Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of s. 27 of the General Clauses Act
  • Article 123 of the Limitation Act of 1963,
  • clause (b) of Rule 2 of Order 29 C.P Code
  • SECTION 51 COMPANIES ACT
  • provision of Rule 2 of Order 29
  • s. 34 of the Companies, Act, 1956.
  • provisions of Order 29 Rule 2
  • s. 27 of General Clauses Act.
  • Rule 2 of Order 29 C.P Code
  • s. 2(15) of the Companies. Act
  • clause (b) of rule 2 Summons
  • s. 51 of the Companies Act
  • s. 34 of the Companies Act
  • s. 5 of the Limitation Act
  • Order 9 Rule 13 C.P Code
  • s. 51 the Companies Act
  • provision of Rule 2
  • Clause (b) of Rule 29
  • Rule 2 of Order 29
  • Order 9 Rule 13
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of s. 27 of the General Clauses Act
  • Article 123 of the Limitation Act of 1963,
  • clause (b) of Rule 2 of Order 29 C.P Code
  • SECTION 51 COMPANIES ACT
  • provision of Rule 2 of Order 29
  • s. 34 of the Companies, Act, 1956.
  • provisions of Order 29 Rule 2
  • s. 27 of General Clauses Act.
  • Rule 2 of Order 29 C.P Code
  • s. 2(15) of the Companies. Act
  • clause (b) of rule 2 Summons
  • s. 51 of the Companies Act
  • s. 34 of the Companies Act
  • s. 5 of the Limitation Act
  • Order 9 Rule 13 C.P Code
  • s. 51 the Companies Act
  • provision of Rule 2
  • Clause (b) of Rule 29
  • Rule 2 of Order 29
  • Order 9 Rule 13
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a suit (T.S No. 13/85) for eviction of the opposite party tenant on grounds of reasonable requirement and damage to the premises. Summons were attempted to be served both by Bailiff and registered post. The registered post summons was returned with the endorsement "Refused" and the opposite party did not appear, leading to an ex parte decree in favor of the petitioner. Possession was executed by breaking the padlock on 22nd September 1985. The opposite party then filed an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P. Code) and Section 5 of the Limitation Act, alleging mala fide service and suppression of summons. The Trial Judge dismissed this application, finding summons had been duly served and the delay in filing was not justified. The opposite party appealed, and the Appellate Court allowed the appeal by setting aside the ex parte decree. The petitioner filed the present revision petition challenging the Appellate Court's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether summons served by registered post at the tenant premises constituted valid service upon a Limited Company under the applicable procedural and statutory provisions.
  2. Whether Section 51 of the Companies Act prevails over Order 29 Rule 2 of the C.P. Code regarding service of summons on a Limited Company.
  3. Whether the ex parte decree obtained without valid service of summons should be set aside.
  4. Whether the application under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P. Code was barred by limitation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Trial Judge rightly found that summons sent by registered post to the business premises of the opposite party was duly served, as the postal endorsement "Refused" gives rise to a presumption of service under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act.
  • The Appellate Judge erred in reversing the Trial Judge's factual finding without evidence that the office was closed at the time of service.
  • The petitioner was unaware of the registered office address of the opposite party, but service at the business premises was proper under Order 29 Rule 2(b) C.P. Code.
  • The application under Order 9 Rule 13 was filed within limitation, as knowledge of the decree was only obtained on 22.11.85.
  • Section 51 of the Companies Act does not exclude service at the business premises if the registered office is not known or if the company carries on business there.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Service of summons on a Limited Company must be made strictly at the registered office as mandated by Section 51 of the Companies Act, which prevails over Order 29 Rule 2 C.P. Code.
  • The premises where the summons was served was only a branch or sales office, not the registered office, hence no valid service was effected.
  • Evidence showed the Calcutta office was temporarily closed from March 1984 to November 1985, so summons could not have been served or refused there.
  • The Appellate Court correctly reversed the Trial Judge's findings based on the evidence and this Court in revision cannot reappraise factual findings.
  • The application under Order 9 Rule 13 was filed within limitation since knowledge of the decree was obtained only on 22.11.85 after enquiry in Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1989 SC 630 Presumption of service of summons sent by registered post under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act. Reiterated that summons sent by registered post to the proper address raises a presumption of service which can be rebutted only by sufficient evidence.
Pannalal v. Murarilal, AIR 1967 SC 1384 Commencement of limitation period when summons is not duly served. Held that limitation starts running from knowledge of the particular decree sought to be set aside, not from vague information.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the provisions governing service of summons on a Limited Company, focusing on Order 29 Rule 2 C.P. Code and Section 51 of the Companies Act. While Order 29 Rule 2 permits service on a corporation at the registered office or place of business if no registered office exists, Section 51 specifically requires service on the registered office of a company. The Court held that Section 51 being a statutory provision prevails over the procedural rule. Therefore, summons must be served at the registered office of the Limited Company.

