Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of U.P. Intermediate Education Act., 1921
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of U.P. Intermediate Education Act., 1921
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — S. R. Singh, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from two writ petitions challenging an order dated 25.11.1995 of the Deputy Director of Education, 1st Region, Meerut, which purportedly complied with this Court's judgment dated 11.1.1995 in writ petition No. 903 of 1995. The petitions concern elections and the Scheme of Administration of Janta Inter College, Bhopa, Muzaffarnagar, an institution recognised under the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921 ("the Act").

Key facts drawn from the opinion:

  • The college is governed by an approved Scheme of Administration under Section 16-A of the Act (including the IIIrd Schedule). The Scheme provided for a three-year term for the committee of management and allowed office-bearers to continue for one month after the three-year term; if no new committee were constituted within that period, a Prabandh Sanchalak appointed by the Regional Deputy Director of Education would take over.
  • The committee constituted after elections held on 24.3.1991 had its term end on 26.3.1994. That committee initiated a new election process (nomination date fixed 17.4.1994 and poll on 24.4.1994) but no nominations were received on 17.4.1994, and late nominations were rejected by the Election Officer.
  • Due to these events, and without appointment of a Prabandh Sanchalak, the outgoing committee continued to manage the college and the District Inspector of Schools allowed a revised election schedule; the election was held on 10.7.1994 and was observed by officials.
  • One petition (referred to as PI in the judgment) challenged validity of the committee formed on 10.7.1994; the other petition (P2) asked whether the Scheme had been validly amended by a resolution dated 21.3.1994 purportedly passed by the outgoing committee in compliance with directions in a letter dated 4.2.1994 from the Regional Deputy Director of Education.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Scheme of Administration could be amended by a committee resolution dated 21.3.1994 without the prior approval of the Director of Education, i.e., whether the purported amendment (extending the period within which a new committee could be constituted) was effective.
  2. Whether the election held on 10.7.1994 — organised and conducted by the outgoing committee after its three-year term had expired — is invalid and the resulting committee liable to be set aside.
  3. Whether a failure to constitute a new committee within the prescribed period (three years plus one month under the Scheme) rendered the outgoing committee's acts (including calling and conducting elections) void or whether they could be validated under principles such as the de facto doctrine or on the basis that the Scheme's timing provisions are directory.

Arguments of the Parties

PI (petitioner in Writ Petition No. 36146 of 1995) — represented by Sri V.M. Zaidi

  • Contended that the outgoing committee had no authority to hold elections after the expiry of its term and that the committee constituted on 10.7.1994 (resulting from that election) is invalid.
  • Argued that the meeting of the general body on 10.7.1994 was called by office-bearers whose terms had expired, therefore actions taken were invalid.
  • Maintained that the purported amendment to the Scheme (extending the period) was not effective because it was never approved by the Director of Education.

P2 (petitioner in Writ Petition No. 2931 of 1996) — represented by Sri R.N. Singh

  • Contended that the outgoing committee had authority to organise and hold elections within three years and six months of its term pursuant to the Scheme as allegedly amended by resolution dated 21.3.1994 in compliance with the Regional Deputy Director's letter dated 4.2.1994.
  • Relied on the proposed amendment to the Scheme to justify the election conducted on 10.7.1994.

Rejoinder

  • Sri V.M. Zaidi replied that the proposed amendment (resolution dated 21.3.1994) neither had the assent of the Director of Education nor was it ever sent to or approved by the Director; therefore the Scheme was not actually amended and the extended period was not effective.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chetram Vashist v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi, AIR 1981 SC 653 Where a provision fixes a time within which a public officer or authority has to act, it generally means the statute considers it reasonable for the officer or authority to act within such period (i.e., time prescriptions may be directory rather than mandatory). The Court relied on this authority to support the view that the Scheme's time-limit for constituting a new committee (three years plus one month) was of a directory character and did not automatically invalidate actions taken after expiry when the election process had started and administrative actions permitted continuation.
Basant Prasad Srivastava v. State of U.P., 1993 (2) UPLBEC 1333 (para 7) Principle that trivial lapses in the conduct of elections or non-material breaches of regulations should not lead to invalidation under ultra vires doctrines (i.e., the court may not set aside decisions for non-material or technical breaches). The Court expressed respectful agreement with this view and applied it to hold that breaches of regulations or the Scheme that do not materially affect the election result should not invalidate the election held on 10.7.1994.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds in distinct steps, each tied to provisions of the Act and facts on record:

