AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs, consisting of M/s. Anand Kumar Pradeep Kumar, a partnership firm formed by the sons of Late Mool Chand, and Shiv Kishan Aggarwal, filed a suit for permanent injunction against the defendants. The plaintiffs claimed to be the registered proprietors and continuous users of the trademark “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA” since 1941 through their ancestors. The plaintiffs had been conducting business under this trademark at 1454, Chandni Chowk, Delhi since 1983. The defendants intended to open a shop at Karol Bagh, New Delhi, using the same trade name and trademark, prompting the plaintiffs to seek an injunction.

The suit was initially filed in the Court of the District Judge, Delhi on December 10, 1991. Subsequently, the plaintiffs amended their plaint to include a claim for damages of Rs. 6.00 lakhs, exceeding the pecuniary jurisdiction of that court, leading to the plaint being returned under Order 7, Rule 10A of the Code of Civil Procedure. The suit was then presented before this Court on February 17, 1992.

The background reveals that the trademark “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA” was originally used by late Shri Ganga Bishan (also known as Haldiram Bhujiawala) since before 1941. The trademark was registered in 1981 based on an application filed in 1972 by four partners of a firm including Ganga Bishan and his descendants. The partnership dissolved in 1974, assigning exclusive rights of the trademark to Shri Mool Chand for India except West Bengal, while rights in West Bengal were reserved for Smt. Kamla Devi and her representatives.

After the death of Mool Chand in 1985, his four sons became registered proprietors of the trademark, which was later transferred to a company formed by them in 1995. The defendants claimed trademark rights based on their father, Shri Rameshwar Lal Aggarwal, who allegedly used the trademark in Calcutta since 1958.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Who are the first adopters/users of the trademark “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA”?
  2. What is the effect of the assignment of the trademark exclusively to Mool Chand by virtue of the dissolution deed dated 16.11.1974?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The trademark “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA” was originally adopted and used by late Shri Ganga Bishan since before 1941.
  • The trademark was registered in 1981 in the names of Ganga Bishan, Mool Chand, Shiv Kishan, and Kamla Devi as partners.
  • By the dissolution deed of 1974, exclusive rights for India except West Bengal were assigned to Mool Chand.
  • The trademark rights were subsequently transferred to Mool Chand’s sons and then to a company formed by them.
  • The defendants have no right to use the trademark outside West Bengal and have started business in Delhi only after the suit was filed.
  • The defendants' use of the trademark in Delhi constitutes infringement and passing off.

Defendants' Arguments

  • Their father, Shri Rameshwar Lal Aggarwal, was the first inventor, adopter, and user of the trademark since 1958.
  • They had a registered trademark (No. 330375) in their names from 1980, claiming use since 1958 in Calcutta.
  • They claim prior user rights and better ownership over the plaintiffs.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Section 12(1) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 Bar against registration of an identical trademark already registered in the name of a different proprietor The court noted that concurrent use of identical trademarks for the same goods is contrary to trademark jurisprudence and that registration of a trademark already registered is impermissible.
Section 32(a) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 Registration is conclusive as to validity after seven years unless obtained by fraud The court held that registration obtained by fraud would not be immune from challenge, and prima facie the defendants' registration was obtained fraudulently or in collusion.
Order 7, Rule 10A of the Code of Civil Procedure Return of plaint for lack of pecuniary jurisdiction The plaint was returned under this rule when damages claimed exceeded the pecuniary jurisdiction of the District Judge's Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the historical use and registration of the trademark “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA.” It accepted that late Shri Ganga Bishan was the first adopter and user of the trademark since before 1941 and that the trademark was registered in 1981 based on an application filed in 1972 by the partnership including Ganga Bishan and his family members.

The dissolution deed of 16.11.1974 assigned exclusive rights for the trademark to Mool Chand for all India except West Bengal, with Kamla Devi and her representatives entitled to use it only in West Bengal. The Court found that the defendants, being successors of Rameshwar Lal (Kamla Devi’s husband), were bound by this agreement and could not claim rights beyond West Bengal.

The defendants’ claim of prior use since 1958 was limited to Calcutta and West Bengal, and not Delhi or elsewhere in India. The Court noted that the defendants began using the trademark in Delhi only after the suit was filed, which constituted infringement or passing off.

The Court also scrutinized the registration of the defendants’ trademark No. 330375, which was granted after the plaintiffs’ registration, and found that the registration was likely obtained fraudulently or in collusion, as the defendants had represented use only in Calcutta and the Registrar overlooked the prior application by the plaintiffs.

