Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2015 DHC 7800
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Security Force General Duty Cadre (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment Rules, 2002,
  • sub-rule (2).
  • Officers) Promotion and Seniority Rules 1975,
  • provisions of sub-rule (2)".
  • Rule 8 of the Border Security Force Rules, 2002
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2015 DHC 7800
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Security Force General Duty Cadre (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment Rules, 2002,
  • sub-rule (2).
  • Officers) Promotion and Seniority Rules 1975,
  • provisions of sub-rule (2)".
  • Rule 8 of the Border Security Force Rules, 2002
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion — High Court of Delhi (17 September 2015)

Factual and Procedural Background

These matters comprise multiple writ petitions (W.P.(C) Nos. 5830/2015, 5839/2015, 5853/2015, 2664/2015, 2667/2015 and W.P.(C) No.163/2014) filed in the High Court of Delhi and decided on 17.09.2015 by a Division Bench of S. Ravindra Bhat and Deepa Sharma, JJ. The petitioners were declared successful in recruitment processes (mostly relating to selections held in 1999 with results declared in 2000) for entry into the Border Security Force (BSF). Many of the petitioners were initially declared medically unfit and were later declared fit by Review Medical Boards in 2002–2003. Because of that initial medical unfitness (and in some cases other administrative issues), they joined training and were appointed in later batches (in 2004–2005), rather than with the original cohort that had been declared successful in 2000.

The common grievance raised was that the petitioners should have their seniority and pensionable service reckoned from the date they were declared successful in the original selection process (i.e., around 2000), rather than from the later dates on which they actually joined service. The BSF had given seniority effect from the date of continuous service based on its interpretation of Rule 8 of the Border Security Force Rules, 2002. The petitioners challenged that position and also sought pensionary benefits under the older pension scheme that ceased on 31.12.2003.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners are entitled to have their seniority reckoned with effect from the date they were declared successful in the original selection process (circa 2000), despite having joined service later due to initial medical unfitness and related administrative delays.
  2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to pensionary benefits under the old pension scheme (which ended on 31.12.2003) although they actually joined service after that date because of delays in issuance of appointment letters.
  3. How Rule 8(2) and Rule 8(3) of the Border Security Force General Duty Cadre (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment Rules, 2002 should be interpreted as between (a) seniority based on continuous regular appointment in a rank and (b) seniority of direct-entry Sub-Inspectors determined by merit of selection.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners contended that they were entitled to reckon their seniority and pensionable service from the date they were declared successful in the original selection process and that it was arbitrary to deny them such seniority on the basis of dates they actually joined.
  • They argued that the delay in their joining was not their fault but due to the respondents' processes (for example, delays in conducting Review Medical Boards, administrative delays in issuing appointment letters, and discrepancies in documentation) and thus they should not be prejudiced vis-à-vis batch-mates who joined earlier.
  • They relied on this Court's decisions in Naveen Kumar Jha vs. Union of India (W.P.(C) No.3827/2012) and Avinash Singh vs. Union of India & Ors. (W.P. (C) No.5400/2010) for the proposition that where appointment is by selection, seniority should reflect merit position in the select list rather than the fortuitous date of joining; they also relied on those decisions for the entitlement to the older pension scheme where administrative delay caused joining after 31.12.2003.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents (BSF/Union of India) relied upon the Division Bench ruling in Roop Ram Kundu vs. UOI & Ors. (W.P.(C) No.3342/1999, as cited in the opinion) to support the proposition that seniority is to be determined on the basis of continuous regular appointment in the rank (Rule 8(2)), and that temporary medical unfitness which is subsequently overcome does not entitle the person to seniority from the original selection date when others had already joined.
  • Respondents emphasized the textual primacy of Rule 8(2) (seniority on the basis of continuous regular appointment) over Rule 8(3), and submitted that the petitioners' claims for seniority based on the original select list were inconsistent with the rules governing seniority.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Naveen Kumar Jha vs. Union of India, W.P.(C) No.3827/2012 (decided 02.11.2012) Held that where appointment is by selection, seniority of the entire batch must be reckoned with reference to merit position in the selection and not the date of joining; directed refixation of seniority and consequential promotive consequences in the facts of that case. The petitioners relied on this decision. The Court noted the decision and its observations but explicitly disagreed with its reasoning on seniority in the present matters because, in the present Court's view, those judgments did not discuss a rule comparable to Rule 8 and therefore were not determinative here.
Avinash Singh vs. Union of India & Ors., W.P. (C) No.5400/2010 (decided 26.05.2011) Stated that for selections, seniority should reflect merit position in the select list and not the fortuitous date of joining; observations also used to support entitlement to older pension scheme where administrative delay caused later joining. The Court quoted and considered these observations. While it did not adopt Avinash Singh's approach to seniority (preferring instead Rule 8 analysis and Roop Ram Kundu), the Court found the observations in Avinash Singh relevant and persuasive in relation to the petitioners' claim for entitlement to benefits under the old pension scheme in light of administrative delay in issuing appointment letters.
Roop Ram Kundu vs. UOI & Ors., W.P.(C) No.3342/1999 (as cited; decision discussed) Held that seniority in any rank is to be determined on the basis of continuous regular appointment in that rank (per Rule 19 of the BSF Promotion and Seniority Rules 1975, as applied in that case); rejected seniority claim based on original merit position where appointment and continuous service had commenced later. The Court preferred the view in Roop Ram Kundu and applied its reasoning to the present petitions to conclude that the petitioners could not claim seniority from the original cohort's appointment dates because the petitioners had, as a factual matter, joined and commenced continuous service later.
Ram Pal Deshwal vs. UOI & Ors., W.P.(C) No.393/2008 (decided 07.03.2011) Discussed the scope of sub-rule (2) of Rule 8 and indicated that sub-rule (2) applies in the case of promotion and that the proviso to sub-rule (2) deals with promotions (carving out an exception where promotion is ad-hoc/temporary/stop-gap). Counsel for one petitioner relied upon this decision. The Court analyzed Ram Pal Deshwal but did not adopt its reading of the proviso; instead the Court held that the proviso is confined to promotees and cannot be extended beyond what it prescribes.
S. Sundaram Pillai vs. V.R. Pattabiraman, 1985 SCR (2) 643 Authority cited for the effect of operation of a proviso (legal principle concerning how a proviso limits or shapes the main provision). The Court referenced this authority to support its textual approach to Rule 8, specifically to show that the proviso to Rule 8(2) must be read as carving out a limited exception rather than altering the main rule's ambit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from a close textual reading of Rule 8 of the Border Security Force General Duty Cadre (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment Rules, 2002. The material provisions (reproduced in the opinion) are:

