Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These matters arise in Writ Petition No. 3782 of 1990 and three connected writ petitions (Nos. 8414, 9510 and 13983 of 1990) concerning the vires of section 25b of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 (as inserted by Haryana Act 1 of 1989) and a notification issued under that section (annexure R/2) effective from 1 April 1989. The notification fixed a responsibility on the contractee to deduct 2% of the amount payable to a contractor for execution of a works contract involving transfer of property in goods, at the time of credit or payment.

The petitioner in the lead case is M/s. Tirath Ram Ahuja, a registered dealer under the Haryana General Sales Tax Act and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, who is a building contractor executing works (both private and public). M/s. Gulmohar Estate Limited was the contractee for certain works executed by the petitioner. The Deputy Excise and Taxation Commissioner / Excise and Taxation Officer (Assessing Authority), Gurgaon, issued a notice to M/s. Gulmohar Estate Limited informing them of their responsibility to deduct 2% from payments to the contractor with effect from 1 April 1989 and to produce contracts and statements of payments (annexure P/1).

The contractor (petitioner) challenged the vires of section 25b and the notification (annexure R/2) by invoking article 226 of the Constitution of India. The court reproduced the statutory text of sections 25b and 26 of the Haryana Act and the two notifications dated 24 March 1989 (one specifying 2% composition under section 26(2) and the other specifying 2% deduction under section 25b).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether section 25b of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 and the notification issued under it (annexure R/2) fixing responsibility on the contractee to deduct 2% from payments to contractors, are constitutionally valid (i.e., the vires of section 25b and the notification).
  2. Whether a provision for deduction at source (under section 25b) can be sustained without a prior assessment (this being the primary ground of challenge).
  3. Whether the impugned deduction mechanism would be arbitrary or unjust in cases where transfer of goods does not take place, or where assessments are delayed unduly by the assessing authority.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Contractor's) Arguments

  • The primary challenge asserted that a statutory provision requiring deduction of tax at source (under section 25b) is invalid if made operative without assessment — i.e., that deduction cannot validly be required prior to assessment determining tax liability.
  • It was contended (or at least suggested) that deduction at source might be applied in situations where no transfer of goods takes place under a works contract and that withholding 2% could be arbitrary, particularly if the Assessing Authority takes years to complete assessment and determine the ultimate liability or entitlement to refund.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Builders Association of India v. Union of India [1989] 73 STC 370 (Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court) After the 46th Amendment, a works contract is treated (by legal fiction) as divisible into a sale of goods and a contract for labour and services; consequently, States may levy sales tax on the value of goods involved in works contracts subject to constitutional restrictions (e.g., article 286). The legal fiction must be carried to its logical end so that the power to tax deemed sales is subject to the same restrictions as ordinary sales. The court relied on the principle that the 46th Amendment and the Builders Association decision permit States to tax the goods component of works contracts and to treat that component consistently with constitutional constraints. This background supported the conclusion that provisions dealing with taxation of the goods element (and mechanisms such as composition under section 26 and deduction at source under section 25b) are within legislative competence and not per se invalid.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in several steps, as reflected in the opinion:

  1. Statutory and Constitutional Context: The court reviewed the statutory text of section 25b (deduction at source on payments for works contracts involving transfer of property in goods) and section 26 (power of the State to accept lump-sum composition from classes of dealers, and in particular section 26(2) permitting contractors to opt to pay a lump sum up to 10%). It also outlined the effect of the 46th Amendment of the Constitution, which rendered works contracts liable to sales tax by treating the goods component as a deemed sale.
  2. Precedent Support: The court cited the Constitution Bench decision in Builders Association of India v. Union of India, explaining that post-46th Amendment the goods component of a works contract can be taxed as a sale and that the legal fiction must be applied fully. This established the legitimacy of taxing goods in works contracts.
  3. Relation between Composition Option and Deduction at Source: The court contrasted the normal ad valorem incidence of tax (section 6 read with section 15) with the composition option under section 26(2) (subject to notification). It noted that where the government issues a notification under section 26, a contractor may opt to pay a specified lump sum (composition) — in the impugned notifications the composition rate for contractors was specified at 2% with effect from 1 April 1989. For contractors who do not opt for composition, the normal ad valorem regime applies.
  4. Nature and Purpose of Section 25b: The court observed that section 25b imposes a responsibility on the contractee to deduct tax at source (up to 10% as may be notified) at the time of credit or payment. The court drew an analogy to section 194-C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which mandates deductions towards income tax from payments to contractors/sub-contractors, indicating that such withholding mechanisms are not unprecedented.
  5. Rejection of the Primary Challenge: The court considered and rejected the submission that deduction at source under section 25b is invalid because it is made without a prior assessment. The court explained that the deduction under the notification is provisional; in effect, whatever is ultimately determined to be due on assessment (after adjustment of the 2% deducted) is recovered from the contractor, and refunds are to be issued where excess has been recovered. Thus, the deduction mechanism does not replace assessment; it operates as an interim mechanism with post-assessment adjustment.
  6. Addressing Concerns about Arbitrary Application and Delay: The court acknowledged the theoretical possibility that deductions might be made in contracts where no transfer of goods occurs, or that assessing authorities might delay finalizing assessments. However, the court refused to impute an improper motive to the framers of the law or assessing authorities. It noted that where there is undue delay in finalizing assessments, the aggrieved party may seek judicial intervention for speedy disposal. In the particular batch of cases, the court found delay in finalising assessments in CWP No. 3782 of 1990 and issued directions accordingly.
  7. Conclusion on Vires: Having examined the statutory scheme, constitutional amendments, relevant precedent, the provisional nature of the deduction, and remedies available to aggrieved parties (including refund mechanisms and judicial review for delay), the court found no justification to strike down section 25b or the notification (annexure R/2).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Court upheld the vires of section 25b of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 and found no ground to quash the notification (annexure R/2); the writ petitions were dismissed with a limited direction in one case.

Direct Consequences and Practical Implications:

  • The notification under section 25b obliges contractees to deduct tax at source at the specified rate (2% as per annexure R/2) at the time of credit or payment to contractors for works contracts involving transfer of property in goods.
  • The 2% deduction operates provisionally; the amount deducted is to be adjusted against the contractor's final liability determined on assessment, and any surplus deduction is refundable to the contractor in accordance with law.
  • Where assessments are unduly delayed, affected taxpayers retain the remedy of approaching the court for directions for speedy disposal; the court issued such a direction in Civil Writ Petition No. 3782 of 1990, directing respondent No. 2 to finalise the assessments for assessment years 1986-87 to 1988-89 within four months of receipt of the order (if not already finalised), and to refund any amount found due without delay.
  • Civil Writ Petition Nos. 8414, 9510 and 13983 of 1990 were dismissed outright; Civil Writ Petition No. 3782 of 1990 was dismissed subject to the limited procedural direction described above. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.
  • No new legal precedent was created by this order beyond the court's application of existing constitutional and statutory principles and reliance on the cited Supreme Court authority; the decision upholds the existing statutory scheme and the notification impugned in these proceedings.

This summary is confined strictly to information contained in the provided opinion.

