AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (tenant) filed a revision against an ejectment order passed by the learned Appellate Authority. The demised premises is shop No. B-VIII/2320, Rupnagar, originally let by owner Vishnu Dutt to the petitioner by rent note Exh. P-2 dated 30.4.1975. Vishnu Dutt died on 14.12.1992. The respondents are members of the family (including Smt. Sunita Chopra and her son) who alleged an oral family partition (circa 1998) that allotted certain commercial property to members of Sohan Lal Chopra’s line (including Pardeep Chopra). The respondents sought eviction claiming bona fide requirement of the premises for Pardeep Chopra to start a business. The learned Rent Controller dismissed the ejectment petition on various grounds (including that the partition was partial and sham); the learned Appellate Authority allowed ejectment relying on oral evidence of partition, municipal/assessment records (mutation in the name of Sunita Chopra for 1998-1999 and 2000-2001), and rent paid to Sunita Chopra. The tenant challenged the appellate order in revision. The High Court (Hemant Gupta, J.) dismissed the revision but granted the petitioner three months to vacate subject to conditions (deposit of arrears within one month and filing undertakings regarding possession and payment of rent).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellate Authority was justified in holding that the demised premises were required by the respondents for their bona fide use and occupation based on alleged oral family partition and corroborating records.
  2. Whether a tenant can challenge a family settlement/partition relied upon by a landlord in eviction proceedings on the ground that it is oral or partial (i.e., whether such settlement can be treated as sham).
  3. Whether comparative hardship between tenant and landlord must be considered when eviction is sought on the ground of bona fide requirement under the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Appellate Authority erred in relying on a judgment of this Court (Gurmail Singh… v. Raghbir Singh…., 2005 (4) RCR (Civil) 373 : 2005 (1) PLR 855) to hold that the tenant cannot challenge the family settlement; that case was distinguishable as it involved title recognized by consent decree.
  • The family settlement relied upon by the respondents is a sham, oral and partial (only shops partitioned while residential, plot and agricultural land remained unpartitioned), and the respondents have not come to court with clean hands.
  • Authorities cited (Devi Dass v. Mohan Lal; Chetan Dass Gupta v. Smt. Sushila Devi; Vasdev Nath v. Jagdish Parshad Gupta and others; Sk. Sattar Sk. Mohd. Choudhari v. Gundappa Amabadas Bukate; Dr. Avtar Singh… v. Ascharaj Lal…; Gurdial Singh and others v. Raj Kumar Aneja and others) support that such family settlements can be challenged by the tenant in eviction proceedings.
  • The Rent Controller considered comparative hardship between tenant and landlord, which the petitioner argued should have been weighed by the Appellate Authority as well.

