AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — Hemant Gupta, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition challenges the Registrar's order dated 13.9.2007 (Annexure P.17) under the Registration Act, 1908, whereby a sale deed allegedly executed on 16.3.2006 in respect of land measuring 9 kanals 10 marlas was ordered to be registered.

The petitioners are the owners of the land. Petitioner No.2 executed a General Power of Attorney in favour of petitioner No.1. The petitioners state that an earlier agreement to sell dated 11.3.2006 was executed in favour of respondent No.2 (Rakesh Kumar) for Rs.6,15,000/-, and that Rs.1,00,000/- was received as earnest money. Petitioners say Rs.99,000/- of the balance was deposited in petitioner No.1's bank account on 13.3.2006.

Respondent No.2 allegedly had a sale deed prepared and presented for registration, reciting consideration of Rs.2,68,000/-. The Sub‑Registrar initially refused registration by order dated 29.9.2006 under Section 86 of the Registration Act, presuming non‑admission of execution by the executants. Respondent No.2 then filed an application under Section 73 of the Act; the Registrar (Ferozepur) recorded evidence and, by order dated 13.9.2007, directed registration (finding that petitioner No.1 had admitted her signatures and that presentation delay did not exceed four months), and registration was effected on 17.9.2007 with a modification note to the description of land.

Separately, respondent No.2 had filed a suit for specific performance based on the alleged sale deed. The trial court refused an ad‑interim injunction on 25.5.2006 but granted liberty that petitioners could sell the land with prior court permission; the petitioners sought permission on 5.9.2006. The petitioners also made a police complaint on 2.4.2006. The petitioners filed the present writ petition seeking quashing of the Registrar's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Registrar lawfully exercised jurisdiction under Section 73 of the Registration Act to order registration of the sale deed when a civil suit for specific performance based on the same transaction was pending in the Civil Court.
  2. Whether, on the material before the Registrar and this Court, the transaction of sale (execution of the sale deed and receipt of sale consideration) was prima facie proved such that the Registrar's order to register the deed was sustainable.
  3. Whether the sale deed was presented for registration within the four‑month period prescribed by Section 23 of the Registration Act, 1908.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Registrar's order to register the sale deed while a suit for specific performance was pending in the Civil Court was unlawful because the Registrar's power under the Act is summary in nature and cannot decide disputed factual questions which fall within the plenary jurisdiction of the Civil Court.
  • Disputed questions regarding execution of the document and receipt of sale consideration were already raised in elaborate pleadings before the Civil Court and could not properly be resolved by the Registrar under Section 73.
  • The document was presented for registration after more than four months from its execution; therefore, Section 23 bars registration in the ordinary manner, and registration ordered by the Registrar was contrary to Section 23.
  • Petitioners alleged that the sale consideration was not actually received as recited in the deed; petitioner No.1 signed under representation and blind faith, and subsequently was unable to get the balance consideration. The petitioners had lodged a police complaint about fraud and alleged snatching of the sale deed.

Respondent No.2's Arguments

  • Respondent No.2 denied the existence of the agreement dated 11.3.2006 and maintained that the sale deed was executed on 16.3.2006 and the entire consideration of Rs.2,68,000/- was paid to the petitioners at their residence.
  • Respondent No.2 filed an affidavit (24.9.2008) explaining sources of cash used to pay the consideration (withdrawals from CC account, funds from M/s Jonty Poultry Farms, sale proceeds of chickens, and cash on hand).
  • Counsel for respondents argued that the Registrar recorded satisfaction about execution (that the deed writer read the deed over to petitioner No.1 and she signed in token of its correctness) and therefore the Registrar's order to register should not be interfered with by the writ court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Banasettappa Laljichikkanna v. District Registrar and another, AIR 1966 Mysore 310 The execution of a document is not merely signing; it requires signing by way of assent to the terms of the contract of alienation embodied in the document. The Court relied on this principle to hold that the Registrar's finding—based only on petitioner No.1's signature—did not amount to proof of execution in the substantive sense (i.e., assent and receipt of consideration) and therefore the Registrar's conclusion was insufficient.
Chandeshwar Yadav v. Smt. Radha Devi & others, 2001(2) ACJ 96 Section 77 of the Registration Act gives an option to the vendee either to file a suit under Section 77 of the Act or to bring a suit for specific performance of the agreement to sell. The Court applied this rule to conclude that respondent No.2, having chosen to file a suit for specific performance in the Civil Court, could not simultaneously invoke the summary remedy under the Act in a manner that bypassed plenary adjudication of disputed facts; hence use of Section 73 before the Registrar was an abuse of process.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court framed two focal points for examination: (1) the legality of the Registrar's order in view of the pending civil suit for specific performance, and (2) whether the sale transaction was prima facie proved.