  • Rule 8(1): a general principle that persons holding a higher rank (officiating or substantive) shall be senior to those holding a lower rank.
  • Rule 8(2): seniority in any rank shall be determined on the basis of continuous regular appointment in that rank; the proviso to sub-rule (2) provides that where personnel hold the same rank and were promoted on the same day, seniority shall be determined according to the order of selection for appointment to that post.
  • Rule 8(3): subject to sub-rule (2), seniority of direct entry Sub-Inspector shall be determined in accordance with merit of their selection through the Staff Selection Board (with additional provisos about batches and limited departmental promotions).

From the text, the Court drew the following conclusions (as expressly reflected in the opinion):

  1. Rule 8(2) establishes the primary rule that seniority in a rank is to be determined by continuous regular appointment in that rank. The Court interpreted "appointed to the rank" to imply joining the cadre and commencing continuous service in the post.
  2. Rule 8(3) is expressly made "subject to" Rule 8(2), meaning that Rule 8(2) retains primacy. Rule 8(3) guides inter se merit among direct recruits who are appointed in the same selection process, but it does not displace the main rule that seniority is anchored to continuous, regular appointment.
  3. The proviso to Rule 8(2) is an exception limited to cases where two persons hold the same rank and are promoted on the same day; it governs the order of selection in such special circumstances but does not broadly override the requirement of continuous regular appointment in Rule 8(2).
  4. On this textual basis, the Court concluded that the petitioners—who had been initially declared unfit and only later declared fit by Review Medical Boards, and who therefore commenced continuous service after their originally selected batch—had in fact joined service later and started continuous work in the rank from those later dates. Consequently, Rule 8(2) governed their seniority.
  5. The Court noted it preferred the reasoning in Roop Ram Kundu (which applied the continuous appointment principle) and explicitly declined to follow the approach in Naveen Kumar Jha and Avinash Singh with respect to seniority, observing that those decisions did not discuss a rule analogous to Rule 8 and that adopting them would unsettle settled seniority lists and affect persons not before the Court.
  6. Separately, with respect to pensionary benefits, the Court recognized a distinct line of reasoning: although the petitioners joined later (in 2004–2005), they had been declared medically fit by 2003. Because there was an administrative delay in the issuance of appointment letters resulting in joining after the old pension scheme's cessation (31.12.2003), the Court—relying on and finding relevant the observations in Avinash Singh (as quoted with approval in Naveen Kumar Jha)—held that in the interests of justice the petitioners should be entitled to the benefits of the old pension scheme.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The writ petitions were allowed partly.

