AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This Civil Revision Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenges the decree and order passed by the Principal District Judge, Tiruvallur in I.A. No. 870 of 2009 in O.S. No. 45 of 2009 dated 04.02.2011.

The petitioners (plaintiffs) instituted a suit under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) seeking removal of defendants 2 and 3 as trustees of "Bhajrang Educational & Social Trust", accounts relating to the Trust and College from 01.04.2011, a declaration that the Managing Trustee's powers under the Trust Deed dated 02.08.2000 were illegal and invalid, and settlement of a scheme for exercise of powers by the trustees.

The plaintiffs had earlier obtained leave to file the Section 92 suit via I.A. No. 144 of 2009 (allowed on 02.04.2009). After service of summons, defendant 1 (respondent in revision) filed I.A. No. 870 of 2009 to revoke the leave, contending that the plaintiffs sought only to vindicate personal rights rather than any public right. The trial court allowed the revocation application and cancelled the leave on 04.02.2011. The petitioners filed the present civil revision challenging that order.

Background litigation includes O.S. No. 63 of 2007 instituted by defendants 1 to 3 in the Sub Court, Tiruvallur, challenging a purported Trust Board meeting held on 12.03.2007 and related nominations; interlocutory applications were filed in that suit and the Sub Judge allowed the defendants' applications and dismissed an application by the petitioners. The opinion also notes previous transactions (registered sale deeds dated 02.08.2000) and partition suits O.S. Nos. 230 & 231 of 2007 initiated by the petitioners' children as pleaded by the respondent's counsel.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the leave granted to the plaintiffs to file a suit under Section 92 CPC should be revoked on the ground that the plaint discloses only a claim to vindicate individual or personal rights rather than public rights of a charitable trust.
  2. Whether the plaintiffs' suit invoking Section 92 CPC is maintainable when the averments in the plaint and supporting documents show the primary object of the suit is to assert personal rights of certain trustees/members rather than to protect public interest in a charitable trust.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Plaintiffs') Arguments

  • The plaintiffs alleged misappropriation of funds by the Managing Trustee and poor or non-existent accounting for the Trust/College receipts.
  • They asserted that they are trustees of the Bhajrang Educational & Social Trust and were being obstructed from participating in administration; they sought relief under Section 92 CPC (including removal of trustees and account rendition).
  • The plaintiffs stated that they had requested convening of a Board meeting by letter dated 18.01.2007 and received no response, and therefore they were entitled to proceed under Section 92.
  • Counsel for the petitioners contended that with the allegations in the plaint, the plaintiffs could legitimately seek relief under Section 92 CPC.

