AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Civil First Miscellaneous Appeal (Motor Accident)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from an award by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Jammu dated 20 September 1985, which awarded compensation of Rs. 95,000 in favour of the respondents/claimants.

Facts (as stated in the record): On 30 May 1984 at about 7:15 A.M., Om Parkash (aged 32) was struck on a Jammu-Pathankot national highway mile-stone 89–90 while walking on the side of the road. The vehicle involved was an Army truck belonging to appellant No. 1 and driven by appellant No. 2. Om Parkash was taken to hospital but died en route. He was survived by his widow (respondent No. 1) and two minor daughters (respondents Nos. 2 and 3, aged 8 and 5).

Procedure: The respondents filed a claim petition under section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act claiming Rs. 3,00,000. The appellants, in their written statement, did not deny the accident or the death but contended that the driver was discharging sovereign acts (a defence of sovereign immunity). The Tribunal framed issues including whether the driver was performing sovereign duties and, if not, the quantum of compensation and the person liable. The Tribunal placed the burden of proving the sovereign-act defence on the appellants, conducted a trial (appellants examined two witnesses; respondents examined the widow and PW-1 Chuni Lal), and awarded compensation after calculations described below. The appellants appealed against the award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the driver (appellant No. 2) at the time of the accident was discharging duties of a sovereign nature such that the Union of India (appellant No. 1) would be immune from liability?
  2. If the answer to Issue No. 1 is negative, what amount of compensation are the petitioners entitled to and from whom?
  3. Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal (total Rs. 95,000) was excessive, specifically whether the deceased's monthly income (claimed at Rs. 800) was sufficiently proved?
  4. Whether the award of Rs. 5,000 towards loss of expectation of life / loss to the estate was duplicative or inappropriate when compensation for dependency had already been awarded?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants did not dispute the accident or death but claimed the driver was discharging sovereign acts; therefore, the Union of India was immune from liability.
  • The award of Rs. 95,000 was excessive because the respondents failed to prove the deceased's income by cogent/documentary evidence. The alleged Rs. 800 per month was only supported by oral evidence and, relying on section 62 of the Evidence Act, the appellants argued that where a fact can be proved by documents the primary evidence is the document itself, and oral proof should not suffice for assessing compensation.
  • The Rs. 5,000 awarded for loss of expectation of life / loss to the estate was argued to be without meaning or duplicative when dependency compensation had already been assessed.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents relied on oral evidence (including testimony of respondent No. 1 and PW-1 Chuni Lal) to prove that the deceased earned Rs. 800 per month as Supervisor-cum-Accounts Clerk.
  • They contended that the appellants had not produced any rebutting evidence or documentary proof to displace the oral testimony and that the Tribunal's approach to calculate dependency and other heads was justified.
  • Respondents accepted the Tribunal's award and did not challenge the quantum before the appellate court (no cross-appeal seeking enhancement was filed).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kasturi Lal v. State of U.P., A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 1039 The test for whether a tortious act committed by a public servant is immune because it was committed in discharge of statutory functions referable to the delegation of sovereign powers of the State. If the tort arose from duties truly of sovereign character, immunity may apply; otherwise, an action for damages lies against the State. The court applied this test to the facts: the goods carried in the Army truck were not arms or ammunition, could have been transported by civil conveyance, and there was no evidence that the driver was performing a duty by virtue of any statutory delegation of sovereign power. Therefore, sovereign immunity did not protect the Union of India and liability for damages lay.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in a sequence addressing evidentiary sufficiency, quantum of compensation, the additional head of loss of expectation of life, and the question of sovereign immunity.

