AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

High Court Summary — H.L. Gokhale, J. (Civil Revision) — Interim Compensation under Section 92-A, Motor Vehicles Act, 1939

Factual and Procedural Background

On 18.2.1989 Nalinkumar Manubhai Shah (aged about 38), an employee of the Gujarat Electricity Board, died while crossing the road at about 7.30 a.m. The incident involved an auto-rickshaw bearing No. GRX 281, driven by respondent No. 1 and owned by respondent No. 2. The deceased's wife and two minor children filed Motor Accident Claim Petition No. 31 of 1989 seeking compensation; parents of the deceased were joined as respondents Nos. 3 and 4, and the insurer (United India Insurance Co. Ltd.) as respondent No. 5.

The petitioners moved an interim application seeking Rs. 15,000 under section 92-A (no-fault liability) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. The driver (respondent No. 1) and the insurer filed affidavits/objections opposing the interim relief; the owner (respondent No. 2) did not file a separate reply but adopted the driver's reply. Key documents (panchnama, F.I.R., post-mortem report, death certificate) were placed before the Claims Tribunal.

The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal No. 1, Ahmedabad, by order dated 15.3.1991, rejected the interim application holding there was no prima facie evidence that the accident had arisen out of the use of the auto-rickshaw. The petitioners challenged that order by filing the present civil revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Claims Tribunal was correct in rejecting the interim compensation application under section 92-A on the ground that there was "no prima facie case and/or evidence" to show that the accident arose out of the use of the motor vehicle.
  2. Whether the documentary material on record (panchnama, F.I.R., post-mortem, injury/death certificate and vehicle/insurance particulars) satisfied the requirements for awarding interim compensation under section 92-A.
  3. Whether, in the circumstances of this case, the High Court should remand the interim application for a summary inquiry by the Tribunal or determine the interim relief itself on the existing material.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners sought interim compensation of Rs. 15,000 under section 92-A based on the principle of no-fault liability.
  • They relied on documentary evidence placed before the Tribunal — panchnama, F.I.R., post-mortem report and death certificate — which, in their submission, established prima facie involvement of the auto-rickshaw and the cause of death (intracranial haemorrhage following head injury).

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondent No. 1 (driver): in his affidavit contended that there was no accident as such — the deceased fainted while crossing the road near the rickshaw; he arranged to send the person to hospital and then proceeded with passengers. He asserted that insurance premium had been paid by cheque dated 17.2.1989.
  • United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (insurer, respondent No. 5): objected on the ground that policy particulars were not disclosed and contended the existence and validity of any policy was doubtful.
  • Respondent No. 2 (owner): did not file a separate reply opposing interim relief and adopted the driver's affidavit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shivaji Dayanu Patil v. Vatschala Uttam More, 1991 ACJ 111 (SC) The requirements for awarding compensation under section 92-A: (i) accident arising out of use of motor vehicle; (ii) death or permanent disablement resulting from that accident; (iii) claim made against owner and insurer. The decision also identifies documentary sources (panchnama, FIR, post-mortem, registration and insurance certificates and rules 291-A & 306-B) which enable the Tribunal to satisfy itself on these matters. The Court applied these principles to hold that the documentary record in the present case met the requirements for a prima facie finding under section 92-A and that the Tribunal erred in dismissing interim compensation without considering those documents and the inferences to be drawn from them.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the purpose and text of section 92-A (no-fault liability) — noting it was introduced by amending Act No. 47 of 1982 and provides Rs. 15,000 as the statutory interim compensation on death under sub‑section (2).

The Court examined the documentary material placed before the Tribunal: the panchnama and F.I.R. which stated the deceased was knocked down by rickshaw No. GRX 281; and the post-mortem report which recorded severe intracranial injuries and opined the cause of death as "shock due to intracranial haemorrhage following head injury."

The Court contrasted this documentary evidence with the driver's sole affidavit: the driver admitted that the deceased "very much came near to his vehicle while crossing the road" and asserted the deceased fainted, that he arranged to send him to hospital, and that a cheque for insurance was signed on 17.2.1989 (with a receipt dated 28.3.1989). The Court observed the driver's affidavit did not explain how such serious head injuries were sustained if the deceased merely fainted, and noted there was no independent evidence produced by the driver to support his account.

Applying the Supreme Court precedent (Shivaji Dayanu Patil), the High Court observed that the specified documents (panchnama, F.I.R., post-mortem, insurance/registration particulars) are precisely those by which a Tribunal can form a prima facie opinion under section 92-A. The Tribunal, however, had not referred to the panchnama or the post-mortem report and had, instead, accepted the driver's affidavit as sufficient to deny interim relief.