    Tirath Ram Ahuja Limited v. State Of Haryana

    G. C. MITAL, J.

    In Writ Petition No. 3782 of 1990 and three similar Writ Petitions Nos. 8414, 9510 and 13983 of 1990 a point of some important but of significance arises regarding the vires of section 25b of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 (for short "the Act"), as inserted by the haryana act 1 of 1989, and the notification issued under the aforesaid section, copy of which is annexure R/2, fixing the responsibility of the contractee to deduct 2 per cent of the amount out of the account of the contract and the valuable consideration payable for the execution of a works contract involving transfer of property in goods at the time of credit to the account of or payment to the contractor of such valuable consideration in cash, by cheque, by adjustment or in any other manner whatsoever. In order to appreciate the point the brief facts which are beyond the pale of controversy are : M/s. Tirath Ram Ahuja is a registered dealer under the Act as well as under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956. Under the State Act the registration certificate was granted with effect from December 17, 1985. The assessee is a building contractor and carries on the business for private works as also public works. The assessee was contracting and executing certain works in the district of Gurgaon for M/s. Gulmohar Estate Limited and when M/s. Gulmohar Estate Limited received a notice from the Deputy Excise and Taxation Commissioner/excise and Taxation Officer-cum-Assessing Authority, Gurgaon, to the effect that as contractee they are responsible under the Act to deduct tax at the rate of 2 per centum of the amount paid from valuable consideration payable by them with effect from April 1, 1989 for execution of works contract whether in cash, by cheque, by adjustment or in any other manner whatsoever, credited or adjusted as the case may be and the tax so deducted was to be paid to the State Government. By a notice they have been called upon to supply a copy of the contract and statement of payments made by them to the contractor with effect from April 1, 1989 and to produce proof of payments made in compliance with law in the Government treasury failing which action as required under law would be taken against them. A copy of the notice dated December 5, 1989, is appended as annexure P/1 to the writ petition. On receipt of the notice (annexure P/1) the contractee informed the contractor, that is the petitioner, about deducted 2 per cent as suggested in the notice. This prompted the contractor to move this Court under article 226 of the Constitution of India, 1950, to challenge the vires of the provisions of section 25b of the Act and the notification (annexure R/2) dated March 24, 1989, which was made effective from April 1, 1989. In order to appreciate the point it will be useful to notice the provisions of section 25b and section 26 of the Act and the same are reproduced hereunder : " 25b. Special provisions relating to deduction of tax at source in certain cases.- (1) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any other provisions of this Act, any contractee responsible for making any payment or discharging any liability on account of the valuable consideration payable for the execution of a works contract involving transfer of property in goods (whether as goods or in some other form), shall, at the time of credit to the account of or payment to the payee of such valuable consideration in cash, by cheque, by adjustment or in any other manner whatsoever, deduct tax therefrom at the rate not exceeding ten per centum of the amount paid or credited, as the case may be, as may be specified by notification by the Government : Provided that no deduction shall be made under this section where the amount or the aggregate of the amounts paid or credited or likely to be paid or credited during the year by such person to a contractor does not or is not likely to exceed one lakh rupees in a case. (2) Any tax deducted under sub-section (1) shall be paid to the State Government in such manner and within such time as may be prescribed. (3) The person making any deduction of tax under sub-section (1) and paying it to the State Government shall issue a certificate of tax deduction to the payee in such form as may be prescribed. (4) Any tax deducted under sub-section (1) and paid to the State Government shall be provisional and shall, on production of the certificate of tax deduction issued under sub-section (3) by the payee, be deemed to be tax paid by the payee for the relevant period and shall be given credit in his assessment accordingly. (5) If any person contravenes the provisions of sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) or sub-section (3), the Commissioner or any person appointed to assist him under sub-section (1) of section 3 may, by an order in writing, direct such person to pay, in addition to the sum deducted, if any, a penalty not exceeding the amount of tax deductible under sub-section (1) : Provided that no such penalty shall be imposed on any person unless he has been given an opportunity of being heard. (6) The tax deducted by a contractee under sub-section (1), remaining unpaid after the due date of payment, shall be recoverable from him as arrears of land revenue. " " 26 (1 ). Payment of lump sum in lieu of sales tax.