Core Rulings:

  • Seniority claims: The petitioners' claims to have their seniority reckoned from the date they were declared successful in the original selection process (circa 2000) were rejected. The Court held that Rule 8(2) requires seniority to be determined on the basis of continuous regular appointment in the rank, and because the petitioners had only commenced continuous service after they were declared fit and joined later batches, they could not claim seniority from the original batch dates.
  • Pensionary benefits: The petitioners were held entitled to the benefits of the old pension scheme (which ended on 31.12.2003) because they had been declared medically fit by 2003 but could not be issued appointment letters and join until 2004–2005 due to administrative delay; in the interests of justice, the Court granted the older pension benefits.

Consequences and practical effects:

  • The petitioners will receive pensionary benefits under the old pension scheme despite their actual dates of joining occurring after 31.12.2003.
  • The petitioners will not be placed for seniority purposes as if they had joined with their original cohort in 2000; their seniority remains determined by the dates on which they commenced continuous regular appointment (i.e., their later dates of joining).
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader implications: The Court emphasized a textual application of Rule 8(2) and preferred the reasoning in Roop Ram Kundu concerning the primacy of continuous regular appointment for seniority. The Court expressly declined to follow other decisions (Naveen Kumar Jha and Avinash Singh) as to seniority because, in the Court's view, those decisions did not consider a provision analogous to Rule 8; the present ruling therefore rests on the Court's interpretation of the recruitment rules as applied to these facts.


Opinion delivered by: Hon'ble Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat and Hon'ble Ms. Justice Deepa Sharma — September 17, 2015.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shoorvir Singh Negi v. Union Of India & Ors

    W.P.(C) No.5830, 5839, 5853, 2664, 2667 of 2015 and 163 of 2014 Page 1 $~$~7 to 9, 12 to 13 and 21

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    Decided on : 17.09.2015

    + W.P.(C) 5830/2015 SHOORVIR SINGH NEGI ..... Petitioner Through: Mr Padma Kumar S., Adv. versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS ..... Respondents

    Through: Ms Saroj Bidawat and Ms Manisha, Advs.

    And

    + W.P.(C) 5839/2015

    RAJIV RANJAN ..... Petitioner Through: Mr Padma Kumar S., Adv. versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS ..... Respondents

    Through: Ms Saroj Bidawat and Ms Manisha, Advs.

    And

    + W.P.(C) 5853/2015

    SATENDRA MOHAN ..... Petitioner Through: Mr Padma Kumar S., Adv. versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS ..... Respondents

    Through: Ms Saroj Bidawat and Ms Manisha, Advs.

    1

    And + W.P.(C) 2664/2015 RAJESH KUMAR SINHA ..... Petitioner Through: Mr Padma Kumar S., Adv. versus

    UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. ..... Respondents

    Through: Mr R.Mishra and Mr M.K. Tiwari, Advs. And

    + W.P.(C) 2667/2015

    PRAMOD KUMAR NAIK ..... Petitioner Through: Mr Padma Kumar S., Adv. versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. ..... Respondents

    Through: Mr R.Mishra and Mr M.K. Tiwari, Advs. along with Mr Arvind Sharma, DC, BSF And

    + W.P.(C) 163/2014

    DEVENDER KUMAR VERMA ..... Petitioner Through: Mr Prashant Sivarajan, Adv. versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS ..... Respondents

    Through: Mr Vivek Goyal, CGSC for respondents along with Mr Arvind Sharma, DC, BSF

    2

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE DEEPA SHARMA

    MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT (OPEN COURT)

    %

    1. In all these petitions, the common grievance urged is that the petitioners are entitled to reckon their seniority and pensionable service with effect from the date they were declared as successful candidates in the original selection process in which they participated The facts pertaining to W.P.(C) Nos.5830/2015, 5839/2015, 5853/2015, 2664/2015 and 2667/2015 are common inasmuch as the petitioners had participated in the recruitment process and were declared successful for the examination held in the year

    2000.

    2. It is contended that the position taken by the Border Security Force (BSF)—the main respondent—in granting seniority with effect from the date of continuous service based upon its interpretation of Rule 8 of the Border Security Force Rules, 2002 is untenable.