On the timing issue, the Court referred to Section 23 of the Registration Act, which mandates that no document other than a will be accepted for registration unless presented within four months from the date of execution (subject to exceptions in Sections 24–26). The Court found that the Registrar's factual finding that the document was presented within four months was incorrect. That factual mistake rendered the Registrar's order unsustainable: "The finding recorded by the Registrar that the document has been presented for registration within four months, is factually incorrect. The order passed by the Registrar in view of the factual mistake itself is not sustainable."

On the pendency of the civil suit, the Court reasoned that the Civil Court possesses plenary jurisdiction to try all disputed questions of fact such as execution of documents and receipt of consideration. The Registrar's jurisdiction under Section 73 is summary and limited. The Court observed that once respondent No.2 had invoked the Civil Court by filing a suit for specific performance, resorting to the Registrar under Section 73 to obtain registration was an abuse of process and lacked bona fides. The Court cited Chandeshwar Yadav to note that the vendee can either proceed under Section 77 or seek specific performance; having chosen specific performance, respondent No.2 could not rely on the Registrar to decide contested factual issues.

Applying Banasettappa Laljichikkanna, the Court emphasized that "execution" involves assent to the terms of alienation and is not established by signing alone. The Court found that the Registrar's conclusion rested only on petitioner No.1's signature and not on evidence that the sale consideration had been received. This was inadequate to prove execution in the substantive sense required.

On the question whether the transaction was prima facie proved, the Court found supporting material for the petitioners: an agreement dated 11.3.2006 bearing respondent No.2's signature, a bank deposit of Rs.99,000/- in petitioner No.1's account on 13.3.2006, and an endorsement of petitioner No.1's presence before the Sub‑Registrar on 17.3.2006. The respondent's affidavit showing withdrawals before 16–17 March 2006 suggested that the respondent's contention of a spur‑of‑the‑moment payment on 16.3.2006 was implausible. The Court also noted the suspicious nature of an allegedly full cash payment at the petitioners' residence with no cheque/draft or recitals of payment before the Sub‑Registrar. Taken together, these factors undermined respondent No.2's account and supported the conclusion that the Registrar's registration order was unsustainable.

Having found (i) a factual error as to the four‑month limitation, (ii) that the Registrar had decided contested questions of fact which properly belonged to the Civil Court, and (iii) that the Registrar's reliance on mere signature without proof of receipt of consideration was insufficient, the Court concluded that the Registrar's order was "wholly illegal" and "not sustainable."

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court set aside the order of the Registrar dated 13.9.2007 (Annexure P.17) and held that the registration ordered by the Registrar was unlawful and unjustified. In emphasis: The Registrar's order directing registration is quashed and set aside.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Registrar's order for registration of the sale deed was annulled; the registration carried out pursuant to that order is invalidated in the context of this writ petition.
  • The Court found that contested factual issues (execution, receipt of consideration) should be determined by the Civil Court in the pending suit for specific performance rather than by the Registrar in summary proceedings under Section 73. The opinion emphasizes the limited, summary nature of the Registrar's jurisdiction under the Act and the availability of plenary remedies in the Civil Court once a suit is filed.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying the cited authorities; it resolves the dispute on the present facts and sets aside the Registrar's order rather than creating a new precedent on registration practice.

Other Directions

The petitioners had reported a complaint to the Senior Superintendent of Police, Ferozepur on 2.4.2006 alleging fraud and non‑action. The Court directed the Senior Superintendent of Police, Ferozepur to take appropriate action on that complaint expeditiously.

    Avnash Kani v. Additional Deputy Commissioner Cum Registrar

    Hemant Gupta, J.:-

    The challenge in the present writ petition is to the order dated 13.9.2007 (Annexure P.17) passed by the Registrar under the Registration Act, 1908 (for short 'the Act'), whereby the sale deed allegedly executed on behalf of petitioners in respect of the land measuring 9 kanals 10 marlas was ordered to be registered.

