Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 3(a), the requirements of Rule 14 of Order 6 of the CPC,
  • Rule 17 of the Civil Rules of Practice and Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC
  • Rule 3(a) of the Rules and Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC
  • Code of Civil Procedure. Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC
  • Rule 14 of Order 6 of the CPC
  • Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC.
  • Rule 52 of the same Rules,
  • provisions of O. 6, Rule 14
  • Rule 3(a) of the Rules
  • Proceedings. Rule 23
  • clause (b) of Rule 3
  • Order 6, Rule 14
  • Rules. Rule 18
  • sub-rule (4)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 3(a), the requirements of Rule 14 of Order 6 of the CPC,
  • Rule 17 of the Civil Rules of Practice and Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC
  • Rule 3(a) of the Rules and Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC
  • Code of Civil Procedure. Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC
  • Rule 14 of Order 6 of the CPC
  • Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC.
  • Rule 52 of the same Rules,
  • provisions of O. 6, Rule 14
  • Rule 3(a) of the Rules
  • Proceedings. Rule 23
  • clause (b) of Rule 3
  • Order 6, Rule 14
  • Rules. Rule 18
  • sub-rule (4)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Fourteen persons purported to file a writ petition. All fourteen signed the vakalatnama, but only the fourth petitioner signed and verified the writ petition itself, stating he did so for himself and on behalf of the other petitioners. An "authorisation letter" purporting to be under Rule 17 of the Civil Rules of Practice and Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC, signed by petitioners 1 to 3 and 5 to 14, stated that those petitioners authorised the fourth petitioner to sign and verify the writ petition on their behalf.

The Court Office objected that either all petitioners should sign and verify the writ petition, or the petitioners who did not sign should file an affidavit or a Power of Attorney authorising the fourth petitioner, since, the Office contended, a mere letter of authorisation did not suffice. The learned counsel for the petitioners disagreed with the Office's objection, and the matter was referred to the judge for determination under the applicable Rules governing writ proceedings (including Rule 3(a) of the Writ Petition Rules and Order 6, Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a mere letter of authorisation, signed by petitioners who do not themselves sign and verify a writ petition, constitutes "due authorisation" under Order 6, Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure as applied to writ proceedings by Rule 3(a) of the Writ Petition Rules.
  2. If a petitioner does not personally sign and verify a writ petition, what form of proof of "due authorisation" is required (e.g., Power of Attorney, affidavit, or other modes such as oral authorisation)?
  3. Whether an affidavit sworn by the person who signs and verifies the petition on behalf of others (i.e., the representative) suffices to prove that the others authorised him to sign and verify.

Arguments of the Parties

Office's Objection

  • The Registry objected that all petitioners should either sign and verify the writ petition personally or file an affidavit or Power of Attorney authorising the fourth petitioner to sign and verify on their behalf.
  • The Office took the position that a mere (unsigned-in-presence-of-official) letter of authorisation is insufficient compliance with the Rules.