In the present case, the premises where summons were sent was a branch or sales office, not the registered office, and no summons was served at the registered office. The petitioner’s ignorance of the registered office address was not a valid excuse; the law mandates strict compliance with service at the registered office.

The Court accepted the Appellate Court’s finding that the Calcutta office was closed during the relevant period, which rebutted the presumption of service arising from the postal endorsement "Refused." The Court declined to disturb the Appellate Court’s factual findings as it functions as the final fact-finding authority in this matter.

Regarding limitation, the Court relied on the principle that limitation begins from the date of knowledge of the specific decree, not from vague or earlier information. Since the opposite party only obtained knowledge of the decree on 22.11.85 and filed the application within 30 days, the application was not barred by limitation.

Consequently, the Court found no illegality in the Appellate Court setting aside the ex parte decree due to non-service of summons in accordance with Section 51 of the Companies Act.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is dismissed.

The Court upheld the Appellate Court’s order setting aside the ex parte decree on the ground of invalid service of summons. The ruling affirms that service of summons on a Limited Company must comply strictly with Section 51 of the Companies Act, requiring service at the registered office. The petitioner’s failure to serve summons at the registered office resulted in non-service, justifying setting aside the decree. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and principles. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

    Harendra Nath Ghosal v. Superfoam Pvt. Ltd.

    M.R Mallick, J.:—This revision petition under s. 115 C.P Code is directed against the order dated 8th January, 1990 passed by the Addl. District Judge, 8th Court. Alipore in Misc. Appeal No. 421/88 arising out of Misc. Case No. 44/85 disposed of by the Asstt. District Judge, 4th Court, Alipore. Facts may be briefly stated as follows:—

    2. The present petitioner as plaintiff filed T.S No. 13/85 in the Court of the Sub-ordinate Judge, 4th Court, Alipore for eviction of the opposite party tenant on the ground of reasonable requirement and also on the ground of damaging a portion of the premises in suit. Summons was sought to be served upon the present opposite party both through Bailiff as well as by registered post. As the Summons of the suit was sent under registered post to the address of the tenanted premises and as the envelope came with the endorsement “Refused” and as the opposite party did not appear to contest the suit, the present petitioner/obtained an ex parte decree from the learned. Trial Judge on 3685. In execution of such decree the petitioner obtained delivery of possession of the suit property on 22nd September, 1985 through Process Server after breaking the padlock of the tenanted premises in terms of the order passed by the Executing Court. The opposite party-defendant thereafter filed an application on 16.12.85 under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P Code along with the application filed under s. 5 of the Limitation Act alleging inter alia that the plaintiff with mala fide intention in collusion with the Process Server and the postal peon suppressed the Summons and registered notice upon the defendant-opposite party and obtained the decree on 3rd June, 1985, that due to some trouble in the business the opposite party's office in Calcutta had to close the operation of business temporarily and during the absence of the men of the defendant the plaintiff hurriedly executed the decree and got the possession of the premises and appropriated the articles and furniture worth of huge amounts, that the officer of the defendant only on 13.11.85 came to Calcutta and found that the landlord is in possession of the said property and upon enquiry in Court on 22.11.85 came to know about the ex parte decree. The present petitioner opposed the said application which was converted in Misc. Case No. 44/85. The learned Trial Judge before whom both the parties led oral and documentary evidence by his order no. 39 dated 25th June, 1988 dismissed the Misc. Case together with the petition under s. 5 of the Limitation Act on the finding that Summons had been duly served upon the present opposite party and that the application under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P Code is, therefore, liable to be dismissed as there was no sufficient ground for condonation of the delay in filing the application.