Respondents' Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The respondents asserted an oral family partition (circa 1998) in respect of the commercial property and relied on municipal records, mutation in favour of Smt. Sunita Chopra, house tax assessment records, and rent paid to Smt. Sunita Chopra (including receipts for August 1999 to July 2000).
  • The respondents claimed bona fide requirement of the premises for Pardeep Chopra to establish his own business; PW-4 (Sohan Lal Chopra) supported the oral partition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurmail Singh… v. Raghbir Singh…., 2005 (4) RCR (Civil) 373 : 2005 (1) PLR 855 Referenced by petitioner to argue that tenant may challenge family settlement/that the authority cannot treat family settlement as unassailable. The Court rejected the petitioner’s submission that reliance on this judgment made the Appellate Authority’s finding incorrect; the Court did not accept the distinguishing contention and upheld the Appellate Authority’s finding on the facts.
Devi Dass v. Mohan Lal, 1982 (2) RCR (Rent) 246 (SC) : AIR 1982 Supreme Court 1213 Relied on by petitioner to support that family settlement can be challenged by tenant in eviction proceedings. The Court noted the citation but did not accept that reliance as sufficient to overturn the factual findings; the Court upheld the ejectment on the evidence before it.
Chetan Dass Gupta v. Smt. Sushila Devi, 1983 (1) RCR 585 Relied on by petitioner to contend tenant may impeach family settlement/partition. The Court recorded the reliance but sustained the Appellate Authority’s conclusion that partition was proved by oral evidence and contemporaneous records; the precedent did not lead to reversal.
Vasdev Nath v. Jagdish Parshad Gupta and others, 1993 (1) RLR 23 Relied on by petitioner for the proposition that family settlement can be challenged by tenant. The Court considered the precedent but found the factual matrix supported the partition and bona fide requirement; the precedent did not alter the outcome.
Sk. Sattar Sk. Mohd. Choudhari v. Gundappa Amabadas Bukate, AIR 1997 SC 998 : 1997 (1) R.C.R (Civil) 513 : 1997 (2) R.C.R (Rent) 148 : 1997 (1) R.C.R (Rent) 98. Relied on by petitioner to support challengeability of family settlements in eviction proceedings. The Court acknowledged the citation but ultimately found the partition proved on the evidence and did not allow the revision; the precedent did not result in interference with the Appellate Authority's factual conclusion.
Dr. Avtar Singh… v. Ascharaj Lal…, 2002 (2) RCR 201 Relied on by petitioner for the proposition that family settlement can be impeached in eviction proceedings. The Court did not find the precedent decisive in the face of the municipal records, rent payments and oral evidence establishing partition, and therefore dismissed the revision.
Gurdial Singh and others v. Raj Kumar Aneja and others, 2002 (1) R.C.R (Rent) 194 : 2002 (2) Supreme Court Cases 445. Relied on by petitioner to support the ability to challenge family settlement/partition. The Court recorded the reliance but held that on the material before it (mutation, assessment records, rent receipts, oral evidence) the partition and bona fide requirement were established; the precedent did not lead to setting aside the ejectment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the matter on the basis of contemporaneous municipal/assessment records, oral testimony and rent payment evidence. Key points of the reasoning were:

  • The alleged oral partition dated to 1998 was given effect in municipal records (mutation in the name of Smt. Sunita Chopra for assessment years 1998-1999 and 2000-2001) and was supported by house tax assessment registers (Exhs. RG, RH and RI).
  • Rent receipts (Annexures R-1 to R-6) showing rent paid by the petitioner to Smt. Sunita Chopra for August 1999 to July 2000 were produced; such payments predated the filing of the ejectment petition (18.9.2000).
  • Sohan Lal Chopra (PW-4) gave oral evidence supporting the partition.
  • On these materials, the Court concluded that the family partition of the commercial property was carried out and given effect to; the Rent Controller’s conclusion that the partition was sham because other properties were unpartitioned was based on conjecture and was unsustainable.
  • The Court held there is no requirement that all jointly owned properties be partitioned at the same time and that, between family members, an oral family settlement need not be reduced to writing.
  • The respondents’ asserted requirement for Pardeep Chopra to establish himself in business was held to be bona fide; the existence of a vacant plot elsewhere did not equate to availability of an already-constructed shop in a busy market.
  • Comparative hardship was held not to be a requirement under the Act; the statutory test is proof of bona fide requirement by the landlord, and once proved the landlord is entitled to seek eviction; the tenant cannot prevent eviction solely because he cannot find alternate accommodation.
  • On the above analysis the Court found no material irregularity or illegality warranting interference in revisional jurisdiction and dismissed the revision petition, while granting the tenant a conditional limited period to vacate.

Holding and Implications

REVISION PETITION DISMISSED.

Direct effects on the parties:

  • The revision against the Appellate Authority's ejectment order is dismissed.
  • The petitioner is granted three months to vacate the premises provided that (a) the petitioner deposits the entire arrears of rent within one month from the date of the order, and (b) files affidavits/undertakings before the learned Rent Controller to hand over vacant possession on expiry of that period and to pay rent for the interim period; such undertakings must be filed within one month.

No broader legal precedent or novel legal principle was announced beyond application of established principles regarding proof of bona fide requirement, admissibility of contemporaneous municipal/assessment records and the non-necessity of writing for intra-family partitions; the decision affirms that a tenant cannot block eviction once bona fide requirement is satisfactorily proved on the material before the court.

    Narinder Kumar Shiv Kumar Dhawan Petitioner v. Sunita Chopra S

    Hemant Gupta, J. — Tenant is in revision aggrieved against the order of ejectment passed by the learned Appellate Authority on the ground that the demised premises i.e shop bearing No. B-VIII/2320, Rupnagar, Tehsil and District Rupnagar, is required by the respondent for use and occupation of one of the landlords, Pardeep Chopra.

