Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Act, 1976 (for short Act) read with Rules 33(v) and 23(1)
  • Clause (d) of sub-section (3) of Section
  • Rule 2(q), consequently Rule 6
  • Act and the PC Rules. Rule 6
  • Rule 2(k) of the PC Rules
  • Rule 2(r) of the PC Rules.
  • Rule 2(1) of the PC Rules
  • Rule 6 of the PC Rules
  • Rule 6 and Rule 33
  • Section 83(2)(zd)
  • Section 1(3)(d)
  • 15 kgs. Rule 3
  • Section 2(b)
  • section 1(3)
  • Rule 2(e)
  • Rule 2(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Act, 1976 (for short Act) read with Rules 33(v) and 23(1)
  • Clause (d) of sub-section (3) of Section
  • Rule 2(q), consequently Rule 6
  • Act and the PC Rules. Rule 6
  • Rule 2(k) of the PC Rules
  • Rule 2(r) of the PC Rules.
  • Rule 2(1) of the PC Rules
  • Rule 6 of the PC Rules
  • Rule 6 and Rule 33
  • Section 83(2)(zd)
  • Section 1(3)(d)
  • 15 kgs. Rule 3
  • Section 2(b)
  • section 1(3)
  • Rule 2(e)
  • Rule 2(1)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a manufacturer of sports goods including footwear, has authorised dealers across India. On 29-03-2006 and 5-04-2006, the 4th respondent searched the petitioner's distributors' showrooms in Belgaum and seized shoes packaged in a manner alleged to violate Sections 39 and 63 of the Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976 (the Act), read with Rules 33(v) and 23(1) of the Standards of Weights and Measures (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977 (PC Rules). The violation pertained to the failure to display the Maximum Retail Price (M.R.P) inclusive of all taxes on the packaging as required by the Act and Rules. Notices dated 8-04-2006 and 26-05-2006 were issued by the 4th respondent, informing the petitioner of the contraventions and directing appearance before the Compounding Authority, failing which prosecution would follow. Consequently, the petitioner filed writ petitions seeking declarations and prohibitions related to the application of the Act and Rules, quashing of criminal proceedings, and release of seized goods. The petitions were clubbed and finally heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rules 6 and 33 of the Packaged Commodities Rules are illegal and ultravires the powers under the Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976.
  2. Whether the petitioner's products are regulated or covered by the Act or the PC Rules.
  3. Whether prosecution under the Act and Rules against the petitioner should be restrained.
  4. Whether the criminal proceedings instituted pursuant to the notices should be quashed.
  5. Whether the seized goods should be released to the petitioner.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Central Government Notification dated 26-09-1977 bringing Sections 1, 2, 3, 39, and 83 of the Act into force does not specify classes of goods and thus does not cover the petitioner's products.
  • Section 83(2)(zd) empowers rule-making, but in the absence of a Notification specifically covering the petitioner’s products, the PC Rules do not apply.
  • The rule of ejusdem generis applies, so without specific Notification, the Act and Rules do not cover the petitioner’s products.
  • Definitions in the PC Rules, especially Rule 2(e) and Rule 2(k), exclude applicability to the petitioner’s products (pairs of shoes).
  • Reliance on the Division Bench of Bombay High Court decision in Subash Arjandas Kataria v. State of Maharashtra, supporting exclusion of such products.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Section 1(3)(d) of the Act is an enabling provision not requiring separate Notifications for each class of goods.
  • The petitioner's products are packed in cartons and delivered to dealers, thus falling under the PC Rules.
  • Non-compliance with printing M.R.P inclusive of taxes disadvantages consumers and violates the Act and Rules.
  • The petitioner's products do not fall within exemptions under Rule 34.
  • Reliance on decisions of Madras High Court (Philips India Limited), Andhra Pradesh High Court (Titan Watches Limited), and pending appeals.
  • The definition of ‘commodity in packaged form’ under Section 2(b) of the Act includes the petitioner's products.
  • Import policy Notification mandates compliance with PC Rules for packaged goods.
  • Rule of ejusdem generis does not apply to Section 1(3)(d) in light of the 1977 Notification and definitions.
  • Reliance on Jayanthi Food Processing (P) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise (2007 SCC) supporting applicability of the Act and Rules.
  • Rule 6 and Rule 33 require declaration of retail sale price inclusive of taxes on packages meant for retail sale.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Philips India Limited v. Union of India, 2002 Writ LR 140 Applicability of PC Rules to packaged commodities Cited by respondents to support applicability of the Act and Rules to petitioner's products; noted that appeals are pending.
Titan Watches Limited v. Senior Inspector, Legal Metrology Weight and Measures Department, AIR 2003 AP 75 Interpretation of the Act and Rules regarding packaged goods Not accepted by this Court; the Court preferred contrary view from Bombay High Court.
Eureka Forbes Ltd. v. Union of India, 2003 2 ALD 742 Applicability of PC Rules Cited by respondents; appeals pending.
Subash Arjandas Kataria v. State of Maharashtra & Ors, AIR 2006 Bombay 293 Definition and applicability of ‘pre-packed commodity’ and exclusions Relied upon by petitioner; Court preferred the view in this case regarding notification sufficiency but rejected its exclusion of the product.
Khaitan Electricals Ltd. v. The Union of India and Another, AIR 2008 KAR 3370 Interpretation of Notification dated 26-09-1977 and Section 1(3)(d) of the Act Followed by this Court to hold that separate Notifications for each class of goods are not required.
Kavalappara Kottarathil Kochuni v. State of Kerala, AIR 1960 SC 1080 Rule of ejusdem generis in statutory interpretation Applied to interpret Section 1(3) of the Act; held that ejusdem generis does not mandate separate Notifications for each class of goods.
Ramesh Mehta v. Sanwal Chand Singhvi, AIR 2004 SC 2258 Principles of interpretation of subordinate legislation Applied to hold that subordinate legislation must be read meaningfully and harmoniously with the parent statute.
TT Private Limited v. Union of India and Others, AIR 1991 KAR 79 Validity of Rule 6 of the PC Rules Rule 6 held intra vires; Court relied on this to reject petitioner's challenge to Rule 6 and Rule 33.
Jayanthi Food Processing (P) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, 2007 8 SCC 34 Applicability of the Act and Rules to packaged commodities Relied upon by respondents to support the consumer-protection purpose and mandatory declarations on packages.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by acknowledging the common factual and legal questions raised by the petitions. It examined the scope of the Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976, particularly Section 1(3)(d), which empowers the Central Government to bring different classes of goods under the Act by Notification. The Court rejected the petitioner's contention that separate Notifications are required for each class of goods, holding that the 1977 Notification bringing Sections 1, 2, 3, 39, and 83 into force was sufficient to cover all packaged commodities, including the petitioner's products.