    3. Being aggrieved the present opposite party preferred appeal and the learned Appellate Judge in Misc. Appeal No. 421/88 by his Judgement and order dated 8th January, 1990 allowed the appeal and set aside the ex parte decree in T.S No. 13 of 1985.

    Being aggrieved the present Revision Petition has been filed.

    4. The appeal has been contested by the opposite party tenant. It is urged on behalf of the petitioner that the learned Appellate Judge committed a great illegality in reversing the finding of fact arrived at by the learned Trial Judge that Summons under registered post was duly served. It is contended that even though there was no material for the learned Appellate Judge to come to the finding that the Summons had been fraudulently suppressed the learned Appellate Judge came to the finding without any evidence that the witness adduced by the petitioner not being in the office of the opposite party at about the time when the Summons was served or possession was taken the learned Trial Judge ought not to have accepted the evidence of the said witness to come to the finding that as the office of the opposite party was closed temporarily at about the lime when the Summons was served then there was no question of the Summons by registered post to be tendered to any authorised person of the opposite party no. 1, that the learned Appellate Judge failed to consider that in the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 no whimper was made that at about the time when the Summons was served the office of the opposite party was closed and that the learned Appellate Judge also illegally held that s. 51 of the Companies Act would govern the service of the Summons upon a Limited Company governed by the Companies Act and when no such Summons was served upon the registered office of the opposite party there was no valid service of Summons upon the opposite party. It is also urged that there was no sufficient explanation as to why even after coming to know about the dispossession on 13.11.85 the application under Order 9 Rule 13 was filed on 16.12.85 that is more than 30 days from the date of alleged knowledge and even on that ground the application ought to have been dismissed being barred by limitation.

    5. On behalf of the respondent it has been submitted that the learned Appellate Judge was perfectly justified in reversing the finding of the learned Trial Judge as in effect there was no proper service of Summons upon the opposite party which is a Private Limited Co., registered under the Companies Act and in case of such Company the Summons has to be served in view of s. 51 of the Companies Act to the registered office, that the premises in which the opposite party was occupying as a premises tenant under the present petitioner was merely a branch and sales office and not the registered office. Therefore, even if it be conceded that the Summons under registered post was sent to the tenanted address, the Summons not having been sent to the registered office of the opposite party, there was no service of summons upon the opposite party and only on that ground the ex parte decree was liable to be set aside. It is also submitted that there was sufficient evidence adduced before the learned Trial Judge that the office of the opposite party was temporarily closed in between March, 1984 to November, 1985 and that the learned Appellate Judge came to the finding of fact on the basis of the evidence and in this revision petition under s. 115 C.P Code this Court cannot sit as a Court of Appeal and reverse such finding of fact on evidence. It is also submitted that when only on making appropriate search in the Court on 22.11.85 the opposite party came to learn of the ex parte decree and the present application has been filed on 16.12.85 the petition cannot be held to be barred by limitation.