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Learned counsel for the petitioners disagreed with the Registry and maintained that the steps taken were sufficient (implicitly contending the authorisation letter and the fourth petitioner's affidavit/verification were enough).
  • It was also submitted (by learned counsel for the petitioners) that the fourth petitioner had filed an affidavit stating the others had authorised him, and that should satisfy the requirement for verification/authorisation.
  • Learned counsel relied on authorities emphasising that the words "duly authorised" in Order 6, Rule 14 need not be restricted to written authority and that oral or other forms of authorisation have been recognised in precedents.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Subiah Pillai v. Sankarapandiam Pillai, AIR 1948 Mad 369 Where a plaint filed with the plaintiff's knowledge and consent is not signed, the omission is a procedural defect that can and should be cured in the interests of justice. The Court relied on this authority to show signing/verifying is procedural and curable, but emphasised that when someone signs for others it must be shown he had due authorisation.
Mohinimohun Das v. Bungsi Buddan Saha Das, (1890) ILR 17 Cal 580 (PC) Part of the Privy Council authority cited for the principle that omission of signature where there is knowledge and consent may be cured. Used as supporting authority for the view that failure to sign is procedural and remediable; reinforces the need to establish actual authorisation when another signs.
Basdeo v. John Smidt, (1899) ILR 22 All 55 (FB) High Court authority supporting the rule that omissions of signature where there is consent can be cured. Cited together with the above cases to support the proposition that signing is procedural and corrective measures are permissible.
Mulla, Commentary on the Code of Civil Procedure (13th ed.) Signing of plaints is procedural; if not signed by plaintiff or authorised person the defect can be cured by amendment at any stage and is not a matter affecting merits or jurisdiction. The Court relied on Mulla to underline that signing/verification is procedural, but that adequate proof of due authorisation is still required when another signs.
Bibi Asghari v. Md. Kasim, AIR 1951 Pat 323 It is sufficient if it is shown that the person who signed on behalf of a plaintiff did so with the knowledge and authority of that plaintiff; such knowledge and authority must be shown to the satisfaction of the Court. Applied to stress that the Court must be satisfied as to knowledge and authority; such proof must meet the Court's standards.
Re: Arbn. The Bengal Jute Mills v. Jewraj Heeralal, AIR 1943 Cal 13 Oral authorisation can suffice if the Court examines the person and records evidence (i.e., the Munib Gumashta was orally authorised and this was accepted after examination in open Court). The Court accepted that oral authorisation has been recognised but emphasised that it was accepted only after in-court examination; thus oral proof is possible but impractical and burdensome.
All India Reporter Ltd. v. Ramchandra D. Datar, AIR 1961 Bom 292 Order 6, Rule 14 relates to procedural requirements in signing/verification; non-compliance is not fatal and can be cured by amendment; "duly authorised" need not be restricted to written authority. The Court noted this authority to acknowledge that written authority is not the only possible mode, but reiterated the desirability and practicability of proof by affidavit or Power of Attorney to establish due authorisation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began from the established procedural requirement that writ petitions must be signed and verified in the manner provided for pleadings under the Code of Civil Procedure (Rule 3(a) of the Writ Petition Rules and Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC). Order 6, Rule 14 permits a pleading to be signed by a person duly authorised to sign if the party is unable to sign by reason of absence or other good cause, but the Code does not define "duly authorised."

The Court analysed practical and procedural considerations to determine what modes of authorisation would constitute "due authorisation." It identified the following concerns and legal materials in reaching its conclusion:

  • Risk of fraudulent or false authorisations: a mere unsigned or unsworn letter of authorisation is not a sworn statement and is not made in the presence of an authorised attesting officer, so it does not minimise the possibility of false authorisations.
  • Rules requiring verification by affidavit: Clause (b) of Rule 3 of the Writ Petition Rules requires facts relied upon by the petitioner to be verified by an affidavit filed along with the petition; this indicates a general preference for sworn statements to verify both facts and the identity/authority of petitioners.
  • Applicability of Appellate Side and Civil Rules: Rules (Appellate Side) such as Rule 23 (vakalatnama execution attestation), Rule 52 (petition signatures to be acknowledged before Registrar or functionary), and Rule 56 (affidavits to be made before enumerated authorities with certification of oath/affirmation) show consistent procedural safeguards to ensure signatures and affidavits are properly attested and authenticated. Civil Rules of Practice (e.g., Rule 17) expressly require that when a proceeding is signed/verified by a person on behalf of a party, a written authority signed by the party be filed together with an affidavit verifying signature, reasons for inability to sign, and proof of the signer's means of knowledge.
  • Precedents: The Court reviewed authorities showing that (a) signing/verification is procedural and curable (Subiah Pillai and related authorities; Mulla), (b) the Courts will require satisfaction that a signatory had knowledge and authority (Bibi Asghari), and (c) oral authorisation has been accepted in exceptional circumstances but only after in-court examination of witnesses (Re: The Bengal Jute Mills). The All India Reporter Ltd. case acknowledged that "duly authorised" need not be restricted to written authority, but this did not obviate the need for reliable proof.

