AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India.
  • Rajasthan Education Service Rules, 1986,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India.
  • Rajasthan Education Service Rules, 1986,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This special appeal under Section 18 of the Rajasthan High Court Ordinance was filed against the order of the learned Single Judge dated 4.2.93, which dismissed a writ petition.

As alleged by the appellant, members of the appellant Organisation were appointed temporarily as lecturers in various Government Colleges of Rajasthan beginning in 1987. These temporary appointments were made by the Directorate of College Education and continued thereafter. The Organisation's writ petition sought regularisation of those members who had completed two years' service and possessed the requisite qualifications. The learned Single Judge, after considering material on record, dismissed the writ petition. The appellant challenged that dismissal by preferring this special appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether members of the appellant Organisation, who were appointed temporarily as lecturers and who had completed the requisite period of service and possessed required qualifications, are entitled to regularisation of their service.
  2. Whether the court can direct regularisation of temporary/ad-hoc lecturers when recruitment to the post of Lecturer is governed by the Rajasthan Education Service Rules, 1986 (framed under Article 309 of the Constitution) and selection is to be made by the Rajasthan Public Service Commission (RPSC).
  3. Whether precedents relied upon by the appellant (for example, Lecturers Forum v. State of Rajasthan; Karnataka State Private College Stop-Gap Lecturers Association v. State of Karnataka; Dr. M.A. Haque v. Union of India; Narendra Chandha v. Union of India) mandate or justify regularisation in the facts of the present case.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Mr. Mridul, learned counsel for the petitioner-appellant, submitted that the appellant's case is covered by the judgment in Lecturers Forum v. State of Rajasthan.
  • The appellant relied on Karnataka State Private College Stop-Gap Lecturers Association v. State of Karnataka, Dr. M.A. Haque v. Union of India, and Narendra Chandha v. Union of India and argued that, on these authorities, the learned Single Judge should have allowed the writ petition and granted the relief prayed for (regularisation).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lecturers Forum v. State of Rajasthan Directed Government to formulate a scheme for regularisation of temporary lecturers who had rendered three years' service (with breaks) by subjecting them to suitability through a screening committee; arose where recruitment rules were under consideration and short-term appointments were made to meet dire necessity. The Court held this decision not applicable to the present case because in the present case the recruitment rules (Rajasthan Education Service Rules, 1986) already exist and there is nothing in those rules providing for regularisation of long-serving temporary lecturers.
Karnataka State Private College Stop-Gap Lecturers Association v. State of Karnataka Supreme Court directions concerning regularisation/implementing High Court orders for stop-gap lecturers in privately managed colleges; observations cautioning governments when favouring one set of employees and the consequences of inconsistent regularisations. The Court found this decision not helpful to the appellant because, in the present case, there was no assertion that lecturers in similar posts had been regularised earlier nor any comparable earlier court order; thus the Karnataka decision could not be used to issue directions here.
Dr. A.K. Jain v. Union of India Dealt with ad-hoc Assistant Medical Officers in Railways; some ad-hoc appointees allowed to continue and some were regularised up to certain cut-off dates. Referred to as part of the jurisprudential background on ad-hoc appointments and regularisation; subsequent consideration in Dr. M.A. Haque qualified the scope of such relief.
Dr. M.A. Haque v. Union of India Supreme Court considered earlier precedents (including Direct Recruit Class II Engineering Officers' Association v. State of Maharashtra and Dr. P.P.C. Rawani) and refused to create a broad precedent for regularisation or creation of supernumerary posts; emphasised strict observance of recruitment rules under Article 309 and warned against bypassing Public Service Commissions. The Court treated Dr. M.A. Haque as not supporting the appellant: the decision refrained from creating a general precedent, confined certain reliefs to special facts, and reiterated that recruitment rules and PSC involvement must be respected.
Narendra Chandha v. Union of India Where officers were promoted without following prescribed procedure and worked continuously; Court directed that continuous officiation be counted for seniority. The Court held this decision not helpful to the appellant because it concerned counting of seniority in special circumstances where promotions had been continued; it did not mandate general regularisation of ad-hoc appointees under the present facts.
State of Haryana v. Piara Singh Principle that an ad-hoc or temporary employee must be replaced only by a regularly selected employee (case concerned subordinate services of class IV employees). The Court found this precedent inapplicable to the present matter concerning lecturers, noting that Piara Singh pertained to class IV subordinate services and therefore could not be analogously applied to the facts here.
Dr. P.P.C. Rawani etc. v. Union of India Supernumerary promotional posts at every higher promotional stage were ordered to be created (a remedy adopted in that special factual context). The Court noted that the Rawani approach was confined to special facts and that the Supreme Court in Dr. M.A. Haque declined to extend that remedy generally; thus Rawani did not support an order for regularisation in the present case.
Delhi Development Horticulture Employees' Union v. Delhi Administration, Delhi Strong condemnation by the Supreme Court of appointing persons on an ad-hoc/temporary basis and later regularising them; observation that no court can be a party to such an exercise. The Court relied on this decision to support the learned Single Judge's approach and to underscore that courts should not participate in regularising ad-hoc appointments where recruitment rules exist and selection is the province of the relevant recruiting agency.
Surendra Kumar v. State of Raj. Appointments on temporary basis; termination of service on availability of properly recruited employees by Public Service Commission was not held illegal; only sympathetic consideration directed. The Court treated this decision as supportive of the Single Judge's dismissal and as authority that termination upon availability of properly recruited employees is not per se illegal; it reinforced that recruitment must follow rules and PSC process.
Direct Recruit Class II Engineering Officers' Association v. State of Maharashtra Referenced in discussion of recruitment and seniority jurisprudence relevant to Dr. M.A. Haque. Was considered by the Supreme Court in Dr. M.A. Haque and formed part of the background cautioning against broad remedial directions affecting recruitment structures; the present Court relied on that limited reading to deny a general direction for regularisation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court heard the appellant's counsel at length and considered the material on record along with the authorities cited. The Court's analysis proceeded through the following steps, grounded in the materials and authorities expressly discussed in the opinion:

  1. The Court examined factual assertions that members of the appellant Organisation were appointed temporarily as lecturers from 1987 and had continued thereafter and that some had completed two years' service and possessed requisite qualifications.
  2. The Court noted that recruitment to the post of Lecturer in colleges is governed by the Rajasthan Education Service Rules, 1986, which are framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution. Those rules provide the mechanism for recruitment and do not contain any provision for regularisation of a Lecturer appointed temporarily or on an ad-hoc basis.
  3. The Court analysed the precedents relied upon by the appellant and distinguished them from the present facts:
    • Lecturers Forum v. State of Rajasthan was distinguished because it arose where recruitment rules were under consideration and short-term appointments were made to meet a dire necessity; in the present case rules already exist and provide recruitment through RPSC without a provision for regularisation.
    • Karnataka State Private College Stop-Gap Lecturers Association v. State of Karnataka was treated as inapplicable because there was no earlier order or comparable regularisation in respect of similar posts in the present case.
    • Dr. M.A. Haque and associated precedents (including Dr. P.P.C. Rawani and the Direct Recruit decision) were examined. The Court noted the Supreme Court's reluctance in those cases to create broad precedents for regularisation or for ordering creation of supernumerary posts; the reasoning emphasises strict compliance with recruitment rules under Article 309 and respect for Public Service Commissions.
    • Decisions such as Narendra Chandha, State of Haryana v. Piara Singh and Surendra Kumar v. State of Raj. were observed to be distinguishable or of limited assistance because of differing facts or differing classes of service.
    • The Court accepted the relevance of Delhi Development Horticulture Employees' Union v. Delhi Administration, where the Supreme Court strongly condemned the practice of appointing on an ad-hoc/temporary basis and later regularising such appointees, holding that courts should not be party to such exercises—this supported the Single Judge's approach.
  4. On these bases, the Court concluded that no direction could be issued to regularise ad-hoc temporary teachers where the recruitment is governed by the Rajasthan Education Service Rules, 1986 and selection is to be made by the Rajasthan Public Service Commission in accordance with those rules.
  5. The Court further concluded that the material before the Single Judge did not entitle the petitioner-Organisation to the relief prayed for, and therefore there was no error or illegality in the Single Judge's order dismissing the writ petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The special appeal was dismissed. The Court affirmed the order of the learned Single Judge dated 4.2.93 which had dismissed the writ petition.

DISMISSED

Implications

  • Direct effect: The appellant's request for regularisation of its members (temporary/ad-hoc lecturers) was denied; recruitment and any grant of regular status remain governed by the Rajasthan Education Service Rules, 1986, and selection is to be made only in accordance with those rules (and the role of the Rajasthan Public Service Commission).
  • The Court declined to extend or create a precedent that would permit judicially-ordered regularisation of ad-hoc lecturers in circumstances where recruitment rules exist and provide the selection mechanism; the opinion makes clear that no new broad precedent was laid down by this decision.
  • The Court relied on existing Supreme Court authorities emphasizing that courts should not be parties to regularising ad-hoc appointments and that recruitment rules under Article 309 and the processes of Public Service Commissions must be respected.

No other points were pressed before the Court, and the appeal was dismissed.

    Rajkiya Mahavidhyalaya Asthai Vyakhyata Sangharsh Samitidh v. State Of Rajasthan And Others

    N.K Jain, J.:— This special appeal u/s. 18 of the Rajasthan High Court Ordinance has been directed against the order of learned Single Judge dated 4.2.93 whereby he has dismissed the writ petition.

