AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 227
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 376 and 354 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 59 of the Prisons Act, 1894
  • Clause (5-A) of Section 3 of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 227
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 376 and 354 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 59 of the Prisons Act, 1894
  • Clause (5-A) of Section 3 of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Maharashtra and the Superintendent, District Prison, Akola appealed to the Supreme Court of India against an order of a learned Single Judge of the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench). The High Court had directed that the respondent—who had been convicted under Sections 376 and 354 of the Indian Penal Code—be released on furlough upon furnishing a surety of Rs 500 already lying in deposit with jail authorities. The State contended that the High Court’s order disregarded specific statutory requirements in the Prisons (Bombay Furlough and Parole) Rules, 1959. Notice of the Supreme Court appeal was served on the respondent, but no one appeared on his behalf.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in granting furlough to the respondent despite non-compliance with Rules 4(4) and 6 of the Prisons (Bombay Furlough and Parole) Rules, 1959.
  2. Whether the deposit of Rs 500 with jail authorities could substitute for the surety bond and familial undertaking mandated by Rule 6.
  3. Whether an adverse report from the District Magistrate and police, citing concerns for public peace and tranquillity under Rule 4(4), could be ignored by the High Court while ordering furlough.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (State of Maharashtra & Superintendent, District Prison)

  • The High Court failed to consider Rules 4(4) and 6, which are mandatory prerequisites for furlough.
  • Rule 6 requires that (a) a relative be willing to receive the prisoner, and (b) such relative execute a surety bond in Form A for an amount fixed by the sanctioning authority; both conditions were absent as the respondent’s sister refused to act as surety because of the respondent’s conviction for rape.
  • Rule 4(4) bars release when the Commissioner of Police (Greater Bombay) or the District Magistrate (elsewhere) does not recommend release on grounds of public peace and tranquillity; the verification report from the District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police opposed furlough.
  • Because furlough is “not an absolute right,” and is distinct from parole, its grant must strictly adhere to the statutory conditions.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments because the respondent was unrepresented before the Supreme Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court (Per Arijit Pasayat, J.) focused exclusively on the statutory framework:

  • Mandatory twin requirements under Rule 6 not met. The respondent had no relative willing to receive him, and no relative executed the requisite surety bond. Substituting the prisoner’s own Rs 500 deposit for a third-party surety violated the plain language of the Rule.
  • Adverse recommendation under Rule 4(4). The District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police submitted negative reports, deeming release detrimental to public peace and tranquillity. Rule 4(4) expressly bars furlough in such circumstances.
  • High Court overlooked statutory bars. Although the High Court acknowledged the absence of a willing surety, it nevertheless ordered release, effectively reading down or ignoring Rules 4(4) and 6. The Supreme Court held that these Rules leave no discretion to dispense with either condition (except the limited power in Rule 6’s proviso, which was inapplicable because the respondent was not in an “open prison”).
  • No finding rebutted the adverse reports. The High Court failed to record any finding contradicting the District Magistrate’s and police’s concerns over public peace, a pre-condition to override Rule 4(4).

Consequently, the Supreme Court found the High Court’s order “indefensible” and set it aside.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed; the Bombay High Court’s order directing the respondent’s release on furlough is set aside.

Implications: The respondent remains in custody but retains the liberty to re-apply for furlough upon satisfying all statutory conditions under Rules 4(4) and 6. The judgment does not set new precedent but reaffirms that compliance with the Prisons (Bombay Furlough and Parole) Rules is mandatory, limiting judicial discretion when statutory bars are triggered.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Maharashtra And Another v. Suresh Pandurang Darvakar .

    Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted.

    2. Heard counsel for the appellants.

    3. None appears for the respondent in spite of service of notice.

    4. The State of Maharashtra and the Superintendent, District Prison, Akola, Maharashtra challenged the order passed by a learned Single Judge of the Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench accepting the respondent's prayer for release on furlough. By the impugned order, the learned Single Judge directed release of the respondent on furnishing his surety of Rs 500 lying in deposit with the jail authorities.

