Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Assigned) 1995 Rules, the Kerala Land Assignment (Regularization of Occupants of Forest Lands prior to 1.1.1997) Special Rules, 1993 and Preservation of Trees Act
  • Kerala Land Assignment (Regularization of Occupation of Forest Lands prior to 1-1-1977) Special Rules, 1993 (for short, the Special Rules).
  • Section 2(e) of the Preservation of Trees Act, casts any criminal liability.8. Rule 13 of the Special Rules
  • KERALA PRESERVATION OF TREES ACT 1986
  • Rules, 1993, both the Preservation of Trees Act and 1995 Rules
  • SECTION 7 KERALA GOVERNMENT LAND ASSIGNMENT ACT 1960
  • Section 61D of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961 (for short, the Act)
  • Section 2(e) of the Preservation of Trees Act,
  • Assigned) Rules, 1995 (for short, the 1995 Rules)
  • Rules and the Preservation of Trees Act
  • Rule 7. Section 2(c) of the Forest Act
  • SECTION 52 FOREST ACT
  • Preservation of Trees Act 1986,
  • Section 2(c) of the Forest Act.
  • Rule 7 of 1995 Rules
  • Section 76(f)
  • Section 2(e)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Assigned) 1995 Rules, the Kerala Land Assignment (Regularization of Occupants of Forest Lands prior to 1.1.1997) Special Rules, 1993 and Preservation of Trees Act
  • Kerala Land Assignment (Regularization of Occupation of Forest Lands prior to 1-1-1977) Special Rules, 1993 (for short, the Special Rules).
  • Section 2(e) of the Preservation of Trees Act, casts any criminal liability.8. Rule 13 of the Special Rules
  • KERALA PRESERVATION OF TREES ACT 1986
  • Rules, 1993, both the Preservation of Trees Act and 1995 Rules
  • SECTION 7 KERALA GOVERNMENT LAND ASSIGNMENT ACT 1960
  • Section 61D of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961 (for short, the Act)
  • Section 2(e) of the Preservation of Trees Act,
  • Assigned) Rules, 1995 (for short, the 1995 Rules)
  • Rules and the Preservation of Trees Act
  • Rule 7. Section 2(c) of the Forest Act
  • SECTION 52 FOREST ACT
  • Preservation of Trees Act 1986,
  • Section 2(c) of the Forest Act.
  • Rule 7 of 1995 Rules
  • Section 76(f)
  • Section 2(e)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition was filed by the Divisional Forest Officer and the forest officials of the Kerala Government under Section 61D of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961, challenging the District Court, Ernakulam's judgment in C.M.A No. 97 of 2010. The first respondent owns a mini lorry and the second respondent owns a pick-up van. It was alleged that on 18.06.2010 both vehicles were used to transport 37 pieces of various species of forest timber illegally felled from land belonging to Josepheena @ Thankama in Kuttampuzha Village. The vehicles were seized by forest officials on allegations of offences punishable under Section 27(d) and (e) of the Kerala Forest Act; a mahazar was prepared and Crime No. 8/10 of the Pooyamkutty Forest Station registered; the final report was placed before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kothamangalam and the criminal case was pending.

The authorized officer under Section 61A of the Act initiated confiscation proceedings in respect of both vehicles. By order dated 09.09.2010 the officer held that both vehicles were used to transport forest timber and ordered confiscation under Section 61A(2). Respondents 1 and 2 challenged that confiscation before the District Court which allowed the appeal and ordered release of the vehicles. The present revision challenges the District Court's legal conclusion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the vehicles were involved in the transportation of any forest timber on 18.06.2010 (as alleged).
  2. Whether cutting, removal or transportation of trees that are specifically referred to in a pattayam (land assignment document) but are not among the ten species named in Section 2(e) of the Kerala Preservation of Trees Act, 1986, constitutes a forest offence under the Kerala Forest Act and the Rules made thereunder (notably the 1995 Rules).
  3. Whether the District Court's reliance on the Preservation of Trees Act alone to deny confiscation was legally correct, given the Special Rules (1993) and the Kerala Forest (Prohibition of Felling of Trees Standing on Land Temporarily or Permanently Assigned) Rules, 1995.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments (owners of the vehicles)