The Court emphasized the principle that a trademark denotes goods from a single source and that concurrent use of identical trademarks for the same goods is impermissible. The defendants’ registration and use beyond West Bengal was prima facie invalid.

Given the above, the Court found the plaintiffs had a prima facie case, the balance of convenience was in their favor, and the defendants had no legal injury from the injunction as they had no prior business in Delhi.

Holding and Implications

The Court granted an interim injunction restraining the defendants from using the trademark “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA” or any identical or deceptively similar mark in India except the State of West Bengal.

The defendants were ordered to submit statements of accounts and documents relating to their business in Delhi since the suit's filing and to preserve such documents.

The direct effect of this decision is to protect the plaintiffs' exclusive rights to the trademark outside West Bengal and prevent the defendants from infringing or passing off in Delhi and other parts of India. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing trademark law principles and the specific facts of this case.

    Anand Kumar Deepak Kumar Another v. Haldiram Bhujia Wala Another

    J.B. Goel, J.

    1. Plaintiff No. 1, M/s. Anand Kumar Pradeep Kumar, a partnership firm constituted by Shiv Rattan Aggarwal, Manmohan Lal Aggarwal and Madhu Sudan Aggarwal and plaintiff No. 2 Shiv Kishan Aggarwal all sons of Late Mool Chand have filed a suit forpermanent injunction against the defendants alleging that they are the registered proprietors of the trade mark and continuous user through their ancestors since 1941 of the trade mark name and trademark “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA”. They had started a shop at 1454, Chandni Chowk, Delhi and doing business there since 1983 using the said trademark. The defendants intended to start a new shop to carry on similar business under the same trade name and with the same trademark at Karol Bagh, New Delhi. They sought an injunction. The suit was initially filed in the Court of the District Judge, Delhi on 10.12.1991. However, subsequently, the plaintiffs amended the plaint incorporating claim for recovery of damages of Rs. 6.00 lakhs which exceeded the pecuniary jurisdiction of that Court and the plaint was returned under Order 7, Rule 10A of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short the Code). The suit was presented in this Court on 17.2.1992.

    2. Briefly the case of the plaintiffs is that late Shri Ganga Bishan who was also known as Haldiram Bhujiawala, had been doing his business of manufacture and sale of salted preparations like Bhujia, papads and sweets etc. since his childhood since before 1941 under the name and style of “Chand Mal Ganga Bishan” and “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA” initially in Bikaner and later on also started in Calcutta he formed a partnership firm in the year 1965 under the name and style of M/s. Chand Mal Ganga Bishan with four partners: (1) Ganga Bishan (himself), (2) Mool Chand (his son), (3) Shiv Kishan (son of Mool Chand) and (4) Smt. Kamla Devi, w/o Shri Rameshwar Lal (his daughter-in-law). The said firm had adopted the trademark of “HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA”.

    3. On 29.12.1972, the said four partners applied to the Registrar of Trademarks for the registration of the said trademark in Class 30. The trademark was advertised in Trademark journal and in due course was registered as No. 285062 (on 27.1.1981) as on 29.12.1972 in respect of sale of Bhujia, papad fried, namkeen, saltish dal etc. in class 30 in Part A in India except the State of West Bengal in the names of the aforesaid following four partners of the firm, namely:

    1. Shri Ganga Bishan @ Haldiram,

    2. Shri Mool Chand,

    3. Shri Shiv Kishan, and

    4. Smt. Kamla Devi.

    4. The said partnership firm was dissolved by means of dissolution deed dated 16.11.1974 and thereby the registered trademark No. 285062 was allotted/assigned exclusively to Shri Mool Chand for the whole of India except the State of West Bengal; and it was agreed that in the territory of the State of West Bengal Smt. Kamla Devi or her representatives could carry on similar business there. Relevant Clauses No. 3,7 and 8 of the Dissolution Deed dated 16.11.1974 provide as under:

    “3. That the Second Party shall be entitled to carry on the said business under the name and style of MESSRS CHANDMAL GANGABISHAN also trading as HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA having its head office at Bhujia Bazar, Bikaner and or at such other place or places; as he may think fit and proper under the said or style. The trademark “HRB- HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA” shall be utilised by the party hereto of the Second party throughout India except in the Territory of West Bengal. The Territory of West Bengal shall be utilised by the party hereto of the Fourth Part and/or by her representatives. The other partners shall have no objection in using the trademark by the parties hereto of the Second and Fourth Parts as mentioned above.