    2. The petitioners are owners of land measuring 9 kanals 10 marlas. Petitioner No.2 has executed a General Power of Attorney in respect of the land owned by the said petitioner in favour of her mother, petitioner No.1. As per the stand of the petitioners, they entered into an agreement to sell of the land measuring 9 kanals 10 marlas in favour of respondent No.2 i.e. Rakesh Kumar for a sum of Rs.6,15,000/-. An agreement of sale was executed on 11.3.2006 and the petitioners allegedly received a sum of Rupees One lac as an earnest money. The date for execution of the sale deed was 17.3.2006. As per the petitioner, a sum of Rupees One Thousand was spent by the petitioners, but the remaining amount of Rs. 99,000/- was deposited by petitioner No.1 in her Savings Bank Account No.26804 with the Punjab National Bank, Jalalabad on 13.3.2006.

    3. As per the petitioner, though the date for execution and registration of the sale deed was 17.3.2006, but respondent No.2 told petitioner on 16.3.2006 for execution and registration of the sale deed. Petitioner No.1 was brought in the Chamber of Rajesh Bajaj, Deed Writer in the New Tehsil Complex, Jalalabad where the sale deed in question was scribed. However, the sale consideration recited as paid to the petitioners was Rs.2,68,000/- but no mention was made in respect of agreement dated 11.3.2006. Respondent No.2 told petitioner No.1 that such sale consideration has been recited to save the stamp duty and the amount has been shown in the sale deed is according to the minimum rate fixed by the State Government for registration of the sale deed. Respondent No.2 told petitioner No.1 that the balance sale consideration of Rs.5,15,000/- would be paid to petitioner No.1 on completion of work. Petitioner No.1 signed the documents on the basis of such representation under blind faith, but when petitioner No.1 demanded the balance sale consideration from respondent No.2, the matter was put off and the petitioners were told that the sale deed would be registered after paying the amount to her. But the amount was not paid by respondent No.2, nor he approached the Sub Registrar for registration of the sale deed. The petitioner appeared before the Sub Registrar on 17.3.2006 and her presence was endorsed by the Sub Registrar. The deed writer also communicated to the Tehsildar in respect of fraud in execution of the sale deed and snatching of the sale deed. The petitioners had made a complaint to SSP, Ferozepur on 2.4.2006, but no inquiry was made.

    4. It is also pointed out during the course of arguments that respondent No.2 filed a suit for specific performance on the basis of sale deed allegedly executed on 16.3.2006 on the same date i.e. 16.3.2006. In the said suit, the petitioners filed a detailed reply. The application moved by respondent No.2 for ad-interim injunction was declined by the learned trial Court on 25.5.2006, but with a rider that if the plaintiffs i.e. the present petitioners want to sell the land, the petitioners shall take prior permission of the Court before alienating the suit land. In pursuance of the said condition, the petitioners sought permission from the trial Court to sell the land on 5.9.2006. The petitioner attached an affidavit dated 13.9.2006 of the prospective vendee along with the said application. At this stage, respondent No.2 moved an application before the Sub Registrar for registration of the sale deed dated 16.3.2006. On the said application, the Sub Registrar passed an order refusing to register the sale deed. The said order reads as under:­

    “29.9.06

    "Sale deed dated 16.3.2006 from Ritu Bala daughter of Sohan Lal son of Dunna Mal and Abinash Rani wife of Sohan Lal son of Dunna Mal, resident of Jalalabad in favour of Rakesh Kumar son of Amrit son of Jiwan Ram resident of Jalalabad dated 13.9.2006 was presented by Rakesh Kumar purchaser under Section 86 of the Registration Act for registration. Notice was sent to the executants and proclamation was also done but the executants did not turn up to register the sale deed. In this situation, it is presumed that the executants are not admitting the execution. Therefore, I hereby refuse the registration of the sale deed and the sale deed be given back to the purchaser."

