Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These matters are two criminal petitions under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure filed by the accused in Crime No. 6 of 2004 (the petitions are Crl. P. No. 250 of 2004 and Crl. P. No. 337 of 2004). The petitioners (referred to as a-1, a-2 and a-3) are accused in an FIR registered on the report of the 3rd respondent (the complainant) for offences punishable under sections 406 and 420 IPC.

The underlying factual matrix: the 3rd respondent is an energy developer who entered a written power purchase agreement dated 18-5-2001 with the petitioners to wheel energy to them through AP Transco lines from a biomass power station. Some developers challenged the 3rd respondent's authority to impose wheeling charges by filing writ petitions; those writ petitions succeeded, and AP Transco challenged the writ orders before the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court passed an interim order confirming an earlier interim order and directed that "during the pendency of the appeals, the transmission charges shall be liable to be paid as per the term of the agreement subsisting between the parties" (interim order quoted in the opinion).

Following the Supreme Court interim order, the Central Power Distribution Company of A.P. Ltd. (APCPDCL) issued a letter directing the petitioners to pay wheeling charges. A dispute arose when the APCPDCL bill for July 2003 included wheeling charges (Rs. 3,90,278). The petitioners paid charges up to June 2003 and thereafter corresponded with the 3rd respondent seeking a meeting (last letter dated 7-1-2004). The 3rd respondent filed a report before the SHO, Gooty P.S., alleging that the petitioners consumed energy but refused to pay, constituting criminal breach of trust and cheating; an FIR was registered in Crime No. 6 of 2004. The petitioners seek quashing of that FIR under section 482 CrPC.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the FIR registered in Crime No. 6 of 2004, alleging offences under sections 406 and 420 IPC, discloses offences that justify criminal prosecution or should be quashed under section 482 CrPC.
  2. Whether the dispute about wheeling charges is essentially a civil/contractual dispute (to be decided by civil courts or arbitration under clause 24 of the agreement) rather than a matter for criminal prosecution.
  3. Whether the ingredients of criminal breach of trust (Section 406 IPC) and cheating (Section 420 IPC), particularly the requisite dishonest/ fraudulent intention (mens rea), are made out on the facts alleged in the FIR.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The dispute between the petitioners and the 3rd respondent is purely civil in nature; initiating criminal proceedings amounts to an abuse of the process of law.
  • Even taking the complaint averments at face value, the ingredients of sections 406 and 420 IPC are not made out because there is no evidence of dishonest intention or fraudulent misappropriation when the promise was made.
  • The terms of the agreement (dated 18-5-2001) contain clause 24 providing for amicable settlement and, failing that, arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, indicating that disputes should be resolved by arbitration/civil process, not criminal prosecution.
  • They relied on two Supreme Court decisions (S.W. Palanitkar v. State of Bihar and Girish Sarwate v. State of A.P.) to support the proposition that not every breach of trust is a criminal offence and that the High Court's inherent power under section 482 CrPC can be used to quash FIRs that do not disclose an offence or where prosecution would be an abuse of process.