    7. That the Second Party shall be at liberty to carry on the business either as a sole proprietor or may invite partners and carryon the business in partnership and deal with the trade mark “HRB - HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA” Regd. at No. 285062 in Class 30 in any manner, he may deem fit and proper.

    8. That parties hereto of the First, Third and Fourth parts shall have no objection if the Regd. Trade Mark No. 285062 in Class 30 is transferred in the name of the Second Party in the records of the Registrar of Trade Marks by taking proper proceedings.”

    5. (Mool Chand is described as party No. 2 and Smt. Kamla Devi as party No. 4.)

    6. Shri Rameshwar Lal, husband of Smt. Kamla Devi, simultaneously by a separate writing of same date also had acknowledged, declared and recognised this right of Mool Chand as the sole/exclusive user and proprietor of this trademark. That writing reads as under:

    “Dated: 16.11.1974.

    TO WHOM SO EVER IT MAY CONCERN

    This is to confirm that the name Haldi Ram Bhujiawala (HRB) which was originally adopted and used by my father since 1941 shall remain the sole property of my brother Mool Chand and his representatives for whole of India except the State of West Bengal. I or any of my representatives shall not claim any further right on this and I shall trade under the name Haldi Ram Bhujiawala in West Bengal only.

    Sd/-

    (RAMESHWAR LAL AGGARWAL)”

    7. Ganga Bishan died in 1980. Mool Chand also died on 30.7.1985 leaving behind him his four sons, namely, Shiv Kishan Aggarwal, Shiv Ratan Aggarwal, Manohar Lat Aggarwal and Madhu Sudan Aggarwal, besides two daughters and his wife. The widow and the two daughters gave “no objections”, thereby relinquishing their right in the said trademark and agreeing for transfer of the registration of the trademark in the names of the aforesaid four sons of Mool Chand. These four sons of Mool Chand had made an application before the Registrar, Trade Marks, on 22.11.1985 for renewal and transmission of the said Registered Trade Mark No. 285062 in their names. Their application was allowed and they have been registered as subsequent proprietors of the said trademark as from 30.7.1985, and the trademark was renewed in their names for 7 years ending on 28.12.1986 as per certificate issued on 28.2.1989. The trademark was further renewed in their names for 7 years from 29.12.1993. After the institution of this suit the aforesaid four persons have formed a company under the Companies Act 1956, with the name of M/s. Haldiram India (Pvt.) Ltd. having registered office at B-1/H8, Mohan Cooperative Industrial Estate, Mathura Road, New Delhi and on their application this Trade mark was transferred and the said company has been registered as subsequent proprietors of the said trademark as from 27.7.1995. The trademark now stands renewed up to 29.12.2000 in the name of the company.

    8. Plaintiff No. 1, the partnership firm had started their business at 1454, Chandni Chowk, Delhi in the year 1983 doing the same business and using the registered trademark “Haldiram Bhujiawala”. It is alleged that the defendants had never carried on the business anywhere else except in Calcutta nor they were entitled to carry on business beyond West Bengal and they are not entitled to do business at Karol Bagh, Delhi under the name of Haldiram Bhujiawala nor entitled to use the trademark “Haldiram Bhujiawala”. And their threat/intention to start such business was illegal. Along with the suit an application for ad interim injunction was filed before the learned District Judge. Temporary injunction was granted by the learned Additional District Judge on 10.12.1991.

    9. The defendants in their written statement have disputed the claim of the plaintiffs. They have pleaded that their father late Shri Rameshwar Lal Aggarwal was the first inventor, adopter and user of this trademark since the year 1958, (as against plaintiff's claim since 1965) and doing his business under this tradename/trademark since then; who had also made application for the registration of this trademark in class 30 in the names of Shri Rameshwar Lal Aggarwal and Shri Prabhu Shankar Aggarwal trading at 7, Jugmohan Mullick Lane, Calcutta-7 claiming its user since 1958, which was registered as No. 330375, and later on the trademark was registered in their names as per certificate dated September 11,1980 as on 2.11.1977 and they have been using this trademark continuously. It is thus claimed that they being the prior user of the trademark have better and overriding rights over the rights of the plaintiffs.

    10. Arguments have been addressed at length. Both claiming right on the basis of prior user.

    11. Two questions arise: (1) Who are the first adopters/users of the trademark; and (2) What is the effect of assignment of the trademark in question to be exclusively used by Mool Chand by virtue of dissolution deed dated 16.11.1974?