    "5. Aggrieved against the said order, respondent No.2 filed an application under Section 73 of the Act for registration of the sale deed dated 16.3.2006. Though the present petitioner submitted a detailed reply controverting the averments made by respondent No.2 and also pointed out that respondent No.2 has already filed a suit for specific performance, but the Registrar, Ferozepur passed an order on 13.9.2007 for registration of the sale deed on the basis of evidence recorded. The Registrar found that the said sale deed was read over by the deed writer to petitioner No.1 and she has signed in token of its correctness. Since she had admitted her signatures on the sale deed dated 16.3.2006, she has executed the document. It was further found that delay in not presenting the sale deed does not exceed four months, therefore, on payment of fine not exceeding 10 times of the amount of proper registration fee, the sale deed was ordered to be accepted for registration. In pursuance of the said order, the sale deed has been registered on 17.9.2007 by modification of description of the land by inserting a note in the said sale deed. On the basis of the said facts, the petitioner has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court for setting aside and quashing of the order passed by the Registrar."

    "6. Learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that the order passed by the Registrar so as to register the sale deed when the suit for specific performance on the basis of un-registered sale deed is pending before the Civil Court, is not only unwarranted but not permissible. It is contended that the remedy under the Act is a summary in nature, whereas respondent No.2 has invoked the jurisdiction of the Civil Court in respect of the execution of the document and the consequential relief flowing therefrom. The order of Registrar to register the document in exercise of the summary power is wholly illegal. It is further that the petitioner has raised elaborate pleadings before the civil Court as well as before the Registrar. Such contended disputed questions in respect of the execution of documents could not have been considered by the Registrar in exercise of the jurisdiction under Section 73 of the Act, more so when the Sub-Registrar has refused to register the document initially. It is further contended that the document was presented for registration after four months from the date of its execution, therefore, in terms of Section 23 of the Act, the document could not be ordered to be registered."

    7. Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon Banasettappa Laljichikkanna v. District Registrar and another, AIR 1966 Mysore 310 and Chandeshwar Yadav v. Smt. Radha Devi & others, 2001(2) Apex Court Journal 96.

    8. Respondent No.2 has filed a written statement before this Court denying execution of the agreement of sale dated 11.3.2006, but asserting that the sale deed was executed on 16.3.2006 and the entire sale consideration of Rs.2,68,000/- was paid to the petitioners at her residence. In additional affidavit dated 24.9.2008 filed, it has been pointed out that respondent No.2 has arranged the funds of Rs.2.68 lacs in the following manner:

    "An amount of Rs.24,000/- was withdrawn from CC account in the State Bank of Patiala Jalalabad on 13.3.2006."

    An amount of Rs.1.65 lacs was withdrawn on 14.3.2006 from the said account, which is running in the name of M/s Jonty Poultry Farms.

    "An amount of Rs.47,700/- was received by respondent No.2 on 14.3.2006 on account of sale of full wagon of the chickens and the remaining amount of Rs.32,000/- was cash in hand with respondent No.2 on account of his business transaction."

    "9. On the basis of the said affidavit, it is contended by the learned counsel for the respondents that the sale deed was executed by the petitioner on receipt of the sale consideration and the Registrar has passed an order in exercise of the jurisdiction vested in him for registration of the sale deed after recording satisfaction of the execution of the document by petitioner No.1 and thus, such order cannot be interfered with in the writ petition."

    10. During the course of arguments on 17.9.2008, learned counsel for respondent No.1.has stated that an application for withdrawal of the suit for specific performance of the contract dated 16.3.2006, has been filed before the Civil Court. He sought sometime to file an affidavit to this effect. However, in the affidavit filed, it has been pleaded that the application for withdrawal was filed on 19.9.2008. The learned trial Court has adjourned the proceedings in the suit sine die vide order dated 23.11.2007 in view of the pendency of the present writ petition.

    11. The matter in issue requires to be examined from two different angles. Firstly, in respect of legality of the order passed by the Registrar under the Act in view of the pendency of the civil suit and secondly whether the transaction of sale is prima-facie proved.

    12. As per the case of respondent No.2, the plaintiff has signed the sale deed on 16.3.2006. The same has been presented for registration vide application dated 13.9.2006 (Annexure P.11), by moving an application under Section 36 of the Act. The said application is moved after more than four months of the execution of the document, therefore, in terms of Section 23 of the Act, such document could not have been registered under Section 23 of the Act. Section 23 of the Act reads as under:

    "23. Time for presenting documents.- Subject to the provisions contained in sections 24, 25 and 26, no document other than a will shall be accepted for registration unless presented for that purpose to the proper officer within four months from the date of its execution."