Drawing these threads together, the Court concluded that while various modes of authorisation exist in law (including oral authorisation in exceptional and examinable circumstances), the practical, reliable and least burdensome modes for establishing "due authorisation" in writ proceedings are either a Power of Attorney or a sworn affidavit by the party who does not personally sign and verify the petition. The affidavit must be sworn before an attesting officer or functionary recognised by law and should state reasons for inability to sign/verify personally and expressly authorise another person to sign and verify on the party's behalf.

The Court also rejected the sufficiency of an affidavit sworn by the representative (the person who actually signs and verifies). The reason given is that such an affidavit would not serve the purpose of assuring the Court that the absent/non-signing party personally authorised the representation, because the representative is in a position to have prepared and sworn to a self-serving affidavit without independent attestation by the non-signing party.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: For the purposes of writ petitions, if some parties do not personally sign and verify the petition, then either a Power of Attorney or an affidavit sworn by those non-signing parties in the presence of an attesting officer or functionary recognised by law—stating the reasons for their inability to sign and verifying that they authorise another person to sign and verify on their behalf—must be filed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties in this case: the Registry's objection that a mere letter of authorisation is insufficient is sustained; the non-signing petitioners must provide the specified form of proof (Power of Attorney or sworn affidavit) to demonstrate "due authorisation."
  • The Court emphasised the practical necessity of such proof to avoid doubts, fraud, or costly oral proof. Although earlier cases recognise oral or other forms of authorisation in exceptional circumstances, the opinion prescribes the filing of a Power of Attorney or a sworn affidavit as the preferred and necessary modes for ordinary writ practice.
  • The opinion does not purport to create a novel substantive rule of law beyond applying and synthesising existing procedural rules and precedents; its effect is to answer the reference by prescribing the required proof of authorisation in the context of writ petitions under the Rules cited.

This reference is answered as set out above.

    M. Parthasarthi v. State Of A.P.

    1. Fourteen persons purport to file this writ petition. Though all of them signed the Vakalat form, only one of them signed and verified the writ petition stating that he was doing so for himself and on behalf of other petitioners. A letter entitled ‘authorisation letter’ purporting to be under Rule 17 of the Civil Rules of Practice and Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC signed by petitioners 1 to 3 and 5 to 14 was also filed with the writ petition. It says:—

    “We, the undersigned petitioners hereby authorise Sri G. Pattabhirama Sarcna 4th Petitioner in Writ Petition Mo. 1 of 1970 to sign and verify the writ petition on our behalf.”

    2. The Office took an objection that all the petitioners should either sign and verify the writ petition or they should file an affidavit or a Power of Attorney authorising the 4th petitioner to sign and verify the writ petition. It was objected that a mere letter of authorisation is not sufficient compliance with the Rules. The learned counsel for the petitioners disagreed with this objection and hence the matter has been referred to me. Rule 3(a) of the Rules which regulate the proceedings under Article 226 (of the Constitution) published on 21-5-1970 requires that the petition shall be signed and verified by the petitioners in the manner provided for signing and verification of pleadings under the Code of Civil Procedure. Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC is the relevant provision and it lays down that ‘every pleading shall be signed by the party and his pleader (if any)’. Where, however, a party, by reason of absence or for other good cause, is unable to sign the pleading, it may be signed by any person duly authorised by him to sign the same OR to sue or defend on his behalf. By virtue of the provisions of Rule 3(a), the requirements of Rule 14 of Order 6 of the CPC, have become applicable to writ proceedings. Accordingly, if a party is unable to sign the writ petition himself, any person duly authorised by Mm can sign the same. The Code does not define the words ‘duly authorised’. Granting a power of Attorney is certainly a ‘due authorisation’ universally accepted by law. What other modes of ‘due authorisation’ could be adopted by law. What other modes of ‘due authorisation’ could be adopted and whether a mere letter of authorisation is one such mode of due authorisation is the question now to be considered.

