matter, it cannot be said that the respondent No. 2, the Speaker has followed the procedures in making the aforesaid appointments. In the backgrounds of this case, it is not open for the respondents 2 to 5 to say that the appointments, aforesaid, were made due to exigencies of the situation as a result of which the normal rules of procedure have not been followed. As has been stated above, similar appointments had been made by the then Speaker of die Assembly without making any advertisement and without holding competitive examination, which had been cancelled by his successor-in-office only on the ground that the normal rules of procedure in making those appointments had not been followed and in that situation, the appointments of 89 persons to the posts of Assistant, Typist and Routine Clerk had been cancelled. The aforesaid order of cancellation was challenged before this Court wherein a counter-affidavit was filed on behalf of the Speaker stating, inter alia, that the then Speaker had appointed those persons on different posts without making any advertisement and/or following the provisions of the rules and, ultimately, on the pleadings of the parties, this Court upheld the order of cancellation, In the facts and circumstances of this case, it is highly unfortunate and regrettable that the holder 'of a high public office has completely forgotten his responsibilities while discharging the statutory duties entrusted to him. The entire system of appointments in the instant case, in my considered view, is wholly illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction, in the case of Krishan Yadav and Anr. (supra), their Lordships of the Supreme Court, while dealing with somewhat a similar question, have held as follows:

    18. It may not be too much to draw an inference that all was motivated by extraneous considerations. Otherwise, how does not account for selection without interview, fake and ghost interview, tampering with he final records, fabricating documents, forgery? Each of this would attract the penal provisions of Indian Penal Code. They have been done with impunity.

    19. The sorry does not end here. From out of the 'selection list' secret communicates have been sent to the candidates. Selections were made without medical test or verification of antecedents.

    20. It is highly regrettable that the holders of public offices both big and small have forgotten that the offices entrusted to them are sacred trusts, Such offices are mean for use and not abuse. From a Minister to a mental, everyone has been dishonest to gain undue advantages. The whole examination and die interview have turned out to be farcical exhibiting base character of those who have been responsible for this sordid episode. It shocks our conscience to come across such a systematic fraud. It is somewhat surprising the High Court should have taken the path of least resistance stating in view of he destruction of records it was helpless. It should have helped itself. Law is not that powerless.

    In the facts and circumstances of this case particularly when the basic facts have not been denied by the respondents, I do not feel it necessary to deal with the other cases cited by the learned Counsel for the petitioners.

    12. After going through the pleadings of the respective parties and after having heard the submissions of the learned Counsel appearing on their behalf in great details, I find that the respondent No. 2, the Speaker, has made the appointments of 285 persons including those of the respondent Nos. 6 to 17 without complying with the requirement of law as also in violation of the constitutional mandate enshrined in articles 14 and of the constitution of india. Thus, such appointments made by respondent No.2, the Speaker, is as initio void and, as such, cannot be sustained and are, accordingly, liable to be quashed.

    13. In the result, this writ application is allowed and the orders of appointments of 285 persons including made by the respondent No. 2, the Speaker of the Assembly, as contained in Annexures-2 Series are hereby quashed being declared as void as initio, but in the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

    Before, however, parting with this judgment, I must observe that the respondent Nos. 2 to 5, if so advised, may now take steps to fill up the vacancies on various posts afresh in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harendra Kumar Pandey And Ors. v. State Of Bihar And Ors.
    (Jan 13, 1995)