    3. The brief facts necessary for deciding the cases are that all petitioners were declared successful in the recruitment process in which they originally participated—mostly in the year 2000. Apparently, the examination was held in 1999 and the results were declared thereafter the next year. The petitioners were initially declared unfit for one reason or the other. When they were declared fit, the petitioners joined the concerned batch/batches according to the availability of vacancies in the batch of training. The facts relating to W.P.(C) No.5830/2015 are that the writ petitioner was found unfit on account of knock knee on 16.03.2002. After his Review Medical

    3

    Board on 17.01.2003, he was declared fit. He thereafter joined in the year 2004. In W.P.(C) No.5839/2015, the petitioner was declared medically unfit on 11.02.2002 on account of hydrocele. He apparently underwent surgery and was subsequently declared fit. However, he could not immediately be appointed because there was a discrepancy in the name as between the certificate produced by him and name disclosed in the application form. Ultimately, he could join only in January, 2005. In W.P.(C) No. 5853/2015, the petitioner was declared unfit on account of hyper tension and obesity. On examination by the Review Board on 18.06.2003 subsequently, he was declared fit; he too joined the service later sometime in 2004. In W.P.(C) No.2664/2015, the petitioner was declared unfit on account of hydrocele. On account of the subsequent corrective surgery, he was examined by the Review Medical Board which declared him fit on 16.01.2003. He joined the BSF subsequently in the later batch. In W.P.(C) No. 2667/2015, the petitioner was declared medically unfit on account of ear problem Chronic Suppurative Otitis Media (COSM). The subsequent Review Medical Board in February, 2003 declared him fit. He was subsequently appointed in 2004. The facts of W.P.(C) No.164/2015 are somewhat different. There appears to be an error in the medical examination as it was declared that he did not fulfil the requite height standard and was short by 0.5 centimetre. The result of the Medical Board was declared on 25.01.2002. The petitioner sought review medical examination which was done on 17.04.2002. He was declared fit on 11.11.2002 and he subsequently joined the BSF.

    4. All the writ petitioners contend that on account of the respondent's fault, they were kept away from employment and consequently made to report in subsequent batches—not along with other recruits who were

    4

    appointed in earlier batches. In other words, the petitioners joined subsequent batches of training unlike those who had participated in the year 2000 selection/recruitment process. This was not on account of their fault, but the BSF's own processes. It was submitted that consequently the interpretation placed upon Rule 8(2) and 8(3) to deny them the seniority at par with their batches originally joined, is arbitrary. Learned counsel for the petitioners relied upon the decision of this Court in Naveen Kumar Jha vs. Union of India, W.P.(C) No.3827/2012 (decided on 02.11.2012). The Court on that occasion had relied upon a decision of this Court's earlier ruling in

    Avinash Singh vs. Union of India & Ors. W.P. (C) No.5400/2010, (decided on 26.05.2011). The Court in Avinash Singh (supra) highlighted as follows:-

    "17. It is settled law that if appointment is by selection, seniority of the entire batch has to be reckoned with respect to the merit position obtained in the selection and not on the fortuitous circumstance on the date on which a person is made to join.

    18. We highlight in the instant case the fortuitous circumstance of the petitioners being made to join as Assistant Commandant on 08.08.2005 is not the result of anything created by the petitioners but is a result of a supine indifference and negligence on the part of the ITBP officials.

    19. Thus, petitioners would be entitled to their seniority as Assistant Commandant with respect to their batch-mates in the context of the merit position in the select panel. We make it clear, the seniority as Assistant Commandant of the entire batch would be a reflection of the merit position in the select list and not the date of joining."

    5

    5. In Naveen Kumar Jha (supra), after noticing the above observations, the Division Bench directed as follows:-

    "11. On facts it needs to be noted that the seven petitioners of WP(C) No.5400/2010 had lost out on their seniority with reference to their merit position in the Select List due to delay in conducting their Review Medical Evaluation and in the interregnum their batchmates had joined ITBP.

    12. On parity of reasoning and application of law the petitioner is held entitled to his seniority being refixed as a Sub-Inspector in CRPF with reference to his merit position at the SSC Combined Graduate Level 2000 Examination i.e. those who joined CRPF pursuant to the said examination in March 2003. The petitioner has already earned promotion to the post of Inspector and accordingly we direct that he would be entitled to seniority refixed in said rank with reference to his revised seniority position in the rank of Sub-Inspector, and this would mean that the petitioner would be considered for promotion to the post of Assistant Commandant as per the revised seniority list.