The Court applied the principle of purposive interpretation, emphasizing the consumer-protection objective of the Act and the impracticality of issuing separate Notifications for every new product. It distinguished the application of the rule of ejusdem generis, holding that it does not mandate narrow interpretation requiring separate Notifications for each product class.

The Court analyzed the definitions under the Act and the PC Rules, particularly the term ‘commodity in packaged form’ under Section 2(b) of the Act and ‘pre-packed commodity’ under Rule 2(1) of the PC Rules. It concluded that the petitioner's shoes, packed in cartons as single units for retail sale, fall squarely within these definitions. The Court rejected the petitioner's reliance on the Bombary High Court decision that excluded certain products from the PC Rules, finding that the petitioner's products do not escape the Act's applicability.

The Court also considered the validity of Rule 6 of the PC Rules, which mandates declaration of retail sale price inclusive of taxes on packages, and upheld its intra vires status based on precedent (TT Private Limited case). It found the petitioner's partial compliance (printing M.R.P excluding taxes) insufficient and upheld the notices issued by the authorities as valid and legal.

Holding and Implications

The Court rejected the writ petitions filed by the petitioner, holding that the Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976 and the Packaged Commodities Rules, 1977 apply to the petitioner's products. The Court affirmed the validity of the impugned notices and found no merit in the challenge to the applicability of the Rules or the seizure of goods.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner must comply with the statutory requirements under the Act and Rules, including printing the Maximum Retail Price inclusive of all taxes on packaging. The ruling does not set a new precedent but reinforces the existing legal framework protecting consumers and standardizing retail sale prices for packaged goods.

    Reebok India Company v. The Union Of India And Others

    Ram Mohan Reddy, J.

    Common questions of fact and that of law arise for decision making. Hence, with the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the petitions are clubbed together, finally heard and are disposed of by this order.