- The State Government may, in the public interest and subject to such conditions as it may deem fit, accept from any class of dealers, in lieu of the tax payable under this Act, for any period, by way of composition, a lump sum to be determined by the State Government and to be paid at such intervals and in such manner a may be prescribed, and thereupon during the period such composition remains in force, the provisions of this act and the rules made thereunder relating to the filing of returns and the maintenance of accounts by such dealer shall not apply to them. (2) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Act, a contractor liable to pay tax under this Act may, in lieu of the tax payable under this Act, at his option, exercisable in the manner prescribed, pay on the total value of a works contract being executed by him, a sum at such interval and in such manner, as may be prescribed, calculated at such rate not exceeding ten per centum, as the State Government may, keeping in view the nature and class of the works contract and subject to such conditions, by notification, specify : Provided that a contractor exercising option under this sub-section shall not be entitled to make purchase of any goods without payment of tax on the authority of his registration certificate for use in the execution of the works contract nor shall he be entitled to make adjustment or claim of refund of tax paid at any preceding stage, or deduct turnover of purchase of such goods : Provided further that the option once exercised shall not be revoked till the expiry of three years from the end of the year in which such option is exercised nor a works contract under execution shall be split on such revocation. (3) A contractor exercising option under sub-section (2) shall, so long as the option remains in force, not be required to maintain accounts of his business under this Act or the rules made thereunder except record of payment received or received or receivable in relation to the works contract executed or under execution. " The notifications issued under sections 25b and 26 (2) of the Act also form part of the record and are reproduced hereunder : " Notification, 24th March, 1989. No. S. O. 49/h. A. 20/73/s. 26/89.- In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (2) of section 26 of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973, the Governor of Haryana hereby specifies that with effect from the 1st day of April, 1989, the sum in lieu of the tax payable by the contractor under this Act, shall be calculated at the rate of two per centum of the total value of the works contract being executed by him. " " Notification, 24th March, 1989. No. S. O. 48/h. A. 20/73/s. 25b/89.- In exercise of the powers conferred by section 25b of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973, the Governor of Haryana hereby specifies that with effect from the 1st day of April, 1989, and contractee responsible for making any payment or discharging any liability on account of the valuable consideration payable for the execution of a works contract involving transfer of property in goods (whether as goods or in some other form), shall, at the time of credit to the account of or payment to the contractor of such valuable consideration in cash, by cheque, by adjustment or in any other manner whatsoever, deduct tax therefrom at the rate of two per centum of the amount paid, credited or adjusted, as the case may be. " Earlier to the 46th Amendment of the Constitution no tax was leviable on indivisible building contracts but by virtue of certain amendments made in the Constitution of India by the 46th Amendment building contracts become liable to sales tax. Again the levy of sales tax on building contracts was challenged and the matter was set at rest by the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Builders Association of India v. Union of India [1989] 73 STC 370 and it was held as follows : ". . . . . . . . After the 46th Amendment the works contract which was an indivisible one is by a legal fiction altered into a contract which is divisible into one for sale of goods and the other for supply of labour and services. After the 46th Amendment, it has become possible for the States to levy sales tax on the value of goods involved in a works contract in the same way in which the sales tax was leviable on the price of the goods and materials supplied in a building contract which had been entered into in two distinct and separate parts as stated above. It could not have been the contention of the Revenue prior to the 46th Amendment that, when the goods and materials had been supplied under a distinct and separate contract by the contractor for the purpose of construction of a building the assessment of sales tax could be made ignoring the restrictions and conditions incorporated in article 286 of the Constitution. If that was the position can the States contend after the 46th Amendment under which by a legal fiction the transfer of property in goods involved in a works contract was made liable to payment of sales tax that they are not governed by article 286 while levying sales tax on sale of goods involved in a works contract ? They cannot do so. When the law creates a legal fiction such fiction should be carried to its logical end. There should not be any hesitation in giving full effect to it. If the power to tax a sale in an ordinary sense is subject to certain conditions and restrictions imposed by the Constitution, the power to tax a transaction which is deemed to be a sale under article 366 (29-A) of the Constitution should also be subject to the same restrictions and conditions. Ordinarily unless there is a contract to the contrary in the case of a works contract the property in the goods used in the construction of a building passes to the owner of the land on which the building is constructed, when the goods or materials used