Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Smart Summary

Opinion Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, John Alexander Vincent Williams, sued for a divorce from his wife, Grace Evelina Williams, on the ground of her adultery with the co-respondent, Robert Conran, and also claimed damages against the co-respondent. The District Judge granted a decree nisi dissolving the marriage and awarded Rs. 3,000 damages against the co-respondent. The decree nisi was brought before the court in this opinion for confirmation.

The parties were married in 1858 at Benares and had several children, only one of whom survived. In 1863 the petitioner, his wife, and the co-respondent (then an unmarried police officer) resided at the police barracks at Allahabad; the co-respondent was intimate with the petitioner and his wife. In 1864–65 the petitioner and his wife moved to Benares. In 1866 Mrs. Williams became gravely ill, expressed a wish to see the co-respondent and to make over her only child to him; the co-respondent visited twice at her request.

About a month later the petitioner was transferred to Cawnpore; his wife, recovering, purportedly wrote a letter saying he was to consider her as dead and that she would not join him (the letter was not produced nor dated). The petitioner described attempts at correspondence with Mr. Conran (letters not produced), including an evasive and rude reply from Conran. The petitioner asserts that he had little information about his wife's whereabouts until, by accident in February 1877, he learned she was at Burdwan with Mr. Conran. He then employed Mr. Smith at Dinapore to make inquiries; Smith discovered the wife was living with the co-respondent. The petitioner personally visited Dinapore in disguise, interviewed his wife, and Mr. Conran allegedly admitted the adultery. Proceedings followed.

The petitioner's account of his activities since 1868 is imprecise in the record: he left the police in 1872, held various employments (estate manager, commander of troops of the Rajah of Benares, agent and business at Dinapore), and does not clearly state where he resided. Evidence indicates that in May 1875 a child was baptized at Dinapore as the daughter of Richard Harper and "Grace Evelina Conran" living at Khagoul (a Dinapore suburb/station). The co-respondent appears to have remained a police officer. Neither the respondent (wife) nor the co-respondent appeared in the suit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decree nisi for dissolution of the marriage and the award of damages should be confirmed by the court in light of the petitioner’s long delay and the circumstances of the case.
  2. Whether the petitioner's alleged delay, possible connivance, or insincerity disentitles him to the relief of a divorce despite the alleged adultery.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner claimed he had no suspicion of his wife's adultery from the time she left him in 1866 until the accidental discovery in February 1877.
  • He asserted ignorance of his wife's residence during the intervening eleven years and maintained that he commenced proceedings as soon as he discovered she was living with Mr. Conran.
  • He described efforts to communicate: letters to Mr. Conran (about 15–20 days after his wife's letter) which elicited evasive and impertinent replies. None of these letters were produced in evidence.
  • He relied on Mr. Smith's inquiries at Dinapore which allegedly established that his wife was living with the co-respondent, and on an alleged admission of adultery by the co-respondent when brought to the dakbungalow.

Respondent(s)

The respondent (wife) and the co-respondent did not appear in the suit; the opinion contains no detailed account of any arguments advanced by them.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the District Judge's acceptance of the petitioner's story and found it untenable. The opinion applies a well-established principle (also noted as recognized in Section 14 of the Act) that where adultery is alleged, delay in seeking relief may suggest that the petitioner either connived at the adultery or was indifferent to it; apparent delay can be rebutted by satisfactory explanation, but the burden of explanation remains on the petitioner.

The court analyzed the petitioner's account of delay and found it "wholly incredible" on the available evidence for several reasons set out in the opinion:

  1. The petitioner did not explain why he would have had no suspicion after his wife's earlier conduct in 1866 (twice sending for Mr. Conran while believing herself near death and offering her child to him).
  2. The correspondence between the petitioner and Mr. Conran, as recounted by the petitioner (though letters were not produced), was itself sufficient to have aroused suspicion in any ordinary person.
  3. Given the petitioner's position and the facilities for inquiry available to him (as a police officer and later as a businessperson with apparent connections to Dinapore), the court found it incredible that he could not, or did not, discover where his wife was residing or that she was living openly with Mr. Conran near the Dinapore railway station (Khagoul).
  4. Evidence showed that a child was baptized in 1875 as the daughter of "Grace Evelina Conran" living at Khagoul; the co-respondent had apparently been in the police and living as a married man at Dinapore, facts the court considered unlikely to have been unknown to the petitioner, who had business there.
  5. On the whole, the court concluded the most reasonable inference from the aggregate facts was that the petitioner knew from the outset that his wife was living with Mr. Conran and intentionally refrained from taking steps to procure a divorce.
  6. Further, the court found that the petitioner had attempted to deceive it by concealing the true facts; because the petitioner failed to explain the delay credibly and is judged to have been insincere, this furnished a basis to deny relief.