  1. Statutory and Scheme framework: The college's Scheme of Administration is approved under Section 16-A of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921 and provides for a three-year term for the committee of management with an added provision that office-bearers may continue for one month after expiry; absent constitution of a new committee within that period, a Prabandh Sanchalak may be appointed by the Regional Deputy Director.
  2. Attempted amendment by committee resolution: The outgoing committee passed resolution No. 3 on 21.3.1994 proposing an amendment (to allow extended time) purportedly in compliance with directions from the Regional Deputy Director (letter dated 4.2.1994). The court held that no amendment in fact took effect because sub-section (5) of Section 16-A requires prior approval of the Director of Education for any change in the Scheme. The court emphasized the statutory definition of "Director" (Section 2(aaa)) which differs from the Regional Deputy Director (Section 2(dd)), and concluded that approval by the Regional Deputy Director alone could not substitute for the Director's prior approval.
  3. Validity of the 10.7.1994 election: The court outlined essentials of a valid meeting: (a) properly convened (proper notice), (b) properly constituted (proper chair, quorum observed, compliance with regulations), and (c) properly conducted (chairman conducts proceedings per regulations). The court found there was no case that members entitled to attend lacked notice of the meeting held on 10.7.1994.
  4. Interpretation of timing and directory/mandatory character: The court interpreted the Scheme's one-month continuation clause as indicating the Scheme contemplated a reasonable period for outgoing committees to complete election processes; it did not necessarily render actions void if the process, already commenced, completed after the strict period. The court invoked Chetram Vashist to reinforce that timing provisions often contemplate a reasonable time and may be directory rather than mandatory.
  5. Administrative practicality and de facto doctrine: The court reasoned that the Scheme, though possessing a statutory flavour, is akin to articles of association enhanced by statutory command. Rigid adherence resulting in administrative inconvenience (e.g., as identified in the Regional Deputy Director's circular) is uncalled for. Given that no Prabandh Sanchalak was appointed, the outgoing committee continued management and the District Inspector allowed a revised election schedule; therefore, the de facto doctrine validates actions taken in exercise of apparent authority so long as they do not violate express statutory mandates.
  6. Materiality of breaches: The court distinguished between breaches that are mandatory and materially affect election results and trivial or non-material lapses. Only material breaches that affect results can invalidate elections. The court expressed agreement with the principle in Basant Prasad Srivastava that trivial lapses should not attract ultra vires consequences.
  7. Specific findings on competing claims: The court found PI's claim that it was validly constituted on an alleged resolution of 17.4.1994 unsubstantiated because 17.4.1994 was the date fixed for filing nominations, and the general body meeting was actually scheduled for 24.4.1994. There was no evidence members were given notice of any meeting on 17.4.1994. Further, alleged office-bearers of PI participated in the 10.7.1994 election process, undermining PI's claim. Consequently, the Regional Deputy Director's recognition of P2 was held to be correct.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED — both writ petitions were dismissed.

Direct holdings and immediate consequences:

  • The proposed amendment to the Scheme of Administration by the committee resolution dated 21.3.1994 was not effective because any amendment required prior approval of the Director of Education under sub-section (5) of Section 16-A of the Act; approval by the Regional Deputy Director alone was insufficient.
  • The election held on 10.7.1994 and the committee constituted thereby (referred to as P2) were held valid. The court found that the outgoing committee's organisation and conduct of the election did not render the result invalid, given the directory character of the Scheme's timing provisions, the absence of appointment of a Prabandh Sanchalak, administrative allowance of the revised schedule, and application of the de facto doctrine and materiality principles regarding breaches.
  • The Regional Deputy Director of Education's rejection of PI's representation and recognition of P2 as the valid committee of management was not in error.
  • Each party was ordered to bear costs as the petitions were dismissed "with cost on parties."
  • The Registry was directed to send a copy of the judgment to the Director of Education (Secondary), U.P., Allahabad with a recommendation that the Director may consider issuing a general circular advising institutions to amend schemes to provide for annual submission of the list of general body members to the District Inspector and Regional Deputy Director, and for continuation of outgoing committees as caretaker committees for a reasonable period (suggested three months) with specified limitations on powers for constitution of new committees.