3rd Respondent's (Complainant's) Arguments

  • The petitioners are not concerned with the wheeling charges dispute between the 3rd respondent and AP regulatory/ transmission authorities; the petitioners cannot withhold payment after utilizing the supplied energy.
  • The facts show that the petitioners used energy but stopped payment, and therefore the ingredients of sections 406 and 420 IPC are made out.
  • The petitioners were not justified in stopping payments of the entire consumption charges; at most they could withhold only the amount equivalent to the wheeling charges demanded by the A.P. Regulatory Commission.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S. W. Palanitkar v. State of Bihar Establishes that every breach of trust will not necessarily constitute the penal offence of criminal breach of trust; a criminal prosecution requires evidence of a mental act of fraudulent misappropriation (mens rea). A breach of trust may be a civil wrong absent such mens rea. The court relied on this principle to observe that the petitioners' prior payments (up to June 2003) and the subsequent dispute arising only when wheeling charges were demanded do not demonstrate dishonest intention at the time of promise; therefore criminal breach of trust is not made out.
Girish Sarwate v. State of A.P. Rep. By Public Prosecutor Explains the scope of section 482 CrPC as protecting the inherent powers of the High Court. The High Court's inherent power is available to make orders necessary to give effect to any order under the Code, to prevent abuse of process, or to secure the ends of justice; power to quash FIRs exists subject to conditions laid down by the Supreme Court. The court applied this principle to exercise its inherent jurisdiction under section 482 CrPC, holding that where an FIR does not disclose an offence and continuation of criminal proceedings would be an abuse of process, the High Court may quash the FIR.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by first establishing the contractual and factual background: there was a written power purchase agreement dated 18-5-2001 under which the petitioners purchased power and had provided bank/corporate guarantees; they paid consumption charges up to June 2003. The dispute arose only after APCPDCL's bill for July 2003 included wheeling charges (Rs. 3,90,278), and subsequent correspondence shows attempts at a meeting between the parties.

The court then set out the legal ingredients for the offences relied on by the complainant:

  • For criminal breach of trust (Section 406 IPC): entrustment of property or dominion and dishonest misappropriation or conversion in violation of law or contract.
  • For cheating (Section 420 IPC): a fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of making the promise; mere subsequent failure to fulfill a promise does not establish such intention at the outset.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found no basis to infer dishonest intention at the time the petitioners entered into the contract or when they initially undertook payment obligations, since they paid until June 2003 and the dispute surfaced only when the transmission/wheeling charge demand arose. The court emphasised that a civil or contractual dispute about charges and liability (including disputes involving transmission/wheeling charges) is properly determined by civil remedies or by arbitration under clause 24 of the agreement, which provides for amicable settlement and arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

The court also relied on the authorities cited by the petitioners explaining that not every contractual breach amounts to a criminal offence and that the High Court may, under its inherent powers and section 482 CrPC, quash criminal proceedings that are an abuse of process. Concluding that the facts did not disclose the mens rea necessary for sections 406/420 IPC and that the controversy was essentially civil/arbitral, the court held that continuation of criminal prosecution would be an abuse of the process of law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court found in favour of the petitioners. Specifically, the criminal petitions are allowed and the FIR in Crime No. 6 of 2004 of Gooty Police Station, registered for offences under Sections 406 and 420 IPC, is quashed.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the criminal investigation and prosecution arising from that FIR cannot proceed against the petitioners on the basis of the present complaint. The court treated the dispute as essentially civil/ contractual (and subject to arbitration as per clause 24 of the agreement) and concluded that criminal proceedings would constitute an abuse of process. The opinion does not purport to lay down any broader new legal precedent beyond applying established principles (as discussed above) to the facts of this case.

    M.D. v. State Of Andhra Pradesh

    (1) These two criminal petitions are filed under section 482 of thecode of criminal procedure by the accused in crime no. 6 of 2000 with a prayer to quash the f. I. R. Therein.

    (2) Petitioners in crl. P. No. 250 of 2004 are a - 1 and a - 2 and the petitioner in crl. P. No. 337 of 2004 is a - 3. 3rd respondent is the complainant and a case in crime no. 6 of 2004 for the offences under sections 406 and 420 i. P. C. , came to be registered on his report.