  1. Evidence of Income:
    • The court rejected the appellants' submission that oral evidence of income must be discarded because section 62 of the Evidence Act prefers primary evidence (documents). The court noted section 59 of the Evidence Act ("All facts, except the contents of documents, may be proved by oral evidence") and explained that where documentary proof is not produced and there is no suggestion or evidence that such documents were within the respondents' power, oral testimony may be sufficient.
    • PW-1 Chuni Lal and respondent No. 1 provided oral evidence that the deceased was paid Rs. 800 per month and there was no cross-examination or rebuttal evidence undermining that testimony. The court therefore accepted the Rs. 800 monthly income for assessment purposes.
    • The court also observed that, given the deceased's skill and position, a presumption consistent with minimum wages supported that the Rs. 800 figure was not excessive.
  2. Assessment of Compensation:
    • The Tribunal calculated annual earnings at Rs. 9,600 (Rs. 800 × 12).
    • It reasonably estimated personal expenses (medicines, clothing, food, etc.) at Rs. 2,600 per annum, leaving Rs. 7,000 as the annual dependency loss.
    • Applying a multiplier of 16 (given the ages and life expectancy evidence), the Tribunal computed Rs. 1,12,000; from this it deducted Rs. 22,000 as an adjustment for an accelerated mode of payment, arriving at Rs. 90,000 as the dependency component.
    • The Tribunal also awarded Rs. 5,000 for loss of expectation of life / loss to the estate (characterised by the court as compensation for mental shock and agony, distinct from dependency). The combined total after adjustments and the State's share came to Rs. 95,000, to be distributed equally among the respondents.
    • The appellate court held the Tribunal's assessment was not excessive and, given no cross-appeal or challenge by respondents to the quantum, upheld the assessment.
  3. Loss of Expectation of Life / Loss to the Estate:
    • The court drew a clear distinction between dependency compensation (pecuniary loss to claimants) and compensation for loss of expectation of life or distress to the estate (mental shock and agony). It held the Rs. 5,000 awarded under this head was not overlapping and could be sustained.
  4. Sovereign Immunity / Vicarious Liability of the State:
    • The appellants' key defence was that the driver was performing sovereign duties for the Union of India. The court examined evidence from appellants' witnesses (Major G.S. Gour and driver M.V. Nambiar) and noted admissions that the stores transported did not include arms and ammunition and could have been carried by civil vehicles.
    • Applying the test from Kasturi Lal (A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 1039), the court concluded the acts were not referable to any statutory delegation of sovereign powers; therefore the sovereign-act defence failed and the Union was liable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The appellate court upheld the Tribunal's award of compensation in the total amount of Rs. 95,000 (which included Rs. 90,000 assessed for dependency and Rs. 5,000 for loss of expectation of life / loss to the estate).

Consequences and orders recorded by the court:

  • The appellants shall bear their own costs and shall pay the respondents' costs in this court (Hearing Fee according to the Schedule).
  • The balance of compensation deposited shall be paid to the respondents, including interest accrued thereon, in accordance with the terms and conditions imposed by the Tribunal for protection of the minors' interests.

Implications: The direct effect is that the Tribunal's monetary award is upheld and the Union of India is held liable (sovereign immunity was rejected on the facts). The opinion applies an established Supreme Court test (Kasturi Lal) rather than announcing a new precedent; the decision enforces the Tribunal's factual findings and quantum on the record.

    Union Of India Uoi And Anr. v. Kusum Sharma And Ors.

    1. This Civil First Miscellaneous Appeal arises out of an award given by Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal Jammu on September 20, 1985 award­ing compensation of Rs. 95,000/- in favour of respondents/claimants.

    2. One Om Parkash, husband of respondent No. 1 and father of respondents 2 &3 met with an accident on May 30, 1984 at 7-15 A.M. on Jammu-Pathankot National Highway while the Army Truck belonging to appellant No. 1 was driven by appellant No. 2 herein & succumed to his injuries on way to Hospital on the very day. Respondents filed a claim petition under section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act (hereinafter called the Act) claiming the compensation of Rs, 3 lacs. It was stated that deceased at the time of accident was 32 years of age, who was survived by his widow and two minor daughters of 8 years and five years respectively, who are respondents 1 to 3 in the present appeal. It was further stated that deceased was earning Rs. 800/- per month by working as Supervisor-cum Accounts Clerk in M/s Nagina Hot Mixture plant, Village Sarore. He was a trained person and would have risen to the high position in due course of time within the next 10-15 years and would have an earning of more than Rs 2,000- per month. The accident took place while the deceased was walking on a kacha track of the Jammu-Pathankot National Highway on the side of the road at Mile-Stone 89-90. Appellant No. 2 came from deceased's rear side while driving Array Truck One Ton BA No. 79C23100H. In the process of over taking a preceeding motor vehicle had taken his vehicle on the wrong side of the road with abnormal speed and hit the deceased by driving the said truck rashly and negligently Deceased was seriously injured as a result of the accident and in that condition was taken to the Hospital while on way he breathed his last