    2. The Petitioner a manufacturer of sports goods including Footwear has its authorised dealers in Belgaum amongst others, in all parts of this country. On 29-03-2006, and 5.4.2006, the 4th respondent is said to have searched the showroom of the petitioner's distributor M/s. Square Cut and M/s. Foot Mark, respectively, and seized shoes in packages said to be in violation of Sections 39, 63 of the Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976 (for short ‘Act’) read with Rules 33(v) and 23(1) of the Standards of Weights and Measures (Packaged Commodities), Rules, 1977 (for short ‘PC Rules’). The inspection, it is said, disclosed that the package in which the shoe was packed, did not contain the Maximum Retail Price (M.R.P) inclusive of all taxes, in violation of Section 2(r) and Section 39 and 63 of the Act and PC Rules. The 4 respondent issued the notice dated 8-04-2006 and 26-05-2006 Annexure-“C”, in each of the writ petitions, pointing out to the contravention of law and informing the petitioner that the violations were compoundable under Section 73 of the Act and directed its appearance before the Compounding Authority, failing which a complaint would be lodged before the Jurisdictional Magistrate. Hence, these writ petitions for the following reliefs:

    (a) A writ of mandamus to declare Rules 6 and 33 of the Packaged Commodities Rules as illegal and ultravires the powers under the Act.

    (b) Mandamus declaring that the petitioner's products are not regulated or covered by the Act or Rules;

    (c) A writ of prohibition restraining the respondents or any of their subordinates from prosecuting/continuing the prosecution against the petitioner under the Act and Rules;

    (d) Quash the Criminal proceedings instituted in the Summons case pursuant to a notice Annexure-“C”;

    (e) For a mandamus to Respondent No. 4 to release the seized goods.

    3. The Petitions are opposed by filing Statement of objections dated 15-07-2008 of Respondents 1 and 2, interalia, contending Section 1 (3)(d) of the Act being an enabling provision does not require the Central Government to issue separate Notifications specifying each and every commodity in packaged form so as to bring them under the provisions of the Act. The fact that the petitioner's products are admittedly packed in cartons and delivered to its dealers for retail trade goes without saying that the PC Rules apply and the non-compliance of which has resulted in the action complained of. In addition, it is stated that the printing on the package the maximum retail price inclusive of the taxes is for the benefit of the consumer without which the consumer will be placed in a disadvantageous position, leading to exploitation at the various levels of trade. According to the respondent, the petitioner's commodities in packed form do not fall within the exemption provided for under Rule 34. The decisions of the Madras High Court in Philips India Limited v. union of India . 2002 Writ LR 140 as well as that of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Titan Watches Limited v. Senior Inspector, Legal Metrology Weight and Measures Department . AIR 2003 AP 75 and Eureka Forbes Ltd. v. Union of India . 2003 2 ALD 742, are said to be carried in appeal, pending before the Appellate Court. In addition, it is contended that the definition of the term ‘Commodity in Packaged form’ under Section 2(b) of the Act refers to ‘units suitable for sale’ and that the same applies to a pair of shoes packed in cartons. It is further contended under the Notification dated 24-11-2000, the Government of India, Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Department of Commerce relating to import policy mandates that all packaged products subject to the PC Rules when packed and sold in domestic market in accordance with all the provisions of the said rules when imported into India. Having regard to the salient features of the Act and the laudable objective behind which it was enacted, to subserve the customer and to standardise the rates, the petitioner's shoes sold in packaged form when taken out for testing or examination, does not change its character as a packaged commodity.

    4. Sri. S.K Sahiji Pal, Learned counsel for the petitioner advances the following contentions:

    (i) the Notification dated 26-09-1977 of the Central Government bringing into force Sections 1, 2, 3, 39 and 83 of the Act w.e.f 26-09-1977, it is contended does not specify the classes of goods and therefore, is not a Notification in the eye of law as mandated by the Parliament covering the petitioner's products. It is further contended that though Section 83(2)(zd) empowers the Central Government to make rules in respect of any other matter which is required to or may be prescribed, and in the absence of a Notification covering the products of the petitioner, the PC Rules have no application. Learned counsel contends that the rule of ejusdem generis applies and in the absence of a Notification specifying the classes of goods, neither the Act nor Rules covers the products manufactured and distributed by the petitioner. The PC Rules it is contended cannot control the Act since the definition of the term ‘pre-packed commodity’ under Rule 2(e) is not in consonance with the definition of the term “commodity in the packaged form”, in Section 2(b) of the Act.