    (3) 3rd respondent is a developer of energy. An agreement came to be entered between the 3rd respondent and the petitioners - accused with regard to the purchase of energy generated by the 3rd respondent. The terms of the agreement are reduced into writing and it is dated 18 - 5 - 2001. Under the said agreement the 3rd respondent company will wheel energy about 10 lakhs per month, subject to availability, to the petitioners - accused through a. P. Transco lines from its biomass power generation station located at pandipadu (v) , kallur (m) , kurnool district on continuous basis starting from the billing month of april, 2001, till 2003. It appears that some of the developers questioned the 3rd respondent authority to impose wheeling charges by filing writ petitions. The writ petitions went in favour of the developers and thereupon the transmission corporation, a. P. , ltd. , challenged the order before the supreme court and the supreme court passed the following interim 'order: -

    "the interim order dated 7 - 5 - 2003 is confirmed so as to remain in operation during the hearing of the appeals. However, over and above the bank guarantees covered by the order dated 7 - 5 - 2003 we are not inclined to ask for further bank guarantees being furnished. The parties, needless to say, shall remain bound to comply with the ultimate decision given by this court. During the pendency of the appeals, the transmission charges shall be liable to be paid as per the term of the agreement subsisting between the parties. Printing dispensed with. The appeals shall be heard on the slp paper books. Parties may file additional document, if any, within six weeks. Original record shall be requisitioned."

    (4) On the basis of the interim order passed in the spl. Leave petitions, central power distribution company of a. P. , ltd. , issued letter to the petitioners - accused directing them to pay wheeling charges. There upon the petitioners - accused addressed a letter to the 3rd respondent - complainant for discussion with regard to the payment of wheeling charges and the last letter addressed to the 3rd respondent - complainant by the petitioners - accused is dated 7 - 1 - 2004 which reads as under:

    "please refer our letter dt. 24 - 12 - 2003, wherein we have requested to attend a meeting on 5th january, 2004 at 3. 00 p. M. But the meeting was not convened as you came only after 5. 30 p. M. Now, we request you to attend a meeting with the undersigned and mr. P. Ch. Nagi reddy, asst. Manager (a and) on 23rd january, 2004 (friday) at 3. 00 p. M. Please note that the issue is to be settled between you and apcpdcl only and we are no way concern with the dispute. We are arranging a meeting at your request only"
    .

    (5) Therefore, 3rd respondent - complainant presented a report before the s. H. O. Gooty p. S. Ananthapur district alleging that the petitioners - accused having consumed the energy supplied by it refused to pay the value of the energy and thereby they committed a breach of trust and cheating punishable under sections 406 and 420 i. P. C. Hence, this criminal petitions by the petitioners - accused with a prayer to quash the f. I. R. In crime no. 6 of 2004.

    (6) Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that the dispute between the petitioners/accused and 3rd respondent is purely a civil in nature and therefore, initiation of criminal proceeding against the petitioners/accused amount to abuse of process of law. He further submits that even if the complaint averments are taken in toto, ingredients of sections 406 and 420 i. P. C. Are not made out and thus the f. I. R. In crime no. 6 of 2004 is liable to be quashed. He took me to the terms and conditions of the agreement entered between the petitioners - accused and 3rd respondent. He also referred clause 24 of the agreement which deals with the arbitration in case of dispute between the parties. For better understanding, i may refer the relevant clause in the agreement and it is thus: -

    "in the event of any dispute or difference between the parties hereto arising out of above or under or touching this agreement or relating to the rights and liabilities of the parties shall in the first instant be amicably resolved, failing which such disputes and differences shall be referred to arbitration in accordance with the provisions of the arbitration and conciliation act, 1996 or any statutory modification thereof for the time being in force."