    6. As regards the service of Summons upon a limited company the provisions of Order 29 Rule 2 have to be looked into. Rule 2 reads as follows:—

    “2. Service on Corporation—Subject to any statutory provision regulating service of process, where the suit is against the Corporation, the Summons; may be served—

    (a) on the Secretary, or any Director, or other Principal Officer or Corporation, or

    (b) by leaving or sending it by post to the Corporation at the registered office or if there is no registered office then at the place where the Corporation carries on business”

    7. Mr. Dasgupta appearing for the petitioner submits that the expression “Corporation” in Rule 2 includes a Company which is constituted under s. 34 of the Companies, Act, 1956. He submits that under clause (b) of rule 2 Summons may be served either in the registered office of the Company or at the place where the Corporation carries on business. He submits that “if there is no registered office” used in clause (b) cannot mean that the Sammons can be served at the business premises of a limited company only when there is no registered office of the Limited Company. He submits that under s. 34 of the Companies Act there cannot be a Company without a registered office. Therefore, the relevant portion of clause (b) will have to be interpreted as meaning that where the limited company carries on business at a place other than at its registered office the Summons can be served even at that place even though such premises is not the registered office of the Company. He therefore, submits that even if the premises is which the opposite party is carrying on business as a premises tenants under the petitioner were not their registered office then under clause (b) of Rule 2 of Order 29 C.P Code a Summons could be served on that office. It is submitted that the petitioner was not aware as to where the registered office of the opposite party was and that in the circumstances the Summons was served in the premises where the Private Limited Company was carrying on business at Calcutta and therefore sending the Summons of the suit on the said address by registered post was a proper compliance of service of process upon a Limited Company that when the said Summons sent to the said business premises of the opposite party was returned by the postal peon with the endorsement “Refused” then in view of the provisions of s. 27 of the General Clauses Act there is a presumption of due service of Summons and the said presumption has not been properly rebutted by the present opposite party by leading the evidence of Mr. Nagrajan who was in charge of the Calcutta office of the opposite party at about the time when the Summons was sent by registered post, and that the learned trial Judge was perfectly justified in holding that the Summons was duly rerved upon the opposite party by registered post and the learned Appellate Judge committed a great illegality in reversing that finding. On this point he has referred to a recent decision of Supreme Court reported in AIR 1989 SC 630 where the Supreme Court has reiterated that when a Summons was sent at the proper address of the addressee by registered post and tendered with the postal authority for service then the presumption of service arises under s. 27 of General Clauses Act. Such presumption even though rebuttable has to be rebutted by the other side by leading sufficient evidence.

    8. On perusal of the record of the learned. Trial Judge we find that the learned Trial Judge caused service of Summons both by Bailiff as well as by registered post. The order-sheet of the Learned Trial Judge revealed that he did not find the service of Summons upon the opposite party through Bailiff to be satisfactory. But on accepting the service of summons through registered post which was returned back with the endorsement “Refused” by the postal authority the Learned Trial Judge fixed a date for ex parte hearing on the ground that the opposite party did not appear to contest the suit. Therefore, in this case we are only concerned as to whether the Summons by registered post has been duly served or not.

    9. On behalf of the opposite party it is contended that Rule 2 of Order 29 C.P Code clearly indicate that the provision of Rule 2 is not exhaustive but this is subject to any statutory provision regulating the service of process upon the Corporation. It is contended that s. 51 of the Companies Act contains such statutory provision regulating service of the document on a Limited Company which includes Summons and such specific provision would prevail over Rule 2 of Order 29 and secondly the Learned Appellate Judge was perfectly justified in holding that the Summons was not served upon the opposite party to its registered office as provided in s. 51 and, therefore, it is crystal clear that there was non-service of Summons upon the defendant-opposite party and the ex parte decree was, therefore, liable to be set aside.