Broader implications:

The court applied established principles (directory vs mandatory timing provisions, de facto doctrine, materiality of breaches) but did not purport to establish any new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities to the facts of this case. The decision's practical implication is validation of the P2 committee and a prompt to the Director of Education to consider administrative reforms via circulars to avoid future disputes.

Final Disposition: Petition dismissed.

    Committee Of Management, Janta Inter College, Muzaffarnagar And Others v. Dy. Director Of Education And Others

    S. R. Singh. J.-

    Both these petitions arise out of the order dated 25.11.1995 passed by the Deputy Director of Educa­tion, 1st Region, Meerut in purported com­pliance of the judgment and order dated 11.1.1995 of the High Court in writ petition No. 903 of 995. The petitioner- committee of management in one petition is the con­testing respondent in the other. The dispute between the parties, in Writ Petition No. 36148 of 1995 pertains of the validity of the committee of management constituted on the basis of election held on 10.7.1994 and recognised by the District Inspector of Schools vide order dated 8.12.1994 and the question involved in the other writ petition is whether the scheme of Administration of the College stood amended as proposed vide resolution dated 21.3.1994 passed by the out-going committee of management in pursuance of direction contained in the let­ter, dated 4.2.1994 issued by the Regional Deputy Director of Education and the nega­tive view of the question expressed in the impugned order is erroneous.

    2. Minimal facts necessary to highlight the controversy and to appreciate the ques­tions herein involved may be stated as below:

    (a) Janta Inter College, Bhopa, Muzaffar-nagar is a recognised institution governed by the provisions of U.P. Intermediate Education Act., 1921 ( here in after referred to as 'the Act') The college has its own Scheme of Administration as approved under Section 16-Aof the Act and other related provisions there of including the IIIrd Schedule, the Scheme of Administration provides for constitution of committee of management by periodical elections and it is the committee of management so constituted periodically that is vested with the authority to manage the affairs is of the institution.

    (b) The Scheme of Administration as ap­proved by the Deputy Director of Education visualised three-year term for the committee of management constituted in accordance with the Scheme with a further stipulation that the office bearers of the committee of management would be entitled to continue for a period of one month next after expiration of its three-year term and if during this period a new committee of manage­ment is not constituted, the term of the out-going committee of management would automatically come to an end by efflux of time and a Prabandh Sanchalak appointed by Regional Deputy Direc­tor of Education would, thereafter, take over the management of the College.

    (c) The committee of management which was constituted on the basis of the election held on 24.3.1991 received its approval recognition by the District Inspector of Schools on 27.3.1991. Its three-year term came to an end on 26.3.1994. But before expiration of its term, it had initiated the process of election on 11.2.1994 for constitution of new committee of management and had in fact fixed 17.4.1994 for filing nominations and 24.4.1994 for poll, if necessary. However, it so happened that no nomination papers were received on the scheduled date i.e. 17.4.1994 and the Election Officer rejected the nomination papers which were received after due date. Conse­quently due to force majeure constitution of the new committee of management could not take place with in the stipulated period but no one was appointed as Prabandh Sanchalak to take over the management of the institution and the out-going committee was not only allowed to manage and conduct the affairs of the College but permitted by the District Inspector of Schools to hold the elec­tion on 10.7.1994 as per revised schedule in presence of the observer sent by him and the District Administration.

    3. The submission made by Sri VM. Zaidi, counsel appearing for petitioners in writ petition No. 36146of 1995 ( here in after called PI) is that the out-going committee of management had no authority to hold the election and the committee of management constituted as a result of the election or­ganised by the outgoing committee of management and held on 10.7.1994 is liable to be invalidated. In other words Sri Zaidi urged that the business transacted in the meeting of the general body held on 10.7.1994 was liable to be invalidated as the meeting was called by the office bearers of the out-going committee of management whose term had already expired. Sri R.N. Singh, learned counsel for the petitioner in writ petition No. 2931 of 1996 (in short P2) urged, on the other hand, that the out-going committee of management had every authority to organise and hold election of new committee of management with in three years and six months of its term pursuant to Scheme of Administration as it stood amended vide resolution dated 21.3.1994 passed by the committee of management in compliance with the general direction is­sued by the Deputy Director of Education 1st Region, Meerut vide letter dated 4.2.1994. In rejoinder Sri V.M. Zaidi urged that the proposed amendment of the Scheme of Administration providing for six months' extension in the terms of the com­mittee of management with the assent of the Regional Deputy Director of Education and another six months with the assent of the Regional Additional Director of Education for the purpose of constitution of a new committee of management would not be deemed to have been brought about in that it was never approved by the Director of Education' nor was the Scheme actually amended on the basis of the resulution dated 21.3.1994.