    In support of submissions, the learned counsel placed reliance on trw decisions of supreme court in s. W. Palanitkar v. State of bihar and girish sarwate v. State of a. P. Rep. By public prosecutor. In the first cited decision, the supreme court held that every breach of trust may not result in a penal offence of criminal breach of trust unless there is evidence of a mental act of fraudulent misappropriation. An act of breach of trust involves a civil wrong in respect of which person wronged may seek his redress for damages in a civil court a breach of trust with mens rea gives rise to a criminal prosecution as well. In the second cited decision a full bench of this court held that section 482 cr. P. C. Is in the nature of protecting the inherent power of the high court and as a matter of fact, this does not confer any power on the high court. It merely states that nothing in the criminal procedure code shall be deemed to limit or affect the inherent powers of the high court. These inherent powers to the high court are available to make such orders as maybe necessary to give effect to any order under the code or to prevent abuse of the process of any court or other wise to secure the ends of justice. Therefore, under section 482 cr. P. C. , the high court's inherent power to pass orders to secure the ends of justice is not limited by any provision in the criminal procedure code. Therefore, even on those principles, if an fir does not disclose any offence and a person complains to the high court, the high court cannot shut its door to him and tell him to face the investigation and also face the trial. In other terms, this has been the consistent view of the supreme court as well. The supreme court has in no uncertain terms stated that power under section 482 cr. P. C. To quash an fir or a complaint is available to the high court, provided the conditions laid down in its judgments are satisfied.

    (7) Learned counsel appearing for the 3rd respondent submits that the petitioners - accused are in no way concerned with the wheeling charges and it is the dispute between the 3rd respondent and a. P. Regulatory commission and the 3rd respondent - complainant filed a writ petition in the high court and secured certain interim directions. A further submission has been made that the petitioners - accused cannot withhold the payment after utilizing the energy developed by the 3rd respondent company and therefore, the ingredients of sections 406 and 420 i. P. C. Are made out. He would further contend that the petitioners - accused are not justified in stopping the payments of entire consumption charges and at the most they can withhold the amount equivalent to wheeling charges demanded by the a. P. Regulatory commission.

    (8) It is not in dispute that the petitioners - accused and 3rd respondent entered into power purchase agreement. As per the terms and conditions of the agreement, the petitioners - accused being the purchasers of the power developed by the 3rd respondent company, provided a bank guarantee towards one month power charges and corporate guarantee for another one month power charges. The petitioners - accused admittedly paid the charges till june, 2003. Tne genesis of the dispute is the letter dated 28 - 7 - 2003 addressed by the central power distribution company of a. P. Limited to the petitioners - accused directing them to pay the wheeling charges. The bill submitted by the central power distribution company for the month of july, 2003 includes the wheeling charges of rs. 3,90, 278 - 00. Indeed 1st petitioner company addressed a letter to the 3rd respondent - complainant for joint meeting and the last of the series of letters is dated 7 - 1 - 2004, which has been already been extracted above.

    (9) The ingredients in order to constitute a criminal breach of trust (i) entrusting a person with property or with any dominion over property (ii) that person entrusted (a) dishonestly misappropriating or converting that property to his own use; or (b) dishonestly using or disposing of that property or willfully suffering any other person so to do in violation (i) of any direction of law prescribing the mode in which such trust is to be discharged (ii) of any legal contract made touching the discharge of such trust.

    (10) To hold a person guilty of cheating it is necessary to show that he had fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of making the promise. From his mere failure to keep up promise subsequently such a culpable intention right at the beginning, that is, when he made the promise cannot be presumed.

    (11) Coming to the facts on hand, 1st petitioner company paid consumption charges basing on the bills sent by the central power distribution till june, 2003. When the central power distribution sent the bills in the month of july, 2003 including wheeling charges, the dispute arose between the parties. In the circumstances, it cannot said that the petitioners - accused have dishonest intention when they made promise to pay the amount to the 3rd respondent as per the agreement between them. The dispute between the parties arose when the central power distribution company of a. P. Demanded wheeling charges. This is purely a civil dispute, which is required to be adjudicated upon through process of civil courts or through the process of arbitration as provided under clause 24 of the agreement. In the facts and circumstances of the case, i am of the view that the continuance of criminal proceeding against the petitioners - accused amounts to abuse of process of law.

    (12) Accordingly, the criminal petitions are allowed and fir in crime no. 6 of 2000 of gooty police station registered for the offences under sections 406 and 420 ipc is hereby quashed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.D. v. State Of Andhra Pradesh
    (Mar 31, 2006)