    3. Though it is not of common occurrence and may happen very rarely, yet the possibility of one person claiming to file a writ petition on behalf of several other persons, but doing so without their authority and consent or even knowledge cannot be altogether excluded. It should be noted that the right to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 is a personal remedy. Only a person who is aggrieved by something done or omitted to be done can bring a cause to this Court by way of a writ petition. It is, therefore, essential to ascertain that only aggrieved persons come to this Court. It is only in order to find out petitioners are such persons, the procedure of Rule 14 of Order 6 of the CPC is adopted in writ proceedings also. If the party or parties himself or themselves sign the petition, it is well and good. Other-: wise, the person, signing and verifying the petition must obtain “due authorisation” from the other petitioners. Undoubtedly it is not only a rule of convenience but also one of prudence to insist upon production of a Power of Attorney or an affidavit, evidencing the claim of the party who signs and verifies a petition that he has been duly authorised by the other petitioners so to do.

    4. An affidavit is a sworn statement of the other petitioners duly attested by an authority authorised by law to so attest. The possibility of getting false authorisations is thus excluded or, in any case minimised by making a sworn statement in the presence of a duly constituted authority. It is pertinent to note that clause (b) of Rule 3 of the Writ Petition Rules requires that:—

    “The facts relied on by the petitioner shall be verified by an affidivit which shall be filed along with the petition.”

    5. It is thus manifest that the Court is very anxious to have not only the petitioners that come to the Court but also the facts alleged by them are verified. Such verification is easily done by an affidavit. A mere letter of authorisation, though purported to be signed by other petitioners, is neither a sworn statement of those persons nor is it signed in the presence of a recognised authority. Thus insistence upon the filing of a Power of Attorney or on a sworn affidavit is a rule of convenience as well as of prudence.

    6. Moreover, reading Rule 3(a) of the Rules and Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC with the other relevant rules of procedure demonstrates that some such proof of ‘due authorisation’ is necessary. Rule 20 of the Writ Petition Rules says:—

    “All the other rules relating to causes and matters coming before the Appellate Side of the High Court will apply to the Writ Petitions and the Writ Appeals in so far as they are not inconsistent with these rules.”

    7. Thus, the Appellate Side Rules of this Court in so far as they are not inconsistent with these Rules, are made applicable to Writ Proceedings. Rule 23 of the Appellate Side Rules of Andhra Pradesh requires the vakalatnama to be executed or its execution attested before any one of the authorities enumerated therein. That authority or functionary shall certify by his signature and designation that the Vakalatnama has been duly executed Likewise, under Rule 52 of the same Rules, if a petition is presented by a party, it shall be signed or marked by him, and such signature or mark shall be acknowledged before the Registrar, or some other functionary who shall certify therein that the contents of the petition were explained by him and the signature or mark of the petitioner was made or acknowledged before him.

    Similarly, as per Rule 56, affidavits intended for use in the appellate side of this Court have to be made before any one of the authorities or functionaries enumerated therein and such officer or person before whom an affidavit is made shall state the day when and the place where the same is taken and sign his name and description at the end, stating that the affidavit was sworn or solemnly affirmed in his presence. Even alterations and interlineations are required by sub-rule (4) to be authenticated by the initials of the officer or person before whom the affidavit is sworn. Thus, great care is taken to see that every vakalat or petition or affidavit filed before the Court is signed or sworn by the person purporting to file it. Rule 52 deals with petitions and there is no reason to hold that the precautions taken for certifying the signature on the petitions are not intended to apply to the filing of Writ petitions.

    It is, therefore, reasonable to assume that the words ‘duly authorised’ in Rule 14 of Order 6 of the CPC mean and require that such authorisation should be in some form analogous to the requirements of Rule 52 of the Appellate Side Rules.