  • The trees were cut from pattayam land (assigned land) and there was no statutory prohibition on cutting such trees; therefore transporting them did not amount to a forest offence.
  • Although the pattayam lists several species in its schedule, the obligation to preserve trees under the Special Rules is limited by Rule 13 to trees as defined in the Preservation of Trees Act; ergo, only the ten species named in Section 2(e) of that Act are protected.
  • Since the specific trees (anjili and maruta) allegedly transported are not among the ten species in the Preservation of Trees Act, their cutting/transportation does not amount to a forest offence.
  • If the pattayam imposes restrictions in excess of the enabling statute or Rules, such excess restriction binds the assignor only; a third party (such as the respondents) can plead ignorance of that fact (though not ignorance of law), and therefore cannot be held criminally liable on that basis.

Revision Petitioner / Government's Arguments

  • The Preservation of Trees Act, though limited to ten species, is distinct from the Special Rules and the 1995 Rules; the latter were promulgated under the Kerala Forest Act and specifically regulate/prohibit felling/cutting on assigned lands.
  • The 1995 Rules (framed under Section 30(c) and Section 76(f) & (g) of the Kerala Forest Act) declare that trees standing on lands temporarily or permanently assigned, where government rights are reserved, are the absolute property of the government (Rule 3) and prohibit felling without sanction (Rule 4), with infringement punishable under Rule 7.
  • Acts punishable under Rule 7 of the 1995 Rules fall within the definition of 'forest offence' under Section 2(c) of the Forest Act and are therefore liable to confiscation proceedings under Section 52 of the Forest Act; consequently, cutting/transporting trees named in the pattayam can be a forest offence even if those species are not in the Preservation of Trees Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Baby v. The Forest Range Officer, 1986 (2) ILR Kerala 57 The court should be slow to give a narrow interpretation to statutory provisions enacted to prevent large-scale depredation of forest wealth and to protect ecology. Used to support the proposition that statutes and rules protecting forests must be interpreted strictly and purposively (not narrowly) to prevent ecological harm.
Divisional Forest Officer v. Balakrishnan (1986 KLT S.N 61 page 38) Under Article 51A of the Constitution every citizen has a duty to safeguard forest wealth; assaults on forest wealth must be viewed seriously. Invoked to underline constitutional duty and the need for strict approach in interpreting protective forest provisions.
State Of Kerala v. P.P Mathew & Anr., 1995 (2) KLT 772 Reiterated the necessity of strict interpretation of statutes intended for protection of forest wealth. Cited to bolster the court's stance favoring stringent application of forest-protective laws and rules in confiscation and penal contexts.
State Of Kerala v. Marina Varghese, 1999 (2) KLT 469 Affirmed the need for strict interpretation of confiscatory provisions related to forest protection. Relied upon to reinforce the principle that protective/confiscatory provisions should not be narrowly construed where forest conservation is at stake.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed the short question as whether the vehicles were involved in transportation of forest timber. It noted that the land belonged to Josepheena @ Thankama and a pattayam had been issued under the Kerala Land Assignment (Regularization of Occupation of Forest Lands prior to 1-1-1977) Special Rules, 1993 (the "Special Rules").

The court examined the content of the pattayam: the schedule lists certain species (including anjili and maruta), and the pattayam contains conditions vesting rights over "forest trees" mentioned in the schedule with the government forest department and obliging the assignee to maintain such trees and to permit inspection/removal by forest officials. Clause 7 of the order of assignment refers to the Preservation of Trees Act, though the pattayam itself does not expressly incorporate that Act; both documents nevertheless denote the listed trees as "forest trees."