    3. On issuance of notice to the appellants by the Tribunal, the appel­lants in their written statement with all fairness have not denied the accident and the death of deceased Om Parkash as a result of the said accident. How­ever, it was contended that the accident occurred, when appellant No. 2 was discharging the sovereign acts of the Union and hence no compensation can be awarded to the respondents. Regarding the income of the deceased, it was only stated that the respondents are called upon to strictly prove the aver­ments, as the amount mentioned of Rs. 800,- per month is exaggerated.

    4. On the pleadings of the parties, the learned Tribunal framed the following issues:-

    1) Whether respondent No. 2 at 7-15 A.M of May 30, 1984 at mile stone 89-90 on Jammu Pathankot National Highway (Village Sarore) while driving Motor Vehicle No. one Ton BA No. 79C2310Q H and acting under the employment of respondent No. 1 was discharging the duties of sovereign nature and while doing so he caused the accident resulting into the death of deceased Om Parkash? OPR

    2) In case issue No. 1 is proved in the negative to how much claim of compensation the petitioners are entitled and from whom? OPP

    3) Relief.

    5. Since the accident and the death of deceased Om Parkash was not denied by the appellants the learned Tribunal looking to the defence taken placed the burden of proving issue No. 1 on the appellants herein, who were respondents before the Tribunal. The appellants examined Major G.S. Gour and appellant No. 2, namely, L/Hav M.V. Nambiar, whereas the respondents examined in rebuttal PW-1 Chuni Lal besides Respondent No. 1-Smt. Kusum Sharma widow of deceased. The learned Tribunal after trial awarded compensation of Rs.90,000/- using the multiplier of 16 years on capitalisation of the annual income of the deceased at Rs. 7,0001- being the residual after deduction of the amount on the deceased himself and a lump sum of Rs. 22,000/- for the accelerated mode of payment. Rs. 5000/- towards the loss of expectation of life and less to the State totaling to Rs. 95,000/- in equal shares to the respondents.

    6. Learned counsel for the appellants while arguing the appeal concentrated his arguments to the limited points & submitted firstly that the award of Rs. 95,000/- is excessive because the respondents failed to prove by cogent evidence the income of the deceased in-as-much as the evidence adduced by the respondents as to the monthly income of Rs. 800/- is only oral and not documentary in support of the said contention has been produced. Learned counsel referring to the provisions of the evidence act argued that the deceased being an employee of a firm as projected in the claim petition, the only way of proving his income would have been by the oral evidence. It is pointed out that when a fact can be proved by a document the primary evidence in accordance with section 62 of the Evidence Act means the document itself produced for the inspection of the Court and proved according to law. In such a situation the proof of the income of the deceased by oral evidence cannot be regarded as sufficient for assessment of compensation on the basis of the income of the deceased. We have examined evidence produced by both the parties in the light of the arguments advanced on this point by learned counsel for the respondents. It is no doubt true that on the principle as laid down under section 62 of the Evidence Act, the primary evidence means the documents itself, but that is not the end of the matter. The argument ignores section 59 of the Evidence Act, which provides in the following words:

    "59. All facts, except the contents of documents, may be proved by oral evidence."