    8. The relevant provisions of the Civil Rules of Practice also make this position very clear. It may be that those rules may not in terms apply to Writ Proceedings. But, the principle of the procedure prescribed therein for Vakalatnamas and affidavits is similar to the one contained in the Appellate Side Rules. Rule 18 relates to the appointment of Pleaders. It also requires that the execution of the Vakalatnama shall be attested by an officer or functionary referred to therein. Rule 33 requires an affidavit to be filed as proof of facts in interlocutory proceedings. Affidavits under Rule 34 have to be sworn in before a recognised officer or functionary. More significant is Rule 17 which requires that if any proceeding which is required to be signed or verified by a party is signed or verified by any person on his behalf a written authority in this behalf signed by the party shall be filed in Court, together with an affidavit, verifying the signature of the party and stating the reason of his inability to sign or verify the proceedings, and proving the means of knowledge of the facts set out in the proceedings of the person signing or verifying the same.

    9. This Rule throws much light on the problem to be resolved in this reference. It requires, that a written authority signed by the party, who is unable to himself sign or verify the proceeding, together with an affidavit stating the reasons of his inability for signing and verifying the proceeding himself, to be filed. No reason is conceivable for making a distinction between this procedure this is made applicable in the Courts of first instance and the procedure that has to be followed in signing and verifying writ Petitions.

    10. It follows therefore, that it is not only a rule of convenience and prudence but also a logical consequence of the relevant rules that a party, who is unable to sign the writ petition himself, should either file a Power of Attorney or an affidavit stating the reason for his inability to personally sign and verify the petition and authorising some other person to sign and verify on his behalf.

    11. Reference to the decided cases cited at the Bar does not lead to a different conclusion. In Subiah Pillai v. Sankarapandiam Pillai, AIR 1948 Mad 369, the Division Bench was dealing with a case where a plaint was filed with the consent and knowledge of the plaintiff but not signed by him. The Court held that the absence of signature is an omission which could be cured and indeed should be corrected in the interests of justice. While doing so, the learned Judges referred to the decision of the Privy Council in Mohinimohun Das v. Bungsi Buddan Saha Das, (1890) ILR 17 Cal 580 (PC) and a decision of the Allahabad High Court in Basdeo v. John Smidt, (1899) ILR 22 All 55 (FB). As summed up by Gentle, C.J, the result of the two decisions by the Judicial Committee and the High Court of Allahabad is that:—

    “Where a plaintiff has not signed a plaint, filed with his knowledge and consent, it is an omission which can be cured, and, indeed should be corrected in the interests of justice.”

    12. The learned Judges of the Madras High Court followed the same Rule.

    13. Learned author Mulla at page 720 of his Commentary on the Code of Civil Procedure, 13th Edition has this to say on the question.

    “The signing of plaints is merely a matter of procedure. If a plaint is not signed by the plaintiff or by a person duly authorised by him in that behalf, and the defect is discovered at any time before judgment, the Court may allow the plaintiff to amend the piaint by signing the same. If the defect is not discovered until the case comes on for hearing before an appellate Court, the appellate Court may order the amendment to be made in that Court. The appellate Court ought not to dismiss the suit or interfere with the decree of the lower Court merely because the plaint has not been signed. The omission to sign or verify a plaint is not such a defect as could affect the merits of a case or the jurisdiction of the Court.”

    14. The above authority shows that signing and verifying a plaint is only a matter of procedure; nevertheless a requirement of the law. If the failure of the plaintiff to sign and verify the plaint is discovered at any stage, it should be permitted to be corrected. At the same time, if the plaint purports to be signed and verified by some person other than the party it should be shown that person has done so on due authorisation, i.e with the knowledge and authority of the party. This does not, however, exclude the need of adequate proof of the claim that the person has signed the plaint after securing due authorisation from the party.