The court emphasized that had the petitioner stated the true facts, the delay might not have been a bar to relief; but because the true facts were concealed, the court could not grant the relief sought.

Holding and Implications

The court refused to confirm the decree nisi and directed that the petition be dismissed.

Consequences for the parties: the dissolution decree made by the District Judge (and its attendant award of Rs. 3,000 damages against the co-respondent) was not confirmed by the court; the petition for dissolution was dismissed. The opinion indicates this result flows from the court's conclusion that the petitioner had either connived at, or been insincere about, the facts and that his long delay was unexplained.

The opinion does not state or claim that it established any new legal precedent; rather, it applied an established principle regarding delay, suspicion of connivance, and the effect of insincerity on entitlement to relief.

    J. Williams v. Williams And Conran

    1. In this case the petitioner, John Alexander Vincent Williams, sues for a divorce from his wife, Grace Evelina Williams, on the ground of her adultery with the co-respondent, Robert Conran; and lie also claims damages against the co-respondent. The District Judge has granted a decree nisi for the dissolution of the marriage with Rs. 3,000 damages against the co-respondent, and this decree is now before us for our confirmation.

    2. It appears that the parties wore married in the year 1858 at Benares. They had several children, but only one survived. In the*year 1863 they were living together at Allahabad in the police barracks, where the co-respondent, who is a single man, also resided, the petitioner and the co-respondent being both at that time Police officers. The co-respondent was on intimate terms with the petitioner and his wife; but there is no reason to suppose that the petitioner had at that time discovered anything which could give him cause for suspicion.

    3. In the year 1864 or 1865 the petitioner and his wife went to reside at Benares, and in the year 1866 Mrs. "Williams became so ill that her life was despaired of. She then expressed a wish to see the co-respondent. She said that she thought she was going to die, and that she wished to make over her only child to him. The petitioner, accordingly, sent for the co-respondent, but it does not appear that the child was actually made over, The co-respondent stayed for a low days, and then went to Allahabad. A week afterwards the co-respondent returned to the house, having been sent for again by the respondent's sister at the respondent's request.

    4. About a month afterwards the petitioner was transferred from Benares to Cawnpore. The respondent was then recovering, and the petitioner states that it was then arranged that he should furnish a house at Cawnpore, and remove the respondent thither when she was stronger. The petitioner says, that whilst he was gel ting the house ready, he got a letter from ins wife, saying that he was to consider her as dead, and that she would not join him. This letter is not produced, nor is the date of it given. The only attempt which the petitioner then made to find his wife was by writing letters, but he does not say to whom he wrote, nor does he give any particulars as to the information he received except with reference to a letter which he says ho wrote to Mr. Gonran fifteen or twenty days after the respondent had expressed her intention not to join him. His account of this correspondence is as follows:

    5. I wrote to Mr. Conran about fifteen or twenty days after my wife told me by letter that she would not join me. I wrote to ask him whether he had ever seen her in the course of his duties at the different stations on the line. Ho evaded a direct answer, and sent me an impertinent answer to the effect that my wife's grandmother, Mrs. McKinnon, had told him that I did not approve of his proceedings with my sister-in-law, and under such circumstances T should not ask him for information. I answered the letter, and lie then wrote to me to say that he did not wish to hear from me again as 1 did not, entertain a high opinion of his morality." None of these letters are produced. He further says, that be heard from his wife in 1868, when she complained that her own relations had charged her with unchastity. He does not produce this letter, nor does he say where it was posted. But he says that lie wrote to her relations stating that these imputations were unfounded. He does not say so explicitly, but he evidently desires it to be understood that this is all that he heard of his wife between 1866, when she left him, and February 1877, when by a mere accident he was informed by a person at Benares that his wife was then at Burdwan with Mr. Con ran. He says, that a few days after receiving this information, when on Ins way through Dinapore, be saw the co-respondent on the railway platform, lie says that he did not speak to him, because he had written to him long before and had received what he calls the rude answer above mentioned. He says that he then employed a Mr. Smith residing at Dinapore to make enquiries, and Mr. Smith ascertained that the respondent was living with the co-respondent at Dinapore. Thereupon the petitioner came down himself to Dimipore, and having disguised himself as a native, went to the house and had an interview with his wife. Subsequently, Mr. Smith sent for Mr. Conran to the dakbungalow, and he then admitted the adultery, Immediately afterwards, these proceedings were instituted.