Respondent's (Defendant's) Arguments

  • The Trust was formed in 2000 with the 2nd defendant as founder and Managing Trustee; the 2nd defendant had nominated the plaintiffs and another as trustees, who allegedly did not take active interest.
  • The respondent contended that notices for the purported meeting on 12.03.2007 were not received by the defendants and that the meeting and subsequent nominations were invalid; accordingly defendants 1 to 3 filed O.S. No. 63 of 2007 challenging that meeting.
  • The respondent detailed prior interlocutory proceedings in O.S. No. 63 of 2007 where the Sub Court allowed defendants' interim applications and dismissed the petitioners' application for injunction (I.A. No. 174 of 2007).
  • The respondent argued that the plaintiffs had sold properties to the Trust (registered sale deeds dated 02.08.2000) and later instigated partition suits (O.S. Nos. 230 & 231 of 2007), and that the 2009 suit was instituted long after negotiations and litigation merely to vindicate private/personal disputes.
  • Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court judgment in Vidyodaya Trust v. Mohan Prasad R. ((2008) 4 SCC 115) to submit that a suit under Section 92 CPC is not maintainable if its primary object is to vindicate individual or personal rights.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vidyodaya Trust v. Mohan Prasad R., (2008) 4 SCC 115 The objection of Section 92 CPC is to protect public trusts of charitable/religious nature from harassment by suits; if the primary object of the suit is to vindicate individual/personal rights, Section 92 does not apply; courts should examine plaint averments initially to determine whether suit falls within Section 92. The trial court's approach and the High Court's view referenced this authority to decide that the plaintiffs' plaint, on analysis, showed the suit was aimed at personal rights and thus not maintainable under Section 92.
V. Rajasekaran v. M. Rajendran, 2007 (2) CTC 769 (Division Bench) Summarised principles: (1) suits under Section 92 must ventilate public rights not personal rights; (2) question of grant of leave can be considered without notice though courts may issue notice; (3) grant of leave depends primarily on plaint averments; (4) averments in written statement/objection can be considered to ascertain bona fides. The court relied on these settled principles (as summarized in this decision) to consider whether the plaintiffs' averments warranted leave and whether the grant of leave was bona fide; these principles guided the court's conclusion that leave was rightly revoked.
Swami Parmatmanand and Saraswati v. Ramji Tripathi, AIR 1974 SC 2141 Establishes that suits under Section 92 should ventilate public rights and not protect personal rights of the plaintiff or others. Referenced as authority for the proposition that Section 92 is inapplicable where the suit's primary object is personal/private rights; used to assess maintainability of the plaintiffs' suit.
R.M. Narayana Chettiar v. N. Lakshmanan Chettiar, AIR 1991 SC 221 On the procedure of considering the question of grant of leave: the court can consider grant of leave without issuing notice, though sometimes notice is issued and considered. Used to support the proposition that revocation of leave can properly be considered and that the court may examine matters even where initial leave had been granted.
Tirupattur Nagarathu Vysiyargal Sangam v. Tirupattur Periyakulam Nadavanam Inam Land Tenants Association, 1998 (1) MLJ 303 Also cited for the principle regarding consideration of leave to sue under Section 92: grant of leave may be considered without notice but courts sometimes issue notice. Referred to among authorities that frame procedural approach to leave under Section 92.
B.S. Adityan v. B. Ramachandran Adityan, 2004 AIR SCW 3004 Another authority cited for the same procedural proposition about grant of leave and issuing notice to defendants. Placed alongside other decisions to justify the procedural course taken in examining revocation of leave.
Unspecified case reported at AIR 1975 SC 371 (cited in text) Stated proposition: Whether leave should be granted primarily depends upon the allegations made in the plaint/application seeking leave. Used to underscore that the court must look to allegations in the plaint as the primary determinant of grant or revocation of leave under Section 92.
L.M. Menezes v. Lawrence Pius, 2004 (1) CTC 321: 2004 (1) MLJ 258 Permits consideration of averments made in the written statement/objection for the limited purpose of ascertaining the bona fides of the applicant seeking leave. Adopted to justify the trial court's consideration of the defendants' objections/averments in assessing whether the plaintiffs' application for leave was bona fide or an attempt to use Section 92 for personal ends.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the pleadings and the documentary evidence (referred to as exhibits P1 to P10). The analysis proceeded on the established test for Section 92 CPC cases: initial scrutiny of the averments in the plaint to determine whether the suit's primary object is to protect public rights or to vindicate private/personal rights.

Applying authorities (notably Vidyodaya Trust v. Mohan Prasad R. and the Division Bench decision in V. Rajasekaran v. M. Rajendran), the court observed that where, on the face of the plaint and supporting documents, the suit discloses a primary objective of asserting individual rights, a suit under Section 92 is not maintainable. The court also applied the principle that, in assessing the bona fides of the applicant for leave, limited consideration may be given to the averments in the written objections.

On review of the materials (P1–P10) and the procedural history (including prior proceedings in O.S. No. 63 of 2007 and the interlocutory orders of the Sub Court), the court concluded that the plaintiffs had instituted the suit essentially to vindicate their personal rights (e.g., to retain certain positions in the Trust or to remove particular trustees) rather than to vindicate any public interest of the charitable trust.

Because the plaint revealed a personal-object focus, and the grant of leave under Section 92 had been obtained for what the court found to be non-public purposes, the trial court's revocation of the leave was considered appropriate. The High Court (in this revision) found no ground to interfere with that conclusion.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The civil revision petition was dismissed, thereby confirming the decree and order passed in I.A. No. 870 of 2009 in O.S. No. 45 of 2009 dated 04.02.2011.

Consequential orders recorded by the court: no costs were awarded, and the connected Miscellaneous Petition was closed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties: The leave previously granted to the plaintiffs to file the suit under Section 92 CPC was properly cancelled and stands confirmed by this court; the plaintiffs' attempt to pursue their claims under Section 92 as a means to vindicate what the court found were private rights has been rejected.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion applies and re-affirms settled principles on the narrow scope of suits under Section 92 CPC (as articulated in Vidyodaya Trust and related authorities). The court did not purport to create any new legal principle beyond applying existing precedents.

This summary is based exclusively on the text of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond what the opinion contains.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    A. Duruvasulu Naidu v. Bhajarang Educational & Social Trust

    Prayer:- Civil Revision Petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India against decree and order passed in I.A No. 870 of 2009 in O.S No. 45 of 2009 dated 04.02.2011 on the file of the learned Principal District Judge, Tiruvallur to set aside the said order.

    ORDER

    This Civil Revision Petition is filed challenging the order passed by the Principal District Judge, Tiruvallur in I.A No. 870 of 2009 in O.S No. 45 of 2009.

    2. The petitioners, as plaintiffs instituted a suit against the respondent and five others under Section 92 of C.P.C praying for removal of the defendants 2 and 3 as trustees of “Bhajrang Educational & Social Trust”; directing the defendants 2 and 3 to render accounts with respect to the Trust and College run by the Trust from 01.04.2011 and declaring the powers of the Managing Trustee under the Trust Deed dated 02.08.2000 as illegal and invalid and settling a scheme for exercise of powers by the Trustees.