    4. Haven giving my anxious considera­tion to the submissions made at the Bar, I am of the considered view that albeit resulation No.3 passed by the Committee of management in its meeting held on 21.3.1994 proposing aforesaid amendment in paragraph 8 of the Scheme of Ad­ministration was fairly well in tune with the general directions issued by the Regional Deputy Director of Education vide letter dated 4.2.1994 but no amendment was ac­tually made in the Scheme of Administra­tion pursuant to the said resolution nor could it be made unless approved by the Director of Education in that sub-section (5) of Section 16-A of the Act clearly provides that 'no amendment to or change in the Scheme of Administration shall be made at any time without prior approval of the Director.' The word "Director" as defined in Section 2(aaa) of the Act includes, for the purpose of Section 3, Additional Director and is quite distinct from the Regional Deputy Director of Education"- a term defined in Section 2(dd) of the Act. The argument that prior approval of the Direc­tor of Education would not be necessary in the instant case in as much as the amend­ment was sought to be made by the commit­tee of management on the basis of general directions issued by the Regional Deputy Director of Education' vide letter dated 4.2.1994 is quite off the mark and cannot be countenanced for the simple reason that any change or alteration in the Scheme of Administration requires prior approval of the Director of Education and not of the Regional Director of Education." Had the amendment been made pursuant to any direction issued by the "Director of Education" the position would have been different. There is neither any allegation nor any proof of the fact that the proposed amendment was ever sent to the Director of Education". That apart the amendment as proposed vide resolution No. 3 dated 1.3.1994 does not appear to have been in­corporated in the Scheme of Administra­tion and, therefore, the resolution is of no avail to P2 and the Regional Deputy Direc­tor of Education was right in holding that in the absence of prior approval by the Direc­tor of Education the Scheme could not have been amended.

    5. Next question that arise for con­sideration is whether the constitution of the committee of management as a result of election held on 10.7.1994 is liable to be invalidated for the reason that the election was organised and held by the out-going committee of management after expiration of its term. In other words the question is whether the business transacted in the meeting of the general body of the institu­tion held on 10.7.1994 was validly trans­acted the business would be said to have been validly transacted, if the members of the general body, whether or not they were present, are held bound by the decision taken at the meeting. In my opinion, they would be so bound if the meeting was validly held and the decision taken thereat does not violate any express or implied mandate of the Act or the Regulations made there under impinging upon the resulf of the elec­tion. Essentials of a valid meeting are that it should be:-

    (a)properly convened i.e. proper notice must be sent by the appropriate authority, to every person entitled to attend the meet­ing;

    (b) property constituted i.e. proper per­son must be in the chair; the Rules as to quorum must be observed and the Regula­tions governing the meeting must be com­plied with; and

    (c) properly conducted i.e. Chairman must conduct that proceedings in accord­ance with the Regulations governing the meeting (See Company Meetings-Law and Procedure by B.K. Sen Gupta-page (5). It is no body's case that persons entitled to at­tend the meetings did not have notice there of. But what is implicit in the submission of Sri Zaidi as to invalidity of the election dated 10.7.1994 is that the persons conven­ing the meeting, giving notices thereof to the members and presiding and conductiing the same had lost their authority to do so due to the reason that their term of office had already expired before 10.7.1994 by ef­flux of time. I am of the view that prescrip­tion of one month period next after expira­tion of the three- year term for the constitu­tion of new committee of management only means that the frame of the Scheme though it to be reasonable for the out-going com­mittee of managment to compele the process of election within its extended term. It does not mean that election, the process of which had already commenced, would be vitiated merely because the process cul­minated in its completion after the stipu­lated period of three years and one month. The language employed in the scheme does not support the contention of Sri Zaidi.The stipulation that the management of the in­stitution would be taken over by a person appointed as Prabandh Sanchalak in the event of failure to constitute the committee of management within the stipuleted period is suggestive of the fact that tne com­mittee would not automatically cease to be functional. In other words it would continue to be funtional untill replaced by Prabandh Sanchalak.