    6. The petitioner's account of himself since 1868 is not very definite. He says that he left the police in 1872, and was then employed as manager of an estate in Oudh for about thirteen months at a salary of Rg. 200 a month. He then got the command of the troops of the Rajah of Benares at the same salary. This post ho held about nine months, and since that time he has been acting as agent for a Mrs. Kawty at Assensole and elsewhere, and also carrying on a general business, apparently on his own account, at Dinapore. He does not say where lie 1ms resided. He says that he does not know where his child is, hut he has heard that he is at a school in Darjeeling.

    7. We have no exact information where the respondent has resided since she left her husband, but it is proved that in May 1875 a child was baptized at Dinapore as being the daughter of Richard Harper and Grace Evelina Conran, therein described living at Khagoul. Khagoul is a suburb of Dinapore, and is in fact the railway station which usually passes under the name of Dinapore. The co-respondent has apparently been all along, and still is, in the police. The petitioner swears that be had no suspicion even against his wife until he received the information in February that she was at Burdwan with the co-respondent.

    8. Neither respondent nor co-respondent has appeared in this suit.

    9. The Judge considers the petitioner's story, though a remarkable one, as implicitly true in every respect, and sufficient to show there was no connivance, collusion, or unusual delay.

    10. We cannot accept this view of the matter.

    11. It has been a long established principle, that whilst on the one band there is no absolute limitation in the case for a petition of dissolution, yet that the first thing which the Court looks to when the charge of adultery is preferred, is, whether there has been such delay as to lead to the conclusion that the petitioner had either connived at the adultery or was wholly indifferent to it; but any presumption arising from apparent delay may always be removed by an explanation of the circumstances. That principle is recognized in Section 14 of the Act.1

    12. Now the way in which the petitioner meets the question of delay in this case is as follows. He wishes it to be believed that lie never suspected the chastity of his wife at all from the time she left him in 1866 until the accidental discovery in February of last year. He also would have it inferred, that lie was wholly ignorant of where his wife was residing during those eleven years, and that he commenced these proceedings as soon as he discovered the truth. Upon the evidence given in this case, this appears to us to be wholly incredible. After his wife's strange conduct in sending twice for Mr. Conran when she supposed herself to be dying, and expressing a desire to band over her child to him, it seems incredible that when a month afterwards she declared her intention to leave her husband, he should not have even suspected Mr. Conran; and this is all the more strange when we consider the petitioner's account of the correspondence which took place between himself and Mr. Conran, winch alone was quite sufficient to have aroused the suspicion of any ordinary man. At least, it was to be expected that, on receiving his wife's letter, the petitioner would have at once come down from Cawnpore to Benares, and have had an interview with his wife, if, as he says, he was really then desirous that she should return to him, and considering her condition, and the facilities which he as a police officer would have for making enquiries, there cannot be the least doubt that he could then have easily found her, if he had been so minded; still less is it credible that during all these years the petitioner has never been able to find any clue to where his wife was residing, or that he has never had any suspicion that she was residing with Mr. Conran. She had never gone to any great distance, and has apparently been residing for a considerable time with Mr. Conran near to the railway station at Dmapore, where these parties have been living openly as man and wife. The petitioner does not deny that he lias been frequently at Pinapore, and as he carries on a business there, the reasonable inference is, that he has been so. It is impossible that it can have escaped his knowledge that Mr. Conran was residing at Pinapore as a married man, and even if it did not come directly to his ears, that the person living at Dinapore as Mrs. Conran was the respondent, which is in itself very improbable; it is at any rate impossible to believe that he did not know where Mr. Conran was to be found, and yet knowing this, he did not make any attempt to obtain information from him as to the whereabouts either of his wife or his child.

    13. Upon the whole, it seems to us impossible to escape the conclusion that the petitioner from the first knew perfectly well that his wife was living with Mr. Conran, and that knowing this, he forebore taking any steps to procure a divorce. This of itself woidd not disentitle the petitioner to a divorce if he were capable of explaining the delay; but when this delay not only remains unexplained, but the petitioner has attempted to get rid of the difficulty by deceiving the Court, it is impossible to avoid the conclusion that there are in this case, if the truth were known, some circumstances of connivance or insincerity which would disentitle the petitioner to the relief which ho asks.

    14. Had the petitioner stated the true facts of the case, it is quite possible that we should not have considered the delay to he a bar to the granting of the decree; but the true facts having been concealed from us, we are not in a position to give the petitioner the relief which he asks. We, therefore, refuse to confirm the decree for the dissolution made by the District Judge, and we direct that the petition be dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    J. Williams v. Williams And Conran
    (Feb 16, 1878)