The High Court held that the Tribunal's conclusion that "for the present there is no prima facie case and/or evidence to establish that the accident has arisen out of the use of the auto-rickshaw" was contrary to the material on record and therefore unsustainable. The Court emphasized that, while the Tribunal may undertake a summary inquiry or seek supplementary information where doubts exist, it could not discard the prima facie inference flowing from the records merely on the basis of the driver's bald affidavit.

Finding irreparable injury to the petitioners (no compensation had been received and the case was already over five years old), the High Court exercised its revisional jurisdiction under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure to set aside the impugned order. The Court considered whether to remit for a fresh summary inquiry but concluded that the material on record was sufficient to allow the interim application without further remand.

Because insurance particulars were doubtful on the present record, the Court limited the interim direction to the owner (respondent No. 2) while permitting that owner to satisfy the insurer and seek reimbursement in due course. The Court left open the question of insurance coverage for determination in the main claim petition on evidence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The High Court quashed and set aside the impugned order of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal No. 1, Ahmedabad dated 15.3.1991 and allowed the petitioners' interim application under section 92-A.

Specific directions and immediate effects:

  • Respondent No. 2 (owner) is directed to pay the petitioners Rs. 15,000 with interest at 12% per annum calculated from the date of the main claim petition, within six weeks.
  • Respondent No. 2 may, on satisfying respondent No. 5 (the insurer) about the insurance, claim the amount from the insurer; the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal may determine insurance coverage in the main claim on the evidence produced before it.
  • The Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad, is directed to dispose of Claim Petition No. 31 of 1989 preferably within three months from the receipt of the writ following this order.
  • Respondent No. 2 is directed to pay the costs of this civil revision application to the petitioners.
  • The revision petition was allowed (order made absolute in the terms described).

Broader implications: The decision enforces the established principle that a Claims Tribunal must base its prima facie satisfaction under section 92-A on the documentary records identified by precedent (panchnama, F.I.R., post-mortem, registration and insurance documents) and not discard a prima facie inference merely because of a self-serving affidavit by the driver. The Court did not purport to create a new legal principle beyond applying the Supreme Court authority and directing relief in the facts of this case.

    Anitaben And Others v. Abdulhakim Allarkhan Shaikh And Others

    H.L Gokhale, J.:— This civil revision application challenges the order dated 15.3.1991, passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal No. 1, Ahmedabad, in Motor Accident Claim Petition No. 31 of 1989, rejecting the application for interim compensation moved under section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. One Nalinkumar Manubhai Shah, aged about 38 years, reportedly died in an accident caused by an auto-rickshaw bearing No. GRX 281 on 18.2.1989 At the relevant time, the said auto-rickshaw was being driven by the respondent No. 1 and was owned by the respondent No. 2 herein. On that day, at the relevant time, i.e, at about 7.30 a.m Nalinkumar was going to the Ahmedabad Railway Station when he met with the accident while crossing the road and died. He was an employee of the Gujarat Electricity Board. His wife and two minor children, therefore, filed Claim Petition No. 31 of 1989, claiming necessary compensation from the driver, owner and the insurer of the vehicle involved in the accident. The parents of the deceased were joined as respondent Nos. 3 and 4. In that petition, the wife and children moved an interim application seeking, amongst other prayers, an amount of Rs. 15,000/-, under section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, which provides for ‘no fault liability’.

    2. The said application was resisted through the affidavit-in-reply filed by the respondent No. 1 herein and also by United India Insurance Co. Ltd., which had been joined as the insurer in the claim petition, and which is respondent No. 5 herein. The owner of the vehicle, the respondent No. 2 herein, did not file any reply opposing the interim relief, but adopted the one filed by the driver. The driver of the auto-rickshaw stated in his reply that there was no accident as such but, at the relevant time, when his rickshaw was carrying the passengers with their load of vegetables, one person (i.e, Nalin-kumar) was crossing the road and he fainted near the auto-rickshaw. He stated that he arranged to send the person concerned in another auto-rickshaw to a hospital for treatment as a humanitarian gesture and, thereafter, proceeded with his passengers. He has further stated in the reply that insurance premium had been paid by the respondents to the United India Insurance Co. Ltd. by cheque dated 17.2.1989 and they had no responsibility to pay any compensation for the accident. The insurance company stated in its objections that the policy particulars concerning the insurance of the rickshaw were not disclosed to it. The learned advocate for respondent Nos. 1 and 2 has shown me the photocopy of the receipt given by the agent of the said insurance company, mentioned in the driver's reply as referred above. It shows that the owner has signed the cheque concerning the insurance on 17.2.1989, i.e, just one day before the date of accident, but the receipt of the cheque is dated 28.3.1989 Be that as it may, the insurance company stated in its reply that since the existence of the policy was doubtful and even if it did exist, according to it, it did not appear to be legal and valid policy. The papers concerning the police panchnama, post-mortem report, death certificate and the F.I.R were produced before the Claims Tribunal. The nature of injuries is described as follows in the postmortem report:

    “Blood and blood clots all over the brain. Rupture of right and left frontal region and left temporal region of cerebral hemisphere.”

    3. The statements in the panchnama and the F.I.R state that the deceased Nalinkumar was knocked down by the concerned rickshaw bearing No. GRX 281. The postmortem report gives the opinion as to the cause or the probable cause of death as follows:

    “Death caused by shock due to intracranial haemorrhage following head injury.”

    4. The learned Judge of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, however, accepted the plea of the driver made on affidavit. The learned Judge held in para 8 of his order as follows:

    “For the present, there is no prima facie case and/or evidence to establish that the accident has arisen out of the use of the motor vehicle, i.e, auto-rickshaw, and in absence of any such prima facie evidence, no award under section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, can be passed.”

    5. Hence, he rejected the application for interim compensation. Being aggrieved by the said order, the wife and two minor children of the deceased Nalinkumar have filed the present civil revision application.

    6. The advocates for the petitioner and respondent Nos. 1 and 2 have taken me through the material on record and addressed me on their rival contentions. The advocate for the insurance company was not present though they were served. However, before the rival submissions are examined, it will be advisable to refer to the relevant legal provision. section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, has been brought in the statute book with a view to providing for immediate compensation on the principle of no fault liability. The said section was inserted in the said Act by amending Act No. 47 of 1982 and brought in force from 1.10.1982 Sub-section (1) of section 92-A reads as follows:

    “Where the death or permanent disablement of any person has resulted from an accident arising out of the use of a motor vehicle or motor vehicles, the owner of the vehicle shall, or as the case may be, the owners of the vehicles shall, jointly and severally, be liable to pay compensation in respect of such death or disablement in accordance with the provisions of this section.”

    7. The compensation payable is provided at Rs. 15,000/- in sub-section (2) of section 92-A in the event of death.

    8. The provisions of this section came up for consideration before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Shivaji Dayanu Patil v. Vatschala Uttam More, 1991 ACJ 111 (SC). At the end of para 44 and in para 45 thereof, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as follows:

    “Moreover, for awarding compensation under section 92-A of the Act, the Claims Tribunal is required to satisfy itself in respect of the following matters:

    (i) an accident has arisen out of the use of a motor vehicle;

    (ii) the said accident has resulted in permanent disablement of the person who is making the claim or death of the person whose legal representative is making the claim;

    (iii) the claim is made against the owner and the insurer of the motor vehicle involved in the accident.

    45. The documents referred to in rules 291-A and 306-B will enable the Tribunal to ascertain the necessary facts in regard to these matters. The panchnama and the first information report will show whether the accident had arisen out of the use of the motor vehicle in question. The injury certificate or the post-mortem report will show the nature of the injuries and the cause of death. The registration certificate and insurance certificate of the motor vehicle will indicate who is the owner and insurer of the vehicle.”