    2. Brief facts which are necessary for the disposal of this special appeal as alleged by the appellant are that the members of the appellant Organisation are appointed temporarily as lecturers in various Government Colleges of Rajasthan. It is alleged that they were appointed in different subjects by the Directorate College Education and have been continuing since 1987. The Organisation preferred a writ petition with a prayer that its members who had completed two years service and possess requisite qualification are entitled for regularisation. The learned Single Judge after considering material on record dismissed the writ petition. Dissatisfied with the order of the learned Single Judge, this special appeal has been preferred.

    3. Mr. Mridul, learned counsel for the petitioner-appellant has submitted that the case of the appellant is covered by the judgment reported in Lecture Forum v. State of Rajasthan (1). He has relied on Karnataka State Private College Stop-Gap Lecturers Association v. State of Karnataka (2) Dr. M.A Haque v. Union of India (3) and Narendra Chandha v. Union of India (4) and as such the learned Single Judge should have allowed the writ petition and should have granted relief as prayed by the petitioner-appellant.

    4. We have heard learned counsel for the petitioner-appellant at length and perused the material on record as well as the case law cited before us carefully.

    5. In Lecturers Forum v. State of Raj. (Supra) (21) temporary Lecturers working in the Rajasthan School of Arts and Rajasthan Sangeet Sansthan, formed an association with the name of Lecturers' Fourm and filed a writ petition. Services of all those petitioners were terminated and order for relieving them were also passed. The grievance of the temporary Lecturers was that the policy of the Government in making their appointments on temporary basis against the permanent and regular posts available in the colleges was violative of the provisions contained in Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India. The learned Single Judge after considering the case of State of Haryana v. Piava Singh (15) wherein it was laid down that an ad-hoc or temporary employee must be replaced only by a regularly selected employee, directed the Government to formulate a Scheme for regularisation of the services of temporary Lecturers who had rendered three years service with breaks by subjecting them to suitability through the medium of screening committee within four months of the receipt of the certified copy of the order. The said case is not applicable to the facts of present case as in that case rule for recruitment were under consideration of the State Government and till the finalisation of the rules, regular selections were not possible and it was asserted that short term appointments were made in order to meet with the dire necessity of teachers. Whereas in the present case rules are already framed and are in existence and the members of the Organisation can be recruited in accordance with rules only. That apart, there is nothing in rule, which provides regularisation of such persons who are continuing for long time.

    6. In Karnataka State Private College Stop-Gap Lecturers Association v. State of Karnataka (Supra), wherein teachers appointed temporarily on ad-hoc basis for three months or less with break of day or two by privately managed degree colleges. Despite the orders of the High Court State die not follow the order passed by the High Court which was passed with the agreement of the respondent. A plea of reservation was raised. It was observed by their lordships of the Supreme Court that no difficulty was pointed out by the respondent for not giving the benefit of the High Court's order to the incumbents. Further the State regularised services of contract letrurers, local candidates, University lecturers, Engineering Colleges Lecturers etc. In this back-ground their lordships of the Supreme Court gave certain directions observing as under:—

    “All the same such policy decisions of government in favour of one or the other set of employees of sister department are bound to raise hopes and expectations in employees of other departments. That is why it is incumbent on governments to be more circumspect in taking such decisions. The petitioners may not be able to build up any challenge on discrimination as employees of government colleges and private colleges may not belong to the same class yet their claim cannot be negatived on the same class yet their claim cannot be negatived onthe respondents' stand in the counter affidavit that the regularisation of temporary teachers who have not faced selection shall impair educational standard without explaining the effect of regularisation of temporary teachers of University and even technical colleges. Which being the unfortunate State of affairs this Court is left with no option but to issue following direction to respondents for not honouring its commitments before the High Court and acting contrary to the spirit of the order, and also due to failure of government in remaining vigilant against private management of the college by issuing timely directions and taking effective steps for enforcing the rules.”

    The aforesaid decision is not helpful to the appellant as in the present case nothing has been said that Lecturers working on similar posts have been regularised nor there is any earlier order of the Court as was in the said case, therefore, on the basis of above decision no direction can be issued.