    2. One Vishnu Dutt, who was owner of the shop in dispute, let out the same to the present petitioner vide rent note Exh. P-2 dated 30.4.1975 Vishnu Dutt died on 14.12.1992 The respondents are the wife and son of predeceased son of Vishnu Dutt, namely, Satish Kumar Chopra. Vishnu Dutt had another son, Sohan Lal Chopra. The respondent No. 1-Sunita Chopra and wife of Sohan Lal Chopra, are real sisters. Deceased Vishnu Dutt had executed a Will dated 27.3.1990 in favour of his son Sohan Lal Chopra and his grandsons, i.e sons of Satish Kumar Chopra, namely Pardeep Chopra and Rajnish Chopra. It has also come on record that Rajnish Chopra has since died and his share in the property has been inherited by his mother, Sunita Chopra i.e wife of Satish Kumar Chopra.

    3. The respondents sought ejectment in respect of the premises in dispute alleging that there was an oral partition in respect of commercial property and in such partition, another shop bearing municipal No. 1616/1 had fallen to Sohan Lal Chopra. It has further been pleaded that Pardeep Chopra was earlier studying but as he has not been able to qualify 10+2 examination and, therefore, the premises are required to enable him to start his own business in the premises in dispute.

    4. Learned Rent Controller dismissed the petition, inter alia, on the ground that the respondents have not come to Court with clean hands inasmuch as the oral partition is not complete partition of the joint property i.e residential house, plot in urban estate and agricultural land have not been partitioned. As per the respondents, only two shops have been partitioned whereas the demised premises is bigger than the shop which is in possession of Sohan Lal Chopra where the parties are already doing the business of selling milk. Learned Rent Controller found that Pardeep Chopra sits with Sohan Lal Chopra in Shop No. 1616/1 and is engaged in the business of selling milk and, thus, found that the respondents have failed to prove their requirement. Learned Appellate Authority found that apart from the oral evidence of partition, there is documentary evidence corroborating the partition i.e the record of the Municipal Committee for the year 1998-1999 and the order dated 3.4.1999 wherein the property was mutated in the name of Sunita Chopra i.e wife of Satish Kumar Chopra. In the house tax assessment records for the years 1998-1999 and 2000-2001, the property in dispute has been shown in the name of Sunita Chopra and similar position is reflected in the assessment registers, Exhs. RG, RH and RI. The Court found that Kumar the respondents have no source of income and that Pardeep Chopra had dropped his studies. Believing such statement, learned Appellate Authority passed an order ejectment on the ground that the premises are required for bona fide use and occupation of the respondents herein.

    5. Learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued before this Court that the finding recorded by the learned Appellate Authority that the tenant has no right to challenge the family settlement after relying upon the judgment of this Court in Gurmail Singh… v. Raghbir Singh…., 2005 (4) RCR (Civil) 373 : 2005 (1) PLR 855, is not correct. It is contended that the said case was in fact, a case based upon the title recognized by consent decree and is, therefore, distinguishable.

    Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the following judgments reported as :—

    (i) Devi Dass v. Mohan Lal, 1982 (2) RCR (Rent) 246 (SC) : AIR 1982 Supreme Court 1213;

    (ii) Chetan Dass Gupta v. Smt. Sushila Devi, 1983 (1) RCR 585;

    (iii) Vasdev Nath v. Jagdish Parshad Gupta and others, 1993 (1) RLR 23;

    (iv) Sk. Sattar Sk. Mohd. Choudhari v. Gundappa Amabadas Bukate, AIR 1997 SC 998 : 1997 (1) R.C.R (Civil) 513 : 1997 (2) R.C.R (Rent) 148 : 1997 (1) R.C.R (Rent) 98.

