Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 18(5) of Customs Act inserted by Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act
  • SECTION 86 CUSTOMS ACT 1962
  • rule the provisions of Section 27.
  • sub section 1 of Section 27
  • u/s 74 or 75 of Customs Act.
  • u/s 26 of Customs Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 18(5) of Customs Act inserted by Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act
  • SECTION 86 CUSTOMS ACT 1962
  • rule the provisions of Section 27.
  • sub section 1 of Section 27
  • u/s 74 or 75 of Customs Act.
  • u/s 26 of Customs Act.

    M/S. Atlantic Shipping Pvt. Ltd. /S v. Cc Jamnagar /S.

    Per: Dr. P. Babu: M/s. Atlantic Shipping Pvt. Ltd. filed a refund claim for Rs.4,85,491/- after the customs duty was provisionally assessed at the time of coastal conversion of the vessel for bunkers. This was purported to be excess customs duty. On finalisation of assessment, the original adjudicating authority sanctioned the refund claim but ordered to be credited the amount to consumer welfare fund. Against this Order-in-Original the appellant went to the Commissioner (Appeals) who upheld the Order-in-Original against which the assessee has approached this Tribunal with an appeal.

    2. The appeal of the appellant was rejected by the Commissioner (Appeals) primarily on the following ground; In the absence of any financial records, lump sum contract price charged for the chartered vessel alone is no indicator that there is no unjust enrichment as lump sum charge my be due to various factors and it does not lead to the inevitable conclusion that the incidence of duty has been borne by the owner of the vessel and not passed to the clients using the services of the vessel. The contentions not supported by any material evidences like balance sheet or audited financial documents fall completely short of discharging the statutory obligations cast on them under Section 18(5) read with Section 27 of the Act. The failure of the appellant to produce the necessary evidence goes to show that they have not been able to rebut that the amount claimed by them as refund was not passed on/collected from any other person as envisaged under Section 18(5) read with Section 27 and 28D of the Act.

    3. This conclusion of the Commissioner (Appeals) was strongly refuted by the appellants and one of the main arguments in support of their claim was that their refund claim was submitted considering the Circular No.58/97 dated 06.11.97. The circular reads as follows: 3. Therefore in modification of existing procedure, it has been decided that if the Steamer Agents do not desire to pay duty on the entire quantity of Bonded stores carried by the ship, it is open to them to take the estimated quantity out of the Bonded stores and pay duty on the same. The remaining quantity may remain on board such vessels in terms of Section 86 of the Customs Act 1962. The duty on stores like alcoholic liquor, cigarettes, etc. (other than liquid cargo like diesel, furnace oil etc.) may be recovered on quantity likely to be consumed during coastal run, and remaining quantity may be kept in bond under customs seal as per procedure laid down under Imported Stores (Retention on Board) Regulations, 1963. The Steamer Agents are required to file the Bill of Entry as soon as the conversion takes place, and the assessment would be completed and duty collected within 7 days of the date of conversion to coastal run. The duty on bunkers like diesel, furnace oil etc. may be recovered at 100% (one hundred and ten) of the duty leviable on the quantity estimated to be consumed during the coastal run at the time of conversion from foreign run to coastal run on provisional assessment basis. The steamer agent may file refund claim if any to get refund of duty at the time of reconversion from coastal to foreign run. The assessment may be finalised within 15 day of reconversion from coastal to foreign run.

    4. It was argued by the appellant that in view of the contents of the circular, the refund is due to them and admissible. The issue of show cause notice was also unwarranted and the order for credit of refund amount into the consumer welfare fund is also improper, sustainable and unjustified. It is not denied that the appellant after receipt of the show cause notice submitted copies of certain documents like Xerox copy of the voyage chartered party agreement dated 10.07.07 agreed upon between M/s. Marcel Produce Broker Corporation and M/s. Essar Oil Limited along with Xerox copy of the authorisation issued by M/s. Great Elephant Corporation, Taiwan in favour of M/s. Marcel Produce Broker Corporation, New Delhi. Xerox copy of invoice 2007/AD/01 dated 16.07.07 raised by M/s. Great Elephant Corporation, Taiwan for USD 1,82,687.50 favour of M/s. Essar Oil Ltd. Xerox copy of remittance advice No.20070805751 dated 07.08.07 issued by Bankers DnB NOR Bank ASA, Singapore.