    7. In Dr. A.K Jain v. Union of India (6) ad-hoc Assistant Medical Officers (Class II) in the Railways, who were original appointed during August 1983 to July 1986 for six months were allowed to continue up to four years. Services of some of the said officers terminated for failure to avail of three chances for selection through UPSC and the rest were facing termination on joining of ASMO selected by UPSC. Under the circumstances, the Supreme Court directed that the services of those appointed on ad-hoc basis up to October 1, 1984 to be regularised if they were found suitable. Since they experienced difficulty in adjusting the seniority. The matter again came up before their lordships of the Supreme Court in Dr. M.A Haque v. Union of India (Supra). Their lordships of the Supreme Court considered the decision rendered by the Constitution Bench in Direct Recruit Class II Engineering Officers' Association v. State of Maharashtra (7) and also considered the case of Dr. P.P.C Rawani etc. v. Union of India (8). In Dr. P.P.C Rawani, case supernumerary promotional posts at every higher promotional state was ordered to be created. Their lordships repelled the suggestion of adopting the same course in M.A Haque's case and observed that it might not be feasible in the medical service in the railways. It has also been observed that the creation of supernumerary posts had its own limitations, both Physical and financial the burden of additional posts even when they were not necessary and could not be accommodated was not easy to carry. Their lordships further observed that the direction given in Dr. Rawani's case (supra) has to be confined to the special facts of that case and should not be extended to other case. In any case, this Court should not give any such directions to the Railways. If, however, the Railways decide to follow that course, they can do so and nothing prevents them from doing it. We would rather refrain from creating a precedent by giving such directions. Their lordships observed as under:—

    “We are also conscious of the fact that candidates in service have a disadvantage as against the fresh candidates in the tests particularly when they face the tests after a long lapse of time. As against this, however, we cannot lose sight of the fact that the recruitment rules made under Article 309 of the Constitution have to be followed strictly and not in breach. If a disregard of the rules and the by-passing of the Public Service Commissions are permitted, it will open a back-door for illegal recruitment without limit. In fact this Court has, of late, been witnessing a constant violation of the recruitment rules and a scant respect for the Constitutional proisions requiring recruitment to the services through the Public Service Commission. It appears that since this Court has in some cases permitted reguiarisation of the irregularly recruited employees some Governments and authorities have been increasingly resorting to irregular recruitments. The result has been that the recruitment rules and the Public Service Commissions have been kept in cold storage and candidates dictated by various considerations are being recruited as a matter of course.”

    In Narendra Chandha v. Union of India (Supra) wherein officers were promoted without following the procedure prescribed in the rules and worked continuously for long periods without being reverted. Under these circumstances the Court directed that their period of continuous offitiation should be counted for seniority.

    In the aforesaid Dr. M.A Haque's case (supra) their lordships of the Supreme Court have refrained from creating a precedent inspite of the fact that in some cases reguiarisation was so permitted. Further that case pertains to seniority of the employees who were regularised by the order of the Court but their seniority remained to be fixed. Likewise in the case of Narendra Chandha (supra), the promotions made earlier without following rules were continued under the circumstances of that case. Therefore, the said decisions are not helpful to the petitioner appellant.

    8. The case of State of Haryana v. Piara Singh (Supra) is not helpful to the petitioner-appellant as that case was of subordinate services of class IV employees and on the basis of the analogy of the said case no relief can be granted to the petitioner-appellant.

    9. In the instant case, as stated above, the recruitment to the post of Lecturer for colleges is governed by the Rajasthan Education Service Rules, 1986, which are framed under proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution. There is no provision for reguiarisation of service of a Lecturer, who was appointed temporarily or on ad-hoc basis. Therefore, no direction can be issued for regularising the ad-hoc temporary teachers and the recruitment can be made only in accordance with the said rules. In view of this, the learned Single Judge has relied on Delhi Development Horticulture Employees' Union v. Delhi Administration, Delhi (9) wherein their lordships of the Supreme Court have Strongly condemned the practice of appointing persons on an ad-hoc and temporary basis and allow them and thereafter to regularise them in service. It has also been observed that no court can be a party to such exercise. Mr. Mridul has contended that the learned Single Judge has erred in relying on said decision as that decision relates to Jawahar Rojgar Yojana a temporary scheme but it is pertinent to note at this juncture that when their lordships had made observations of such a nature in such a case then they are of more importance and relevance for the purpose of present case, which relates to State Services where selection can only be made by the Rajasthan Public Service Commission in accordance with the rules. So also the learned Single Judge considered the case of Surendra Kumar v. State of Raj. (10) wherein appointments were made on temporary basis and services of employees were terminated on availability of proper recruited employees by Public Service Commission and the order of termination of services was not held to be illegal by their lordships of Supreme Court and only a direction was given to give sympathetic consideration. Thus, the learned Single Judge has rightly dismissed the writ petition holding that simply they are continuing in service for longer time no mandamus can be issued as the recruitment can only be made by the RPSC in terms of Rules of 1986. That apart the petitioner Organisation is not entitled to any relief prayed for on the basis of alleged material supplied in the writ petition. In view of above discussion, there is no error or illegality in the order passed by the learned Single Judge and we are not inclined to interfere with the same.

    10. No other point has been pressed before us.

    11. In the result, the special appeal has no force, so it is hereby dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajkiya Mahavidhyalaya Asthai Vyakhyata Sangharsh Samitidh v. State Of Rajasthan And Others
    (Oct 14, 1993)