    13. The respondents are therefore directed to revise the seniority position of the petitioner in the two ranks within a period of four weeks from today and thereafter consider the petitioner along with other eligible persons for promotion to the post of Assistant Commandant."

    6. It is also argued that the petitioners cannot be made to suffer with respect to pensionary benefits on account of the fact that the delay was caused by the respondents in issuing the appointment letters. Having been declared fit by the Review Medical Board in all cases in 2002-2003, the fortuitous circumstance that the appointment letters led to their joining after the new pension scheme came into force could not deprive them of the more

    6

    beneficial provisions of the older pension scheme which ended on 31.12.2003. In support of this argument, learned counsel relied upon Naveen Kumar Jha (supra).

    7. Learned counsel for the respondents relied upon an earlier Division Bench ruling of this Court in Roop Ram Kundu vs. UOI & Ors. W.P.(C) No.3342/1999 (decided on 16.08.2012). In that case, the petitioner had been declared temporarily unfit and was subject to another medical examination conducted later. He had overcome the medical problem from which he was temporarily suffering and was subsequently declared fit barely two months after the original declaration of unfitness. The Court rejected the claim for seniority based upon the original results and stated as follows:-

    "6. Thus any challenge to petitioner's temporary medical unfitness as per the review medical board became a matter which no longer is capable of being adjudicated upon by any Court.

    7. However, taking into account that the petitioner was being declared temporarily medically unfit, the authorities subjected the petitioner to another medical examination which was conducted in July 19, 1996. The petitioner had overcome the medical problem from which he was temporarily suffering. He was opined to be medically fit and accordingly an appointment letter dated September 17, 1996 was issued.

    8. Now, the petitioner prays that he be accorded seniority as per his merit position obtained at the examination with all consequential benefits.

    9. Suffice would it be to state that as per Rule 19 of the BSF (Subordinate Officers and Under Officers) Promotion and Seniority Rules 1975, seniority in any rank has to be determined on the basis of continuous regular appointment in that rank.

    7

    10. Being repeatedly declared temporarily medical unfit, till he was declared fit in September, 1996 resulting in appointment letter being issued on September 17, 1996, would require petitioner to be placed with respect to seniority, not with reference to the merit position which he had obtained when the examination was conducted in the year 1992 more so for the reason W.P.(C) No.149/1996 filed by the petitioner stands dismissed in default and revival whereof has not been prayed for."

    8. The Border Security Force General Duty Cadre (Non-Gazetted) Recruitment Rules, 2002, to the extent they are relevant, are extracted below:-

    "8. Seniority—(1) Persons holding a higher rank whether in an officiating or substantive capacity shall be senior to the persons holding a lower rank.

    (2) Seniority in any rank shall be determined on the basis of continuous regular appointment in that rank. Provided that the seniority of the personnel holding the same rank and promoted on the same day shall be determined in accordance with the order of selection for appointment to that post.

    (3) Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (2) seniority of direct entry Sub-Inspector shall be determined in accordance with merit of their selection through Staff Selection Board. Provided that the persons selected on an earlier batch will be senior to those selected in subsequent batches. Provided further that the seniority of Constables/Head Constables selected under Limited Departmental Competitive Examination Scheme as Sub-Inspector against reserved quota shall be determined in accordance with their merit of selection

    8

    and shall be placed below the Sub-Inspector (Direct Entry) batch with whom they join training."

    9. The petitioners highlight Rule 8(3) to say that seniority of direct entry Sub-Inspector would be determined in accordance with the merit of their selection through Staff Selection Board. Although this argument is attractive, the fact remains Rule 8(3) expressly states that it is "subject to provisions of sub-rule (2)". This in turn means that the primary rule is

    "continuous regular appointment in that rank". This Court is of the opinion that the question of an individual being "appointed to the rank" would imply his joining the cadre. In all these cases, the petitioners do not dispute that they had joined the cadre or the concerned post only after they were declared medically fit by the Review Medical Board—in 2003. Though they were initially declared successful in the recruitment process, their medical conditions constituted a barrier for their entry into the service. That barrier was lifted on account of their overcoming unfitness and the subsequent determination of the Review Medical Board. Obviously, therefore, they joined and started continuously working in the post of Sub-Inspector from the later dates. This interpretation is supported by the judgment in Roop Ram Kundu (supra)—a proceeding initiated as far back as in 1999 when the petitioner claimed seniority of merely three months. He was initially declared temporary unfit in July, 1999, but was subsequently declared successful in September, 1999. In the interregnum in Roop Ram Kundu

    (supra), the original batch to which he belonged had already joined the training. He was, therefore, directed to join the subsequent batch. This Court is of the opinion that the BSF's position cannot be faulted given the fact that he entered the cadre or joined the post subsequently.