    15. The Patna High Court in Bibi Asghari v. Md. Kasim, AIR 1951 Pat 323, held that it is sufficient if it is shown that a person, who has signed the plaint on behalf of a plaintiff has done so with the knowledge and authority of the latter. It is plain that such ‘knowledge and authority’ should be shown to the satisfaction of the Court, to exist.

    16. In Re: Arbn. The Bengal Jute Mills, v. Jewraj Heeralal.*, AIR 1943 Cal 13, it was held by the Court, after examining the person concerned in open Court, that during the temporary absence of the principals, the Munib Gumashta was orally instructed and authorised to do everything in connection with the business and, therefore, he was duly authorised as contemplated by Order 6, Rule 14 of the CPC. From this it was sought to be argued by the learned counsel that even oral authorisation is sufficient. It should not, however, be forgotten that this oral authorisation was accepted by the Calcutta High Court only after examining the person concerned in open Court and recording his evidence. After all, in every case the real question is whether there is ‘due authorisation’ and the Court, if it thinks it necessary can call for and examine witnesses or examine other evidence in order to test whether there has been due authorisation or not. However, it is undoubted that it would result in great waste of time and money of the Court as well as the parties to establish due authorisation by adducing oral evidence for due authorisation must be proved as a fact. Filing of an affidavit or a Power of Attorney are the easiest and at the same time safest method available to prove that fact.

    17. Once again the decision in All India Reporter Ltd. v. Ramchandra D. Datar, AIR 1961 Bom 292, lays down the same rule that the provisions of O. 6, Rule 14 merely relate to procedural requirements in presenting, signing and verification of a plaint and non-compliance therewith is not fatal and can be cured by amendment at any stage. An observation here resting on AIR 1943 Cal 13 that:

    “The words ‘duly authorised’ in Order 6, Rule 14 need not be restricted to mean authorised by proper written authority or by Power of Attorney.”

    was very much stressed by the learned counsel before me. It is true oral authorisation is permissible. But, at the same time it should be remembered that the Court, must be satisfied that the person signing and verifying the petition on behalf of the parties is duly authorised to do so. That satisfaction can be brought about only by certain accepted modes of proof. As I said, adducing oral evidence in this behalf results in great loss of time to the Court and hardship to the parties and is, therefore, undesirable.

    18. There is, therefore, no doubt in my mind to hold that in order to avoid all future difficulties, doubts or complications it is essential for the parties to prove ‘due authorisation’ by producing a Power of Attorney or a sworn affidavit of the party who is not personally signing and verifying the petition. Even so, learned counsel submitted that the requirement of filing an affidavit has been satisfied in this case by the fourth petitioner who has filed and verified the petition on behalf of the other petitioners, has himself filed an affidavit stating that the other writ petitioners have authorised him to sign and verify the writ petition. But such an affidavit by a person who is actually signing and verifying the petition does not meet the requirements of the situation. What is required is the affidavit of the party or parties who is or are not signing and verifying. Otherwise, the very purpose for which such an affidavit is required is likely to be defeated. After all, the fourth petitioner, who is swearing to the affidavit has already signed the petition and it would not be difficult for him to swear to another affidavit. If the Court is to be satisfied that the parties had authorised him to sign and verify the petition on their behalf, it is their affidavit that is essential to prove such authorisation and not the affidavit of the person who has come forward that he has got a representative capacity.

    19. For the reasons, I answer the reference by holding that if some of the parties to the writ petition do not personally sign and verify it, but authorise somebody else to sign and verify on their behalf either a Power of Attorney or an affidavit sworn by them in the presence of an attesting Officer or functionary recognised by law stating the reasons for their inability to sign and verify the petition personally and authorising another person to sign and verify on their behalf, should be filed.

    20. Before I part with the case, I must express my thanks to the learned Principal Government Pleader who has rendered me valuable assistance on my request.

    21. Reference answered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M. Parthasarthi v. State Of A.P.
    (Aug 11, 1970)