    5. According to the learned counsel for the appellants, the High Court has not kept in view Rules 4(4) and 6 of the Prisons (Bombay Furlough and Parole) Rules, 1959 (in short “the Rules”). The said Rules have been framed in exercise of powers conferred by clauses (5) and (28) of Section 59 of the Prisons Act, 1894 (in short “the Act”) in its application to the State of Maharashtra as it stood then. The expression “furlough system” is defined in clause (5-A) of Section 3 of the Act, while the expression “parole system” is defined in clause (5-B) of the said provision. The underlying object of the Rules relating to “parole” and “furlough” have been mentioned in the report submitted by All-India Jail Manual Committee and the objects mentioned in Model Prison Manual. The “furlough” and “parole” have two different purposes. It is not necessary to state the reasons while releasing the prisoner on furlough, but in case of parole reasons are to be indicated in terms of Rule 19. But release on furlough cannot be said to be an absolute right of the prisoner as culled out from Rule 17. It is subject to the conditions mentioned in Rules 4(4) and 6. Furlough is allowed periodically under Rule 3 irrespective of any particular reason merely with a view to enable the prisoner to have family association, family and social ties and to avoid ill-effect of continuous prison life. Period of furlough is treated as a period spent in the prison. But Rule 20 shows that period spent on parole is not to be counted as remission of sentence. Since the furlough is granted for no particular reason, it can be denied in the interest of society; whereas parole is to be granted only on sufficient cause being shown.

    6. Rules 4(4) and 6 read as follows:

    “4. When prisoners shall not be granted furlough.—The following categories of prisoners shall not be considered for release on furlough:
    (4) Prisoners whose release is not recommended in Greater Bombay by the Commissioner of Police and elsewhere, by the District Magistrate, on the ground of public peace and tranquillity.
    6. Furlough not to be granted without surety.—A prisoner shall not be granted furlough unless he has a relative willing to receive him while on furlough and ready to enter into a surety bond in Form A appended to these Rules for such amount as may be fixed by the sanctioning authority:
    Provided that the sanctioning authority may dispense with the requirement of execution of such bond by relatives of prisoners confined in open prisons as defined in clause (b) of Rule 2 of the Maharashtra Open Prisons Rules, 1971.”

    7. A bare reading of Rule 4(4) indicates that release can be refused when the same is not recommended by the Commissioner of Police in Greater Bombay and elsewhere, by the District Magistrate on the ground of public peace and tranquillity.

    8. Rule 6, inter alia, provides that a prisoner shall not be granted furlough unless he has a relative willing to receive him while on furlough and is ready to enter into a surety bond in Form A appended to the Rules for such amount as may be fixed by the sanctioning authority. The proviso authorises the sanctioning authority to dispense with the requirement of execution of such bond by relatives of prisoners confined in open prisons as defined in clause (b) of Rule 2 of the Maharashtra Open Prisons Rules, 1971. Therefore, the twin requirements flowing from Rule 6 are: (a) a relative of the applicant should be willing to receive him while on furlough, and (b) he must be ready to enter into a surety bond. In the instant case, the relatives refused to execute such surety bond. The verification reports received by the police from the District Magistrate, Amravati and Superintendent of Police, Amravati indicate that the sister of the respondent refused to stand surety as the respondent allegedly committed rape on his stepmother and has been convicted for offences punishable under Sections 376 and 354 of the Penal Code, 1860 and sentenced to suffer imprisonment for seven years with fine. In view of the adverse police report and non-compliance with the requirements stipulated under Rules 4(4) and 6, the competent authority rejected the application for grant of furlough by order dated 18-7-2005.

    9. Unfortunately, the High Court does not appear to have addressed itself to these relevant aspects. It took note of the fact that nobody was willing to stand surety for release of the respondent. The High Court directed that he can be released on furnishing surety of amount lying in deposit with the jail authorities. That is not the only condition for release on furlough. There is another requirement. Even if it is held for the sake of argument that furnishing of surety of any amount lying in deposit with the jail authorities can be construed to be in compliance with the requirements of Rule 6, Rule 4(4) mandates that the prisoner who seeks to be released cannot be released if not recommended by the authority concerned on the ground of public peace and tranquillity. The High Court has not recorded any finding that the report of the District Magistrate and/or the Superintendent of Police had not objected to the release on furlough on the ground of public peace and tranquillity.

    10. Looked at from any angle, the High Court's order is indefensible. The same is set aside. It is, however, open to the respondent to apply for release on fulfilment of the requisite conditions as prescribed in the Rules. Needless to say that the same shall be considered in its own perspective in accordance with law. The appeal is allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Maharashtra And Another v. Suresh Pandurang Darvakar .
    (Apr 13, 2006)