    The above provision clearly indicates that if a document is produced in the court and is available with a party, its contents can be proved only by tendering the document and proving the same according to law. The rule that in each case best evidence, of which the case in its nature is susceptible should always be given naturally leads to the division of evidence into primary and secondary this kinds of proof affords the greatest certainty on the fact in question. If a particular fact is proved by the direct oral evidence of which no rebuttal is available on record especially in such cases as one in hand where a man has lost his life and the Courts called upon to determine the compensation to the survivors, some sort of speculation is permitted looking to the common course of conduct of human life. What is denied in the written statement is against the claim of Rs. 800/- per month, as the monthly income of the deceased that the figure is exaggerated. It is denied that the deceased was a trained and skilled worker holding the post of Supervisor-cum-Accounts Clerk with the firm, respondent No. 1 in whose hands the deceased was giving his monthly income proves in categorical terms that he was paying Rs. 800/- per month. That fact is amply proved by the statement of PW-I Chuni Lal. There is no cross-examination by the appell­ants either on the respondents or on PW-1 pointing out towards the credibility of the statement as to the income of the deceased. There is no evidence in rebuttal even nor a suggestion that the said income could be proved by putting in some document to rebut the statement of the respon­dents and her witness. In other words, there is no ground to dis-believe the statement of the respondent No. 1 and her witness PW-1 Chuni Lal on this score that the income of the deceased was Rs. 800/- per month. When such is the position of the oral evidence it can not be discarded under section 62 of the Evidence Act. There is nothing on record to show that the production of the record of the company where the deceased was working was within the power of respondents or that the firm was maintaining the record regarding payments of monthly remuneration to the deceased. In this view of the matter, we would not be justified in this appeal in discarding the findings arrived at by the learned Tribunal, because some other evidence which could have been brought before the court in support thereof was not tendered. Even otherwise looking to the nature of the work of the deceased it is a matter of common experience and even the presumption under law that the skilled worker like that of the deceased is expected to earn at least the minimum wages provided under the Labour laws, which cannot be less then Rs. 30/-per day according to which monthly earnings of the deceased of Rs. 800/ cannot by any stretch of imagination be regarded as excessive. In view of this evidence, we do not find any force in this ground of attack of the learned counsel for the appellants.

    7. This brings us to the assessment of compensation made by the Tribunal taking into account monthly income of the deceased at Rs. 800/-. The learned Tribunal on speculation calculated that the deceased might have spending on his person amount on medicines, clothing, food etc., around Rs. 2,600/- annually & rest of his income was to be utilized by the respon­dents for their maintenance. In this way, learned Tribunal after calculating total annual earnings of Rs. 9,600/- of the deceased deducted Rs. 2,600/-from the said total, leaving the balance of Rs. 7,000/- annually for the purpose of counting the annual loss of the dependency allowance caused to the respondents on account of the un-natural death of the deceased Om parkash. Admittedly deceased was 32 years of age at the time of accident, he left respondent, No. 1, the young window, who was also of about 32 years of age and two minor daughters aged 8 & 5 years. By applying the multiplier of 16 years, learned Tribunal assessed the compensation at Rs. 1,12,000/-. On capitalisation, learned Tribunal deducted Rs. 22.000/- out of it on the ground of accelerated mode of payment and thus held the respondents/claimants entitled to get Rs. 90.000/- towards the compensation payable equally. Looking to the evidence adduced before the Tribunal as to the expectancy of life in comparison to the other living members of the family of the deceased, in our view the assessment is on the lower side rather than in any way excessive. However, because there is no cross appeal before us and the respondents have shown contentment with the compensation so granted it can in no case be said as excessive. It is now well settled that while assessing compensation several facts are to be kept in mind, when the death is caused by an accident. The court has to consider & balance the loss to the claimants of any further pecuniary benefits that would have accrued to them had not the death by accident taken place. In the case in hand, since the dates were available to determine the pecuniary benefits or loss occasioned to the claim-ants'respondent due to the death of the deceased, which in no way can be without any basis. The argument, therefore, fails & we hold that the quantum of compensation determined by the learned Tribunal cannot be regarded as excessive, which is hereby upheld.