    6. In Chetram Vashist v. Municipal Cor­poration of Delhi, AIR 1981 SC 653, it was held that where a provision fixes a time within which a public offficer or authority has to act in performance of the duty, it generally means that the statute considers it reasonable for the officer or authority to act within stich period.

    7. The scheme of Administration may have statutory flavour but it is neither a Statute properly so called nor Rules and/or Regulations made under the Act. It is in the nature of articles of association with the command of Statute supperadded to it. Rigid adherence to it at the cost of ad­ministrative inconvenience e.g. those indi­cated in the Circular dated 4.2.1994 is, in my opinion, uncalled for. It may be observed that even statutory provisions imposing similar duty on a body or authority are sometimes held only directory. The prin­ciple has been succinctly stated by Justice G.P. Singh on Statutory. Interpretation, Fifth Edition in the follwing words:

    "Where a Statue imposes a public duty and lays down manner in which and the time within which duty shall be performed, injustice or incon­venience resulting from a rigid adherence to the Statutory prescriptions may be relevant factor in holding such prescriptions only directory."

    8. The Scheme of Administration, no doubt, visualised that the term of the com­mittee of management would automatically come to an end if a new committee of management did not take over the charge within the stipulated period of three years and one month of the commencement of the term of out-going committee of management, but this was directory and since none was appointed as Prabandh Sanchalak by the Regional Deputy Director of Education and the out-going committee of management was allowed by the District Inspector of Schools to go ahead with the revised election schedule, the business transacted in the meeting of the general body held on 10.7.1994 cannot be in­validated inasmuch as de facto dobtrine would come into play.

    9 Breach, if any, of a provision in the Regulations or approved Scheme of Ad­ministration pertaining to election of the office bearers to the committee of manage­ment may violate the decisions taken at the meeting if it is found that the breach is of a mandatory provision and such breach has materially affected the result of the election. Breach or violation of either the Regula­tions or the approved Scheme of Ad­ministration not materially affecting the result of the election would not invalidate the decision taken at the meeting of the general body convened for the purpose of electing the office bearers and the members of the committee of management for, in my opinion, a trivial lapse in the conduct of election should not be visited with the con­sequences of ultra vires doctrine. For the reasons stated above, I am in respectful agreement with the view taken in Basant Prasad Srivastava v. State of U.P. 1993 (2) UPLBEC1333(para7).

    10. It may be observed that PI claims itself to be validly constituted committee of management on the basis of the alleged resolution passed by the general body of the institution in its meeting allegadly held on 17.4.94, but the fact of the matter is that 17.4.1994 was the date fixed for filing nomination and the meeting of the general body was scheduled for 24.4.1994 and not for 17.4.1994 and there is nothing on record to indicate that the members of the general body were ever given notice of the alleged meeting on 17.4.1994. That apart the al­leged office bearers of PI admittedly par­ticipated in the deliberation of the meeting held on 10.7.1994 i.e. in the election in ques­tion. The Regional Deputy Director of Education has committed no error in reject­ing the represention filed by PI and recongnising P2 as validly constituted com­mittee of management.

    11. In view of the above discussion the writ petitions fail and are dismissed with cost on parties. The Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the Director of Education (Secondary) U.P. Allahabad who may examine the necessity of issuing a general circular requiring the institutions governed by the Act to get their schemes suitably amended making there in provisions for annual submission of the list of members of the general body to the Dis­trict Inspector of Schools as well as Regional Deputy Director of Education and continuance of the out-going committee of management for a reasonable period, say three months, next after its stipulated period, as care-taker committee of manage­ment with limitation specified on its power for the purpose of constitution of the new committee of management with in its ex­tended terms.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Committee Of Managem... v. Dy. Director Of Educ...
    (Aug 26, 1996)