The court considered the respondents' reliance on Rule 13 of the Special Rules (which refers to trees as defined in the Preservation of Trees Act) and their argument that obligations were consequently confined to the ten species in Section 2(e) of the Preservation of Trees Act. The court accepted the government's counter-argument that separate statutory instruments operate for different, complementary purposes: the Preservation of Trees Act addresses a limited list of species, the Special Rules govern assignment and the terms of pattayam, and the 1995 Rules (made under the Kerala Forest Act) impose restrictions on felling/transport of trees standing on assigned lands where government rights are reserved.

The court analyzed the 1995 Rules: Rule 3 declares such trees the absolute property of the Government; Rule 4 prohibits felling/cutting/maiming without sanction; Rule 7 prescribes punishment for infringement. Because Section 2(c) of the Forest Act defines a "forest offence" to include offences punishable under the Act or rules made thereunder, acts punishable under Rule 7 of the 1995 Rules fall within the definition of a forest offence and attract confiscation proceedings under Section 52 of the Forest Act.

Relying on the purposive need to preserve ecological balance and established precedent favoring strict interpretation of forest-protective laws (as cited), the court concluded that where land is covered by a pattayam under the Special Rules, the 1995 Rules apply and the assignee is bound by the pattayam to preserve the trees listed therein even if those species do not appear among the ten species in the Preservation of Trees Act. To read down a pattayam clause merely because the Preservation of Trees Act lists fewer species would be to do violence to the terms of the assignment.

The court held that cutting, removal and transportation of at least two species listed in the pattayam (anjili and maruta), although not covered by the Preservation of Trees Act, are cognizable as offences under the 1995 Rules and thereby under the Forest Act. It found that the lower court erred in relying solely on the Preservation of Trees Act and remitted the matter to the lower appellate court for fresh consideration in light of this legal conclusion. The court observed that because the District Court allowed the appeal on a legal interpretation, it had not considered other possible defenses available to the respondents; thus a fresh consideration was required.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision is allowed; the impugned order of the District Court is set aside and the matter is remitted to the lower appellate court for fresh consideration in light of the Court's legal conclusions. Both sides are directed to appear before the lower appellate court on 24.11.2015.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The District Court's order releasing the vehicles has been set aside and the confiscation matter must be re-decided by the lower appellate court applying the legal position articulated by this Court.
  • Legal consequence articulated by the Court: For land covered by a pattayam under the Special Rules, the Kerala Forest (Prohibition of Felling of Trees Standing on Land Temporarily or Permanently Assigned) Rules, 1995 apply; cutting, removal or transportation of trees specifically mentioned in a pattayam can constitute a forest offence under the 1995 Rules and therefore under the Kerala Forest Act even if those species are not among the ten species listed in the Kerala Preservation of Trees Act, 1986.
  • The Court found the lower court's reliance on the Preservation of Trees Act alone to be legally unsustainable and a manifest error; the matter is remitted for reconsideration and any other defenses available to respondents are to be examined by the lower appellate court.

    Divisional Forest Officer v. P.M. Jalal

    Sunil Thomas, J.:— This revision at the instance of the Divisional Forest Officer and the forest officials of the Kerala Government, filed under Section 61D of the Kerala Forest Act, 1961 (for short, “the Act”) is directed against the Judgment of the District Court, Ernakulam in C.M.A No. 97 of 2010

    2. The first respondent is the owner of a mini lorry and the second respondent is the owner of a pick up van. It was alleged that on 18.06.2010, both the above vehicles were used to transport 37 pieces of different species of forest timber illegally felled from the property belonging to one Josepheena @ Thankama, situated in Kuttampuzha Village. The vehicles were seized by the forest officials alleging commission of offences punishable under Section 27(d) and (e) of the Act. The mahazar was prepared and Crime No. 8/10 of the Pooyamkutty Forest Station was registered. After investigation, final report was laid before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kothamangalam and the crime is pending.