    9

    10. At some stage, counsel in one of the proceedings W.P.(C) No.163/2014, relied upon the order in Ram Pal Deshwal vs. UOI & Ors. W.P.(C) No.393/2008 (decided on 07.03.2011) to state that Rule 8(2) is really meant for regulating seniority of promotees. In Ram Pal Deshwal

    (supra), the Court observed as follows:-

    14. Suffice would it be to state that sub-rule (2) would apply in case of promotion and where the promotion is ad-hoc, temporary or stop-gap i.e. fortuitous, seniority would rank on the basis of continuous regular employment. The proviso to sub-rule (2) makes clear the ambit of the sub-rule. The proviso deals with promotions and carves out an exception to what is contemplated by sub-rule (2). The proviso, therefore, highlights the ambit of sub-rule (2).

    11. This Court is of the opinion that Rule 8(1) firstly states a general principle, i.e., those holding higher rank whether in an officiating or substantive capacity would be senior to persons those holding a lower rank. Rule 8(2) then prescribes a principle of universal application. i.e., the seniority in any rank "shall" be determined on the basis of continuous regular appointment in that rank. Thirdly, the proviso of Rule 8(2) states that the seniority of the two individuals holding the same rank "and promoted on the same day" shall be determined in accordance with the order of selection for appointment to that post. In other words, the provision carves out an exception from the general rule prescribed in Rule 8(2) of seniority on the basis of the regular appointment to the rank. The exception is that in case of promotees, the seniority is to be determined "in accordance with the order of selection for appointment to that post". However, the proviso is silent as to the matters left out which are part of the main provision, i.e., Rule 8(2). The corollary irresistibly, therefore is that Rule 8(2) applies for other

    10

    categories, i.e., direct recruits. If one were to construe Rule 8(2) in this manner, the mandate of Rule 8(3), i.e., that seniority of direct entry Sub- Inspector would be determined in accordance with the merit of their selection, is a rule to guide inter se merit of those who are appointed in the same selection process. However, it would not in any way disturb or detract from the application of Rule 8(2), i.e., the seniority in the rank has to be determined on the basis of continuous regular appointment.

    12. This Court does not read proviso to Rule 8(2) in the manner sought to be urged or as appears to have been read in Ram Pal Deswal (supra). This is for the simple reason that the provision carves out an exception only for promotees and its intendment cannot be extended beyond what is prescribed. (see S.Sundaram Pillai vs. V.R.Pattabiraman, 1985 SCR (2) 643 for the effect of operation of proviso).

    13. Respectfully, we differ from Naveen Kumar Jha (supra) and Avinash Singh (supra) as we find that no discussion of a rule akin to Rule 8 has been made in these judgments. In our opinion Rule 8 is determinative of the question of how seniority must be calculated for the present petitioners. We are also mindful that interfering in the manner sought will upset already settled seniority lists and affect persons who are not parties before us. We prefer instead the view taken in Roop Ram Kundu (supra), a decision that was not brought to the notice of the court in either Naveen Kumar Jha (supra) or Avinash Singh (supra).

    14. In view of the above discussion, we are of the opinion that the petitioners claim for seniority from the date their batch mates or original batch mates who were otherwise appointed in the normal circumstances in 2000-2001 cannot succeed.

    11

    15. As far as the claim for pensionary benefits based upon the old pension scheme which ended on 31.12.2003 is concerned, we are of the opinion that a somewhat different result would have to follow. Undoubtedly, all the petitioners were declared medically fit by 2003. However, they could not be issued with appointment letters and joined subsequently in 2004 or 2005. It is here that the observations in Avinash Singh (supra) quoted with approval in Naveen Kumar Jha (supra) become relevant. Although the petitioners were declared fit earlier—at least much before the cessation of the old pension rules, there was an administrative delay in the issuance of the appointment letter asking them to join training. In these circumstances, in the interests of justice, we hold that they should be entitled to the benefits of the old pension scheme.

    16. The writ petitions are allowed partly to the above extent, i.e., that the petitioners are entitled to the benefits of the old pension scheme. No costs.

    S. RAVINDRA BHAT

    (JUDGE)

    DEEPA SHARMA

    (JUDGE)

    SEPTEMBER 17, 2015

    BG

    12

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shoorvir Singh Negi v. Union Of India & Ors
    (Sep 17, 2015)