are incorporated in the building. The contractor becomes liable to pay the sales tax ordinary when the goods or materials are so used in the construction of the building and it is not necessary to wait till the final bill is prepared for the entire work". In consonance with the 46th Constitution Amendment the Act was also amended and the goods transferred in execution of works contract was also made liable to sales tax. The value of valuable goods covered in the building contract has to be separated from the labour charges, etc. , involved therein and it became the duty of the contractor to supply the evidence as to how much value out of the total contract was towards the labour charges and the remaining had to be considered as the value of the goods transferred and sales tax was leviable on the value of such transferred goods. Section 6 of the Act is the charging section and section 15 provides rate of tax. The rate of tax varies from 20 per cent to 8 per cent as the maximum limit subject to issue of notification by the Government which may be at a lower rate but the rate of tax cannot exceed the optimum limit. In view of the charging section 6 a dealer is liable to pay tax at the prescribed rate if his turnover exceeds the taxable quantum provided in section 7 of the Act. Section 26 of the Act empowers the State Government to accept prescribed lump sum from any class of dealers, in lieu of tax payable under the Act, for any period, by way of composition. If the State Government issued notification under section 26 of the Act option becomes available to an assessee for payment of lump sum subject to the conditions laid down in the section and the notification issued thereunder and without exercise of option he continues to be liable to pay tax under the remaining provisions of the Act, that is, on ad valorem basis. To lay emphasis, we repeat that normally the incident of taxation is under section 6 read with other provisions of the Act at the rates specified in section 15 of the Act. But if the Government makes a provision for receiving lump sum tax by resorting to issue of notification under section 26 of the Act then option becomes available to the assessee for payment of lump sum on the conditions prescribed. Similar to section 25b of the Act there is a provision in section 194-C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for making deductions towards income-tax out of the payments to be made to the contractor and sub-contractor. The primary challenge to the vires is on the ground that without assessment no provision for making deduction can be held to be valid. On a consideration of the matter we are not satisfied with the argument. On the building material to be purchased by the building contractor the normal incident of sales tax is eight to ten per cent but under the notification issued under section 26 (2) of the Act if a building contractor opts to pay lump sum tax he is liable to pay tax at the rate of 2 per cent on the value of the works contract. For those who do not opt to be governed by the provisions of section 26 (2) of the Act and the notification issued thereunder the responsibility of the contractee of such building contractor has been fixed by a notification (annexure R/2) to deduct 2 per cent of the amount out of the account of the contractor which is adjustable in the manner provided. Ultimately, whatever is found due on the basis of assessment after adjustment of 2 per cent is recovered from the building contractor and if surplus is found to have been recovered, refund is issued. An argument was sought to be raised before us that there may be a building contract in which transfer of goods may not take place but under the Act from the bills of the contractor the contractee will deduct 2 per cent of the amount which will be payable to the contractor after assessment and the Assessing Authority may not complete the assessment for years together. Such a motive cannot be imputed either to the farmers of law or to the Assessing Authorities. If, however, in a given case it is shown that there is undue delay in finalising the assessment, the aggrieved assessee can always come to court for obtaining a direction for speedy disposal. In the bunch of cases before us we have a case of such type and in that we are issuing requisite directions. However, neither a reasonable argument has been raised before us nor any justification has been shown to strike down the provisions of section 25b of the Act or the notification issued thereunder, copy whereof is annexure R/2. Accordingly, we uphold the vires of section 25b of the Act and find no ground to quash the notification (annexure R/2 ). In Civil Writ Petition No. 3782 of 1990 for the assessment years 1986-87 to 1988-89 the assessments have not been finalised by the Assessing Authority and there is no reasonable explanation for the delay in completing the assessments. Accordingly, while upholding the vires of the provisions of section 25b of the Act and validity of the notification we issue a direction in Civil Writ Petition No. 3782 of 1990 to respondent No. 2 to finalise the assessments within four months of the receipt of this order, if not already finalised. In case it is found that the assessee is entitled to refund, refund be made to him without delay in accordance with law. While Civil Writ Petition Nos. 8414, 9510 and 13983 of 1990 are dismissed, Civil Writ Petition No. 3782 of 1990 is dismissed with the aforesaid limited direction. The parties are left to bear their own costs. Writ petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tirath Ram Ahuja Limited v. State Of Haryana
    (Jun 8, 1991)