    12. It is not disputed that the parties in the suit are the successors (grandsons) of late Shri Ganga Bishan, plaintiffs being the sons of his son Mool Chand whereas defendants are the sons of his other son Rameshwar Lal. Both the parties have relied on documents in support of their respective claim.

    13. It appears that some third party namely Haldiram Madan Lal trading at Calcutta had also sought registration of this very trademark “Haldiram Bhujiawala” through Application No. 284166B in Class 30. Ganga Bishan @ Haldiram s/o Chandmal then aged 75 years had opposed it and in his affidavit filed in Opposition No. CAL-1048 on 25.6 1976, in paras 1 and 2 of his affidavit he had claimed as under:

    1. That ‘HALDIRAM’ is my nick-name and I have been commonly known and called by the name Haldiram than personal name ‘GANGA BISHAN’,

    2. That from my very young age I have been in the business of manufacturing of and sale of Bhujia, Papad, Namkins and Sweet-meals and have been trading under the Trade Name ‘HALDIRAM BHUJIAWALA’ at Bikaner, The tradename Haldiram Bhujiawala is presently being used by me ….x

    14. Rameshwar Lal Aggarwal (Predecessor-in-interest of the defendants) in Opposition Proceedings against his Application No. 330375 for registration of the trademark in his name, in para 3 of his affidavit dated 19.6.1978 has also admitted the use of this trademark by his father, as under:

    3. Haldiram form the essential part of the trademark of the firm of my father who was trading in the name and style of “Haldiram Bhujiawala” since his young age.

    15. This admission made by the predecessor-in-interest of the defendants would bind the latter. It shows that this tradename and trademark was not invented/adopted first by Shri Rameshwar Lal as now claimed by defendants, but by his father late Shri Ganga Bishan since his childhood using the trade name of Haldiram Bhujiawala in the course of his business. Shri Ganga Bishan died in the year 1980 at the age of over 75 years. He must have been using this tradename for over 40 years before his death as claimed by the plaintiffs.

    16. Plaintiffs have placed on record copy of Certificate No. 137011 dated 27.1.1981 whereby this trademark “Haldiram Bhujiawala” (with the logo HRB in a particular design) has been registered as No. 285062 w.e.f. 29.12.1972 in Class 30 for India except the State of West Bengal in the names of (1) Ganga Bishan @ Haldiram,(2) Mool Chand, (3) Shiv Krishan and (4) Kamla Oevi trading under the name of “Haldiram Bhujiawala” and “Chand Mal Ganga Bishan”, Bhujia Bazar, Bikaner. They as partners were using this trademark and their partnership firm was dissolved on the terms agreed in dissolution deed dated 16.11.1974. In its Clauses 3, 7 and 8 already reproduced, Shri Ganga Bishan, Shiv Krishan and Smt. Kamla Devi had relinquished/assigned their right and claim in this trademark in favour of Mool Chand exclusively for the whole of India except the State of West Bengal.

    17. Shri Rameshwar Lal, husband of Kamla Devi had also bound himself to this effect in his declaration dated 16.11.1974 given simultaneously. Smt. Kamla Devi and her husband and for that matter their heirs and successors are bound by this and they can use the trademark only within the State of West Bengal and not beyond that. On the death of Mool Chand on 30.7.1985, on the application made on 22.11.1985 by his four sons, namely, Shiv Krishan, Shiv Ratan, Manohar Lal and Madhu Sudan to the registration of the trademark was transferred in their names vide certificate dated 28.2.1989 issued by the Registrar of Trademarks, inter alia recognising their claim/right on the basis of the said dissolution deed dated 16.11.1974 and as successors in interest of Mool Chand and trademark was renewed in their names and later this trade mark has been transferred in the name of the aforesaid company formed by them.

    18. Plaintiff No. 1, a partnership firm, constituted by three of the sons of Mool Chand, namely, Madhusudan, Shiv Ratan and Manohar Lal, had started their business at 1454, Chandni Chowk, Delhi in the year 1983 doing the same business under the same trademark. The fact of their doing this business since 1983 at Delhi is not disputed by the defendants in their written statement. Plaintiff No. 2 is the fourth son of Mool Chand who has been registered as joint user with them. The plaintiffs who are the successors-in-interest of late Ganga Bishan as well as of Mool Chand are thus the registered proprietors of this trade mark having registration as from 29.12.1972. They are also prior user of the tradename and the trade mark in question in Territory other than Calcutta. Use or, adoption of this trademark by Rameshwar Lal as alleged even if it is from the year 1958 has been in Calcutta only as they have not been using the trade name or trademark in Delhi or rather beyond West Bengal. And by virtue of dissolution deed dated 16.11.1974, this trademark has been assigned exclusively to Shri Mool Chand for use in India except the State of West Bengal. Parties to this settlement and their successors in interest are bound by it. The defendants are thus bound by this settlement dated 16.11.1974 and as such they cannot claim any right contrary to its terms. The material placed on record also shows that the defendants have been using this trade mark in relation to their business primarily in Calcutta. In any case it is not their case that they had been doing business in Delhi before this suit was filed on 10.12.1991 nor sale figures in Delhi have been made available.