    3. The petitioners filed I.A No. 144 of 2009 seeking leave of the court to file a suit under Section 92 of C.P.C and the trial court allowed the application on 02.04.2009 After receiving the summons in the suit, the 1 defendant, respondent herein filed I.A No. 870 of 2009 to revoke the leave granted to the plaintiffs to file the suit mainly contending that the plaintiffs are not seeking to vindicate any public right but only seek a declaration of their personal right. The application was resisted by the petitioners by filing a counter.

    4. The learned Trial Judge allowed the application and cancelled the leave granted in I.A No. 144 of 2009. Questioning the order dated 04.02.2011 in I.A No. 870 of 2009 in O.S No. 45 of 2009, the present revision has been filed.

    5. Mr. S. Parthasarathy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that the plaintiffs have made allegations of misappropriation of funds in the plaint, that the plaintiffs are admittedly trustees of “Bhajarang Educational & Social Trust” and the defendants are not running the Trust in a democratic fashion and they have also not maintained the accounts of the Trust. It is further submitted that the plaintiffs by letter dated 18.01.2007 requested the defendant to convene the meeting of the Trust Board but there was no response from him. The learned Senior Counsel also submitted that, with the allegations made in the plaint, the plaintiffs can seek the remedy under Section 92 of CPC as they have got alternate remedy.

    6. Per contra, Mr. R. Muthukumarasamy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent submitted that the Trust was formed in the year 2000 and the 2nd defendant, as the founder and Managing Trustee of the Trust has nominated the plaintiffs and one Mr. Balram Naidu, the 4th defendants as the Trustees of the Trust but they did not evince any interest in the functioning of the Trust. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that in the year 2007, the 1 plaintiff issued a notice stating himself as the Secretary of the Trust as they were nominated in a meeting held on 12.03.2007 The plaintiffs contended that on 05.02.2007, they issued a notice to the respondent for convening a Trust Board meeting on 12.03.2007 and in the meeting, the 1 plaintiff and the 4 defendants have nominated themselves as Secretary and Treasure of the trust, respectively.

    7. The learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the defendant did not receive notice dated 05.02.2007 and therefore the defendants 1 to 3 filed suit in O.S No. 63 of 2007 before the Sub Court, Tiruvallur seeking for declaration of the meeting purported to be held on 12.03.2007 as illegal and invalid. The defendants have also prayed for a consequential relief in the suit. The learned senior counsel further submitted that the defendants 1 to 3 filed interlocutory applications in the suit in I.A No. 151 to 153 of 2007 to restrain the 1 plaintiff and 4 defendant from acting as a Secretary and Treasurer; for injunction restraining the defendants 5 to 7 from acting as Trustees and for injunction restraining from holding any meeting of the Trust. In the suit, the petitioner herein filed I.A No. 174 of 2007 seeking for injunction restraining the defendants 2 and 3 from interfering with the rights of the first plaintiff and 4 defendant in the management of the Trust. However, the learned Sub Judge, allowed the applications filed by the defendants in I.A Nos. 151/07 to 153 of 2007 dismissing the applications filed by the petitioners in I.A No. 174 of 2007.

    8. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the petitioners have sold their properties to the Trust by registered sale deeds dated 02.08.2000 but instigated their children to file a suit claiming partition in O.S Nos. 230 & 231 of 2007. The learned Senior counsel contended that long after the negotiations of litigations, the petitioners instituted this suit on 31.03.2009 only to vindicate their private and personal disputes. The learned Senior counsel relying upon a judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Vidyodaya Trust v. Mohan Prasad R. reported in (2008) 4 SCC 115 submitted that the present suit is not maintainable even though it is coached in the way to invoke Section 92 of CPC.

    9. It is not in dispute that “Bhajarang Educational & Social Trust” was established by the 2 defendant Mr. M.G Baskaran and as per the Trust Deed dated 02.08.2000, he was nominated as Founder and Managing Trustee of the Trust. The plaintiffs have contended that after commencing of the College, the conduct and behaviour of the 2 defendant has changed and with a view to defraud the other Trustees, he started to act against them and also against the interest of the Trust. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the Managing Trustee obstructed the other Trustees in participating from the administration of the Trust and he had received amounts by way of capitation fees from the students of the College but has not maintained accounts properly.