    (ii) It is next contended that Rule 2(k) of the PC Rules defines a ‘packer’ while 2(1) defines ‘pre-packed commodity’ and that the Explanation-I therein excludes the applicability of the rules to the commodity being a pair of shoes which the petitioner has put up for retail trade. Learned counsel relies upon the decision of the Division Bench of the High Court of Bombay in Subash Arjandas Kataria, Mumbai v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. . AIR 2006 Bombay 293

    5. Per contra, learned Senior Standing counsel for the Central Government reiterates the averments in the Statement of objections and in addition submits that the rule of ejusdem generis does not apply to section 1(3)(d) in the light of the Notification of the year 1977 coupled with the definition of the term ‘commodity in packaged form’ in Section 2(b) of the Act. Learned counsel contends that the Act as well as the PC Rules were enacted to protect the consumers so as to pay only such price as has been permitted and printed on the package. Learned counsel places reliance upon the decision in Jayanthi Food Processing (P) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Rajasthan . 2007 8 SCC 34. It is further contended that since the petitioner's commodity was kept for ‘retail sale’ defined in Rule 2(q), consequently Rule 6 applies, requiring declaration of the ‘retail sale price’ as defined in Rule 2(r) of the PC Rules. Learned counsel hastens to add that the shoes packed in carton boxes for retail sale was for consumption of the ultimate user, the consumer, making it mandatory for every package to contain declarations including theretail sale price.

    6. In almost identical circumstances, Bopanna, J., in Khaitan Electricals Ltd. v. The Union of India and Another . AIR 2008 KAR 3370, not persuaded to accept the view of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Titan Watches Limited (supra), followed the view of the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Kataria's case (supra) in so far as it relates to the reasons, findings and conclusions that the Notification dated 26-09-1977 bringing into force Sections 1, 2, 3, 39 and 83 of the Act was sufficient and did not require a separate Notification for different class of goods under Clause (d) of sub-section (3) of Section 1. In the present day scenario of market trends and technological advancements, it is well nigh impossible for the Central Government to issue Notifications to bring into fold new classes of goods manufactured by hour and the day. If the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is accepted, it would lead to a narrow interpretation and cause hardship rendering the application of the act impracticable. The Courts must give a purposive interpretation of section 1(3) of the Act, in view of the laudable object in framing the Act which is in the larger interest of the consumer as also to standardise the rates applicable to the product when put up for retail sale throughout the country. This, I am afraid, cannot be achieved by applying the rule of ejusdem generis., to interpret section 1(3)(d) as requiring issue of a Notification every time a new product belonging to a class of goods is manufactured and put for retail sale.

    7. In Kavalappara Kottarathil Kochuni v. State of Kerala . AIR 1960 SC 1080 reported at page 1103, their lordships of the Supreme Court, interpreting the word ‘otherwise’, in the context in which it is used, held that it must be construed by applying the rule of ejusdem generis, when general words follow particular and specific words of the same nature, the general words must be confined to the things of the same kind as those specified. It was further held that it is clearly laid down by decided cases that the specific words must form a distinct genus or category and that it is not an inviolable rule of law but is only permissible inference in the absence of an indication to the contrary. In my considered opinion, in sub-Section (3) of Section (1) of the Act the phrase “by Notification, appoint and different dates may be appointed for different

    (a) xxx

    (b) xxx

    (c) xxx,

    (d) classes of goods,

    in the context only means that by the notification the Central Government may appoint different dates for different class of goods and not for the Central Government to issue separate Notifications for different classes of goods to bring them under the Act.

    8. It is no doubt true that clause (zd) of sub-Section 2 of Section 83 of the Act, empowers the framing of rules in respect of any other matter which is required or prescribed, pursuant to which the ‘PC Rules’ are framed. In the light of the finding that section 1(3) does not contemplate a separate Notification to cover different class of goods, under the Act, the contention that the Rules do not apply to the petitioner's product is without merit.

    9. Section 2(b) of the Act defines ‘commodity in packaged form’ to mean commodity packaged in any bottle, tin, wrapper or otherwise in units suitable for sale, whether wholesale or retail. Rule 2(1) of the PC Rules defines ‘pre-packed commodity’, thus:

    (1) “pre-packed commodity” with its grammatical variations and cognate expressions, means a commodity (or article or articles) which, without the purchaser being present, is placed in a package of whatever nature, so that the quantity of the product contained therein has a pre-determined value and such value cannot be altered without the package or its lid or cap, as the case may be, being opened or undergoing a perceptible modification and the expression “package”, wherever it occurs, shall be construed as a package containing a pre-packed commodity;”

    “Explanation I: Where any such weight or measure is, or other goods are, delivered to a carrier or other bailee for transmission, the movement of such weight, measure or other goods shall, for the purposes of sub-Clause (ii), be deemed to commence at the time of such delivery and terminate at the time when delivery is taken from such carrier or bailee.