    19. It is also seen that the application for registration of this trademark was filed with the Registrar (Trademarks) on 2.11.1977 in the names of Shri Rameshwar Lal Aggarwal and Shri Prabhu Shankar Aggarwal trading at 9, Jagmohan Mullick Lane, Calcutta-7 (which was later on registered as No. 330375 in Class 30 on 11.9.1980) was advertised in the Trademark Journal No. 734 dated January 19, 1980 wherein its use was claimed only in Calcutta. Before this application was advertised, the Office of the Registrar had raised an objection in their letter No. U-3/996 dated 14.4.1978, inter alia, to the effect that the trademark “Haldiram” was already pending consideration in application No. 285062. To this, a reply dated 18.7.1978 was filed on behalf of the applicants by Shri R.N. Prabhakar as their Advocate/Attorney, and in para 5 of which he has stated as under:

    5. As regards the cited pending trademark under Application No. 285062, it is to submit that applicants are the only firm trading under the name Haldiram Bhujiawala at Calcutta and no application is pending in the name of the applicants.

    20. Obviously, it was intended and was so represented on behalf of the applicants (No. 330375) that the registration was sought for use of the trade mark only in Calcutta. . That was obviously in consonance with the right reserved to them under the dissolution deed dated 16.11.1974 and otherwise available to them.

    21. Further in support of his Application No. 330375 by way of evidence, Rameshwar Lal had filed his affidavit dated 19.6.1978 wherein also he has not alleged or claimed that he was using this trademark outside Calcutta or beyond the State of West Bengal.

    22. Shri R.N. Prabhakar, Advocate, had acted for and represented the (plaintiffs)/ applicants in Trade Mark No. 285062 made for registration of the trademark on 29.12.1972 and it was he who had pursued and got the registration transferred in the names of four sons of Mool Chand vide certificate dated 27.1.1981 from the office of the Registrar, Trade Marks. Shri R.N. Prabhakar, Advocate, had also made the other Application (No. 330375) for registration of the trademark on behalf of Rameshwar Lal and Prabhu Shankar Aggarwal on 2.11.1977. It was within his, knowledge about the respective rights of the parties in this trade mark though in this application or even in reply dated 18.7.1978 he has not categorically disclosed and declared that the applicants were entitled to the use of the trademark only in and not beyond the State of West Bengal, however, the intention obviously was to get the trade mark registered for use in Calcutta only. Otherwise it would be a deliberate attempt on his part to have concealed a material fact to obtain registration in the latter's name. The Registrar has not appreciated it and has overlooked that Shri Rameshwar Lal and Prabhu Shankar had claimed registration for use in Calcutta only and obviously ignored the application No. 285062 filed on 29.12.1972 for registration of this trade mark for India in names of four other persons already pending consideration and the trademark was registered (330375) vide certificate issued on 11.9.1980. Registration of trade mark on the basis of application filed by Shri Rameshwar Lal much later than, the other application (No. 285062) filed on 29.12.1972 is intriguing. There could not be two similar registered trademarks in respect of same goods operating simultaneously. Either the Registrar has been misled or the said Registration No. 330375 has been granted fraudulently and in collusion with the applicants. In respect of a registered trade mark, the rights of the parties are to be determined as at the date of application. And Section 12 (1) of the Act is a bar against registration of an identical trademark which is already registered in the name of a different proprietor. Concurrent use by two or more persons of the same trademark for the same goods is completely contrary to the whole essence of trade mark Jurisprudence for a trademark is intended to denote that the goods come from one source and one source only.