    9. In the instant case, the above referred documents have been brought on record. The nature of injuries suffered by Nalinkumar, as described in the postmortem report, is serious enough. The cause of death is stated in the said report to be shock due to intracranial haemorrhage following head injury. Undoubtedly, Nalinkumar received serious head injuries due to which he appears to have died. The panchnama and the F.I.R have indicated the cause of death as the rash and negligent driving of auto-rickshaw No. GRX 281 by respondent No. 1. As against this documentary evidence, we have only the driver's affidavit and no other evidence in his support. The driver, in his affidavit, accepts that Nalinkumar very much came near to his vehicle while crossing the road. It is not his case that Nalinkumar was knocked down by any other vehicle. His only plea is that Nalinkumar came near his vehicle and fainted. The driver also states that he immediately arranged to send him to hospital for treatment. He is, however, totally silent as to how Nalinkumar was found to have sustained such serious head injuries leading to his death, though, according to him, Nalinkumar just fainted near his vehicle and yet was required to be immediately hospitalised, in which he helped the injured. The merits of the driver's reply will be examined by the learned Judge of Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal in details at the final hearing of the matter after the regular trial. However, the plea of the driver cannot be allowed to deny or postpone the claim for interim compensation on the basis of ‘no fault liability’, as provided under section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. This is particularly so when in the facts of the present case, there is adequate documentary evidence in support of prima facie inference of the involvement of autorickshaw No. GRX 281 in the said accident and an implicit admission of involvement in the accident in the driver's reply, when the learned Judge recorded “…he clearly says that the person concerned sustained no injury due to fall and not by dashing of rickshaw.” In fact, no submissions were advanced to counter the logical inference which flows from the material on record. The learned Judge, in his impugned order, nowhere refers to panchnama or postmortem report containing the nature of injuries and medical opinion on cause of death, leave aside discussing the inference flowing therefrom. The finding of the learned Judge in para 8 of his order referred to above that, “for the present there is no prima facie case and/or evidence to establish that the accident has arisen out of the use of the auto-rickshaw” is, thus, contrary to the material on record and, therefore, wholly unsustainable and has to be interfered with. It will have to be held that there is prima facie case and evidence to establish that the accident has arisen out of the use of the auto-rickshaw.

    10. As observed by the Supreme Court in the above cited judgment, the relevant rules and the documents concerned contain adequate provisions which would enable the Claims Tribunal to satisfy itself in respect of the matters necessary for awarding compensation under section 92-A of the Act of 1939. The object underlying the enactment of section 92-A is to make available compensation as expeditiously as possible and the said award is to be made before adjudication of the claim under section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. The said object would be defeated if, while determining the interim compensation, the Claims Tribunal is required to hold a regular trial, in the same manner as for adjudicating a claim petition under section 110-A of the Act. This has got to be done on the basis of documentary evidence as provided in the relevant rules. In case the Tribunal entertains any doubts about the correctness of any of the documents, the relevant rules empower the Tribunal to obtain supplementary information from the concerned officers and hold a summary inquiry. However, without doing that, the Tribunal cannot discard, only on the basis of the driver's reply, the prima facie inference which flows from the documents on record as also from the driver's reply. By doing so, the Tribunal has failed to exercise a jurisdiction vested in it. An irreparable injury is already caused to the petitioners. The impugned order, if allowed to stand, would further aggravate the injury. They have received no compensation at all though more than five years have gone since the death of the only bread-earner in their family and the trial of the claim petition is yet not over. In view of the above referred reasons, this is a fit case to interfere and set aside the impugned order in exercise of powers of High Court under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    11. Having interfered with the impugned order, it will have to be examined whether the Tribunal should be now directed to hold a summary inquiry to decide the interim application. Remanding the interim application to the Claims Tribunal for an inquiry, at this stage, will result into further delay in the award of interim compensation. However, as discussed above, there is adequate material on record to satisfy the requirements of section 92-A. The rival advocates have fully addressed me on the interim application. Hence, there is no reason why the interim application should not be allowed. In the facts of the present case, however, the interim application will have to be allowed against the owner only as the exact particulars of the insurance are not available. He may, however, satisfy the insurance company by producing further evidence regarding insurance and claim the amount from it. The present order is on the basis of material on record as of now and the Claims Tribunal will be at liberty to arrive at appropriate conclusion regarding the insurance coverage in the main claim petition on the basis of the evidence that may be produced before it.

    12. Hence, the following order: The impugned order of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal No. 1, Ahmedabad, dated 15.3.1991, in Claim Petition No. 31 of 1989 is quashed and set aside. The interim application of the petitioners is allowed. The respondent No. 2 is directed to pay the petitioner, within six weeks hereof, the sum of Rs. 15,000/- only with interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum thereon calculated from the date of main claim petition, as prayed in para 13(A) of the interim application. Respondent No. 2 may, however, on satisfying the respondent No. 5, insurance company, about the insurance, claim the amount from it. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ahmedabad, shall dispose of main Claim Petition No. 31 of 1989 preferably within three months from the receipt of the writ following this order since the matter is sufficiently old. The rule is thus made absolute in the above terms. Respondent No. 2 will pay to the petitioners the costs of this civil revision application.

    13. Revision petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Anitaben And Others v. Abdulhakim Allarkhan Shaikh And Others
    (Mar 19, 1994)