    10. The plaintiffs have further contended that on 18.01.2007, they requested to convene a meeting of Board of Trust on 12.03.2007 and in the meeting, the defendants 5 to 7 have been appointed as additional trustees and the 1 plaintiff was nominated as Secretary and the 4 defendant has been nominated as Treasurer of the Trust. Though the plaintiffs have contended that they issued a notice on 18.01.2007 to convene meeting on 12.03.2007, the defendants denied receipt of notice. The defendants 1 to 3 have also filed a suit in O.S No. 63 of 2007 questioning the meeting held on 12.03.2007 and the nominations of the 1 plaintiff and the 4 defendant as Secretary and Treasurer of the Trust. The defendants have also challenged the appointment of new trustees who are added as defendants 4 to 6 in the suit.

    11. Indisputably, the Sub Court, Tiruvellore allowed the applications filed by the defendants 1 to 3 herein on 20.07.1999 and the same was also confirmed in CMA Nos. 27, 28 & of 29 of 2007. A cursory look of the prayer of the plaint would reveal that the plaintiffs and the defendants 4 to 7 wanted to hold their positions in the Trust and they are seeking for removal of the defendants 2 and 3 alone. The plaintiffs who have lost their case in O.S No. 63 of 2007 have filed the suit only to vindicate their personal right in the year 2009. It is useful to refer the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in (2008) 4 SCC 115 which reads as follows -

    18. Prior to legislative change made by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act (104 of 1976), the expression used was “consent in writing of the Advocate General”. Sub-section (3) has also been inserted by the Amendment Act. The objection of Section 92 CPC is to protect the public trust of a charitable and religious nature from being subjected to harassment by suits filed against them. Public trusts for charitable and religious purpose are run for the benefit of the public. No individual should take benefit from them. If the persons in management of the trusts are subjected to multiplicity of legal proceedings, funds which are to be used for charitable or religious purposes would be wasted on litigation. The harassment might dissuade respectable and honest people from becoming trustees of public trusts. Thus, there is need for scrutiny.

    19. In the suit against public trusts, if on analysis of the averments contained in the plaint it transpires that the primary object behind the suit was the vindication of individual or personal rights of some persons an action under the provision does not lie. As noted in Swami Paramatmanand case a suit under Section 92 CPC is a suit of special nature, which presupposes the existence of a public trust of religious or charitable character. When the plaintiffs do not sue to vindicate the right of the public but seek a declaration of their individual or personal rights or the individual or personal rights of any other persons or persons in whom they are interested, Section 92 has no application.

    20. In Swami Paramatmanand case, it was held that it is only the allegations in the plaint that should be looked into in the first instance to see whether the suit falls within the ambit of Section 92. But if after evidence is taken it is found that the breach of trust alleged has not been made out and that the prayer for direction of the Court is vague and is not based on any solid foundation in fact or reason but is made only with a view to bringing the suit under the Section then suit purporting to be brought under Section 92 must be dismissed.

    12. In a Division Bench decision of this Court in V. Rajasekaran v. M. Rajendran reported in 2007 (2) CTC 769, it has been held as follows -

    12. From those decisions, it can be said that the following principles are well settled:

    (1) Such suit should be filed to ventilate the right of the public and not for protecting the personal right or the individual right of the plaintiff or to any other person (see Swami Parmatman and Saraswati v. Ramji Tripathi AIR 1974 SC 2141)

    (2) Even though the question of grant of leave can be considered by the Court without issuing notice to the defendant, since the defendant can seek for revocation of leave, the Court at times consider the question of grant of leave after issuing notice to the defendant. (See R.M Narayana Cheettiar v. N. Lakshmanan Chettiar, AIR 1991 SC 221; Tirupattur Nagarathu Vysiyargal Sangam v. Tirupattur Periyakulam Nadavanam Inam Land Tenants Association, Tirupattur Town, 1998 (1) MLJ 303 and B.S Adityan v. B. Ramachandran Adityan, 2004 AIR SCW 3004).

    (3) The question as to whether leave should be granted or not primarily depend upon the allegations made in the plaint/application seeking leave. (See AIR 1975 SC 371).

    (4) However, since the Court is required to find out the bona fide of the applicant, the averments made in the written statement/objection can be considered for the said limited purpose (See L.M. Menezes v. Lawrence Pius, 2004 (1) CTC 321: 2004 (1) MLJ 258).

    13. In the above referred judgment, this Court has held that the averments made in the written statement or objection of the tenant can be considered for the limited purpose to find out bonafides of the plaintiffs for instituting the suit.

    14. In the case on hand, the learned Principal Judge, Tiruvallur has considered in detail the documents/exhibits P1 to P10 and observed that the petitioners have instituted the suit to vindicate their personal rights and thus cancelled the leave granted in their favour. In my considered opinion, the petitioners have not made out a case warranting interference by this Court.

    15. In the result, the civil revision petition is dismissed confirming the decree and order passed in I.A No. 870 of 2009 in O.S No. 45 of 2009 dated 04.02.2011 No costs. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    A. Duruvasulu Naidu v. Bhajarang Educational & Social Trust
    (Dec 11, 2014)