    10. Section 51 of the Companies Act which deals with service of document on Company enjoins that a document may be served on a Company or an officer thereto fey sending it to the Company or officer at the registered office of the Company by post under a certificate of posting or by registered post or by leaving to its registered office. That the expression “document” used in s. 51 of the Companies Act includes Summons is clear from s. 2(15) of the Companies. Act The “Document” in view of s. 2(15) of the Companies Act includes Summons, notices, requisition, order, other legal processess and registers whether issued, sent or kepi in pursuance of this or any other Act or otherwise. In that view we are satisfied that the learned Appellate Judge was perfectly justified that when Rule 2 of Order 29 provides for service of process in a suit against a Corporation subject, however, to any statutory provision regulating such service, therefore, in the matter of service of Summons upon a Limited Company the provision of Rule 2 of Order 29 shall be subject to s. 51 of the Companies Act. The result is that provision of S. 51 would prevail over Rule 2 of Order 29 C.P Code. Therefore, a Summons upon a Limited Company has to be served at its registered office in terms of s. 51 of the Companies Act. In this particular case it is not the case of the petitioner that the premises in suit was the registered office of the opposite party. It is sought to be argued on behalf of the petitioner that the petitioner was not aware of the registered office of the opposite party-company. But such a contention is not at all acceptable. The plaintiff filing a suit against a Company registered under the Companies Act has to cause the service of summons strictly in terms of s. 51 of the Companies. When a Private Limited Company for the purpose of their Branch and Sales Office at the Calcutta took tenancy of the premises from the present petitioner for starting a Sales or Branch Office there it was for the plaintiff to properly ascertain and be satisfied about the address of its registered office because in the case of any proceeding to be initiated against Limited Company in a Court of Law the service of Summons or notices have all to be served in the registered office of the Company in terms of s. 51 of the Companies Act. Admittedly in this case no such summons was served upon the registered office, of the opposite party. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioner that such office was never disclosed and that even though in a criminal proceeding the registered office was disclosed as at a place in the State of Kerala. The notice of this revision case on being served upon the opposite party at that address was returned back ‘Unserved’.

    11. We are of the view that it is not material that the opposite party did not disclose to the petitioner the address of the registered office. It is the mandate of law that a Summons upon a Limited Company has to be served at its registered office in accordance with the s. 51 the Companies Act and when that has not been followed in this case then it must be held that the Summons upon the opposite party of the suit was not duly served upon the opposite party and there is admittedly a non-service of Summons upon the opposite party at the address of his registered office.

    12. Mr. Dasgupta has submitted that Summons under Clause (b) of Rule 29 could be served in the premises in suit even though it was not the registered office of the opposite party. In view of the above we are unable to accept the above contention of Mr. Dasgupta. Mr. Dasgupra submits that a Limited Company must have a registered office and Clause (b) in the second part must be interpreted as permitting the service of Summons at any other business place of the Limited Company than the registered office.

    13. We are of the view that Rule 2 of Order 29 provides for service of Summons and notices upon the Corporation. Even though a Company governed by the Companies Act includes within the definition of Corporation as the legal concept of a Company is a Corporation aggregate, the expression “Corporation” has not been defined in the C.P Code. Therefore, the dictionary meaning of Corporation could have to be used in interpreting Rule 2. Apart from Corporation aggregate there is the legal concept of Corporation sole constituting a single individual. Moreover, the expression “Corporation” could also include a statutory Corporation established by any law for the time being in force in India. Therefore, in respect of such types of Corporation there may not be registered office and the second part of Clause (b) contemplates the service of Summons of notices upon such a Corporation having been no registered office. In respect of such Corporation Summons at the place where the Corporation carries on business would be sufficient compliance under Rule 2 of Order 29 C.P Code. But so far as a limited company is concerned the service of Summons has to be effected in terms of s. 51 of the Companies Act and in this case when admittedly there was no service of Summons upon the registered office of the opposite party there was no valid service of Summons upon the opposite party.

    14. Even assuming that the Summons could have been served in the premises in suit where the defendant was running an office occupying the same as a tenant under the present petitioner we have great doubt as regards whether the said Summons by the registered post was not duly served or not. Before the learned Trial Judge the petitioner examined one C.S Baby who has stated in his evidence that from March 1984 to November, 1985 the Company was temporarily closed and nobody was available at the office of Calcutta and it was under lock and key during that period. He has further stated that only on 22.11.85 he came to know about the existence of the decree against the opposite party, that on 13.11.85 he wanted to enter the office when he noted that their lock was changed, that he called the landlord who was not telling clearly and that thereafter he lodged a G.D Entry at the Thana.