    Explanation II: Where the movement of any such weight, measure or other goods commences and terminates in the same State, it shall not be deemed to be a movement of such weight, measure or other goods from one State to another merely by reason of the fact that in the course of such movement it passes through the territory of any other State;”

    10. Indisputably, ‘in packaged form’ commodities excluding statutory exceptions, are governed by Sections 1, 2, 3, 39 and 83 of the Act brought into force w.e.f 26.09.1977, while Rule 2A, makes Chapter-E of the ‘PC Rules’ applicable to all pre-packed commodities except in respect of grains and pulses of quantity more than 15 kgs. Rule 3 states that the provisions of the Chapter shall apply to the packages intended for retail sale and the expression “package”, wherever it occurs in the chapter shall be construed accordingly.

    11. A feeble attempt was made by the learned counsel for the petitioner to contend that the definition of the term pre-packed commodity’ in Rule 2(1) being a sub-ordinate legislation overrides the principal legislative definition of the term ‘commodity in packaged form’ in Section 2(b) of the Act.

    12. In Ramesh Mehta v. Sanwal Chand Singhvi . AIR 2004 SC 2258, the principles of interpretation of subordinate legislation having fallen for consideration the Apex Court held thus:

    “A subordinate or delegated legislation must also be read in a meaningful manner so as to give effect to the provisions of the statute. In selecting the true meaning of a word regard must be had to the consequences leading thereto. If two constructions are possible to adopt, a meaning which would make the provision workable and in consonance with the statutory scheme should be preferred.”

    13. The definition of ‘prepacked commodity’ in Rule 2(1) is exhaustive while the explanation I also contains illustration, when read in the context of the definition ‘commodity in prepackaged form’ in Section 2(b) of the Act. The definition of the phrase ‘commodity in the packaged form’ in Section 2(b) of the Act though not exhaustive, cannot be read in isolation, but with me legislative history of the Act. Keeping in mind the purport and object of the Act and what it seeks to subserve, the definition of the phrase in Rule 2(1) must be given a meaningful application, with a view to make the Act workable. The consequences are that as long as the commodity in a prepackaged form, is a package, and the commodity contained therein has a predetermined value, which cannot be altered on being opened or on undergoing a perceptible modification. In the circumstances, the definition in Rule 2(1) a subordinate legislation, cannot be said to override the principal legislative definition of the phrase in Section 2(b) of the Act, or that the Rule controls the Act.

    14. In the admitted facts of this case, the shoe packed in a carton is in single unit meant for retail sale. It may be that the pair of shoe is opened from the package so that the customer tests it but having regard to the Explanation (1) to Rule 2(1), it is amply clear that the petitioner's product falls within the definition of the term ‘pre-packed’ commodity. In that view of the matter, I am not persuaded to accept the view taken by the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Kataria's case holding that sun glasses exposed for retail sale after being removed from the cartons would not fall within the definition of the term ‘pre-packed’ commodity.

    15. In the light of Rule 2 A making Chapter-II applicable to all pre-packed commodities while Rule 3 makes the chapter applicable to packages intended for retail sale meant for consumption by individual or group of individuals or any other customer, the petitioner's products placed for retail sale in package of single units, cannot escape from the applicability of the Act and the PC Rules. Rule 6 requires every package to make certain declarations including retail sale price. There is also no dispute that the declaration was partly made on the package by printing Maximum Retail Price (M.R.P) without printing the price inclusive of taxes. No exception can be taken to the action of the authorities under the act and Rules, and the notices impugned cannot but be said to be valid and legal.

    16. The validity of Rule 6 of the PC Rules came up for consideration before this Court in TT Private Limited v. Union of India and Others . AIR 1991 KAR 79, whence it was held to be intra vires. Although the relief is to declare Rule 6 and Rule 33 as ultra vires the Constitution, nevertheless arguments are not advanced. Learned Central Government Counsel submits that Rule 33 is omitted by Notification dated 17.07.2006

    In the result, these writ petitions are without merit and are accordingly, rejected.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Reebok India Company v. The Union Of India And Others
    (Jan 31, 2009)