    5. The provisions of refund are governed by Section 27(1) which reads as follows: SECTION 27. Claim for refund of duty. (1)?Any person claiming refund of any duty and interest, if any, paid on such duty

    (i) paid by him in pursuance of an order of assessment; or

    (ii) borne by him, may make an application for refund of such duty and interest, if any, paid on such duty to the Assistant Commissioner of Customs or Deputy Commissioner of Customs (a) in the case of any import made by any individual for his personal use or by Government or by any educational, research or charitable institution or hospital, before the expiry of one year; (b) in any other case, before the expiry of six months, from the date of payment of duty and interest, if any, paid on such duty, in such form and manner as may be specified in the regulations made in this behalf and the application shall be accompanied by such documentary or other evidence (including the documents referred to in section 28C) as the applicant may furnish to establish that the amount of duty and interest, if any, paid on such duty in relation to which such refund is claimed was collected from, or paid by, him and the incidence of such duty and interest, if any, paid on such duty had not been passed on by him to any other person (Emphasis supplied)

    6. The Boards circular cited is only clarificatory in nature and cannot over rule the provisions of Section 27. A plain reading of sub section 1 of Section 27 will make it clear that it is the responsibility of the appellant to submit proper documentary evidence and claimed the refund. Obviously the onus of proof is on the appellant. Commissioner (Appeals) in his order has rightly relied upon the judgment of the Honble High Court of Karnataka in the case of CC Mangalore Vs. Agrotech Foods Ltd. reported in 2010 (249) ELT 348 (Kar.). For the sake of emphasis I reproduce the relevant portion of the judgment. It is as follows; Therefore, a claim for refund to be sustained and to be released can be achieved only in a situation where ultimately the assessee is able to satisfactorily prove before the authorities that such a duty component had not been passed on to the customers of the consumers and it had been actually borne by the assessee itself and then alone, perhaps a refund application would result in flow of some amount to the assessee. But in any other situations, even if it results in a refund of duty, it would flow to the fund and not to the assessee.

    7. The original adjudicating authority had given a clear finding that no records or books of accounts especially the ledgers, balance sheets and schedules to the balance sheet or annual report of M/s. Great Elephant Corporation have been produced by the party. No evidence or cast analysis has been produced in proof that the lump sum freight charged by the M/s. Great Elephant Corporation is exclusive of duty paid. Shri Samir Kumar Sinha, G.M of M/s. Atlantic Shipping Pvt. Ltd. appearing on behalf of the appellants formed favour in the order of this Tribunal in CC Kandla Vs. Ambica Maritime Ltd. reported in 2007 (220) ELT 887 (Tri. Ahmd.). For the purpose of distinguishing the matter, I may quote from the order of the Tribunal which is as follows: As such, it was a case of estimated duty leviable when ultimately the duty liability was finally assessed, at the time of conversion of vessel from coastal run to foreign run, the same was found to be less than the duty deposited by the respondent. The initial deposit of duty was on estimation basis and as such has been rightly held by the Commissioner (Appeals) to be a deposit. The same was a notional amount and the quantity for which the duty was paid was not consumed entirely in India and as such I am of the view that Commissioner (Appeals) has rightly held that the doctrine of unjust enrichment will not be applicable. Revenues appeal is, accordingly, rejected.

    8. While distinguishing, it is to be mentioned here that the doctrine of unjust enrichment applies even when assessment was done on provisional basis. Section 18(5) of Customs Act inserted by Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act w.e.f. 13.7.06, provides that if any amount is found to be refundable after finalisation of provisional assessment, such refund will be subject to doctrine of unjust enrichment. Refund will be granted to importer/exporter only in following cases - * If importer/exporter/buyer has not passed on incidence of the duty to another person. * If imports are made by individual for his personal use. * In case of Refund of export duty, if any, u/s 26 of Customs Act. * In case of Duty drawback payable to exporter u/s 74 or 75 of Customs Act.

    9. In Bussa Overseas Vs. UOI reported in 2003 (158) ELT 135 (Bom. HC DB), it has been held that even in case of customs, refund after provisional assessment is subject to provision of unjust enrichment. It was also held that what is paid at the time of provisional assessment is customs duty and not only deposit same view in CCE Vs. Godavari Fertilisers reported in 2006 (202) ELT 511 (CESTAT).

    10. On explicit analysis, the various contentions of the appellant do not survive neither factually nor legally. I have no hesitation, therefore, to reject the appeal filed by the appellants. Accordingly, I uphold the impugned order of the original adjudicating authority sanctioning of refund and crediting the same to consumer welfare fund as upheld by Commissioner (Appeals). (Pronounced in Court on ___________________) (P. Babu) Member (Technical)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. Atlantic Shipping Pvt. Ltd. /S v. Cc Jamnagar /S.
    (Apr 29, 2011)