    "Provided that a copy of a decree or order may be presented within four months from the day on which the decree or order was made, or, where it is acceptable, within four months from the day on which it becomes final."

    "13. The finding recorded by the Registrar that the document has been presented for registration within four months, is factually incorrect. The order passed by the Registrar in view of the factual mistake itself is not sustainable. It shows that the Registrar has passed an order without examining the facts carefully. This fact alone is sufficient to set aside the order passed by the Registrar on 13.9.2007."

    "14. Apart from the said fact, respondent No.2 has invoked the jurisdiction of Civil Court for specific performance of the agreement dated 16.3.2006. The petitioners have filed reply to the said suit. An ad-interim application has been disposed of giving liberty to the petitioner to sell the property after obtaining the permission of the Court. The jurisdiction of the Civil Court is plenary in nature and, therefore, all questions in respect of execution of the documents and the receipt of the sale consideration or the execution of the agreement are the issues, which are required to be examined in the Civil Suit. Though the statement was made before this Court that the application has been filed for withdrawal of the suit for specific performance but factually the said application has been filed only after the orders were passed by this Court on 17.9.2008. Once, the matter is pending before the Civil Court at the instance of respondent No.2 alone, wherein all the questions are required to be examined, the invocation of the jurisdiction of the Registrar under Section 73 of the Act is nothing but an abuse of process of law. As a matter of fact, if the Registrar refuses to register a document, an aggrieved party has a right to invoke the jurisdiction of the Civil Court under Section 77 of the Act. It necessarily implies that the order of Registrar is summary in nature and limited in operation. But once, the parties were before the Civil Court, the invocation of the jurisdiction of the Registrar lacks bona-fide. The manner in which the Registrar has ordered registration even though the factum of pendency of the Civil Suit raising disputed questions of fact was raised, speaks volumes of the conduct of officer in ordering registration of the document. To say least, we are of the opinion that the order registering of the document lacks bona-fide."

    15. In Banasettappa Laljichikkanna's case (supra), the Court has found that execution of the document does not mean merely signing, but signing by way of assent to the terms of contract of alienation embodied in the document. In the present case, the stand of the petitioners is categorical that they have not received sale consideration but that petitioner No.1 has signed the document. The finding recorded by the Registrar is only based upon signing of document and not on the basis that the sale consideration was received by petitioner No.1. Still further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Chandeshwar Yadav's case (supra), has held that Section 77 of the Act, gives an option to the vendee either to file a suit under Section 77 of the Act or to bring a suit for specific performance of the agreement to sell. In the present case, respondent No.2 having chosen to file suit for specific performance, the remedy provided under the Act, were not available to the said respondent.

    16. In respect of the 2nd question, the petitioner has relied upon an agreement of sale dated 11.3.2006, the said agreement bears the signature of respondent No.2. Petitioner No.1, further pointed out that a sum of Rs.99,000/- was deposited in her Savings Bank Account on 13.3.2006. She has appeared before the Sub Registrar on 17.3.2006. Said appearance has been endorsed by the office of Sub Registrar. It, thus, appears that the stand of the petitioners that there was an agreement of sale on 11.3.2006 and, she appeared before the Sub Registrar is sufficient to return a finding that the stand of respondent No.2 that there was no agreement, is not correct. Still further, the affidavit dated 24.9.2008, shows that the said respondent has withdrawn certain amount from the Bank Account from 13.3.2006, meaning thereby that the contract of sale was not executed at the spur of the moment on 16.3.2006. It is not explained as to how and why, the sale consideration has not been paid through cheque or draft nor any payment was recited to be payable before the Sub Registrar. The entire payment of Rs.2.68 lacs is purportedly made in cash and at the residence of the petitioners such conduct leaves a strong suspicion on the entire nature of the transaction propounded by respondent No.2.

    17. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the order passed by the Registrar (Annexure P.17) is wholly illegal, unjustified and consequently, the same is set aside.

    18. The petitioners have also made a complaint to the Senior Superintendent of Police on 2.4.2006 and as per the petitioner, no action has been taken thereon. Therefore, we direct the Senior Superintendent of Police, Ferozepur to take appropriate action on such complaint expeditiously.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Avnash Kani v. Additional Deputy Commissioner Cum Registrar
    (Oct 3, 2008)