    3. The first revision petitioner herein, who is the authorized officer under Section 61A of the Act, initiated confiscation proceedings with respect to both the vehicles. After notice to all concerned, by order dated 09.09.2010, it was held that both the vehicles were used for transporting forest timber and thereby involved in the commission of the forest offences and ordered confiscation under Section 61A(2) of the Act. This was challenged by respondents 1 and 2 herein before the District Court, which allowed the appeal by the impugned judgment and ordered release of the vehicles. The legality and correctness of that finding is challenged in this revision.

    4. The short question on which the entire issue is formulated is whether the vehicles were involved in the transportation of any forest timber. Admittedly, Josepheena @ Thankama had been issued a pattayam under the Kerala Land Assignment (Regularization of Occupation of Forest Lands prior to 1-1-1977) Special Rules, 1993 (for short, “the Special Rules”). The precise contention set up by the owners of the vehicles was that trees were allegedly cut from the pattayam land and there was no prohibition in cutting such trees.

    5. The species of trees allegedly cut are Jackfruit trees, Maruta, Angili, Venga, Mango tree and Payyani. A schedule is seen incorporated in the Pattayam, which refer to the few species of trees by name, which are teak, Anjili, Maruta, Vellilavu, Cheeni and Mullu venga. The first condition in the pattayam is that the entire right over all forest trees standing in the assigned land and specifically referred to in the Schedule vests with the government forest department, and the assignee is bound to maintain all trees existing at the time of assignment and such trees as may be grown in the property later. Second condition is that the assignee shall assist the forest officials to enter the property to inspect such trees, from time to time and if necessary, to remove such trees. However, Clause 7 of Order of Assignment of Registry enjoins that ‘"identified forest trees, viz, teak, rosewood, sandalwood, blackwood, ebony, etc, and mentioned in the Kerala Preservation of Trees Act, 1986 (Act 35 of 1986) in the land shall be accounted and preserved by Forest Department”. Evidently, the assignment order refers to the preservation of Trees Act, though the pattayam does not refer to that Act. However, both the documents denote the trees as “forest trees”. The Preservation of Trees Act does not define “forest tree”. It defines only “tree” under Section 2(e) with reference to the specific species of trees mentioned therein. The trees mentioned therein are sandal wood, teak, rosewood, irul, thempavu, kampakam, chempakam, chadachi, chandana vempu and cheeni. Since “forest tree” is not defined, the term can have only the literal meaning of trees grown in a forest. The contention of the owners of the vehicles was that if few trees other than those referred to in the Kerala Preservation of Trees Act, 1986 (Act 35 of 1986) (for short, “Preservation of Trees Act”) are mentioned in the order of assignment or patta, either mistakenly or fraudulently, that did not create any legal obligation on the assignee to preserve such trees.

    6. However, the pattayam is the formal document of title and is issued in accordance with Form 6 of the Special Rules and hence, it is liable to be relied on as the formal deed of title. The restriction imposed in Pattayam is absolute and without reference to any restriction imposed by any statute. Hence, the covenant binds the parties, runs with the land and the assignee and his successors in interest, are not entitled to cut any tree mentioned in the Schedule of the pattayam. Since the land assigned once formed part of forest and was assigned to the holder, being the person in possession prior to 1977, only by virtue of the Special Rules, the assignment is not unconditional, but restrictive, subject to the Rules and conditions incorporated in the pattayam.

    7. Now it has to be examined whether cutting of the trees covered by Pattayam issued under the Special Rules constitute a forest offence as defined under Section 2(c) of the Forest Act. Admittedly, none of the trees which were allegedly transported by the respondents is included in 10 species of trees specifically referred to in Section 2(e) of the Preservation of Trees Act. However, among the several species of trees that were cut and removed, the trees specifically referred to in the patta are anjili and maruta. Hence, the issue involved in the present case narrows down to whether the act of transporting the above two species of trees referred to in the patta, but are not covered by Section 2(e) of the Preservation of Trees Act, amounts to an offence. In other words, whether cutting of any tree mentioned in the patta, but, not forming the species of trees mentioned in Section 2(e) of the Preservation of Trees Act, casts any criminal liability.