    8. Adverting to the next contention put forward by the learned counsel for the appellants that the determination of Rs. 5000/- towards the loss of expectation of life and loss to the estate has no meaning, when the compensation as pointed out hereinabove for the loss of life has already been granted. On scrutiny of this argument we find that the same is also fallacious. A distinction is to be drawn between the compensation assessed towards the dependency allowance and the loss of expectation of life and loss to the estate, which can easily be termed as compensation towards the mental shock and agony. It is not, therefore over-lapping but independent of the loss occasioned due to the accident towards the dependency allowance, we can, therefore, safely count it towards the compensation for mental shock and agony which has been termed by the learned Tribunal towards the loss to the estate. In this head award of Rs. 5,000/- in our opinion cannot be termed as excessive or without any basis. This argument also, therefore, fails and cannot be sustained.

    9. Lastly on the ground of vicarious liability of the estate as imposed in the instant case, because the accident is caused by the Army Truck belong­ing to appellant No. 1, the protection of sovereign act is not available to the appellant No. 1-Union of India. From the pleadings as well as from the evidence led by appellants on issue No. 1, the findings on this court are also not assailable. We have minutely gone through the statement of DW-1 M Major G.S. Gour and DW-2 Driver M.V. Nambiar, who was driving the vehicle at the time when the accident occurred. It is clearly borne out from their statements that the goods, which were carried on in the vehicle could be transported by any other means of civil conveyance & the persons, who were travelling in the vehicle could also be taken by the civil vehicle engaged for the purpose. DW-1 Major G.S. Gour has gone even to the extent of saying that deceased Om Parkash died due to rash and negligent driving on the part of respondent No. 2. On the face of such evidence when the factum of accident is admitted and amply proved by the mouth of the witnesses of the appellants there cannot be any escape to Union of India for the liability of accident and no protection can be advanced under the sovereign act. Dealing with this preposition, their Lordships of the Supreme Court in the case of (Kasturi Lal Versus State of U.P.) reported in A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 1039 held :-

    "If a tortious act is committed by a public servant and it gives rise to a claim for damages, the questions to ask are: was the tortious act committed by the public servant in discharging of statutory functions which are referable to, & ultimately based on, the delegation of the sovereign powers of the State to such public servant? If the answer is in the affirmative, the action for damages for loss caused by such tortious act has been committed by a public servant in dis­charge of duties assigned to him not by virtue of the delegat­ion of any so erring power, an action for damages would lie."

    Major G.S. Gour, DW-1 in his statement categorically accepted that the supplies of store items, which were carried on by appellant No 2 in the Army Truck did not contain in it the items of arms and ammunition. Such types of supplies could be carried by engaging some civil conveyance. There is nothing on record to show that appellant No. 2 was discharging the statutory functions under delegation of the sovereign powers, he is admittedly a public servant. The act of taking the supplies in the truck, by which the accident was caused could be performed by employing any other agency and the driver under such circumstances cannot be said to have been performing take duty by virtue of any statutory delegation of any sovereign power and hence an action for damages would lie against Union of India. The findings •of the learned Tribunal on issue No. 1, in our opinion, therefore, are not assailable. The appellants have utterly failed to support their contention in proving that the act of appellant No. 2 while driving the ill-fated army truck was of a sovereign nature. The ratio of the above dictum of A.I.R. 1965 S.G.!039 (Supra) applies with full force in the facts and circumstances of the present case. We nave, therefore, no doubt in our mind to uphold this award on merits as well. No other point was argued.

    10. In the result, the appeal fails, which is hereby dismissed with costs. The appellants shall bear their own costs and pay that of the respon­dents in this court. Hearing Fee according to the Schedule. The balance of compensation in deposit shall be paid to the respondents including interest accrued thereon in accordance with the terms and conditions imposed by the Tribunal under the award for the protection of the interest of the minors.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India Uoi And Anr. v. Kusum Sharma And Ors.
    (Mar 15, 1988)