    15. On behalf of the petitioner it is urged that the learned Trial Judge rightly disbelieved this testimony as he was admittedly not posted in Calcutta office at about the time when the Summons was served by registered post and therefore he was not competent to depose about the facts prior to November, 1985 when according to him he for the first time came to Calcutta to join the Calcutta office in November, 1985.

    16. Mr. Dasgupta submits that at the material time Mr. Nagrajan was the Officer-in-Charge of the Calcutta office that even in November, 1985 he came to Sales-Tax Office in Calcutta representing the opposite party company and that the failure of the opposite party to examine Nagrajan before the learned Trial Judge was fatal and the learned Trial Judge, therefore, rightly disbelieved the testimony of P.W 1, C.S Baby. We are of the view that the Court of Revision cannot interfere with the finding of fact based on evidence by the Appellate Court which is the final Court of fact. The appellate Court on appreciating the evidence adduced by the parties accepted the opposite party's story that their office was closed between March, 1984 to November, 1985. Mr. Dasgupta has submitted that such a case was not made in the petition and was made only in evidence. But on considering the evidence of the present petitioner in the proceeding under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P Code we find that the present petitioner who was himself residing on the upper floor of the premises admitted in his evidence that at about the material time the office of the opposite party in Calcutta remained closed on most of the time. He has not in his evidence stared specifically that even at about the time Summons was alleged to have been served by registered post in the Calcutta office of the opposite party, the office of the opposite party remained opened. When the opposite party was living in the same premises he could have definite knowledge as to whether when the Summons was allegedly served in the premises in suit by the postal authority the office of the opposite party was open and there was some competent persons on behalf of the opposite party to whom the Summons could be tendered and refused.

    16A. In the circumstances the learned Appellate Judge did not commit any illegality by accepting the testimony of C.S Baby that the Calcutta office of the opposite party remained temporarily closed from March 1984 to November, 1985.

    17. If the office of the opposite party at Calcutta was closed at about the time when the postal peon is alleged to have tendered the Summons at the said office then there could definitely be nobody either to accept it or to refuse the tender. In that view the presumption of service must be held to have been duly rebutted by this very strong circumstance negativing valid tender and refusal of the Summons through postal authority.

    18. The petitioner has alleged that on 13.11.85 the representative came to Calcutta and found that the lock of the office has been changed that thereafter on 26.11.85 the opposite party came to ascertain about the ex parte decree and within 30 days thereof the present application has been tuned. On behalf of the petitioner it is urged that there is no explanation as to why within 30 days of 13.11.85 the application was not filed. Once it is found that the Summons has not been duly served under Article 123 of the Limitation Act of 1963, then the time from which the limitation is to be reckoned is the date of the knowledge of the decree. P.W 1 has in his evidence stated that on 13.11.85 when he met the landlord he was not given satisfactory answer and it is only on 22.11.85 he came to know for the first time the existence of the decree. In Pannalal v. Murarilal, AIR 1967 S.C 1384 the Supreme Court has held that when Summons has not been duly served limitation does not start running against the defendant from a date because he has received some vague information about a decree being passed against him and the knowledge of the decree means the knowledge of the particular decree sought to be set aside. In that view we are unable to interfere with the judgement and order passed by the learned Appellate Judge allowing the Misc. Appeal and setting aside the ex parte decree passed in T.S No. 13/85. The Revision Petition is, therefore, dismissed. In the circumstances of the present case we direct the parties to bear the respective costs themselves.

    M.N Roy, J.:—I agree.

    Application dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harendra Nath Ghosal v. Superfoam Pvt. Ltd.
    (Mar 14, 1991)