    8. Rule 13 of the Special Rules provides that “the trees as defined in the Preservation of Trees Act 1986, as described in the patta issued to the assignee shall be accounted for and preserved by the Forest Department.” Relying on this, Mr. Mathew Kuriakose, the learned counsel for the respondents, contended that though condition no. 1 of pattayam may appear to cover all trees mentioned in the Schedule, by virtue of Rule 13, the obligation of assignee was limited to such of the trees mentioned in the Schedule as are the trees covered by Preservation of Trees Act. The crux of the contention was that since the Rule applied only to trees as defined in the Kerala Preservation of Trees Act, the holder of pattayam was not statutorily bound to preserve such of the trees covered by the preservation of Trees Act, notwithstanding the mentioning of more species of trees in the Pattayam than covered by the Act.

    9. The argument of the learned counsel was that though anjili and maruta, which were the only two species of trees referred to in the patta and were allegedly transported by the respondents, were not trees covered by the Preservation of Trees Act, it does not amount to commission of a forest offence. It was further contended that when the Special Rules and the Preservation of Trees Act do not bar or impose any restriction with respect to trees other than the 10 species of trees specifically named in the Preservation of Trees Act, the revenue authorities while issuing the patta could not have imposed a further restriction regarding other trees also. It was contended that when the Rules specifically refer to trees as defined in Preservation of Trees Act, the obligation of the assignee was confined to such trees alone, and even if more trees are referred to in the pattayam, it was inconsequential, being in excess of Rules. A further contention was set up that even assuming that the cutting of trees other than those mentioned in the Preservation of Trees Act are prohibited, by virtue of being included in the patta and thereby casts a criminal liability, it should not implicate respondents herein, since such restriction was not known to the respondents. The premise of such contention was that, if there is restriction in the patta with regard to trees in excess of the enabling statute, that binds the assignor only and being a question of fact, a third party can legitimately set up a plea of ignorance of fact, though he cannot plead ignorance of law.

    10. Mr. M.P Madhavankutty, learned Spl. Government Pleader (Forest) who effectively countered the above contention pointed out that Preservation of Trees Act is a distinct statute specifically enacted, for the purpose of restricting the indiscriminate felling and destruction of trees in the State of Kerala resulting in considerable soil erosion and destruction and loss of the timber wealth of the State, though, the Act is confined to 10 named trees mentioned therein and the restriction under the Act was subject to Section 5 of the Act. However, the Special Rules were issued by the Government invoking powers under Section 7 of the Kerala Government Land Assignment Act, 1960. It provides for assignment of land alone, which were in possession of the occupants prior to 1977.

    11. It is pertinent to note that the Kerala Forest (Prohibition of Felling of Trees Standing on Land Temporarily or Permanently Assigned) Rules, 1995 (for short, “the 1995 Rules”) were promulgated by the Government invoking the powers conferred under Section 30(c), Section 76(f) and (g) of the Kerala Forest Act. Section 30(c) of the Act authorizes the Government to frame Rules to regulate or prohibit the cutting, sawing, conversion and removal of trees and timber, its collection and its removal. Section 76(f) empowers the Government to frame of Rules to regulate or prohibit, the felling cutting and such other activities of trees standing on land temporarily or permanently assigned, the right of Government over which has been expressly reserved in the deed of grant. The 1995 Rule is intended to impose a restriction with respect to the trees which stand in the assigned land. Rule 3 declare that all trees, standing on lands temporarily or permanently assigned, the right of the Government over which has been expressly reserved in the deed of grant or order of assignment of such land, shall be the absolute property of Government. Rule 4 prohibit, felling, cutting or maiming of any tree covered by Rule 3, without the sanction of the competent authority. An infringement of the above Rule is an offence punishable under Rule 7. Section 2(c) of the Forest Act defines a forest offence as an offence punishable under the Forest Act or Rules made thereunder. Consequently, an act liable for punishment under Rule 7 of 1995 Rules falls within the definition of a forest offence and hence liable for confiscation proceedings under Section 52 of the Forest Act.