    23. It appears that after the plaintiffs came to know about the registration of this trademark in the name of the defendants/their predecessor, they lodged an opposition with the Registrar, Trade Mark. Though that was disallowed but an appeal is admittedly pending before the High Court of Calcutta. The registration of the trademark in the name of defendants/their predecessor-in-interest having effect beyond the State of West Bengal thus is under dispute. Fraud vitiates all transactions. Registration of the trademark obtained by fraud would not acquire finality/immunity from challenge under Section 32(a) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 (for short “the Act”), which provides as under:

    32. Registration to be conclusive as to validity after seven years.––Subject to the provisions of Section 35 and Section 46, in all legal proceedings relating to a trademark registered in Part A of the register (including applications under Section 56), the original registration of the trademark shall, after the expiration of seven years from the date of such registration, be taken to be valid in all respects unless it is proved––

    (a) that the original registration was obtained by fraud; or

    (b) XX XX XX

    (c) XX XX XX

    24. A party would not be allowed to take advantage of its own fraud and as such prima facie this trademark could not be availed by the defendants beyond the State of West Bengal.

    25. The following result emerges from the above discussion:

    1. Late Shri Ganga Bishan who was also known as Haldiram Bhujiawala was the inventor/first adopter and first user of the tradename “Haldiram Bhujiawala” which he had adopted since his childhood in or before 1941 and he has been doing business in this tradename.

    2. He had adopted and used the trademark “Haldiram Bhujiawala” with the logo of “HRB” in a particular shape and design since 1965 while doing business in partnership under the names and style of (1) Chand Mal Ganga Bishan and (2) Haldiram Bhujiawala with four partners, namely, Ganga Bishan (himself), Mool Chand, Shiv Kishan and Smt. Kamla Devi.

    3. By means of dissolution deed dated 16.11.1974, the trademark was exclusively assigned to Shri Mool Chand for use in India except the State of West Bengal.

    4. Smt. Kamla Devi who was a party to the dissolution deed as a partner is bound by the terms of this dissolution deed.

    5. Rameshwar Lal, predecessor-in-interest of the defendants has also bound himself in his simultaneous declaration made on 16.11.1974 confirming/accepting the same.

    6. After the dissolution of the firm on 16.11.1974 Shri Mool Chand exclusively became entitled to the use of this trademark in India except in the State of West Bengal.

    7. After the death of Shri Mool Chand, this trademark was transmitted to his four sons, namely, Shiv Kishan Aggarwal, Shiv Ratan Aggarwal, Manoharlal Aggarwal and Madhusudan Aggarwal w.e.f. July 30, 1985.

    And they became the registered subsequent proprietor of this trademark.

    8. Subsequently, this trademark was assigned/transmitted in the name of the company Haldiram (India) Pvt. Ltd. in 1995.

    9. Defendants or their predecessor-in-interest-Rameshwar Lal was doing his business only in Calcutta.

    10. The plaintiff No. 1, M/s. Anand Kumar Deepak Kumar, comprising of three sons of Mool Chand had started a shop in Chandni Chowk in the year 1983 and using the said trademark. They are prior user of this trademark in Delhi. They thus are both registered proprietors as well as prior user of this trademark.

    26. The defendants prima facie are not entitled to its use. They have started a shop in Delhi in February, 1992 after this suit was filed, using the tradename/trademark of “Haldiram Bhujiawala” which is infringement of the registered trade mark of plaintiff, or in any case passing off.

    27. Plaintiffs have thus prima facie case in their favour.

    28. Defendants had no business in Delhi when the suit was filed. As such the question of their suffering any legal injury, damage or loss does not arise. The balance of convenience is also in favour of the plaintiffs as if the defendants are allowed to use identical trademark concurrently, this will create confusion among the public and loss, harm and injury to the plaintiffs. Plaintiffs have thus made out a strong case for grant of temporary injunction.

    29. This application is accordingly allowed and it is hereby ordered as under:

    1. Defendants, their agents/representatives/servants or successors-in-interest are hereby restrained by means of interim injunction from using the tradename and/ or trade mark “Haldiram Bhujiawala’ with or without the logo, as registered vide Registration No. 285062 or any other trade mark identical or deceptively similar thereto, in India except the State of West Bengal;

    2. the defendants shall submit within two months, statement of accounts showing the details of the sales, made by them in Delhi since 10.12.1.991 using this tradename and/or trademark verifying its correctness on affidavit;

    3. the defendants shall make discovery on affidavit within one month of all the documents, account books, papers etc. relating to such business since 10.12.1991 and shall file an undertaking that they shall not destroy or part with such documents till further orders of this Court; and

    4. they shall make available for inspection by the plaintiffs all such documents, account books, papers, etc. pertaining to the said business, if so required.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Anand Kumar Deepak Kumar Another v. Haldiram Bhujia Wala Another
    (May 1, 1999)