    (v) Dr. Dr. Avtar Singh… v. Ascharaj Lal…, 2002 (2) RCR 201; and

    (vi) Gurdial Singh and others v. Raj Kumar Aneja and others, 2002 (1) R.C.R (Rent) 194 : 2002 (2) Supreme Court Cases 445.

    to contend that the family settlement relied upon by the respondents can be challenged by the tenant in proceedings to seek eviction of the tenant. Such family settlement relied upon by the respondents is a sham transaction propounded only with a view to seek eviction of the petitioner. It was contended that such family settlement is alleged to be oral and is partial in respect of shops alone whereas agricultural land, residential house and another commercial plot have hot been partitioned. Thus, the respondents have not approached the Court with clean hands.

    6. However, I am unable to accept the argument raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner.

    7. The oral partition is alleged to have been arrived at in the year 1998 and soon thereafter the same has been given effect to in the municipal records i.e for the assessment years 1998-1999 and 2000-2001. In fact, receipts, Annexures R-1 to R-6 are the rent receipts for the payment of rent for the months of August, 1999 to July, 2000 produced by the tenant. Such rent has been paid by the petitioner to Smt. Sunita Chopra even prior to the filing of the ejectment petition on 18.9.2000 Still further, Sohan Lal Chopra had been examined as PW-4, who has also supported oral partition. Thus, by virtue of the oral evidence of the co-owners, the municipal record and the payment of rent by the petitioner after the said partition leaves no manner of doubt that the family partition of the commercial property was carried out and given effect to by the parties.

    8. The finding recorded by the learned Rent Controller that since agricultural land, residential property and the plot have not been partitioned, therefore, the partition of the commercial property is sham is, in fact, based upon surmises and conjectures alone. There is no requirement that all the properties owned by the parties jointly have to be partitioned at one and the same time. The argument raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the family settlement is oral and partial is of no significance. Since the family settlement is alleged to be between the members of the same family, therefore, such family settlement need not be reduced into writing, No doubt, the parties are owner of some other properties such as residential house and agricultural land. But Late Vishnu Dutt was owner of only two shops. In one shop i.e Shop No. 1616/1, one of the sons of Vishnu Dutt is carrying on the business of selling milk whereas the other shop is in possession of the present petitioner. Now, after the death of her husband, Sunita Chopra along with her son has sought the ejectment of the tenant to establish his son in business. Such requirement cannot be said to be lacking in any bona fide. It business jointly with Sohan Lal Chopra. It was pointed out that since wife of Sohan Lal Chopra and Sunita Chopra are real sisters, therefore, it is natural for Pardeep Chopra to carry on business with his uncle. I do not find any substance in the said argument. Even if Pardeep Chopra is carrying on business along with his uncle, that will not be a ground on the basis of which it can be said that an adult son must carry on business as a subordinate along with his uncle and he has no right to establish a separate business and to grow in life independently.

    9. Still further, another argument has been raised that another commercial plot in the same urban area is available with the respondents and, therefore, the petitioners cannot be ordered to be evicted. It has come on record that the said plot is a vacant plot. As such, the same cannot be equated with the constructed property in busy market from which the eviction of the tenant is sought.

    10. Lastly, learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that the learned Rent Controller has taken into consideration the comparative hardship of the tenant vis-a-vis the requirement of the landlord whereas the said aspect has not been considered at all by the learned Appellate Authority. The comparative hardship is not required to be considered under any provision of the Act. The Act contemplates the eviction of the tenant on proof of “bona fide requirement.” The respondents herein have led evidence to the effect that the premises in dispute are required for their bona fide use and occupation. As a landlord, the respondents have a right to seek ejectment of the tenant on satisfaction of bona fade requirement. It is for the tenant to find out alternative accommodation for carrying on its business in accordance with law. However, he cannot compel the landlord that he cannot get premises vacated because the tenant is unable to find out another accommodation.

    11. In view of the above discussion, I do not find any material irregularity or illegality in the finding recorded which may warrant interference of this Court in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction. Consequently, the revision petition is dismissed.

    12. However, the petitioner is granted three months time to vacate the demised premises provided the petitioner deposits the entire arrears of rent within one month from today and also files an undertaking by way of affidavit before the learned Rent Controller to hand over physical vacant possession of the premises to the respondents herein on the expiry of the aforesaid period. The petitioner shall also file an undertaking to pay rent for the period he remains in possession. Such undertakings be filed within one month from today.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narinder Kumar Shiv Kumar Dhawan Petitioner v. Sunita Chopra S
    (Oct 9, 2006)