    12. Evidently, the Kerala Forest (Prohibition of Felling of Trees Standing on Land Temporarily or Permanently Assigned) 1995 Rules, the Kerala Land Assignment (Regularization of Occupants of Forest Lands prior to 1.1.1997) Special Rules, 1993 and Preservation of Trees Act operate for three different specific objects and purposes. With respect to a land covered under the Special Rules, 1993, both the Preservation of Trees Act and 1995 Rules apply with respect to the trees covered thereby. The assignee is bound by the terms of the pattayam and are bound to preserve all trees, mentioned in pattayam, notwithstanding that they may not be covered by the Preservation of Trees Act. Reading down or narrowing scope of a clause in the patta on the basis of the Preservation of Trees Act alone, will be amounting to doing violence to the restriction under which the grant was made. Cutting of such trees may visit with penal consequences under the Kerala Forest Act.

    13. This is essentially because the object of the above Statutes and Rules include Preservation of ecological balance, protection of soil and other issues which have a direct bearing on the sustenance and protection of environment. The need for strict interpretation of statutes intended for protection of the forest wealth, which is a treasure of the nation, has been considered in the various decisions of this Court earlier. In Baby v. The Forest Range Officer (1986 (2) ILR Kerala 57), the learned Single Judge had held that when the legislature had taken note of the colosal depredation of the forest wealth, and when it is scientifically established that such wanton waste of forest-cover would take the country perilously near desertification and a total disturbance of the ecology and environment, the court should be slow to give a narrow interpretation to well-meant statutory provisions. This was approved by the decision in Divisional Forest Officer v. Balakrishnan (1986 KLT S.N 61 page 38), wherein it was held that under Article 51A of the Constitution of India, it is fundamental duty of every citizen to safeguard the forest wealth and an assault on the forest wealth of the country has therefore necessarily to be viewed with all seriousness. The necessity of giving strict interpretation while interpreting the confiscatory provisions of the Act, which otherwise would lead to disastrous consequences of forest wealth, which is a very endangered bounty of nature, was reiterated by this Court in the decisions in State Of Kerala v. P.P Mathew & Anr. (1995 (2) KLT 772) and in State Of Kerala v. Marina Varghese (1999 (2) KLT 469). The Constitutional mandate under Articles 48A and 51A(g) and the statutory obligation imposes an obligation on the assignee also to preserve such trees in trust for the Governemnt.

    14. In the light of above, with respect to the land covered by patta issued under the Special Rules, the 1995 Rules also apply. Otherwise, there was no purpose in mentioning such trees specifically in the schedule. Hence, cutting, removal and transportation of atleast two species of trees, though they are not covered by the Preservation of Trees Act are cognizable as an offence under 1995 Rules and thereby under the Forest Act also. This legal position has not been taken note by the court below. Hence, the finding of the court below to the above extent relying on the Preservation of Trees Act alone, is not legally sustainable and is a manifest error committed by the court below. Since the court below allowed the appeal on a legal interpretation, the lower appellate court did not consider the other defences if any, available to the respondents. Hence, the matter requires a fresh consideration by the lower appellate court in the light of the legal principle referred above.

    15. In the result, the revision is allowed. The impugned order is set aside and the matter is remitted to the court below for a fresh consideration in the light of the legal conclusion arrived at as above. Both sides shall appear before the lower appellate court on 24.11.2015

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Divisional Forest Officer v. P.M. Jalal
    (Oct 16, 2015)